5 ms·
Residential-only zoning is "the bad kind of zoning". It wasn't invented to keep factories away from homes; it was /literally/ invented in Berkeley to stop Chine
by astrange 4y ago
Residential-only zoning is "the bad kind of zoning". It wasn't invented to keep factories away from homes; it was /literally/ invented in Berkeley to stop Chinese immigrants from being able to afford homes by running laundry businesses out of them.
- eric-hu 4y agoI did a search to check the history of this claim, but maybe I wasn’t searching for the right thing. Would you mind sharing a link?
- jai_ 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-family_zoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-family_zoning It's the first sentence in the History section
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoI admittedly rolled my eyes at the WP link. To atone for this, I’ve copy and pasted the relevant references from that line in the History section: [1] Baldassari, Erin; Solomon, Molly (October 5, 2020). "The Racist History of Single-Family Home Zoning". NPR. Archived from the original on November 14, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20201114004918/https://www.kqed.org/news/11840548/the-racist-history-of-single-family-home-zoning https://web.archive.org/web/20201114004918/https://www.kqed.... [3] Hansen, Louis (March 1, 2021). "Is this the end of single-family zoning in the Bay Area? San Jose, Berkeley, other cities consider sweeping changes". San Jose Mercury News. https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/03/01/is-this-the-end-of-single-family-zoning-in-the-bay-area/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/03/01/is-this-the-end-of-si... [4] Ruggiero, Angela (February 24, 2021). "Berkeley to end single-family residential zoning, citing racist ties". San Jose Mercury News. https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/02/24/berkeley-to-end-single-family-residential-zoning-citing-racist-ties/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/02/24/berkeley-to-end-singl... [5] Yelimeli, Supriya (February 24, 2021). "Berkeley denounces racist history of single-family zoning, begins 2-year process to change general plan - Council unanimously approved a resolution that will work toward banning single-family zoning". Berkeleyside. https://web.archive.org/web/20210301140957/https://www.berkeleyside.com/2021/02/24/berkeley-denounces-racist-history-of-single-family-zoning-begins-2-year-process-to-change-general-plan https://web.archive.org/web/20210301140957/https://www.berke... [8] Baldassari, Erin (March 13, 2021). "Facing Housing Crunch, California Cities Rethink Single-Family Neighborhoods". NPR. Archived from the original on March 31, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210331194917/https://www.npr.org/2021/03/13/973770308/facing-housing-crunch-california-cities-rethink-single-family-neighborhoods https://web.archive.org/web/20210331194917/https://www.npr.o...
- Cardinal7167 4y agoWhy did you roll your eyes at it if it provided exactly the correct type of referential value it’s supposed to?
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoWell because I had to click thru WP itself. Also, as a sibling comment put it, it does weird me out that all cited sources are from such a limited pool.
- swatcoder 4y agoAccurate or not, I hate that all of these references are from one 6-month regional news cycle. They may as well be 1 citation, rather than 5. The excess just makes the inclusion of claim look more motivated by political investment than a desire to be informative.
- stonogo 4y agoI hate that people's instinct is to play 4D chess with the intent of some random Wiki editor instead of even glancing at the data contained in the references. Here are some aged references for your discerning palate: Density Zoning and Class Segregation in U.S. Metropolitan Areas (2010) https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6237.2010.00724.x https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6237.2010.00724.x Distributive politics, ward representation, and the spread of zoning (1993) https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01047991 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01047991 Urban Land Developers and the Origins of Zoning Laws: The Case of Berkeley (1986) https://escholarship.org/uc/item/26b8d8zh https://escholarship.org/uc/item/26b8d8zh Fifty Years of Zoning (1966) https://www.jstor.org/stable/25723800 https://www.jstor.org/stable/25723800
- edgyquant 4y agoThis disputes the claim it originated in SF and the reasons listed. Odd that Wikipedia is centered on SF and its claim is backed up by (several experts believe.) Looks to me like another example of Wikipedia pushing a narrative and pretending it’s fact. https://economics21.org/history-zoning-america-flexible-housing-approach https://economics21.org/history-zoning-america-flexible-hous...
- enragedcacti 4y agoZoning and SFH zoning are aren't the same thing, and wikipedia concurs with your article w.r.t. early US zoning policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoning#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoning#United_States Looks to me like another example of HN guy pushing a narrative and pretending it’s fact. Or maybe someone just made a mistake and a more charitable reading would show that there is perhaps not a conspiracy going on but instead just a misunderstanding.
