6 ms·
I have a lot of respect for Carter. Not only did he really seem interested in world peace instead of the warmongering from the MIC, he also remained active for
by wkat4242 4y ago
I have a lot of respect for Carter. Not only did he really seem interested in world peace instead of the warmongering from the MIC, he also remained active for all these years furthering humanitarian causes. And he was a brilliant nuclear engineer who cleaned up a nuclear accident with this team in Canada.
I know he wasn't popular in the US which I don't really understand. It sounds to me like he fought the vested big money interests too much and they campaigned against him. I'm a European though and as such I don't know a lot about his domestic policies. Perhaps those were not as well received as his international leadership.
But I'm very sure that if most world leaders were like him, the world would be a much better place.
I'm very sad to hear he's in a hospice now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fortran77 4y ago[flagged]
- code_runner 4y agoCan you elaborate a bit on this claim?
- fortran77 4y agohttps://www.adl.org/resources/news/anti-semitic-reactions-jimmy-carters-book-white-supremacists https://www.adl.org/resources/news/anti-semitic-reactions-ji...
- coin 4y agoOpinion piece from the Anti-Defamation League, not the most neutral source
- vore 4y agoThe ADL has a stunningly broad definition of anti-Semitism. They claim they draw a distinction between criticism of the Israeli government vs the Jewish people, but they do not allow much daylight between the two. Criticism of Israeli government actions against Palestinians is actually denying Israeli self-determination which is actually anti-Semitism, sorry!
- cldellow 4y agoThat link doesn't seem to support your claim that Carter wants to erase Israel. The link describes what a bunch of white supremacists think about the book. Some (many?) of them likely haven't read it, and are reacting to the title alone. I will admit that I also haven't read it. But I know it contains this paragraph: > The security of Israel must be guaranteed. The Arabs must acknowledge openly and specifically that Israel is a reality and has a right to exist in peace, behind secure and recognized borders, and with a firm Arab pledge to terminate any further acts of violence against the legally constituted nation of Israel. That doesn't sound like erasing to me?
- joshuamorton 4y agoQuoting stormfront isn't particularly convincing about Carter's views, and given that a quick jaunt to the Wikipedia article shows Carter stating he fully supports Israel and that it's a "wonderful democracy" makes me wonder what you're talking about. Carter's views can't even be called antizionist. He plainly supports Israel's right to exist.
- klabb3 4y agoI agree, this line of rhetoric (look, the extremists agree with this, therefore it’s wrong and you’re reprehensible for even entertaining the thought) is deserving of a hall of fame in terms of logical fallacies. It’s an obviously incomplete proxy for morality, and can be weaponized to create all kinds of absurd conclusions, including new forms of extremism. However, it’s a dominant rhetorical strategy today, that many are guilty of. I don’t know how much is deliberate short term “winning the argument” vs how much people genuinely believe it, but it’s unfortunate for the majority of people who want to discuss issues under civil conditions. The second order effects are concerning, because this leaves public debate (ironically) to extremists, narcissists and manipulators.
- rocket_surgeron 4y ago[flagged]
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoGreat person but he was unpopular as a president at the time because he failed to stop high inflation and to resolve the Iranian hostage crisis. The latter especially sunk his chances of re-election. So much of politics is about what happens when you’re in office, but also how you deal with what happens.
- syzarian 4y agoWhat I don’t understand about narrative that Carter failed on Iran is that Regan never got enough blame for blatantly violating U.S. laws and negotiated with Iran despite saying we don’t negotiate with hostage takers. Carter got far too much blame and Reagan far too little. https://www.vox.com/2016/1/25/10826056/reagan-iran-hostage-negotiation https://www.vox.com/2016/1/25/10826056/reagan-iran-hostage-n...
- krapp 4y agoTo put it simply, winners write the history, and Reagan's influence on American politics and culture far outstripped Carter.
