6 ms·
Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger
- jerry1979 4y ago> Water samples on Friday showed the plume is now completely gone, DeWine said. I saw an unverified video linked on reddit that alleged to show that the contaminants sink to the bottom of water [1]. Could this be the reason why the water does not appear contaminated? [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/11480zm/east_palestine_oh_water_condition/ https://old.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/11480zm/east_palest...
- vore 4y agoI don't mean to downplay the disaster, but just because there's a sheen that appears when disturbing the creekbed doesn't indicate it's a result of the contamination from the disaster or even petroleum-related contamination at all: for instance, bacteria can form a similar oil-like sheen on water. I don't think it's possible to conclude anything without sampling the water, and definitely not from a video of someone just stirring up the water. (as also mentioned in the Reddit comments, the fact that the Twitter poster is a staunch North Korea supporter should make people evaluate the context of this video a little more critically -- I don't mean they can't be right, but they are at least pushing this with a certain agenda)
- icelancer 4y agoThe other person who posted a viral video of the water with an oil-like sheen was US Senator JD Vance, who is... ahh... well, basically the furthest thing from what the other Twitter poster put out.
- gruez 4y agoHorseshoe theory. Both the extreme left and the extreme right has reason to doubt/oppose the current political establishment.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThe nice thing about extremists is that they're sufficiently non-invested in making the status quo look good that they're happy to point out when it's shit. Frankly I really like the extremists on both sides of the isle. While I might vehemently disagree with them on specifics they are at least generally principled people who derive their policy positions from their beliefs logically and I have respect for that.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBut they'll also happily claim that the status quo is terrible even when it is in fact objectively quite good. Re your second paragraph: Things that logically derive from insane starting points can still be insane. Often are, in fact. When they are right, they are right only by random accident. I'm not saying "don't read them", but don't use what they say to adjust your priors very much.
- andsoitis 4y ago> While I might vehemently disagree with them on specifics they are at least generally principled people Being so staunchly principled that you cannot compromise or be practical or be open to have your mind changed is not a virtue, in my mind. If anything it is arrogant. > who derive their policy positions from their beliefs logically and I have respect for that. Outcomes are more important. If your beliefs are abhorrent then your policies will follow. That is not something to admire.
- ericmay 4y agoYes but being principled to the point that you do obviously stupid things isn’t good, and it’s even worse when idealogical zealots seize hold of power. We want people to poke holes in things which is what I think you were getting at, but they should be nowhere near anything serious.
- myko 4y agoInterestingly the GOP is the "extreme right" in the US, where the Democratic party is primarily centrist/center right folks. Makes for really weird inter-party interactions within the Democrats.
- vore 4y agoJD Vance has a similar motivation for making the current administration take the flak for it, so I would also take him with a grain of salt.
- newsclues 4y agoThe government should want to do testing and prove Vance to be a conspiracy loony then right?
- vore 4y agoOf course. I don't doubt the scale of the disaster but it's very easy in the face of uncertainty for anyone to jump to conclusions without doing their due diligence, either due to some agenda or just inadvertently.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- briandear 4y agoThe Air Traffic Control meltdown we’re seeing (ask any airline pilot about the vaccine mandate’s effect on ATC and pilot early retirement/staffing) the shipping port mess in 2021, continuing supply chain transport issues, seemingly frequent train crashes — Shouldn’t Buttigieg be taking flak? The FAA budget for example stated a priority for “equity” and inclusion. Shouldn’t the priority be air fucking safety? The FAA is a mess right now. And it’s Buttigieg’s fault. But at least we were able to spend millions changing “airmen” to “air missions” in the NOTAM system — all while doing nothing to actually fix the NOTAM system. Now the FAA also wants to stop people from using the term “cockpit” — not realizing that there is nothing in the history of that word that is “gendered.” Just stupidity and madness. JD Vance is right to hammer the administration: while DoT is worrying about gendered language, trains are derailing with toxic chemicals and planes are nearly crashing because of faulty ATC. https://aerocorner.com/blog/why-is-cockpit-called-cockpit/ https://aerocorner.com/blog/why-is-cockpit-called-cockpit/
- hanselot 4y agoI'm not trying to be unreasonable but if this was a school shooting everyone would be calling for the ban of all guns. The scale of this is vastly greater, yet the reaction is just unfathomable to me given the scale of this disaster. Again, not trying to stir anything. Just an observation.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> The scale of this is vastly greater The probable human deaths from this spill is a number somewhere between zero and 10 over decades. That's a massive difference from a mass-casualty shooting.
