8 ms·
London is handing out free meals for all primary school children
- password8 4y ago[flagged]
- cassianoleal 4y agoI have no idea what you even mean by your comment or how it relates to the article. You just sound xenophobic for no reason.
- binarymax 4y agoIt’s programs like this that actually fill me with hope - that taxpayer money is used for something directly helpful to the people. I’d love to see similar progressive assistance enacted in more districts.
- password8 4y agoCompletely short term. It's a band-aid at best.
- PreachSoup 4y agoIt's just food, we have plenty of it. What's a long term and non band-aid solution to let children eat?
- wccrawford 4y agoBasically anything that enables their parents to feed them again instead. Nobody like taking handouts and they'd much rather take care of their own families instead. Help them prosper via various different means and they'll be happier and healthier than taking government handouts 1 day at a time.
- vidarh 4y agoFeeding children is a proven way of increasing the educational attainment, and by extension in the long run enables more (future) parents to prosper.
- mjmahone17 4y agoHandouts are great and make our community better! I like taking handouts, and I love when the community, through guaranteed services, provides help taking care of my family. I love the government handouts that pay for road maintenance right up to my home. And bus service so I don’t need to buy a car. I also love the public library near me, which is a handout that gives my community a rich place to go and participate in arts and reading groups without requiring me to spend a penny! Handouts can help people prosper, and specifically children have no say in whether their parents have the means or motivation to meet their needs. We should help children prosper regardless of their parents, which means schools should provide free meals, laundry service, childcare for students’ younger siblings, etc. What “different means” would help students prosper than ensuring their needs are met?
- chriswarbo 4y ago> Nobody like taking handouts and they'd much rather take care of their own families instead. Interesting; what are the sample size and 95% confidence intervals on the study you're citing? > Help them prosper via various different means Erm... that's exactly what's happening? This is not the entirety of the UK's economic policy.
- lm28469 4y agoAnd let children go to school without food ? Sometimes the short term solution is necessary
- denton-scratch 4y ago> Nobody like taking handouts and they'd much rather take care of their own families instead. That's a big part of why this provision is to be universal. You can't feel bad about taking "handouts" if all your fellow pupils are also getting it.
- 4y ago
- substation13 4y agoIf it is made into a permanent policy then it is long term.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIdeally, it will be subject to accountability, and the service will not be outsourced to some cheap company employing the lowest quality labor serving the lowest quality food. I have seen that, and I would like the government to specify that all schools need to have kitchens or a central kitchen staffed by people employed by the government.
- credit_guy 4y agoIn New York City all kids in the public school system qualify for free meals. No questions asked. From Pre-K to 12th grade. I believe this has been going on since 2019. During Covid, since kids could not go to school, all kids (or rather their parents) received some debit cards that could be used to buy food.
- paxys 4y agoCalifornia has started this as well. Free breakfast and lunch to 100% of students in the state across all grades regardless of income or anything else (first state in the country to do so I believe). It's bizarre to me that this isn't already the standard. India has been successfully doing it for two decades now, and the program now covers 120 million children.
- vr46 4y agoI like Mayor Sadiq Khan, he's had an extremely hostile opposing government, one that's made him beg for funding for the public transport system and one that's changed the entire Mayoral electoral system from a fair-ish one to a very unfair one, and various policing crises that get laid at his door, so nice to see him using his business tax windfall to help school kids when the government won't. Plus a pandemic. Further context: yes, it's the mayoral elections this year. Even further context: while some boroughs do offer blanket free meals, most don't and during the school holidays in the pandemic, many children were going without a decent meal as the goverment voted to not provide them. My partner and many others stepped up in our borough along with the local rugby club who made the meals to deliver to children and families in need.
- _Wintermute 4y ago> yes, it's the mayoral elections this year. Pretty sure it's not until mid 2024?
- vr46 4y agoAh yes, I'm a year early, thanks for pointing it out.
- cassianoleal 4y agoMay 2024. https://metro.co.uk/2023/02/20/when-is-the-next-london-mayoral-election-and-who-is-running-18309268/ https://metro.co.uk/2023/02/20/when-is-the-next-london-mayor... Edit: downvoted for sharing information. :facepalm:
- ploppyploppy 4y agoI despise Khan. Elite-accepted Populist with aggressive net-zero policies that are driving down low-income self-employed workers.