- michaelscott 4y agoReagan played the political game far better than both Carter and Nixon (Watergate notwithstanding). He was a master at couching effective foreign policy tactics, which often relied on detente (eg negotiating with Iran), within the augur of American values and exceptionalism that spoke to the people of the time ("we don't negotiate with hostage takers"). The former was critical to actually get things done, but a president has to realise that the latter is just as critical because you need that public support to get the former through the door.
- refurb 4y agoPretty much this. As much as people hate politics, its the politicians who can work thr system that are the most effective. Image is important because thats what maintains support, but you also need to be pragmatic at the same time and do things that might lose you support because voters dont understand the trade offs.
- coin 4y ago> really seem interested in world peace Definitely. He returned the Panama Canal to Panama because it's the right thing to do despite perhaps not being in the US' best interest. He advocated Palestine's rights despite all the resistance from the pro-Israel community.
- oxfeed65261 4y agoApparently my grandfather had a bumper sticker, “Keep the canal, give ‘em Carter.”
- candiddevmike 4y agoSeems so subtle and nuanced compared to FJB and other slogans you see today.
- starkd 4y agoIt only becomes nuanced when it gets framed by a historical context, when we can look back and explain it all. Carter has mellowed a lot over the years. He was a very young president. At the time, one of the chief complaints about his white house was that it was rudderless, that it lacked leadership. He gave an infamous speech where he described the country as being in a malaise.
- mc32 4y agoThis is true, but crassness has permeated the public arena. Online, radio, TV, even print media, so it's not surprise to see it on bumper stickers announcing the politician partisans deeply dislike.
- chx 4y agoHe also signed SALT-II which got never ratified and returned the Hungarian Crown to Hungary (which was a Soviet satellite at the time). https://hu.usembassy.gov/embassy/budapest/embassy-history/return-holy-crown-st-stephen/ https://hu.usembassy.gov/embassy/budapest/embassy-history/re...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lenzm 4y agoI think the general image of him is that he was a good person, perhaps the "best" to ever hold the office, but was not effective as President. That he was idealistic, naive and impractical. I don't necessarily agree with the above and he was before my time.
- Miraste 4y agoHe was unpopular for a number of other reasons, some of which were just bad luck. Inflation was high, the economy was poor, there was a massive oil shortage, and the Iranian hostage crisis went poorly. There were a lot of smaller issues too, like the 55mph speed limit. While he had good intentions and was far more forward thinking than other presidents, he wasn’t an adept administrator and didn’t manage to get buy-in on any of his plans. It’s another sad instance of good people making bad politicians.
- incanus77 4y ago> he wasn’t an adept administrator I can't find too much on this now except for the fact it happened, but initially Carter decided to buck tradition and not have a chief of staff, preferring instead a more level cabinet that could come to him as needed. I can't remember where I heard/read/saw this analysis, but it was cited as a major faux pas which led to him being completely inundated with competing priorities. The office of president is much more complex than that of the governorship of even a large state, and not having a trusted chief of staff who could help Carter prioritize led to a more ineffectual office.
- starkd 4y agoThere were stories of him personally doing scheduling charts for the White House Staff. That probably was an exageration that did not happen that often, but he was a technocrat. He loved getting involved in details. More evidence that engineers generally make poor politicians.
- snapetom 4y agoChris Matthews touches on this and other examples in Hardball. Carter is a great man, but just wasn't a very suave politician. Another example Matthews cites was getting rid of the presidential yacht. Sure it made for a few good public points, but it handicapped Carter in losing a historically valuable tool for many informal handshake political deals.
- JJMcJ 4y agoThe idea of a Cabinet that had direct and easy access to the President made sense when there were four or five people, as was the case early in American history. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/21/Top_Left_Cabinet_Image.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/21/Top_Left... C. Northcote Parkinson, of Parkinson's Law fame, has written on this, both in British and American history. The inner council seems to grow and is replaced as the leader's inner council by a smaller body over time.
