6 ms·
Germany raises red flags about Palantir’s big data dragnet
- haspoken 4y agohttps://archive.is/aabRs https://archive.is/aabRs
- jwildeboer 4y agoSmall correction to the article: it is not „a top constitutional court“ it is THE top constitutional court. The German Bundesverfassungsgericht is the equivalent of the US Supreme Court.
- davidktr 4y agoFirst part yes, second part not quite. The US Supreme Court is the highest court for all legal matters, whereas the BVerfG only hears cases where constitutional matters are involved. In all other cases the branch courts like BGH for criminal and civil cases are the top courts. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oberster_Gerichtshof_der_Vereinigten_Staaten#Vergleich_mit_dem_deutschen_Bundesverfassungsgericht https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oberster_Gerichtshof_der_Verei...
- snowpid 4y agolinked letter to share holders by Palantine (https://www.palantir.com/newsroom/letters/letter-to-shareholders/november-7-2022/en/ https://www.palantir.com/newsroom/letters/letter-to-sharehol...) : "It has been our experience, however, that some countries, particularly in continental Europe, including Germany, have fallen behind the United States in their willingness and ability to implement enterprise software systems that challenge existing habits and modes of operation. There have been repeated attempts to build replicas of Silicon Valley in continental Europe, in Germany and elsewhere, but the results have been decidedly mixed. We have found that large institutions in the United States have been far more willing to investigate the most significant sources of systemic dysfunction within their organizations, which in the current moment often relate to the ability or rather inability of an institution to metabolize its own data." Honestly I feel the opposite in this high level description of cultural difference but it is the only rationalisation of the CEO who is very likely pissed off by data protection. Oh boy, at least they are honest in their arrogance.
- hef19898 4y agoWell, Palantir is a glorified spreadsheet provider whose only selling point is access to a ton of data its clients could not have otherwise. Their sales people are pretty good so, kind of the equivalent of the stereotypical IBM or SAP sales rep.
- kornhole 4y agoIt sounds like people using private Nextcloud servers is throwing a wrench in their machine.
- webdoodle 4y ago> linked letter to share holders by Palantine I think of Thiel and Karp that as Palpatine and Vadar too. ;)
- eyphka 4y agoI'm Swiss and American. Comparing culture is difficult, but limiting it to willingness to adopt software for large enterprise and adapt the business, I agree with the assessment. Ironically, the increased calcification of those large enterprise has lead in Europe, especially Germany, in markets where competition is possible, the very fast displacement of large enterprises by startups. E.g. n26
- mistrial9 4y agook but you are agreeing with a company that is enacting mass surveillance using new technology It seems that "slow" adoption is a feature no adoption sounds right to me
- t8sr 4y agoWeird, I am also mainly contrasting US and Swiss business culture, and I've come to the exact opposite conclusions. In Switzerland, every interaction with any large enterprise can be done entirely on your phone, fast, securely and conveniently. The SBB, the post office, the banks, the city of Zurich, the tax office - all of them let you do everything online. And unlike the US versions of these things, it actually works! The only thing you can't do online is vote, and that's probably a good thing.
- kornhole 4y agoMaybe we shouldn't be synching our contacts with government accessible cloud services such as Apple, Google, MS etc.
- lrem 4y agoFunny that you chose, of all things possible, the contact list as your example. You can safely assume that competent governments on both sides are aware of most forms of electronic communication, including pstn, email and all major chat services, as well as post, courier and similar services. With cell phone tracking, as well as the extensive video surveillance all over the place, they also have a pretty good idea of face to face communication. If you want to hide a contact from the government you don't disable cloud sync. You use direct radio. Or, if you don't want to attract attention by having said radio, you leave all electronics at home and meet deep in a forest.
- tenpies 4y agoIronically, I wonder if something like lettermail is now more secure. We do know that the exterior of every single piece of mail handled by the USPS is photographed, documented, and retrievable later[1]; but the content of the envelope seems like it may have some level of protection, if only because of the absurdly costly effort of opening and re-sealing in a way that doesn't reveal tampering. Throw in some level of cryptography, use cursive (so it's harder to OCR), and use code words, and you probably have something better than e-mail. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tracking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tra...
