5 ms·
One important thing that server racks don't address is noise.
by amelius 4y ago
One important thing that server racks don't address is noise.
- layoric 4y agoThis is what turned me off as well. I ended up getting older Dell 2011-3 dual socket workstation for cheap. Still heaps of power, room for upgrades but whisper quiet when idle and under load.
- hinkley 4y agoWhen craigslist was brand spanking new I found a ruggedized 1/4 height rack that looked like it was surplus military. My second stroke of luck was that the hall closet in my apartment had a corner in it that would exactly fit this rack, telephone wiring junction box was immediately above the rack, and all of the house wiring was straight Cat5 runs from there, so a few new outlet covers and some cable rejigging and we had internet everywhere (but only 2 pair where the phone plugged in), terminated at the rack, which was partly muffled by winter coats. You can't push a lot of BTUs this way, but you can do a few. My solution before this was to hide a tower PC behind the couch. For the right kind of couch and the right vent holes, you can eat an awful lot of ambient noise by using major furniture. There's lots of space out there for things like this. I also tried at one point to build an air filter that would fit under a bed (less noise, no floor space, fewer dust bunnies.
- horsawlarway 4y agoVery much this. One interesting thing about going the rack route is that most of the hardware optimizes for considerations a data center/large corporation might have. That can be nice in a lot of ways (hardware is fairly robust, layouts are usually friendly for quick access/maintenance, overall density of machines is pretty good). But it means almost no one is paying attention to how much noise these things make, because for most of the target audience that's WAY down the list of things they care about. I have a couple of - not elderly but not new - 1u and 2u machines, and they are LOUD AS FUCK. I used to run my server farm in my office when it was just spare personal computers (under the table I use for hobby projects), but I quickly ended up moving it down the basement when running the rack machines. They're just too loud for comfort on a semi-regular basis.
- reilly3000 4y agoYep! I really got into a lot of trouble with my family for my HP G8 boxes. It was like the sonic equivalent of that episode of Seinfeld, where the Kenny Rogers Roaster sign was outside of Kramer’s apartment. There are fans mods and firmware updates, but in the end it’s probably the best use of one’s time to buy G9+ as they are far quieter. /r/homelab has some great data about these issues. Also watch out for network gear. A 48 port POE brocade switch was as loud if not louder than the servers. Pro-tip: if you can spare more rack units, get a bigger server case. 1U is usually far louder than 2+
- imiric 4y agoThere are a few manufacturers that make silent racks[1]. They're hard to come by, and are much more expensive than regular racks, but there's a small market for them. Otherwise, manual soundproofing is an option, but then you have heat to deal with. Most servers aren't very loud unless you're stressing the hardware, and fan settings can usually be tweaked, or fans replaced with silent alternatives. Still, you wouldn't want this kind of equipment humming next to you in the same room, so it's best to dedicate a small server closet, room, or garage, if you have the space. That said, a custom server build in a rack mounted enclosure is not the same as using enterprise servers. My gaming PC is in a 4U enclosure and is as quiet as any tower PC. [1]: http://quiet-rack.com/ranges.php http://quiet-rack.com/ranges.php
- hinkley 4y agoI keep thinking that Oxide computers is missing a trick and that someone should be building minicomputers ported to plug coolant lines straight into the rack. Either glycol lines or minisplit lines. The hot row/cold row stuff makes sense when you've got a data center, but if computers are eating the world then more and more people will need 80u of rackspace total, maybe at 3 branch offices.
- m463 4y agoI think it's because out-of-sight, out-of-hearing-range... and the smaller the fan, the more RPMs (noise) needed to move the same quantity of air.
- deepspace 4y agoYes! I went down the rackmount rathole about 20 years ago, and for 10 years all my computing equipment was installed in a 44u cabinet. The problem is that rack mount plus low noise equals very high cost, if it is even achievable. Eventually I could not stand the noise anymore, and got rid of the rack. So did every single one of my colleagues who tried rackmount. As others have mentioned rackmount equipment is also expesive, often ridiculously so. I am very happy to leave racks in the data center where they belong.
- CommieBobDole 4y agoI put mine in the basement. Handles most of the noise unless things get really exciting. I have a friend who keeps his server rack in his unheated detached garage. Works great unless it gets really cold and all the servers shut down due to low input air temperature. Which I never really knew was a thing.
- hinkley 4y agoOne of my regrets is that my house doesn't have a basement with a furnace in it. For years I've had a design in my head to build a data closet next to the furnace, so the cold air return can suck air straight off of the servers in winter, and the closet sucks in air from a duct along the foundation. And now that you can get heat pump water heaters, that strategy would work a bit better still.
- xxpor 4y agoI've seen that happen when it hit -1 (C). The sensor was an 8 bit unsigned counter so it rolled over... and the BMC thought it was on fire.
- moondev 4y agoCorrect, because a rack is silent! What and how you mount in the rack matters. Here is my AIO cooled threadipper in a 4U enclosure https://imgur.io/a/LlZy6px https://imgur.io/a/LlZy6px
- aidenn0 4y agoGet a 3U or 4U case and replace all of the fans that come with it with something designed for desktops. A full size tower is basically a 4U case on its side, so there is identical room for fans &c. I have a 3U setup where the loudest thing in it is the GPU fan on the 1050Ti.
- dualboot 4y agotechnically a Mid-Size tower. There really aren't any Full-size tower cases anymore.
- jjav 4y ago> One important thing that server racks don't address is noise. They relocate the noise to where you aren't, so they do address it. As I mentioned in another comment, my desktop used to be a big Sun server (forgetting model right now) loud as a jet engine. But it was in the rack far from anyone and my desktop was a totally silent SunRay.