4 ms·
This obscures the tax burden from the end user, transparently blending it with the price of the goods and the merchant's profit. Consumers should be consciousl
by sneak 4y ago
This obscures the tax burden from the end user, transparently blending it with the price of the goods and the merchant's profit.
Consumers should be consciously aware of the split.
- Schnitz 4y agoIt can be itemized on the receipt but the easily readable advertised price should be the number you pay, period.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoAirlines are required to advertise total price, but break out taxes at purchase. This is a solved problem. https://www.transportation.gov/policy/aviation-policy/airline-rules-fares https://www.transportation.gov/policy/aviation-policy/airlin...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epicureanideal 4y agoPersonally I find it very interesting that a $20 restaurant meal might only be netting $1 to the owner. Makes me feel like going out isn’t actually that bad of a deal.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoLots of retail businesses have less than 5% profit margin. Even insurance companies, including health insurance, have less than 5% profit margins.
- epicureanideal 4y agoWell I do wonder about the exec compensation at insurance companies though. 5% profit but mega million compensation packages…
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhy would insurance company executives have any more (or less) negotiating power than any other similar sized business? Cursory look at insurance company executive pay does not show any anomalies.
- yamtaddle 4y agoNb. health insurance profit margins are now capped, in the US.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAt 15% to 20%. So smaller profit margins indicate downward pressure on pricing from competitors.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWell, in point of fact, the limit is actually a mandate on how much they must spend on medical care. Their own operating expenses, salaries, advertising, et c., have to come out after that. So they could theoretically make 15% under that limit—except in practice that's actually impossible. Which means margins aren't necessarily 5% because of competition. [EDIT] That is, I'm skeptical that if one removed that limit, competition would keep margins where they are. Forcing all profit to come out of 15% of revenue probably does play a major role in keeping the actual margin as low as it is.
- johngladtj 4y agoIt also encourages healthcare price increases, since the best way for them to increase profits becomes increasing revenues, rather than reducing costs
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe fact that they settle for sub 5% profit margins means they individually do not have the pricing power to do that. Clearly, a competing insurance company will steal business via lower premiums. I suppose one could assert they are all in cahoots and have a secret deal to accept low single digit profit margins to keep out of the news cycle, while simultaneously agreeing to pay healthcare providers more and more each year, but I would want proof.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoA lot more of it goes to the landowner in the form of rent. It could be around 25-35%.
- earthnail 4y agoWhy? The business is built on infrastructure that is paid for with taxes. Tax is included in all end user prices in every European country I’m aware of.
- sneak 4y agoNo, the business is built on infrastructure that is paid for with a tiny fraction of taxes. They are not congruent. Taxes in Europe are also much higher in general. Perhaps this is a result of obscuring the amounts in the advertised prices—it never raises to the level of conscious consideration of the tax burden at point of purchase.
- vineyardmike 4y agoIf the government runs a deficit- which it does- then the taxes are literally too low to cover the infrastructure so it can’t be “a fraction”. Sure you can argue some of that goes to military (a safe nation is kinda infrastructure) and healthcare/Welfare (healthy and fed employees and customers are good for business too) but regardless your view on taxes, they all somehow end up back to helping the nation regardless of how efficiently or directly that happens.
- johngladtj 4y agoInfrastructure is essentially a rounding error on most developed countries state expenditures. In many cases it's even self-sustaining due to licensing agreements with companies that managed the infrastructure in return for the toll revenue. The idea that the primary purpose of taxes is to provide infrastructure hasn't been true ever. The bulk of expenditures are social welfare programs and other similar handout and wealth transfer programs intended to punish the successful and reward the failures for political purposes. Social security, healthcare, education often comprise over 50% of expenditures in most first world countries. Interest and debt are also another major expenditure. The "core responsibilities of the state" , that is the military, justice system and internal security, infrastructure usually consume less than 20% of government expenditures.
- hiq 4y agoIn Europe I still haven't seen a bill without the VAT clearly shown in the final bill. I've also seen shops showing the two prices, one without the VAT, one with. But if only one is shown, it should be the one I will pay.
- darreninthenet 4y agoThat's because it's illegal in the EU to display or advertise a price to a consumer (ie not another business) without VAT added.
- vore 4y agoAs the average consumer, I would much rather see how much money I need to take out of my pocket on the sticker price rather than deeply considering what the tax burden of my jug of milk is.
- lockhouse 4y agoWe can have both. Sticker price can be all-inclusive price with taxes and fees required to be listed in detail on the receipt.
- crote 4y agoSo have them put both prices with and without taxes on the label if they want to. The total tax burden will be listed on the receipt anyways.
- rootusrootus 4y agoSo, the same reason we can't have the convenience of pre-filled tax returns from the IRS? People need to be able to feel the pain of the taxes they pay, because it might help bring them closer to the ideological conservative viewpoint.
- lockhouse 4y agoWhy would ensuring people know how much they are paying in taxes be a bad thing?
- zamadatix 4y agoIt's not so much the concept that's bad as the proposed execution. Bold the amount that came from tax next to the total on the receipt or similar, it'll have the same effect without requiring people agree it's more important than knowing what the actual price of something is going to be.
- rootusrootus 4y agoYou can do that without making them do all the paperwork. For nearly all taxpayers the IRS already knows how much you owe, and can give you a return that is already filled out. But people like Grover Norquist believe that anything that makes paying taxes easier will cause people to become more accepting of taxation in the first place. So we all need to suffer the pain of filling out a return from scratch, to make sure we have the right attitude towards taxes. Nobody is having the information hidden from them in any case. Even pre-filled from the IRS, it would be right in front of you.
- yamtaddle 4y ago1) There are other ways to do that that don't annoy people so much. 2) Surveys about understanding of how taxes work, of personal or typical tax burden, and even about whether a given individual believes they were affected by some new high-profile tax law or other (versus whether they actually were...) demonstrate pretty damn conclusively that this approach has entirely failed, anyway.
- twblalock 4y ago
- arrrg 4y agoSellers can still make it very clear how much of the sum were taxes. Here in Germany every bill, every receipt will contain that information. (I mean, obviously, it’s legally required.) Different sellers do this differently in terms of clarity, though I think this has little to do with any kind of price signal to the buyer or sticking it to the government or something like that. My feeling is that the more likely it is that the customer is a company (which do not have to pay VAT) the more clearly do sellers communicate the VAT part of the price. In fact, if you are not selling to consumers you can ditch that VAT altogether when you communicate your prices. Alternatively (when talking about online retailers) they may provide a toggle to switch between being a business customers or a private customer, e.g. here the toggle top left next to the Conrad logo: https://www.conrad.de https://www.conrad.de