- nervysnail 4y agoIn addition to what 'lrem' said: Don't turn off your devices before going to the forest, as, if both persons don't create network traffic for, let's say five hours, then the government could derive that these persons are related. Of course this is not applicable if your threat model is low.
- photochemsyn 4y agoPalantir would have formed the core of both the Gestapo's and the STASI's population-monitoring programs, and perhaps Germany has had enough of that kind of thing?
- omnibrain 4y agoThat's more or less it. With the "Volkszählungsurteil" and varios judgements regarding "Rasterfahndung" and later "Schleierfahndung" and "Lauschangriff" our constitutional court constructed some sort of "basic human right to privacy" called "Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung" (right for informational self-determination). The judgements footed on various articles of our moder (post 1945) constitution and its bill of rights and indirectly in the experiences under NSDAP and SED rule.
- tg180 4y agoWhile reading the article I couldn't stop thinking that the new partnership with Crisis24, which is not irrelevant in the Konstanz tech scene, has contributed to making Palantir's data collection "less virtual" for the German DPAs.
- jonnybgood 4y agoPretty sure Germany uses Excel and variety of DBMS's. What do you think makes Palantir any different?
- johannes1234321 4y ago> variety of DBMS's. This is the key. Germany doesn't have a central citizen database or something like that, but each municipality has a system on their own. Any bad actor can't search through that to discriminate, deport or whatever people. This of course also leads to problems like paying out corona support money to students still isn't completely done etc. Palantir tries to create an Über-Database.
- mclightning 4y agoLarge-scale immediate query-ability.
- jackmott 4y agoIts pretty gross that tech people look up to this company and its founder. We should be doing everything we can to bring them down. This company led by a man who regrets that women got the vote and that apartheid ended in south africa and runs a company that helps governments spy on citizens. He also helped trumps insurrection attempt while readying himself to bail out to new zealand in case whatever sick experiment he had in mind didn’t work out to his advantage. nevermind if the rest of us plebs die.
- LightDub 4y ago[flagged]
- itronitron 4y agoI don't know any tech people that look up to this company or its founder.
- morpheuskafka 4y agoIt's just a strange feeling to be browsing LinkedIn and see a job pop up for a company like this. Almost like it's an ad to work for the Nazi party or something. Like do people just click on these, read the description, and apply for the job without a second thought of what it is they actually do? It's not even like the military or three-letter agencies that can claim to be serving their own country, it's just a for-profit enterprise that will serve any government that hires them.
- TotempaaltJ 4y ago> it's just a for-profit enterprise that will serve any government that hires them. Palantir does only work with "Western-aligned" governments, so this isn't quite true. > Palantir Technologies CEO Alex Karp says that employees unhappy with the company’s mission—or its dealings with Western governments and militaries—should leave. > > “We want people who want to be on the side of the West, making the West a better society,” Karp said on Wednesday at an event for the World Economic Forum, continuing that Palantir “may not be your cup of tea.” https://fortune.com/2023/01/19/palantir-ceo-alex-karp-world-economic-forum-dont-work-here/ https://fortune.com/2023/01/19/palantir-ceo-alex-karp-world-...
- zo1 4y agoI don't want to be "that guy", but is this the same Germany that arrests people over social media posts because of "hate speech"? It's the first thing that popped into my head after reading the headline. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/23/technology/germany-internet-speech-arrest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/23/technology/germany-intern... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_by_country#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_by_country#Ge... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung
- elkos 4y agoOne has to take into account the historical and cultural background of such laws. The analysis of public and personal data by the government in a massive scale was also part of that cultural and historical background.
- nervysnail 4y agoYea, for their ancestors may have once killed millions. And that this ancestor ideology is not to be revived/resurrected in order for their country to not kill millions more. When you drink bleach and feel bad, you don't drink it again, yes? Then, it follows, you have to take precautions. Not everyone should follow an American understanding of things, in this case, the First Amendment.
- Smoosh 4y agoAmazing how American Freedom™ doesn't extend to self-determination.
- dean177 4y ago“A court has issued strict limits on how police can pull innocent bystanders into big data investigations”
- LightDub 4y agoAbout time. Dragnet the dragnets.