12 ms·
Moving my PC into my rack in a 2U case
- omgtehlion 4y agoI moved my PC/NAS to a similar 2U box. With onboard GPU, but instead 7 ssds and 10GbE network card. Though, I did it in a 2U optical cross box. I paid $30 for it, and replaced some panels with fans and grilles. Not 200 euros, holy moly!
- OJFord 4y agoStandard tower cases can easily cost that (or more), perhaps partly driven by it increasingly only being gamers buying them (so you can charge more for RGB, funky angles, or also minimalism, etc.), but server stuff is often more expensive than a desktop counterpart would be, different market but also more specialised I suppose. I paid almost £260 iirc for a 4U case with 16x3.5" hot swap bays, a few years ago, and that seemed like a great deal (without waiting for something used on eBay anyway). Now, I still haven't really made use of it... but that's on me.
- atorodius 4y agoIs this the same U they use in Eurorack modular? Coundnt find details
- rcarmo 4y agoI just did something similar, but with a compact case: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34855826 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34855826 (I don’t have room for a rack, but I do have a moderately tidy server closet with an UPS, and remote to these machines with GPU-accelerated RDP.)
- Lammy 4y agoI have a similar build but using this 2U case that puts all the ports/cards in the front: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01LX0SO53/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01LX0SO53/
- geerlingguy 4y agoThat's a nice looking case! Seems like it would be especially good for a router or networking box. In the course of my build I found out about PlinkUSA and Sliger, who both have a few decent 2U options for those of us who don't want screaming server fans.
- binaryanomaly 4y agoI have this as well https://www.yakkaroo.de/19-zoll-2he-server-gehaeuse-ipc-c236-36cm-kurz https://www.yakkaroo.de/19-zoll-2he-server-gehaeuse-ipc-c236... with Noctua fans installed. I run proxmox, opnsense (virtualized) and other workloads on it. It's really good and runs almost completely silent because of the Noctua fans. The build quality of the case is lower end though with sharp edges!
- leetrout 4y ago> I still run on a boring old 60 Hz 1080p monitor This is surprising to me. I really enjoy 4k for the better text readability.
- geerlingguy 4y agoI should've been more specific — I do that on my gaming/secondary PC. My main Mac Studio setup is run through a 27" 4K LG display (which is also at 60 Hz, though).
- bravetraveler 4y agoFor someone that reads as many logs as you/I do - I strongly suggest looking into high refresh rates! They seem very gaming oriented, because well, they are - but being able to read things as they fly by is a huge help. I'm always the person in calls at work going: "you missed it!"
- geerlingguy 4y agoHaha that sounds like it could be its own gaming competition—competitive log streaming. I have done that though, where you just let loose the firehose, and scan for patterns during some nasty event.
- bravetraveler 4y agoEven creating sub-communities; log sanitation at-scale! I'm game :)
- mbreese 4y agoI’ve been unknowingly training for this competition for years.
- sophacles 4y agoI worked at an ISP for a while where we set up a projector display and just had the log firehose on the wall at all times. I never really paid direct attention to it, and it had terrible resolution and a lowish refresh rate. Even still, the human brain is an amazing pattern matching machine and the feed gave us a lot of useful insight. Regularly someone on the team, even non-technical folks, would walk by and say "oh looks like $customer is having problems" just because their brain had divined a pattern from exposure and correlation. Sometimes we could turn those moments into automated alarms, sometimes we couldn't figure out how our brains made the determination. To this day I still try to keep a log feed visible along with the grafanas or whatever - it is shockingly useful even if I don't ever read those logs on the display.
- noncoml 4y agoRecently I found myself with a mini ITX motherboard and got a Ghost S1 case for it. The space saved and convenience of such a small factor is life changing. I’m never going back to ATX and big towers.
- ncrmro 4y agoI got a Raw S1 which I love form factor wise. My Ryzen 5800X3D I think has issues with c states which caused reboots from low to high power states. Thought it was the 3800RTX and 600w PSU. Upgrade SFX-l which has you loose the rear 120mm fan. Whole thing really started to cook itself till I disabled the c state and switched back to the 600w
- ct0 4y agoDid the same thing, harder to build but the space savings is fantastic.
