8 ms·
Upper management – employee productivity has gone way down in the last couple of years. Employees – yikes, sounds like we should do something about that. Can y
by paxys 4y ago
Upper management – employee productivity has gone way down in the last couple of years.
Employees – yikes, sounds like we should do something about that. Can you tell us how you are measuring productivity? Is shipping velocity slower? Is our revenue lower than projected? Maybe we need to adjust priorities or roadmaps? Let's come up with a plan to make sensible product and process changes that will help us better hit our targets.
Management – ...
Employees – can we even say for sure that productivity is down?
Management – we can, trust us.
Employees – ok, what can we do about it?
Management – 10% of you are fired.
Employees – that will just make the remaining people less productive.
Management – and everyone has to come in to the office 3 days a week.
Employees – but we were hired as fully remote. Most of us don't even live near an office. What will this accomplish?
Management – this will fix all our problems, trust us.
Employees – but what problems are we trying to fix?
The worst part of this is that a year later these companies will magically declare that all employees are 2.37x more productive now, and WFH was always a mistake. The corporate world/media will eat it up, and so office culture will get even more entrenched.
- cardosof 4y agoYes, that's how it works. There's no outside impartial judge looking at arguments from both sides to declare who's wrong, there's no law saying being a hipocritical and cynical are crimes. It's just people, relationships, employers and employees, and money.
- laichzeit0 4y agoWell imagine if you worked your way all the way up to Exec level and for the last few years all you could do was dress up in your expensive suites just to sit in front of a webcam. You’d also feel like a complete clown. You want people in the office so they can see you walking from meeting room to meeting room and hear the sound of your leather (not rubber) soled shoes as you traverse through the corridors of mere mortals. How else do you assert dominance? People need to _see_ that you’re important and that you matter.
- pm90 4y agoThis rings true to me. Most people at those levels enjoy the “perks” of high status endowed by a job. It’s part of their identity.
- bart_spoon 4y agoI remember a NYTimes article from the last year describing the culture clash between employees wanting to work remote, and management wanting to work in person. The most illustrative example was a CEO of a company in Seattle. When an employee said they appreciated WFH because the lack of commute gave them the time to take jiujitsu classes, the CEO told them they respected their interests, but they needed to consider if their future was in the UFC or working for the company. The same CEO, when asked about why he preferred working in the office, mentioned something about being more energized by the view from his office, and something about liking the fried chicken restaurant next to the building. It was a particularly egregious example, but I’m fairly certain this is almost entirely a matter of upper management simply personally preferring the in office lifestyle, in no small part due to the perks of upper management. But it’s hard to justify the glitzy downtown office building or corporate mega campus when they have a average occupancy rate if 20%, which seems to be the case when employees have a choice, and so they are trying to force their preference upon everyone else with made-up assurances about how much more productive everyone is in office.
- pm90 4y agoI mean yes rule by diktat if needed but at that point the kind of workers you need to thrive will start looking elsewhere. I guess that’s not an immediate consequence so nobody faces any penalty.
- dalyons 4y agourgh. I hate how accurate this is. The lack of any data or measurement absolutely kills me. Its all just based on exec feels.
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoI think there are legitimately people out there who can’t function without other people being in the same room as them - and if they happen to be in a position of authority where they can inflict that on other people it causes a lot of problems for everyone else. I’m in a situation like that now where even though that person is six levels above me and will never know my name or speak with me directly, they are constantly trolling everyone to make sure people have cameras turned on, reminding everyone that remote work is a privilege (no it is keeping us alive, disease monkey), and they are plotting regional and global meetups for teams, or buying everyone VR headsets, etc. But to what ends? Why would I want to get into a COVID tube and fly to Germany to eat a throw-away processed turkey sandwich and bag of chips with co-workers and then fly back in another COVID tube a day later? What would be accomplished by that? Considering the airfare and hotel costs those have to be the most expensive bag lunches ever made.
- wildrhythms 4y agoThe VR headset thing makes me laugh. I'd like to see a higherup wear a VR headset for more than 5 minutes.
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoLuckily those little telepresence robots are out of vogue so nobody has proposed (threatened?) to make us use those yet.
- edgyquant 4y agoWhat should they base it on? Lines of code or jira tickets? Most of the metrics you can name are things we as devs have insisted for years are not adequate to measure dev productivity.
- rullelito 4y agoI'm working at a FANG and this is 100% accurate.
- vasco 4y agoI'm 7 years into fully remote, and will not work for a company that does even hybrid teams. You just need to work somewhere that sees the world as you see it instead of trying to understand any meaning behind megacorp decisions.
- sussexby 4y agoI’m nearly 7 years into hybrid/remote and am seeking opportunity to rejoin a proper collaborative working environment that’s physical, not virtual. However, what’s right for me isn’t right for you and enforcing a rule one way or another does not work so I agree with your point. Megacorps need to understand that we humans have a range of preferences and, if we’re to assume some prefer remote and some prefer office, then making a big decision as Amazon has will alienate a decent amount of workers. Cue calamity.
- throwaway426079 4y ago" a proper collaborative working environment that’s physical, not virtual." If you believe that only physical environments can be properly collaborative then you invalidate the remainder of your post.
- JackFr 4y agoThe parent never claims that only a physical environment can be properly collaborative. Literally the next sentence after the one you quote is “what’s right for isn't right for you”.
- throwaway426079 4y agoIt reads exactly that way.
- sussexby 4y agoI’m stating that I’m after an environment that’s physical, not virtual. I’m not saying that only physical environments have those qualities - I’m saying through my experience I work better, feel better, and contribute better when I can communicate in a physical space and not a virtual one. Again, as I say, whatever is right for the individual. If virtual works for you, that’s great, but I’m consciously stepping out of remote work as I really struggle with it.
- seydor 4y ago> Most of us don't even live near an office. What will this accomplish? you will be fired without being fired
- bick_nyers 4y agoJust keep working remote then
- SergeAx 4y ago> magically declare that all employees are 2.37x more productive now If this is not true, other companies will include WFH in their offers and will kill two rabbits with one shot: win best talents and will make them more productive.
- bart_spoon 4y agoI think these two are related and get to the core of the matter: > Management – 10% of you are fired. > Employees – but we were hired as fully remote. Most of us don't even live near an office. I don’t think there is any solid evidence demonstrating on-site makes workers more or less productive than remote. But companies have demonstrated over the last 6 months that they overhired to an absurd degree. This is just a way of further reducing headcount without having to actually do layoffs.
- roncesvalles 4y agoUntil software companies acknowledge that the loss of productivity is due to overengineering and technical debt gumming up the machinery, the problem will not be fixed. It's not a people problem, it's very much an engineering problem. Unfortunately when you're high up the management ladder, every problem looks like a people problem.