4 ms·
> For that reason, Zilly said that when the case goes to trial he’ll instruct the jury that it may presume the text messages were detrimental to the city’s lega
by rayiner 4y ago
> For that reason, Zilly said that when the case goes to trial he’ll instruct the jury that it may presume the text messages were detrimental to the city’s legal position and that there’s significant circumstantial evidence they were deleted intentionally.
This is a common and fitting, though usually devastating, sanction for spoliation of evidence.
- next_xibalba 4y agoTo which side is it usually devastating? I would assume it would be for the destroyer of evidence, but maybe good lawyers can explain that away and seed sufficient doubt?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> To which side is it usually devastating? To the obvious one. "Assume there was evidence so bad they risked criminal charges to get rid of it" makes instilling doubt a lot harder.
- next_xibalba 4y agoAre you a litigation attorney?
- unyttigfjelltol 4y agoIt's a terrible result for everyone, plaintiff, defendant and court. Plaintiff because, culpable or not, those texts may be the best explanation for whatever happened. Losing them means they're framing their arguments a bit in the dark. It's easier to persuade if you land pretty close to an actual truth, and that's harder without complete discovery of executive communications. For defendants, because the explanations are actually pretty plausible for a municipal IT operation, and it's dumb for big liability to ride on some stupid, irrelevant IT gaffe on some peripheral technology. The court because there isn't a good answer and deciding big cases on questionable legal presumptions and fictions that themselves turn on irrelevant technical arcana-- these are the things people dislike about lawyers.
- ceejayoz 4y ago"the explanations are actually pretty plausible for a municipal IT operation" Nah. > The former mayor has offered a number of explanations for the missing messages, including that she dropped her phone in water, that she inadvertently changed the phone’s deletion settings and that “someone” set a new phone to delete messages older than 30 days, resulting in a rolling deletion of previous messages. Individually, sure. Combined? That's an unlikely set of circumstances. This, too: > The order notes that Best’s phone at some point was also set to delete text messages after a month, despite her obligation to keep them due to pending litigation. Zilly noted that the former chief apparently deleted more than 27,000 of those text messages by hand. All this while subject to a litigation hold looks very bad. Letting them wiggle out of it would encourage such behavior in the future.
- sva_ 4y agoCompare that to when the president of the European Commission gets away with deleting her texts. https://www.euronews.com/2022/01/28/von-der-leyen-text-messages-to-pfizer-ceo-should-be-released-says-eu-ombudsman https://www.euronews.com/2022/01/28/von-der-leyen-text-messa... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/29/european-commission-defiant-over-von-der-leyens-pfizer-texts https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/29/european-commi...
- myko 4y agoSimilarly the trump admin/campaign deleting texts to hide from Mueller (Stone, Flynn, Bannon, etc.) https://thehill.com/policy/national-security/454580-mueller-we-believe-some-trump-campaign-officials-deleted-communications/ https://thehill.com/policy/national-security/454580-mueller-...
- mc32 4y agoOh, did they use bleach bit or did they wipe them with a rag?
- vuln 4y agoYou're getting downvoted from what I can only assume is your inaccurate quoting. "What? Like with a cloth?" Is the full quote here's the video. https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/video/hillary-clinton-jokes-wiping-email-server-cloth-33165989 https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/video/hillary-clinton-jokes-... BleachBit's Response https://www.bleachbit.org/news/bleachbit-stifles-investigation-hillary-clinton https://www.bleachbit.org/news/bleachbit-stifles-investigati...
- mc32 4y agoYou're right! I'm sure readers of the parent poster appreciate the poster's completeness and their refusal to tell half truths as well as not omit details, so one can only conclude that its my manner of speaking which betrayed my class and thus the disapproval of the Oxford educated. The other one that gets me constantly is drapes instead of drapery.
- evil-olive 4y ago> Zilly said that when the case goes to trial this article is about a month old; the case recently settled [0] (at least, a preliminary notice of settlement was filed, it's not finalized yet, and none of the details are public) it seems very likely that these sanctions convinced the city to settle instead of going to trial, or at a minimum forced them to settle for less favorable terms than they were hoping for. 0: https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/law-justice/seattle-settles-chop-lawsuit-after-judge-levied-sanctions-over-deleted-texts/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/law-justice/seattl...
- a_e_k 4y ago"Adverse inference" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_inference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_inference