- noncoml 4y agoYeah, you need to plan your build order a bit. Can’t just shove everything in and then find out you didn’t connect the cpu power
- outworlder 4y agoI have a meshlicious. I can fit a full ATX PSU no problem (could have more SSDs or 2.5" drives otherwise). Because it's a "sandwitch", the GPU and CPU are drawing air from opposite sides of the case. It's all mesh so airflow is great. Pretty small too. Not as small as your Ghost, but it can accommodate really large GPUs if need be. Even watercooling would be viable (I've seen some great custom loops, for the CPU even a two fan AIO would fit). I do miss ATX because ITX boards generally do not have any expansion slots. Sure they come with Wifi, but if I decide to, say add a 2.5G(or 10G) network card, video capture or what have you, I'm out of luck. I do not miss the case sizes. ATX are spacious, but TOO spacious, usually. Because the mainboard is large, most cases don't seem to optimize for space at all. So you fill the thing to the brim with all expansions you can think of and there's still a lot of wasted volume. Were I to go back to ATX, it would be with a non-orthodox case(open case, inside a desk, etc).
- ziml77 4y agoA few years ago I bought a switch that could rack mount and ended up looking at getting a rack to put most of my stuff in. I quickly abandoned that idea when I saw that rack mount makes things cost significantly more. I remember that the UPS pricing was especially nasty. Felt like they were just charging what they could get away with considering that it's really only businesses buying rack mount equipment. Though if I ever buy I house I might end up going Linus level crazy and put a rack in the basement or a utlity room with fiber optic cabling back to my desk for peripherals to attach.
- hashhar 4y agoA nice compromise is to buy a tower UPS - the ones which are deeper but not as high - and then place them on a cantilever shelf on the rack. Mine occupies 3U of rack space and I can even place my NAS on the shelf in front of the UPS.
- aftbit 4y agoOn the other hand, surplus rack mount servers are very cheap on eBay. You can certainly stick non-rack UPSes into a rack. I did this for about a year (two APCs sitting at the bottom of the rack) before I got a great deal on some surplus rackmount UPSes.
- geerlingguy 4y agoYeah; buying new is extremely expensive. Many cities have an e-waste recycler from whom you can get great deals (otherwise browse Craigslist and Marketplace, there are good deals (sometimes free) on older equipment. For UPSes, a reputable brand (like APC) will still function fine but might need new batteries, which are a lot cheaper than a whole UPS.
- ziml77 4y agoThat's a great point about a second-hand UPS. My mind has been tainted by all the non-removable batteries inside consumer products so I completely forgot that a worn-out battery on an old UPS is easy to replace.
- deviantbit 4y agoI moved my two workstations into two 4U cases. Not going back.
- chao- 4y agoI moved my desktop into a 4U case* about six years ago and never looked back. Then I wanted to build my own NAS and--oh look at that I already have one rackmount chassis... I guess I'll get another and some posts? I did and it was also a great call. *Larger fans running slower for less noise
- yboris 4y agoAre there any rack mount cases with 6-8 (3.5") hard drive slots that are under $100?
- denimnerd42 4y agonot in 2023. Under 200 yes.
- yboris 4y agoWhere is a good place to shop? NewEgg? Are there better prices elsewhere?
- denimnerd42 4y agoI like rosewill house brand on newegg. Sometimes their prices are better on their ebay site.
- kube-system 4y agoYou can get close if that's all you're looking for: https://www.ebay.com/itm/124039115388 https://www.ebay.com/itm/124039115388 With adapters for the 5.25 bays, this meets the criteria: https://www.amazon.com/RackChoice-Compact-Rackmount-Chassis-Support/dp/B0BGY9FBM3 https://www.amazon.com/RackChoice-Compact-Rackmount-Chassis-...