- shkkmo 4y agoIf you want something more rigourous than a wikipedia article, that article's oldest source is the 2020 NPR article which links to this paper: http://www.schoolinfosystem.org/pdf/2014/06/04SegregationinCA24-2.pdf http://www.schoolinfosystem.org/pdf/2014/06/04SegregationinC... TLDR: the real estate developer that founded Claremont (Mason-McDuffie Co spearheaded by Duncan McDuffie) imposed conditions in its titles that explicitly bared non-whites and prohibited commercial enterprises. However, those title conditions couldn't control neighboring areas, so McDuffie pushed to get zoning laws passed that were explicitly inspired by anti-chinese laundry regulations in LA. The Berkley regulation was "expedited" to prevent a "negro dance hall" from opening. To me, the existence of the anti-commercial provisions in the McDuffie title restrictions in addition to explicit racial exclusions indicates that racial exclusion was not the only motivating factor in adopting single family zoning laws. However, the context and immediate usage does make it pretty clear that racial exclusion was a significant part of the motivation.
- nemo44x 4y agoNo it’s just completely untrue. This is a common tactic today to say something was created for <racist|sexist|homophobic> purposes so the entire concept is bad naturally. See how activists say policing was invented to catch slaves or some ridiculous claim. There’s a bunch of others.
- stonogo 4y agoNo, it's completey true. The first businesses affected by Berkeley residential zoning were Chinese and Japanese laundries (c.f. Ordninance 575-NS). Another zoning ordinance was passed to block a "negro dance hall." See Pollard's "Outline of the Law of Zoning in the United States," and Paul Ong "An Ethnic Trade: The Chinese Laundries in Early California." (Journal of Ethnic Studies, Winter 1981)
- astrange 4y agoI said literally and I meant literally. You can just look up the Berkeley city council meeting minutes! That's why they said they were doing it!
- klipt 4y agoBut are you sure Berkeley was the first place in the world to create a residential only zoning? If not, they don't deserve the inventor label.
- pwinnski 4y agoOkay, they didn't invent racist policies that persist to this day, they just furthered their racist goals by using existing policies that persist to this day. Better?
- gowld 4y agoIt's a shame that our national history is ridiculous.
- pwinnski 4y agoYes, it is absolutely ridiculous that slave patrols existed and formed the basis for later police departments in the south. It is also ridiculous that labor-busting squads existed in the north, which formed the basis for later police departments in the north. The history is there, it is what it is, as ridiculous as that is. You might argue that modern police have far outgrown their origins, and then it would be up to readers to decide which whether your claim is also ridiculous, given how many police departments generally exhibit qualities consonant with their origins.
- wnissen 4y agoIf you have an interest, the most comprehensive book I'm aware of is "Zoned in the USA: The Origins and Implications of American Land-Use Regulation" by Sonia Hirt. Cornell University Press. 2014. ISBN 978-0-8014-5305-2. She's the one quoted in the LA Times article: https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-01-19/single-family-zoning-us https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-01-19/single-fam... Full disclosure, I was so impressed with Prof. Hirt's book that I wrote her Wikipedia page.
- astrange 4y agoAlso The Color of Law: https://www.epi.org/publication/the-color-of-law-a-forgotten-history-of-how-our-government-segregated-america/ https://www.epi.org/publication/the-color-of-law-a-forgotten...
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoRight - but that part of residential zoning still stays, right? It's just that you can build a duplex on a "single-family residential lot". But you still can't teach piano lessons out of your house without one of your neighbors constantly calling the city and complaining about how you're causing traffic problems, right? And you definitely can't wash other people's clothes or dishes in your house, right??
- edgyquant 4y agoYou should clarify “in SF” since this isn’t true for the actual history of residential zoning (which originated in New York)
- stonogo 4y agoBerkeley legislated residential zoning four months before New York did.
- astrange 4y agoWell, this article is about the Bay Area.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mherdeg 4y agoGosh, growing up near Cleveland I always thought zoning "started" in Euclid Heights. I guess there are lots of different firsts?
- leviathant 4y agoFeels a bit like the oddly pervasive "Our city is x on the top 10 list of places Russia would nuke first because of local industry y" myth that existed in places all across America.
- Phrenzy 4y agoImagine the post WWIII disappointment while walking around your pristine neighborhood. "Nobody thought enough about us to want to eliminate us."
- beebmam 4y agoCorrect me if I'm misrepresenting you here, but are you claiming that the reason that something is invented is always the reason why it continues to be used?
