6 ms·
Workers’ Pay Globally Hasn’t Kept Up with Inflation
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoThis is obvious to anyone that works. What do we do about it?
- dontlaugh 4y agoThe threat of industrial action is a great motivator for employers. Unionising your workplace makes that threat possible.
- jjtheblunt 4y agodoes that work better than jumping to a preferable employer (assuming such is possible)?
- photonbeam 4y agoYes, it means they cant pick you off one by one, but have to negotiate against a group that has real leverage
- everforward 4y agoThat assumes everyone has that option. There's likely not enough "preferable employer" jobs for everyone to have one in many sectors. There's also a divide between tactics efficient at the individual level and that efficient at a national or global level. E.g. you can tell an individual they should be a doctor/lawyer/engineer/etc and that's good advice, but if everyone does it then who grows food and cleans floors and etc?
- ec2y 4y agoYou obviously don’t have my sucky union. The idiots let our agreement lapse over the pandemic and can’t their act together for a new one. (I’d suspect they were being union busted but I’m in Australia where unions are normal.)
- sudosysgen 4y agoThere are heavy limitations on union industrial action in Australia that make this sort of thing much more likely to happen. It's a tremendously contrived system and as a result Unions often up very chummy to the employer as elements which may be more amenable to confrontation can get frustrated with the immense complexity and difficulty that brings. Any kind of industrial action used for bargaining is almost impossible to get authorized. I'd say the Australian union system is one of the worst in the world, and most Australian unions are structurally busted.
- missedthecue 4y agoThis is why truckers (unionised) make a lot of money while software devs (nonunionised) scrape by
- kar5pt 4y agoHow do you put on pants in the morning?
- missedthecue 4y agoMy comment was facetious satire illustrating that productivity increases, not cartels, are the key to rising wages. I'm sorry it was difficult to understand.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoIn a place like SV what percentage of truckers have been laid off compared to software people? How many are really increasing productivity in the long run anyway? When you think about it, their own employers must be satisfied with the lower productivity of a smaller staff or they wouldn't be kicking people out. Edit: Not my downvote. Corrective upvote actually.
- zokula 4y ago[dead]
- wolongong942 4y agoAvoid careers that have been devalued to a greater extent by the following: • Women entering the work force • Immigration • Globalization
- x11vnc4life 4y agoVery Charlottesville 2017.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoGet involved with local politics. E.g. the internal party selection process for a candidate for a seat in the UK parliament may only involve a few hundred people - if that seat is safe (i.e. practically guaranteed to that party) then those few hundred effectively choose the representative, and so have a large voice in determining policy. (Ironically the one time I was one of the few hundred, our chosen candidate - who was excellent - got beaten by the Greens in an election upset)
- krageon 4y agoPolitics is all backroom stuff and old boy networks. You may get involved, but to even start influencing a little you will need many years of networking before you can ever get started. And statistically speaking, you are unlikely to succeed. Objectively it is the only advice that makes sense, but viewed from the individual it doesn't really yield any kind of solution.
- azmodeus 4y agoIf you organise yourself you can make an impact a group of 50-100 is easy to build and can achieve a lot. Once you build a group it's easier to network as well. This takes a lot of time and effort for 5-10 years. Don't defeat your voice, fight cynicism.
- pmyteh 4y agoThere is a certain amount of agency in UK parliamentary selections, but the leaderships of both major parties have (for a good while) been keen to limit that. I'm not saying that it's futile -- you'll certainly get a choice of candidates that the leaderships are happy with -- but I'm not sure it's a decent mechanism for achieving change anywhere except at the margins.
- SideQuark 4y agoDon't accept free money during a pandemic? Except that would be bad too..... Govt handouts during the pandemic added significant money without increased production to keep people afloat, which is good short term. The cost of that is inflation medium term. Long term wages rise to offset inflation. This has always been the pattern. Adding money for nothing to the system devalues each piece of money, so inflation is expected. Long term wages for context https://www.visualizingeconomics.com/blog/2008/05/04/average-income-in-the-united-states-1913-2006 https://www.visualizingeconomics.com/blog/2008/05/04/average...
- throwaway5959 4y agoI’m so tired of this nonsense. The checks cut, at least in the US, only barely added to peoples bank accounts and were for the most part quickly spent. Just look at excess savings, there was a brief spike and now it’s back lower than ever. Stop spreading this propaganda.