- whats_a_quasar 4y agoUnless you have sources, I don't think there's much evidence either that he fought big money or was driven out of office by them. He lost primarily because the economy was bad in the second half of his term, with inflation and oil supply shocks. Also, his adminstration botched the handling of the Iranian revolution, which lead to the hostage crisis, a huge public debacle. He was a competent president, but not flashy, and presidents are not guaranteed a second term. So I don't think we need to imagine shadowy corporate interests to explain the election
- wkat4242 4y agoIt was mainly my thought because I noticed he campaigned against the space shuttle and other big projects (though eventually he turned on this for disarmament reasons, Ars Technica had an article on this a couple weeks ago). But you're right, it's more how I imagine American politics than anything else.
- wefarrell 4y agoPersonally I don’t think the US should ever be expected to handle any foreign revolutions.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a not-unreasonable position without context, but I think the American public reasonably expects the American president to handle foreign revolutions vis-a-vis hostage taking.
- peteforde 4y agoThat's a tricky position to hold, because they keep doin' them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wIOqHSsV9c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wIOqHSsV9c
- blululu 4y agoThe Iranian revolution was not a big issue in the election. It was the fact that American embassy staff was held at gunpoint for nearly two years so they could put the Shah on Trial. People were not happy about that.
- mhb 4y agohe was a brilliant nuclear engineer There are some other views about that: "He started nuclear power school (a six month course of study that leads to operator training) in March, 1953. In July 1953, his father passed away and he resigned his commission to run the family peanut farm." https://atomicinsights.com/jimmy-carter-never-served-nuclear-submarine/ https://atomicinsights.com/jimmy-carter-never-served-nuclear...
- voz_ 4y ago> I know he wasn't popular in the US which I don't really understand. Note, these are not my opinions, but I am going to seek to answer this based on the things I have read on him. In short, the general opinion is that he was a weak, pitiful, activist president. His overtures toward peace, anti-imperialism, humanitarian causes were laden with activism rhetoric that one would normally use if they were outside the structures of power. Once one is within the structure of power, then one is expected to speak less, and do more. Consider a parallel story of outspoken-activist-turned-president Theodore Roosevelt, speak softly and carry a big stick and all that. Carter spoke loudly and forgot his stick. This, combined with a perceived lack of policy and agenda, on top of a time of various crises, made him look rather unfit for the job. Again, please remember that this is the summary of a general stance many hold. I was not yet alive and so cannot necessarily speak to the zeitgeist of the time, firsthand. My personal opinion is that, if you squint, his presidency is a lot like that of Trump, in that his presidency lacked a focus and tried, and rather failed, to react to events at the time. And of course, rather different in that he was not a corrupt buffoon. To expand on this, I actually think that if we waved a magic what-if wand, and got Carter today, he would be hailed as a fantastic president, if only by comparison, so you know, context matters.
- yyyk 4y ago>My personal opinion is that, if you squint, his [Carter's] presidency is a lot like that of Trump The parallel goes further. Both of these presidents initiated a very different economic policy, and this was expanded on by the succeeding president despite the successor being a standard bearer of the other party: * Carter initiated deregulation and appointed Volcker to the Fed. * Trump initiated China tariffs and decoupling, and was leery of trade deals in general. Another parallel is the unique foreign policy both had compared to their 'ordinary' successor. e.g. I don't think any other President would have been so supportive of Mugabe like Carter was.
- voz_ 4y agoPresidency as an outsider art, perhaps?
- 4y ago
- woodruffw 4y agoMost US presidents (with a few conspicuous exceptions) experience post-presidential "glow": they become folksy pater familarum in the public's eye. Carter has experienced this more than most, in parts because (1) he's lived longer than every other president to have left office, and (2) he was widely perceived as being kind and genteel, too kind and genteel, while in office. Carter seems to be a genuinely good and kind human being, but his actual domestic legacy is mostly mediocre. His greatest achievement on the domestic side is probably establishing the Department of Education (no mean feat!).