- newsclues 4y agoDoes that count the people that may die early of cancer in decades to come?
- shadowgovt 4y agoYes. The carcinogenic effects of acute exposure to vinyl chloride are low, and most of it was burned off intentionally by setting the train cars on fire. Those most at risk are the first responders; everyone who heeded the evacuation order should be pretty much fine.
- TrispusAttucks 4y agoBurning vinyl chlorine turns it into phosgene. The deadliest chemical weapon from WW1. I'd say there's some risk involved. https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2023/02/17/was-vinyl-chloride-used-in-world-war-i-wwi-and-what-does-it-do-to-the-body/ https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2023/02/17/was-vinyl-chloride-use...
- shadowgovt 4y agoSome risk, yes, which is why I mentioned the first responders, as they were closest to the burn itself. Phosgene breaks down in the environment on timescales measured from hours to days. The five-day evac window was more than enough to remove all appreciable amounts of phosgene from the environment. And given how reactive it is, you can trust the lack of anyone showing up in a hospital in east Ohio looking like they climbed out of an eastern-front trench as indicative that the phosgene has not caused harm. It's real easy to over-estimate the damage this spill will do. In practice, people have been using (and spilling) vinyl chloride for over 180 years; we have a pretty good sense of the damage it can do. Not a good situation, but far on the low end of environmental impact risks (somewhere north of "a car full of diapers" and far, far south of "a car full of perchloroethylene").
- FpUser 4y ago>"he fact that the Twitter poster is a staunch North Korea supporter should make people evaluate the context of this video a little more critically" I've heard Putin saying that the sky is blue. Now I have to wear colored glasses.
- wyager 4y agoA bunch of people here in CT have been posting pictures of weird white deposits on their cars from rain (which, apparently, is currently carrying stuff from OH). Seems like there's a pretty high chance that this ends up as one of those things where we may not be fully aware of the fallout (no pun intended) until years from now, if ever.
- trpv 4y agoThose “weird white deposits” are normal and have always been a thing. The rainwater evaporates but leaves some minerals behind
- version_five 4y agoThere are minerals in rainwater? It's effectively distilled, no? How does it get minerals?
- tormeh 4y agoYes, but as with acid rain, rain can contain some non-waterthings, I think.
- version_five 4y agoNo doubt, but presumably those non water things are all things that evaporate, so wouldn't get left behind then the rain dries. The rain would have to pick up something up on the way down for it to contain something that precipitates out. That could be dust or soot, I'm not sure what else, but any minerals would have to come in that way
- night862 4y agoThe water vapor will precipitate around airborne particles causing them to drop out of the sky.
- tromp 4y ago
- trpv 4y agoI wonder how many of the symptoms people are reporting are just placebo
- phyzome 4y agoYes, you're naturally going to see a mix of mass psychogenic illness and actually-chemically-induced symptoms, and it's going to be terribly difficult to tell them apart, especially from just news reports. :-/
- userbinator 4y agoNocebo, more precisely.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoI wonder how many of the symptoms are real and are causing suffering of innocents caught in what's now a political tug-of-war.
- trpv 4y agoWhat does the derailment have to do with politics? (serious question, I don't follow news or politics)
- thatguy0900 4y agoWell the president just told rail workers they couldn't strike like a month ago. They wanted to strike because of unsafe working conditions and skeleton crews and crazy shifts. But I'm not really sure it's a political issue, both parties are on the side of the railroad owners here. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/02/biden-signs-bill-averting-rail-worker-strike-despite-lack-of-paid-sick-days.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/02/biden-signs-bill-averting-ra...
- mcv 4y agoIt's definitely a political issue, but there's no party tugging on the side of safety for railroad workers. This is the result of deregulation by both parties, and corporate greed cutting costs on safety margins in order to make more profits.
- ok_computer 4y agoAir and surface water measurements are mentioned for the train car contents. Is anyone aware if there is top soil or swipe testing for the train car contents or suspected partial combustion compounds? That black cloud did not look like the cleanest burn. Isn’t it naive to burn a mixture then test for the fuel in the aftermath and say look no fuel here there must be no contamination? What a mess.
- ttymck 4y agoPurely speculating: it's possible, in the scenario that you described, that the fuel is far more toxic than the combustion compounds, so something was indeed achieved Of course, my understanding is that the combustion compounds are also toxic, but I wanted to respond to what you've written.