- marpstar 4y agoI spent a lot of time playing in bands and doing the home recording thing 10-15 years ago. Had a bunch of rack mount gear and dreamt of building out a mobile recording rig using a DJ case[1] like my dad had (for DJing weddings). Eventually found someone selling an old 4U (which is about as tall as a standard desktop is wide) ATX server case, locking front panel and all, on craigslist for cheap. It was super heavy (as was all of the other audio equipment), but having all of my stuff in one case (and only needing to set up a display, keyboard, and mouse) was pretty great. Never had much issue with heat/noise, but wasn't overly concerned at the time either. [1]: https://www.pssl.com/products/gator-console-rack-10-top-6-bottom-space https://www.pssl.com/products/gator-console-rack-10-top-6-bo...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avsteele 4y agoA 3U case can support full height cards. Anyone have a favorite 3U rackmount PC case? The only I've used and like goes out of stock regularly though.
- neilv 4y agoWhen I built my most recent home GPU server, it seemed like 3U wasn't tall enough to fit a big GPU upright, given the PCIe power connectors on top of the card, so I went 4U. Though I think you could get a double-wide GPU into a 2U with a PCIe riser cable/card.
- vluft 4y agoheck, you'll have difficulty fitting a 4090 in a 4U without special right-angle pcie power connectors
- Lammy 4y agoFor 3U/4U I like iStarUSA cases. I went for 4U for the quieter 120mm fans and so it can fit half-hight bays sideways on the front panel. Here's my video encoding workstation in an iStarUSA D-400L-7SE: https://imgur.com/a/YLjDX0e https://imgur.com/a/YLjDX0e
- jdboyd 4y agoI just bought a iStarUSA D-300 and I was disappointed that there were no easy mount points for 2.5" SSDs.
- Lammy 4y agoI just mount them to one wall of the case with double-sided adhesive tape lol You can also spring for their matching drive bays http://www.istarusa.com/en/istarusa/product_speclist.php?series=HDDCage&sub=Tray&Factor=2.5 http://www.istarusa.com/en/istarusa/product_speclist.php?ser...
- vluft 4y ago
- cptskippy 4y agoI'm confused why you'd choose ITX and a chassis that requires half height cards. There are plenty of 2U chassis that accept ITX and allow full height cards rotated 90 degrees using a riser.
- KaiserPro 4y agoYou can also rack mount "workstations" from HP and Dell. The downside is that they are 4/5u. But they are a fucktonne quieter than server hardware. The difficult part is getting the HDMI/DP extenders to work reliably or low latency enough without spending $2k. Having said all that, Jeff's approach is most likley cheaper, if more fiddly. its certainly neater and more compact.
- vluft 4y agofiber optic DP cables are maybe $70 or $80 and work pretty well in my experience. on the pricier side if you have something with TB support, you can do display and USB over that to a fiber optic TB cable (about $400); this is my current setup for my racked PC in another room to my office, with a TB hub (caldigit TS4) that splits out display and USB.
- LeSaucy 4y agoAny idea if those are thunderbolt 4? Its hard to find any vendor that will state support for 4K144hz through a dock over any sort of extension, right now I am limited to "only" 4K60.
- shmoogy 4y agoI run a fiber optic display port and can do 4K 120 from 50 feet away. Thunderbolt cables are incredibly expensive I just ran the DisplayPort, an Ethernet, and usb cable - not sure I've seen any TB4 optical cables that are long lengths yet, just the Apple one that's like 6 feet for $200. You can buy Tb3 ones for 400 or so.
- kentonv 4y agoI have a 50ft Monoprice SlimRun DisplayPort cable on my 4k 144hz gaming monitor and it works great. However, it's just a DisplayPort cable, not thunderbolt, direct from PC to monitor, no dock. And it cost $170. :/
- vluft 4y agothe only available fiber optic thunderbolt cables I'm aware of right now are from corning, and they are thunderbolt 3. I'm running 5120x1440@120hz through it (and a variety of USB); 4k144hz would be about 35% more bandwidth. Corning lists the cable as supporting 2x4k or 1x5k (presumably both at 60hz); 5k is the same bandwidth as mine, and 2x4k is some what more but less than 4k144hz. Total bandwidth on the cable is 40g and bandwidth needed for 4k144hz is about 32g I believe. can't guarantee it'd work, but 4k120hz probably does?
- amelius 4y agoOne important thing that server racks don't address is noise.