- jmfldn 4y agoLondoner here. I think those from outside this city, let alone outside this country, would be amazed at the amount of working poor there are here, let alone non-working poor. Yes, it's a 'rich' city, it's also got a lot of the worst poverty in the UK too. We are in a bad shape generally in the UK, a lot of this country is pretty behind other g8 nations these days on quite a few key development metrics.
- altacc 4y agoI moved out of London about 15 years ago but continued to visit and work there and the difference in such a short amount of time is shocking. The income disparity and cost of living was bad when I lived there and seems to have gotten significantly worse each year. It's bad for Londoners and it's bad for London as it has a sterilising effect on London life and culture.
- machiaweliczny 4y agoIf I had too guess problems are due to assets inflation (foreign buyers) + hard Brexit instead of staying in trading union like Switzerland.
- jmfldn 4y agoYep for sure. Asset inflation caused by things like quantative easing, the poorly-implemented covid furlough scheme and various other 'trickle up' economic policies over the decades, helped to fuel the rampant wealth inequality we see now. A lot of this money goes into property speculation for example. Sky high house prices are in no small part caused by this. Austerity measures also played a massive part in where we are now. Brexit hasn't helped either.
- 908B64B197 4y agoI think a lot of commonwealth countries are realizing now that allowing questionable foreigners to park their questionably acquired wealth into assets might have artificially have boosted their countries perceived prosperity, but was no substitute to real economic growth based on innovation. It's a painful to take a look at cities like London and Vancouver and compare them to SF and Seattle.
- altacc 4y agoThis is politics, so not really HN content, but it is great news and should be nation wide and more common across the globe. Studies, including the UK government's own study (from the last government) showed that there was significant improvement in attainment for pupils from lower income backgrounds and also general health improvements. For about £400 per pupil per year you can create significant benefits for children and therefore future adults. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/184047/DFE-RR227.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/UIFSM_Bodyweight_Outcomes.pdf https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/0...
- easytiger 4y agoAren't you concerned that there are people having children who refuse to feed them? > For about £400 per pupil per year you can create significant benefits for children and therefore future adults Parents used to feed their children when I grew up. What's changed? And if that's the case why is childhood obesity soaring in the same areas that so desperately need money to feed children? There are over 10million school age children. So your very conservative estimate of £400 is £4bn that has to be found year on year.
- oarsinsync 4y ago> Parents used to feed their children when I grew up. What's changed? And if that's the case why is childhood obesity soaring in the same areas that so desperately need money to feed children? Fast food is now a fraction of the cost of healthy food. Cost of living has been steadily increasing (and more recently, more suddenly increasing) while wages have remained stagnant. Home ownership rates have declined, resulting in more people paying to keep a roof over their head instead of investing in their own future equity. Instead of having any security to support their families, they’re paying significant %s more in prepay utility services.
- ploppyploppy 4y ago> Fast food is now a fraction of the cost of healthy food. So are they feeding them fast food or not?
- pigtailgirl 4y ago-- in uk school lunch is not free? - this is typical lunch every school child in Korea provided free daily - thought this was usual in developed countries? -- https://imgur.com/a/8KECVAp https://imgur.com/a/8KECVAp
- christkv 4y agoWhere do I sign up that looks delicious.
- yamtaddle 4y agoA lot of countries seem to manage to provide really good school lunches. Totally unlike, say, the US, where it's usually crap and has gradually been getting worse. I think it all but requires some existing, quality-valuing food culture. Try to serve good lunches to kids here and you'd have all the parents crying about how their kids "can't" eat that and need an Uncrustable and chocolate milk instead or whatever.
- cameronh90 4y agoWe used to have free milk, but Thatcher got rid of that (Thatcher, Thatcher, milk snatcher). One challenge in the UK, especially somewhere like London, is we have a fair amount of diversity in food choices. Providing nutritious, tasty meals on a very limited budget with options for vegan, vegetarian, kosher, halal, gluten free and other diets can be a challenge for schools, and many primary schools are quite small without cooking facilities. When I was young, it was normal in primary to bring a "packed lunch" from home, usually a sandwich and crisps. The standard UK lunch as an adult is still a sandwich for most people. The move towards free cooked school meals has been suggested because turns out that many don't have access to a daily healthy cooked meal at home.
