3 ms·
Why this infatuation with low Earth orbit? Why not put just few satelites further out, like every other satellite internet provide does except starlink? EDIT:
by scotty79 4y ago
Why this infatuation with low Earth orbit? Why not put just few satelites further out, like every other satellite internet provide does except starlink?
EDIT:
To people bringing up latency. Far away satellite has them far enough that they cover large area so the signal goes to satellite and back and that's it. Distance introduces latency.
But in case of constallation packet must bounce through multiple satellites and/or ground stations to arrive at the target so that introduces latency too. So it's usually not great either.
EDIT 2:
Never mind. Apparently Starlink manages to get pretty decent latency so far: https://blinqblinq.com/starlink-latency-and-ping-times/ https://blinqblinq.com/starlink-latency-and-ping-times/
The question reamins, if the goal is for the Europe to have a backup system for disasters such as armed conflict is the ping really key factor?
- 58028641 4y agoDoesn’t that have higher latency (further distance) and lower speeds (more users per satellite)?
- forrestthewoods 4y agoLatency
- renewedrebecca 4y agolatency.
- drewg123 4y agoAccording to https://frankrayal.com/2021/07/07/latency-in-leo-satellites-vs-terrestrial-fiber/ https://frankrayal.com/2021/07/07/latency-in-leo-satellites-..., GEO has about 20x the latency of LEO. I think this is why starlink is so much more usable than traditional satellite internet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mhandley 4y agoStarlink originally planned to put their first shell at 1100 km altitude. They changed to 550km for several reasons. First, because it offered slightly reduced latency. Second, so long as you launch enough satellites, the reduced coverage region for each satellite is offset by having more satellites and hence (other things being equal) more bandwidth per area of land. Third, satellites at 550 km will naturally deorbit in a few years if something fails. So although they plan to actively deorbit the first satellites after 6 or 7 years to replace them with newer ones, if they get something wrong and have a lot of satellite failures, they really won't cause a long term problem. At 1100 km the orbit won't decay for centuries. If you have satellites fail, the rest of the constellation will be doing avoidance maneouvers for a very long time. Thus if your launch costs are low enough and you can mass-produce satellites cheap enough, you want them as low as possible. Somewhere around 500 km is about as low as you want to go, before too much of the satellite mass ends up being fuel to maintain orbit.
- elif 4y agoThe constellation has direct line of sight while fiber follows crazy paths. Constellation /decreases/ not /increases/ latencu
- Gravityloss 4y agoThe van Allen radiation belt [1] starts at 650 km (and ends at 58,000 km). The satellites would probably have a shorter lifetime if they were higher. Since the speed of light is 300,000 km/s, adding 300 km adds one millisecond of delay, or 2 milliseconds to a roundtrip. Doesn't seem a lot for satellite internet? Geostationary orbit is at 36,000 km, then for lag that is indeed problematic as it's then 240 ms for a round trip. Still bearable. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Van_Allen_radiation_belt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Van_Allen_radiation_belt