- astrange 4y agoNow it's probably because people don't like "traffic" outside their homes, but basically yes, that's why single-family zoning is still in place. It's extremely silly to want to ban eg corner stores in your neighborhood. In SF where people have discovered "left-NIMBYism", people will now argue that keeping it is fighting racism, but then if you go into the suburbs they'll still happily argue the original position.
- gameman144 4y agoThe idea that the reason something was made defines its current reason for existing seems demonstrably wrong, though. Consider the microwave magnetron: invented to mess with radar, but now in every kitchen. Maybe the reasons haven't changed in thisinstance, but holding that as a rule seems pretty incorrect.
- astrange 4y agoLuckily we don't have to argue about abstractions since we can just go look at land use. I do think a lot of people want to keep single family zoning because they think it makes their properties more valuable but 1. historical segregation is part of that and 2. if your home price goes up, that only makes you richer as long as you don't want to buy any other homes that've also gone up.
- chung8123 4y agoPeople want single family zoning because they enjoy it more. People wanting single family housing is what makes it valuable not the single family housing itself.
- throw009 4y ago[flagged]
- swampthinker 4y agoA brave, throwaway opinion.
- eternityforest 4y agoGroundwater? It all goes in the same sewer, and the water you drink comes from the same tap. What does it matter if it's 5 miles away or next door, when we don't locally source water or dispose of waste locally? Large centralized industries are probably going to be more efficient than small ones, but maybe not accounting for customer travel related pollution. There's air pollution, of course, but few people want to ban wood stoves, and I doubt many medium industries you'd find without zoning pollute as much as 6 if those on one block.
- nradov 4y agoInstallation of new wood stoves is generally banned in California. Only certain types of pellet fuel stoves are allowed in new construction. And at times all wood burning is banned in certain regions for air quality reasons (except in homes that have no other source of heat).
- pigsty 4y agoLiving in a city where laundromats (even moderately large professional ones) are nowhere near residential areas is, to say it briefly, stupid. You want them right near your home so you can drop by any time. Nobody wants to go 45 minutes out of their way just to drop off some clothes.
- krisroadruck 4y agoI think all the people who have washers and dryers in their own homes would disagree that having a laundromat on their street would be a value add. It would just bring traffic from outside of their neighborhood into it. I'm not making a case for or against, but instead saying this is a matter of perspective based on who's making the judgement call.
- rsync 4y ago"Residential-only zoning is "the bad kind of zoning"." I wish I could mind-meld with you and transmit the memories and experiences of growing up in a residential area with no zoning. You know that sci-fi trope where the empath gets the memory dump and breaks away screaming and crying because they can't handle the trauma that comes through ? It would be like that. You think you'll get cute shops and pop-ups and delightful mixed-use and stimulating workshop spaces and crafty folks doing things artisanally. What you will actually get is half-built cars. Everywhere. You will get mobile homes and immobile RVs. You will get horses. Not rich-people horses, but "Grandma died and she had a horse and nobody knew what to do with it so we fenced part of the front yard" horses. Someone will disconnect from city sewer because they "know how to build septic". Someone will get llamas. You think I'm making this up and I promise you I am not. You've lived so long in a nicely regulated, rules-based order that you have no idea the kind of bullshit people engage in the minute the rules go away.
- astrange 4y agoI've been to Japan (+ several other countries that aren't the US). It's pretty nice there. As to whether or not zoning laws are what prevent people from owning horses, that's not clear to me. But a law saying you can't build a bookstore or apartment on the lot doesn't seem very related.
- jojobas 4y agoIn Japan you just don't do any of those things due to exceptionally high, by European or American standard, social pressure do to The Right Thing. Or, at the very least, to not do anything out of the ordinary.
- astrange 4y agoOut of Tokyo and San Francisco, which one requires all new buildings to go to subjective design reviews where your neighbors complain about shadows and tell you they don't like the color you plan to paint it and the style of windows facing the road? Hint: it's not Tokyo, which actually does have a fair number of old ugly poorly-maintained buildings scattered around random nice neighborhoods. Which is fine and not hurting anyone.
- pengaru 4y agoNot saying zoning isn't abused, but this is the kind of outcome you get without zoning laws too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdDuHxwD5R4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdDuHxwD5R4
- occz 4y agoI agree. Note how I didn't use residential only-zones, instead opting for residential zones, which can and should be mixed-use. This is not to say that there are some incompatible land uses to be considered - industrial uses can broadly be considered to be incompatible with residential uses, for example.