- mikeyouse 4y agoMeh.. the majority of the deregulation that Reagan is credited with actually happened under Carter (craft beer, trucking, airlines, oil, nuclear, natural gas), he appointed Volcker specifically to beat inflation who then spiked rates to 17% which caused the slowdown that likely contributed to Carter's reelection loss.. Noah Smith has a good post on the topic: https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/much-of-what-youve-heard-about-carter https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/much-of-what-youve-heard-a...
- woodruffw 4y agoYep. Carter's folksy image obscures a lot of his domestic agenda in the American memory, but he was an economically conservative Democrat.
- quercusa 4y agoAre there any current national Democrats who would be to the right of Carter?
- woodruffw 4y agoEconomically, most national Democrats are about as conservative as Carter, if not further right. Carter is in many ways the progenitor of the neoliberal wing of the DNC; he brought back Progressive Era views that had previously been sidelined by the New Deal. Socially, Carter is some probably slightly left of the DNC’s national position.
- digianarchist 4y agoThe Carter administration was certainly better than others when it came to foreign-policy but he still authorized and funded Operation Cyclone [0]. To say that he was interested in world peace is pure revisionism. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone
- boomboomsubban 4y agoWhile he definitely deserves blame for the project starting under his watch, he still did far less with it than Reagan. >Funding officially began with $695,000 in mid-1979,[3] was increased dramatically to $20–$30 million per year in 1980, and rose to $630 million per year in 1987 His total funding of it was around 5% of what the Reagan administration spent in one of it's eleven years funding it.
- nivenkos 4y agoHe funded and armed the Mujahideen in Operation Cyclone though - which has literally caused endless trouble with the rise of radical Islam. So it wasn't all "world peace".
- wkat4242 4y agoTrue, but this is something that could have gone both ways. It could easily have led to an enlightened movement as well. At he time the Mudjahedeen were very much in the "good guys" book.
- rtkwe 4y agoHow much of that was the US's Cold War classic evaluation where Anti-Communist seems to vastly dominate any other consideration in the decision of who to back? Just look at the dictators and death squads we actively trained here in South and Central America.
- Dudeman112 4y ago>At he time the Mudjahedeen were very much in the "good guys" book At the time the dictatorship back home was also very much in the "good guys" book according to the USA Starting to think they are just shit a selecting who to put in that book Fuck Operation Condor
- ponzimechanic 4y agoNo. Zbigniew Brzezinski said in a French magazine interview that they purposely baited the Soviets into invading Afghanistan to give them their own Vietnam. In the late 90s, Zbigniew said that it was worth Al Qaeda’s rise by saying something like it was better to end the Soviet Union than to have a few pissed off Muslim terrorists. Of course, Zbigniew’s partner David Rockefeller was accused of propping up Carter as the Trilateral’s candidate. There’s derisive articles about it in the NY Times.
- calgarymicro 4y agoWorth noting that Brzezinski repeatedly denied making that quote, and the author admitted to fabricating parts of the article.
- derbOac 4y agoI think there's been a gradual reassessment of him over the years in the US. I'm not saying everyone sees him as a fantastic president, or that they necessarily should, but my sense is that he's seen more positively now than he was at one time.
- blululu 4y agoThe cards were stacked against him. The legacy of Vietnam and the Yom Kippur War led to a massive debt, and an oil embargo from OPEC. This led to high inflation, high unemployment and constrained federal budgets for the first time in ~40 years. Arguably he saw the correct way out through innovation and American energy independence but the technology wasn't there yet and the electorate had little stomach dealing with high unemployment and high inflation through austerity for the length of time needed. He was also perhaps too principled for Washington politics, and he routinely got his ass handed to him by his own party in Congress which had no desire to curb spending on even the most obviously wasteful programs. But these are all excuses and as President you don't really get to make excuses. As much as I admire and respect the man and support his vision for America, the reality is things just didn't work out for him as president.