- ok_computer 4y agoI think it was an impossible call to make and the product of a bunch of terrible circumstances and prior decisions. Additionally the response team was probably motivated to act instead of wait for the situation to develop unpredictably and they were reading a climbing temperature. If they believed it was avoiding an uncontrolled explosion where the was no idea how the rail car contents would release then it could be the right call in hindsight. I can see not wanting a big plume of that uncombusted stuff releasing, persisting and causing acute and chronic harm. I cannot argue anything about the call to burn it or not that sounds like a terrible choice. My point is the rush to resume normalcy and choose the risk of false negative reassurance when its clear this is not a well thought out procedure is terrible. Testing for raw components alone neglects the entire set of potential contamination and routes. Also is a one mile radius evacuation adequate for an open burn like that? I don't know what is but it'd be nice to have support to leave for a time if living on the outside margin of "might not die depending on wind direction". The story coverage in newspapers is decently good I don't think anything is being swept under the rug. But the official response and effort to put the threat in the past seems like damage control to exit the news cycle vs having any concern whatsoever about the people that live there. It is a poor populated area of the country and it is acceptable to open burn a million pounds of chlorinated petrochemicals. I know this happens in different ways under environmental permitting all over the US like in the gulf, etc. so its not unique. Still its terrible. And the state and local officials are handling the media coverage and disaster response while the US federal government is shooting down multiple balloons out of the air with $400k missiles in the great 2023 balloon wars. It is absurd.
- CSMastermind 4y agoI've posted on Hackernews before mentioning that I grew up in East Palestine and my entire immediate and most of my extended family either live in the town itself or within 20 miles. It's been surreal to see this event unplay in the media. Some things I haven't seen talked about: 1. How desperately poor most of the population in that area is. My fear is that if the crash has long terms effects people will never get justice. These are people who can't afford to go to a doctor regularly. They can't afford to miss work. They can't afford to sue a railroad and they'll very likely take a small payment to waive all liability because any amount of money right now is better than whatever they might theoretically get in the future. And for the most part no one there would tell you they're poor or disadvantaged. I don't mean to imply that they are downtrodden or helpless. I certainly didn't think that of myself or anyone else growing up there. It is only with the perspective of having left and having traveled the world and having risen through the economic ladder that I have the ability to look back and see how disadvantaged they will be against a large corporation. Barring legislation and government intervention I cannot imagine they will have even a shot in hell at getting a fair evaluation and fair deal. 2. Train wrecks happened in the area somewhat frequently Growing up I remember at last 3 or 4 train wrecks bad enough that people had to be put up in hotels. I don't know if that's a lot of a little for an area in a ~10 year span but it feels like a lot. I also don't know if train wrecks are tracked and reported anywhere other than local paper archives but I would be very interested to see the internal data and memos the railroad has related to derailments. If anyone is aware of such a resource please let me know.
- Kalium 4y agoA quick search (it was the first hit for train derailment tracker) brings up this: https://safetydata.fra.dot.gov/officeofsafety/publicsite/query/AccidentByStateRailroad.aspx https://safetydata.fra.dot.gov/officeofsafety/publicsite/que... Having poked at it a bit, it does seem happy to spit out a list of train derailments sliced and diced in quite a few different ways.
- eigenhombre 4y agoThe data on the site is fascinating, and can be downloaded as CSV, XLS, etc. (I live about 100m from a rail corridor, and though I love trains, I do worry occasionally about accidents).
- dkokelley 4y agoI'm pretty worried about this. The fallout/plume won't just be isolated to a region we can avoid or mitigate. It's in our waterways and in our air. I wouldn't be surprised if a year from now we can detect it all around the world. We might not know the full extent of the disaster for many years.
- xcrunner529 4y ago[dead]
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoMy unresearched hunch is that your concern is under-appreciating how big the Earth is.
- myko 4y agoI think they're right that it will be detectable globally in a few years if folks know what they're looking for, but I don't think it will show up meaningfully as an impact to health outcomes far outside the currently contaminated region.
- everforward 4y agoI'd be surprised. Doing quick napkin math, there were very roughly 4.710^30 particles of vinyl chloride released. Google says there are 4.610^46 molecules of water in the ocean (I can't vouch for that). So the concentration would be something like 0.0000000001 ppm. And that's only counting the ocean, not air or freshwater or dirt. I don't know if that's in the realm of detectable, but I think it's certainly not significant. The local effects could be bad, but I don't think there will be any kind of global effects.