- adam_arthur 4y agoYou’re wrong. Excess savings is still elevated far above pre-pandemic trends. https://theovershoot.co/p/americas-excess-household-savings https://theovershoot.co/p/americas-excess-household-savings You’re likely referencing the savings rate, which is a different concept. This measures how much of newly earned income is saved, not how much excess savings somebody has in an absolute sense. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT Aside from savings, household credit is still below pre-pandemic trends in real terms, just touching the nominal trend recently.
- throwaway5959 4y ago> Americans liquidated more than $1 trillion of “excess” savings in 2022, eliminating more than half of the surplus accumulated since the pandemic began. Sounds like the problem is solving itself then?
- 4y ago
- olliej 4y agoDoes this surprise anyone?it’s amazing that companies are permitted to increase prices due to “inflation” but not simultaneously increase wages. But more importantly all these companies blaming inflation for prices increases but then reporting proportionately increased profits should be required to pay a recovery tax to bring their profit back down to pre “inflation” proportion. And of course this is all moot, because inflation calculation intentionally ignore anything that doesn’t impact corporations (cost of living, credit interest rates for individuals, etc), and does include things like interest rates that corporations receive.
- Natsu 4y agoWhat do you mean by "allowed"? Inflation happens because we print more money than there are goods to buy and all costs begin to rise because there's still only the same amount of stuff to go around, but more demand. You can mandate price fixing, but that just tends to cause death spirals where the cost of producing something rises above what you're allowed to charge, so you either keep producing and can't pay your own workers or you stop producing and there's no further supply at any price. Of course, the fact that this has played out before means that I know that people will just ignore the lessons from Brazil, Zimbabwe, etc. and screw themselves yet again because inflation solves political problems while causing real ones.
- gruez 4y ago> it’s amazing that companies are permitted to increase prices due to “inflation” but not simultaneously increase wages. The implied proposal sounds like a great way to get a wage-price spiral.
- hourago 4y agoThis is the main reason that Western society is radicalizing. Workers are fish in a smaller and smaller pond. Long term it is unsustainable, but like bubbles it is very difficult to predict when it will melt down. A healthy society needs to be fair. To work hard just to continue being poor, a part from cruel, will have long lasting political consequences. Some people will go to Communism, other to Fascism as left or right authoritarian regimes grow with people desperation. Things can get better, there are many good know ways of redistributing wealth and creating opportunity for younger generations. People deserves better.
- im_down_w_otp 4y agoAnother dimension besides just the economic outcomes is the constant appearance of normalized, or even celebrated, impropriety. There's no real accountability for exploiters and no meaningful restitution for the exploited in pretty much any domain. Institutions which advertise themselves as society's equalizers (e.g. "Nobody is above the law") regularly prove to be either nakedly inadequate in the best cases or even active promoters of predation in the worst cases. So people stop believing in the premise. Impartial institutions, or at least the believable perception of impartiality, is perhaps the most essential component to sustain "Western society". For example, I strongly suspect that if any real accountability and real restitution had followed in the wake of something like the 2008 financial crisis, we'd see a lot less radicalization today.
- rsa4046 4y ago> For example, I strongly suspect that if any real accountability and real restitution had followed in the wake of something like the 2008 financial crisis, we'd see a lot less radicalization today. Very much agree with this — an opportunity stupidly discarded.
- skfingngihg 4y agoObama parlayed it into a Netflix deal and donations to his favored causes. He used it, just not to help people.
- jasonjamerson 4y agoOf course. They said, "Oh, you want $15 /hr minimum wage? Cool we'll wait 5 years and cut the value of money in half while we pump the stock market. We'll still be rich and 15 will be 7.50."
- quacked 4y agoThe prices of goods in the reach of the bulk of potential consumers always conveniently remains enough that they have to work their whole lives to buy those goods. There's no real reason that for most people in the US a loaf of bread costs half an hour, and yet here we are. That's about how much it cost in 1950, too.
- bobolino123 4y agoI realized it some years ago that real estate in Switzerland and Germany is unattainable for younger workers without inheritance. Especially in Germany not only wages didn't keep up, the tax and security deduction kept increasing. Either I try a slow life (which many do), emigrate to the US, emigrate to a cheap country and work as freelancer and/or start a B2B SaaS business which would give me the most freedom. I always enjoyed building something cool, so of course I chose the entrepreneurial path. Side note: After over a year of nights + weekends and 96k SLoC later I'm finally ready to launch in the next 2 months, joining you lads :) tbh wealth isn't a motivator anymore, I just wanna help customers getting the most value if they use my SaaS.