- emmelaich 4y ago> brilliant nuclear engineer Was he though? He did a B.Sc. and then "nuclear power school, a six-month non-credit course" which he did not finish (through no fault of his own). The course was started after the clean-up in Canada.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yyyk 4y ago* Initiated deregulation and an inflation-hawkish Fed. * Very dubious energy policies - which were not dominated by environmentalism but by the search for alternate fossil fuel sources, all of them way more polluting than conventional fossil fuels. * Mixed foreign policy record, failing badly in on Iran and Zimbabwe but helping with Egypt-Israel peace.
- starkd 4y agoHe was a very young president, and since he had an engineering background, he tended to get stuck in the weeds. There are stories of him micro-managing affairs, involving himself in affairs that should have been left to low-level staff. And he had a terrible speaking ability. It was not uncommon to walk away from his comments not knowing just what he had said. As with many, he has mellowed with age. His humanitarian efforts post-administration are probably the best summation of the man. While his policies were deeply unpopular, it is notable he is one of the last presidents not to sell out the white house after he left office. He still lives in a relatively modest home.
- sammalloy 4y ago> And he had a terrible speaking ability. It was not uncommon to walk away from his comments not knowing just what he had said. I’ve listened to hours of Carter talking and never once had this impression.
- starkd 4y agoYou are very much in the minority. There were many jokes about Carter at the time. Many comedians did impressions of him. He was not known for his great oratory. He was often referred to as a technocrat.
- sammalloy 4y agoI was around at the time and I’ve read the literature since that era. I don’t recall such criticism and I’ve never read anything criticizing his oratory skills.
- starkd 4y agoInteresting. Your memory obviously is very different, but I remember Dan Akroyd did impressions of him on SNL. A very monotone delivery was very characteristic, only to be outdone by Mondale.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI liked him (am American). He tried to bring the Metric system to the U.S., as en example. I have a hilarious road trip Kodak photo from the 70's where our family are standing in front of a sign at some mountain pass in the Rocky Mountains and the sign gives the elevation in both feet and meters. A recent Google street-view I found for the same location shows elevation in feet only. To hell with Reagan.
- rco8786 4y agoHis popularity grew quite a bit after his presidential term, to be fair. I wasn’t around during his leadership so I can’t comment on what that was like. But he’s quite obviously a generous, honest, genuinely good human.
- starkd 4y agoThere is a lot to complain about him, but it is notable that he was one of the last presidents to not sell himself out after leaving office. He still lives in a relatively modest home in Georgia. Clinton, Gore and Obama all became mega millionaires within a few short years of leaving office. What are they paying them for? Carter never sullied himself, and for that, he deserves respect.
- stevespang 4y ago[dead]
- throwawaysleep 4y agoHe failed to deal with Iran.
- rawgabbit 4y agoCarter was a good man but a poor president. The US was rocked by years of inflation brought on by the oil crises (Arabs embargoed USA for supporting Israel) and deficit spending (Vietnam War). The average citizen did not believe Carter had any solution to the economic turmoil. With hindsight, we can debate if Reaganomics actually worked; but that is besides the point. The voters believed in it; unfortunately, they didn't believe in Carter. You can contrast this with FDR who was president during the Great Depression. FDR was more pragmatic. He said he was willing to try anything if it helped the average American. That was what voters wanted to hear. About FDR, one of America's most successful presidents. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/03/04/how-the-deal-went-down https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/03/04/how-the-deal-w... Roosevelt was neither self-reflective nor a deep thinker voters trusted Roosevelt to lead the country through eight years of economic desolation As Kennedy emphasizes in “Freedom from Fear,” there was no master plan, no guiding philosophy, for the reforms that Roosevelt oversaw. Some were his idea; some were Congress’s; some were left over from the Hoover Administration. Roosevelt was >>improvising<<.
- dgeiser13 4y agoI was 10 years old when Jimmy Carter took office and he's always been popular with me.