- jacooper 4y agoBTW kosher = halal, both have almost the same requirements.
- anon7725 4y ago
- taskqa 4y ago[dead]
- Minor49er 4y agoHopefully this does what is intended. Similar programs in the States generate huge amounts of waste because the food must be provided for all students who qualify, yet a large portion does not get eaten and gets thrown away. At least this is the case in my local district
- denton-scratch 4y agoI was impressed by this announcement. It was accompanied by reports of: * Teachers bringing in packed lunches for pupils who routinely arrived at school with none * Pupils pretending to have a packed lunch, because they didn't want to be stigmatized as poor because they got a free school meal You can't learn if you're hungry. Teachers can't teach if there's even a few hungry pupils in the class; they become disruptive. If everybody's fed, then everybody wins. The bureaucracy around means-tested benefits is itself costly; in some cases, it costs more than the marginal cost of making the benefit universal. These people are not "scroungers" - they're children under 8. It's common sense.
- nixlim 4y agoPrimary school here is until 12 (Year 6)
- denton-scratch 4y agoYeah, I checked that after posting; I was wrong. Thanks!
- machiaweliczny 4y agoGood to see some sane development. In no rich country should kids go hungry. We in Poland have 500PLN/month ($250 PPP) per kid and that’s very good program in my opinion. Free meals in schools were always there for poor kids but IMO it’s always rewards people who hide their income and disincentivises work so I like this universal approach better. I think we currently have dollar-for-dollar support, if you get some income you get less support which fixes some of issues with hard support line.
- nemo44x 4y agoIt’s amazing to me how mismanaged “the church” has been the last 60 or so years. This is the kind of thing they owned (feed poor people) for centuries as it legitimized their influence. You still see it in many parts of the world. It’s as if they became more obsessed with their own internal affairs and politics they didn’t bother to notice that a political wing was subverting them by taking their job. It’s no coincidence we see so much moralizing and other quasi-religious posture from them. They’ve been better managed then and have eaten the church’s lunch.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoI am an immigrant to Britain, and I am sad for Britain, and I am said about moving to Britain. It is really hard to describe. before I moved to Britain I thought it's a rich country, but actually it's a poor country with one rich city (London + Oxford/Cambridge) GDP of London is $66,000. Second biggest city in UK is Birmingham, has GDP per capita $30,000. I have wasted 10 years in that god-forsaken place. Birmingham is not unique, Manchester, Glasgow, and other big cities are withing ~15% error margin. Second biggest city in Germany is Hamburg, has GDP per capita $85,000. To find a city in Germany that is as poor as Birmingham, you have to go to the 4th poorest city, Oberhausen [1], population 200K, rank 59 by size and rank 104 by GDP. UK even loses comparison to post-soviet countries - Prague, Czech republic, GDP PP is $57,000, Double of Birmingham. Bratislava, Slovatia - $45,000. Warsaw, Poland - $32,000 And that's average. Then there are some truly god-forsaken places like North & East Ayrshire, has GDP €16,200. I don't even know how that's possible, Yakutia, Siberia has GDP of $18,000 Brexit vote was about stopping immigrants from getting in, British people do not realise they should be the ones getting out. You could hand an average non-london Britton a ticket to a random European capital their standard of living would improve. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German_cities_by_GDP#:~:text=List%20of%20German%20cities%20by%20GDP%20%20,%20%2094%2C190%20%2034%20more%20rows%20 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German_cities_by_GDP#:...
- jacooper 4y agoIt sounds you moved out, if so where to?
- ploppyploppy 4y agoYou speak of my country with disgust and it offends me. You know what's kept those wages outside London so low?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoI am sorry if any of it came across as disguist. I am feeling very compassionate to people that have suffered tremendous economic mismanagement. I have seen people get offended at the suggestion that maybe some 'lesser' fountries are doing better, and we can learn from them. Even compairing Britain to Poland was disrespectfull to them. > You know what's kept those wages outside London so low? My guess would be, lowest public investment in the regions in OECD? https://www.tuc.org.uk/news/uk-near-bottom-oecd-rankings-national-investment https://www.tuc.org.uk/news/uk-near-bottom-oecd-rankings-nat... Also 'native' white British poor people get treated like crap? Look at british TV shows - Benefit Street, Villabising poor people. Or how much educational outcomes are 70% predicted by parents income.