- secretsatan 4y agoAt least in Switzerland, they try to keep the rents under control, one of the motivators for me to move from the UK was out control rent increases
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>Workers’ Pay Globally Hasn’t Kept Up with Inflation This is by design.
- SideQuark 4y agoYet wages generally do rise against inflation, otherwise we'd be as poor as we were in 1600, so this "by design" must not be true...... https://www.visualizingeconomics.com/blog/2008/05/04/average-income-in-the-united-states-1913-2006 https://www.visualizingeconomics.com/blog/2008/05/04/average...
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI would estimate in 1600 there were trades like bricklayers or wheelwrights who earned multiples of the average income, but comparable work today, even with overtime, is average or less. It didn't get that way overnight, one generation gives way to another, as in the graph. For example there were far different people enjoying the peaks to the right of Bill Clinton than there were suffering the downturns beforehand, which continued for so many. So the adjacent data there actually comes from two different places but it's the best generic income statistic we have. Looks like the professor has done a realistic job in his own way of rationalizing some moving targets through history and coming up with some figures that may be about as comparable as they can be over the decades. I can only imagine it took a lot of math to visualize this as meaningfully as it is. But remember it's the well-heeled people who bring the average up disproportionately more as the income disparity between high & low widens over the decades. If you consider a time when a dollar had been an ounce of silver like forever (about the left half of the chart), then made it through the Nixon & Reagan Recessions, you would have seen how the average person (not the average income) was too devastated to participate in very much of the upticks since those crushing years. But still subject to downticks being amplified to push them surely below the trough every time since. As the middle class, even the upper-middle class, had their wealth systematically removed by predatory forces that caused even more of a downward spiral in the average and below-average earners. Often dipping well beyond the belt-tightening of the '80's, while the well-to-do maintained their compensation during the same adversity, not much differently than they're doing now by declaring higher dividends. Keeping the high-rollers in position to exclusively benefit when it does turn around, leaving everyone else further behind each time. And in terms of "per Tax Unit", the left 2/3 of the graph is with one earner, but after that it's two different breadwinners for the most part. Even though these are legitimate statistics, and look as similarly adjusted for inflation as other experts, it can be definitely confirmed that average income alone, no matter how well adjusted, is not a very accurate indicator of how the income of the non-exceptional population has been devastated by inflation worse than average. From what we know now, or at least the way it appears. If they could only have half of their dollars paid to them in half ounces of silver, they'd surely be a lot better off, but probably still not where it should have been, before all these additional means of devaluing the currency became possible. Remember the way Bill Clinton was like when he started campaigning, it was the first contingent of overtime workers to have worked 20 years bringing in two incomes without getting ahead at all, compared to their fathers who had accomplished way more in their 20 years on one income. And there were even more younger people who recognized that the promise of employment just wasn't what it used to be, since at the time it looked more hopeless than ever going into the future. So one of his campaign promises was to grant $5000 to any American who would start their own business, employment hadn't been much hope for quite some time. By design you were supposed to get an ounce of silver for each dollar you worked for. That design changed long ago.
- krageon 4y ago"Inflation" is also measured ridiculously. Groceries and all utilities (basic and luxury) have become 50-100% more expensive but somehow the inflation is 8%? Not for anyone poor it isn't, for them it is 50% or more. I understand of course other parts of the market (stocks, perhaps other expensive things like cars and industrial equipment) have not experienced the same price increase and for this reason the inflation is measured as less. This is purely an academic difference for most people, who would not be encountering these products anyway.
- gruez 4y ago>Groceries and all utilities (basic and luxury) have become 50-100% more expensive but somehow the inflation is 8%? Where are you getting "50-100%" for "Groceries and all utilities"? The BLS is only reporting 11.3% for the "Food at home" category.
- neilwilson 4y agoThat's a tautology: workers pay not keeping up with price changes is how we stop inflation. Inflation is not enough stuff to go around. That loss has to be absorbed by people getting less. Either everybody gets a little less by wages not buying what they used to, or some people get a lot less by jobs and businesses disappearing. Ideally we'd just make more, but after two years of messing around with global supply chains, we've fundamentally damaged them so they no longer have excess capacity to supply. Like an overstretched spring, it won't just go back to where it was. It's going to take a while to get the virtuous spiral working again.
- black_13 4y ago[dead]