- userbinator 4y agoIt seems very strange that they'd rather burn the vinyl chloride instead of attempting to capture or recover it, both from an environmental and economic perspective.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoPicking up liquid off the ground seems very difficult, I imagine.
- ovao 4y agoNot for Bounty.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoWhat East Palestine needs is a publicity-stunt visit from Vince Offer with a truckload of ShamWows!!!
- di456 4y agoIt boils at 7.88°F. It sounds like without pressurization or chilling the risk of an explosive release was deemed higher than the risk of burning it.
- InCityDreams 4y ago7.88f is -13.4c.
- sacred_numbers 4y agoVinyl chloride, when burned, can create poisonous byproducts such as phosgene and carbon monoxide. Vinyl chloride that leaks into the environment is a carcinogen that can cause damage decades into the future. It's a tradeoff, but probably a good one. We can deal with the acute danger of poisonous gas by temporary evacuations and air filters. Once a carcinogen is in the ground or the water, though, it's much more difficult to get it all cleaned up.
- version_five 4y ago[flagged]
- nobaddays 4y ago[flagged]
- bushbaba 4y agoOr that Biden used federal authority to quash the railroad union protests for better wages as safer conditions.
- mikeyouse 4y agoI mean, Biden brokered a deal to avert the strike, worked with the house and senate to craft a law guaranteeing the railworkers the benefits they were seeking which was then filibustered by senate republicans, but that's apparently too complicated or politically inconvenient for HN to understand so they pretend like stopping the strike was the end of that story. https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/3758436-senate-rejects-proposal-to-give-rail-workers-seven-days-of-paid-sick-leave/ https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/3758436-senate-rejects-p...
- blix 4y agoYou could easily rephrase your comment as "Biden took away their only option for self-directed action and then passed the buck to an organization known for doing nothing." Sometimes complexity doesn't actually add anything useful :) Focusing on the DC play-by-play is good for convincing yourself the other team is at fault, and not much else.
- mikeyouse 4y agoSure, you could rephrase it to something inaccurate if it was your prerogative to "both sides" something that failed almost entirely along party lines after attracting the support of several very conservative senators. I'm not sure what value that adds though :)
- photochemsyn 4y agoI would absolutely not trust 'government experts' or anyone hired by Norfolk Southern to do a thorough job of sampling and testing the surrounding environment. The EPA's gross failures in the Deepwater Horizon blowout with respect to overseeing the use of surfactants like Corexit should be proof enough of that. Unfortunately a rigorous sampling and testing protocol by an independent registered laboratory (which is what you'd need for the collection of evidence that would hold up under legal scrutiny) is an expensive and involved process. The technology needed is well-established, just collect a lot of vials of water, soil, stream bed cores etc. on a grid scale focusing on the entire region, paying attention to downwind zones from the accident in particular. Then they need to be run through an established, documented extract-and-analysis procedure (gas-chromatography-mass-spectrometry would be appropriate, maybe high-pressure-liquid-chromatography for some of the less volatile species). You'd want to look for the species that were on the train, of course, but also the various combustion products (which could be more hazardous than their source materials) - the list I've seen is vinyl chloride, benzene, butyl acetate, ethylene glycol monobutyl ether, ethylhexyl acrylate and isobutylene, plus some other petroleum products. What kind of combustion products were generated is a more complex issue (phosgene has been mentioned, hydrogen chloride etc.). At the very least, people should be collecting and labeling samples in a manner that provides proof-of-origin, maybe video documentation and so on. Here's an example of the kind of sample storage vial needed. Cost is about $3 each, you have to buy them in lots of about 75 or so. Maybe someone should set up a GoFundMe for this? https://www.fishersci.com/shop/products/sample-vial-teflon-lined-cap/50230665 https://www.fishersci.com/shop/products/sample-vial-teflon-l... If you have the collected samples, documented and securely stored, you can potentially get them all analyzed later by a certified lab, providing court-acceptable evidence.
- walleeee 4y ago> The technology needed is well-established, just collect a lot of vials of water, soil, stream bed cores etc. on a grid scale focusing on the entire region, paying attention to downwind zones from the accident in particular. Then they need to be run through an established, documented extract-and-analysis procedure. Yes, and in addition, surface- and groundwater transport should be simulated given any known hydrogeologic data on the region. The federal government in fact develops free and open source software for exactly this. NS should have limited involvement in the testing process, feds and independent parties should collect data independently and compare results in public view.