- layoric 4y agoThis is what turned me off as well. I ended up getting older Dell 2011-3 dual socket workstation for cheap. Still heaps of power, room for upgrades but whisper quiet when idle and under load.
- hinkley 4y agoWhen craigslist was brand spanking new I found a ruggedized 1/4 height rack that looked like it was surplus military. My second stroke of luck was that the hall closet in my apartment had a corner in it that would exactly fit this rack, telephone wiring junction box was immediately above the rack, and all of the house wiring was straight Cat5 runs from there, so a few new outlet covers and some cable rejigging and we had internet everywhere (but only 2 pair where the phone plugged in), terminated at the rack, which was partly muffled by winter coats. You can't push a lot of BTUs this way, but you can do a few. My solution before this was to hide a tower PC behind the couch. For the right kind of couch and the right vent holes, you can eat an awful lot of ambient noise by using major furniture. There's lots of space out there for things like this. I also tried at one point to build an air filter that would fit under a bed (less noise, no floor space, fewer dust bunnies.
- horsawlarway 4y agoVery much this. One interesting thing about going the rack route is that most of the hardware optimizes for considerations a data center/large corporation might have. That can be nice in a lot of ways (hardware is fairly robust, layouts are usually friendly for quick access/maintenance, overall density of machines is pretty good). But it means almost no one is paying attention to how much noise these things make, because for most of the target audience that's WAY down the list of things they care about. I have a couple of - not elderly but not new - 1u and 2u machines, and they are LOUD AS FUCK. I used to run my server farm in my office when it was just spare personal computers (under the table I use for hobby projects), but I quickly ended up moving it down the basement when running the rack machines. They're just too loud for comfort on a semi-regular basis.
- heelix 4y agoIn the early 90's, my Bride considered the pile of computers around my desk. "Why not just get one big one?" Fast forward a couple weeks where I was shopping at the Lockheed outlet store - and found a Sun 3/280s and 19" wide, 8' tall rack for $25. She was not amused to have a 'big one' the size of a fridge in our tiny apartment. That old server has gone through many, many incarnations of hardware.
- kvandy 4y agoWhat did you run on it?
- geerlingguy 4y agoHaha you were technically correct, the best kind!
- rexreed 4y agoIs there a website or link for more details on that Lockheed store?
- heelix 4y agoI think it closed down when they shut down the factories here in the Minneapolis area (Eagan). It was a neat place, at the time.
- systems_glitch 4y agoStill have the Sun3? :P
- heelix 4y agoJust the shell, but it is loved. :) Will be housing a new threadripper next, when AMD gets around to the zen 4 releases. https://i.imgur.com/S5F31qW.jpg https://i.imgur.com/S5F31qW.jpg https://i.imgur.com/SpMMPXQ.jpg https://i.imgur.com/SpMMPXQ.jpg The magic had already left the old Sun hardware, when we tried it.
- buildbot 4y agoTangential - does anyone know of a good smallish rack that has some sound deadening but also can mount say, a c4140 that is 36in long? Would be nice to rack all my computer gear in one place, but if so, I would want to put everything in it.
- alexjplant 4y agoNo idea about sound deadening capabilities but the live sound industry also uses the 19" rack standard so there are a bunch to choose from [1] if you want something non-traditional from a computing perspective. The roto-molded Gators were my personal favorite when I was trafficking a lot in rack systems... even more tangentially I really wish I'd help onto my ADA rig (MP-1, Quadraverb, Microtube 200) as now they're going for stupid amounts of money. [1] https://www.sweetwater.com/c459--Rackmount_Cases https://www.sweetwater.com/c459--Rackmount_Cases
- geerlingguy 4y agoI remember TechnoTim (on YouTube/Twitch) installed a fully enclosed rack that had temperature-controlled fans at the top for extra ventilation. It seemed like he liked how it muted the noise a bit, but I'm not sure how much.
- buildbot 4y agoHmm I'll check that out, thank you!
