6 ms·
How Your Metabolism slows down when you try to lose weight
- jonahbenton 4y agoIncredibly stupid study. 800 calories a day is not a diet, it is starvation. Of course metabolic rate is going to slow way down.
- jjeaff 4y agoI think it has more to do with how fast you lose it than how few calories you eat. The Biggest Loser contestants ate 1200-1500 calorie diets and still had abnormally low BMR even 5-10 years out.
- kuhewa 4y agoYou've mentioned the biggest loser study a few times, but my understanding is the metabolic adaptation of BMR is thought to be due to their dramatic increase in physical activity, not just the caloric restriction https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/oby.23308 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/oby.23308
- jjeaff 4y agoYes, that is what I was referring to. Although I think it was though to have more to do with the dramatic weight loss rather than the increase in physical activity or caloric restriction. 1200-1500 calories is a very reasonable daily restriction.
- jjeaff 4y agoI'm glad to see there is more research getting publicity for things like this. There are a lot of people out there that have never dealt with trying to lose a lot of weight who think it's all just as simple as "calories in and calories out", "it's the first law of thermodynamics, man!" It's like saying that running a marathon is easy, just keep running and don't stop! It is so much more complex and there are a lot of factors and more variation between people than many realize. Obesity is a true epidemic and over simplifying the problem is not helping us solve it.
- goostavos 4y agoThere is only calories in and calories out. Did you go a week without losing any weight? You consumed too many calories. Whether you chalk that up to "muh metabolism" or some kind of magical universe defying intervention, the end result is that you consumed to many calories to lose weight. Dial things back by 500 and see what the scale says next week. No amount of mocking "the first law of thermodynamics, man" makes it not true. For everyone complaining about the complexity of losing weight, the gym bros just keep weighing out their chicken and broccoli to great result.
- zxienin 4y agoNot all calories are equal. Calories from carb rich food are metabolized different than calories from “healthy“ fat rich food. Metabolism of former also raises insulin + glucose in blood stream, which influences obesity more than later.
- jjeaff 4y agoNot to mention how different foods might affect different hormone levels and even the microbiome in your gut which seems to have a lot of affect on the brain as well as other systems.
- kuhewa 4y agoThe only way those differences really matter, as long as you are getting enough protein that you arent catabolizing muscle mass, is in what they do to how much you eat and perhaps exercise. Even if an insulin spike makes you crave junk food and not want to go for a walk, it's all still CICO to more than a first approximation.
- jjeaff 4y agoSee, you are a perfect example of what I was talking about. You seem to know just enough to be very confident in what you are saying, but you are very, very wrong. Another user in an above thread lays out some of the minutia that comes into play. Calories in: What kind of calories? When you eat them, how fast you cut them, how your body reacts to the restriction, how your gut biome reacts, how your brain and willpower reacts, how your family and friends react.... Calories out: what is your actual resting burn, how does that change as you adjust calories in, how does it change as you adjust the type of calories in, how does your resting burn react long term to weight loss.... It's as simple as calories in, calories out, just like the theory of relativity is as simple as e=mc2.
- zxienin 4y agoI started reading and listening to Jason Fung’s explanation of body internal system [1]. What actually influences weight is hormonal cycles. I am experiencing positive results so far, working on this explanation. Take steps to reduce not only amount of insulin presence in blood stream, but reduce its sustained presence. Reduce visceral fat. The problem is solved by mix of correct nutrition, moderate physical lifestyle and intermittent fasting. Never by “dieting” or sustained calorific deficit. Fasting should not be primarily thought of as reducing calories. Rather as creating longer gap inside body without insulin running though blood stream and toggling body to use fat as metabolism source. Weight loss (from fat reduction, not muscle) is secondary benefit. [1] https://youtu.be/RL8x7FTSo-Y https://youtu.be/RL8x7FTSo-Y
- kuhewa 4y agoThe only way those interventions work though is because their net result is less calories consumed versus expended. It's cool if that works for you, but if you've lost weight you very much have sustained a caloric deficit.
- zxienin 4y agoThis [1] presentation by Robert Lustig is dense packed with quality insights. Surrounding daily life with sugar, carbs is the root. [1] https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM
- steve1977 4y agoWell yes, if I was 110 kg and go down to 80 kg, then my BMR will go down of course, as there is “less body” to support so to speak.
- jjeaff 4y agoYes, but how much will it go down? Will it go down proportionally? What more and more studies are finding is that it goes down very significantly and can stay very low for many years, making it near impossible to keep weight off. The "Biggest Loser" study found that many of the people who lost weight on the show had a BMR much lower than other people of similar characteristics, but who had always been that size. In other words, many times, the smug skinny person saying it's as simple as "calories in / calories out" doesn't realize that the people they are preaching to have to eat fewer calories and/or workout more than the lifelong skinny person has ever had to just to maintain a similar weight. Simply because at some point in their life, even 5-10 years prior, they were once overweight.
- steve1977 4y agoIn my personal experience, yes it does go down quite a bit. But I also wonder if having a lower than average BMR to begin with predisposes to becoming overweight. To make matters worse, how much you burn during exercise goes down substantially as well. But in the end, the only thing I found for myself to work is to always track my weight and what I eat. So I’m always in control basically, no matter if my BMR is average or lower (or higher). And that’s all that counts at the end of the day.
- kuhewa 4y agoThat's it, and some of the coverage of the biggest loser followups I simply find hard to believe, like one contestant years later having to limit food to 800 cal a day to maintain a healthy weight. I'll be my life savings that wouldn't be borne out if they put the patient in a metabolic ward and actually measured expenditure.
- cosmin800 4y agoOld news, more low quality posts.
- meetingthrower 4y agoThis was one of my hopes for the new "weight loss drugs" like smeglitude, etc. But in reading about them they don't seem to act on metabolic rate, but just really cut the desire to eat food. So they work by calorie restriction at the end of the day vs actually changing metabolism? Am I wrong here? After reading the reviews of the drug, I decided to just do calorie counting of everything entering my mouth. Down 20 pounds so far in a month or so...
- kuhewa 4y agoThings that change your actual metabolic rate are scarier. Like DNP. Ultimately the increased calorie expenditure needs to be spent somewhere and if it isn't just heat then it would have be be a large increase in NEEE (i.e. you get jittery) or I dunno, maybe you just get the compulsion to go on runs or do chores or just perfuntory tasks (like meth heads)
- grwthckrmstr 4y agoFor weight loss, through a decade of research and trial and error, here's what I have found. - eat more than your BMR (basal metabolic rate) but less than your TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) in order to maintain your BMR as you lose weight - the gap between BMR and TDEE can be increased with exercise - cardio burns calories but weight/resistance training helps build/maintain muscle mass as one's body drops weight, hopefully more from fats - every week or so, resetting one's system by eating a very high calorie or carb heavy meal helps jolt the system as well as one's mindset. I personally find it easy to stick to good eating habits if I eat like shit once a week (on purpose, rather than accident).