- vluft 4y ago
- kentonv 4y agoSo I'm the guy who rack-mounted a bunch of game machines for https://kentonshouse.com https://kentonshouse.com -- and am currently nearing completion of a new house with even more machines. Here's some of the challenges I've personally encountered in this. *Fitting the GPU* A normal GPU, mounted in the normal way (perpendicular to the motherboard), will not fit in a 2U case. It looks like Jeff's solution was to buy a half-height GPU. Neat! I didn't actually realize those exist. But it looks like NVidia's regular consumer-oriented GPUs don't come in this form factor; Jeff instead went with an RTX A2000, which is part of NVidia's "professional" GPU line. The problem with this is that it's way more expensive to achieve the same gaming performance. In my previous house I solved the problem by using 3U chassis. This provides just enough space to mount the GPU perpendicular. However, it still had problems. Modern GPUs require supplementary power direct from the PSU. The socket for this usually points outward, away from the motherboard. In a 3U chassis, this socket is right up against the top plate so there is no room to plug in the power. Sometimes you can find a GPU that has the power socket pointing in a different direction, but they have become rare. I actually had to physically mod ten GTX 1060's by hand, cutting away the plastic socket housing and directly attaching each power wire to the corresponding pin. Big PITA but it worked. In the new house I'm going with 2U, but using a riser card. So, the GPU is mounted parallel to the motherboard. This seems to work OK. The big problem is ensuring the chassis and the motherboard both have their expansion slots aligned right for this. Most 2U chassis are designed for perpendicular, half-height expansion cards. A smaller fraction support full-height parallel cards on a riser. The motherboard also has to have a PCIe slot in the correct place for the riser. This is usually the "top" slot, closest to the CPU, and I've noticed a lot of motherboards these days are opting to omit that slot to make more space around the CPU. The chassis I'll probably go with is the iStarUSA D-200: https://www.istarusa.com/en/istarusa/products.php?model=D-200 https://www.istarusa.com/en/istarusa/products.php?model=D-20... (I'm not too excited about it though, and would be happy for other recommendations.) At least one motherboard that worked when I tried it was the ASUS PRIME B660-PLUS, but I haven't made a final motherborad selection yet. A further problem which might be specific to this chasis is that the total horizontal space between the riser card and the power supply is tight. Some GPUs are excessively "tall" and won't fit. (The same problem probably applies to 3U chassis with perpendicular mounting.) I was just barely able to fit the EVGA GeForce RTX 3070 Ti 08G-P5-3785-K into the space. *RAM orientation* Servers orient their RAM modules parallel to the direction of air current, that is, perpendicular to the back of the chasis. For reasons I don't understand, consumer / gaming motherboards almost never do this, they orient the RAM parallel to the back. Maybe this is because desktop chassis are not usually optimized for efficient airflow anyway so it doesn't matter? And there's more space on the board if the RAM can be mounted this way? I dunno. Anyway, in my experiments so far this has just not caused a problem. Yeah, the RAM has non-ideal orientation, but there haven't been any issues with overheating. ::shrug:: *PSU* Servers use a different form factor of PSU. This is infuriating because all the server PSUs available retail seem to be terrible compared to desktop PSUs! They tend not to support higher-end wattage (needed for power-hungry GPUs) and they are never "modular" (you get a bundle of cords sticking out of the PSU and there's no way to remove the ones you don't need except with scissors). There are some 2U chassis that actually allow you to mount a desktop PSU. However, in practice they are not actually compatible with any modern desktop PSU, because all such PSUs these days are designed with their intake fan on the top or bottom, not on the front/back. In a 2U chassis, that intake will be totally blocked by the top/bottom of the chassis. I am going to have to live with crappy server PSUs I guess. *Retail server market is awkward* More generally, I get the general feeling that the server-oriented components which are available via normal retail channels like NewEgg are... not what big server farms actually use. Everything seems kinda crappy? Maybe I just feel this way because they don't candy-coat everything the way the consumer market does. But I have the funny feeling that people building out datacenters generally order mass quantities of chassis, PSUs, and even motherboards tailored specifically to their needs, and as a result the retail market for server components may be surprisingly small and poorly served. But that's just my suspicion based on my experiences here.
- systems_glitch 4y agoI went through this in the early 2000s when I was a) exposed to rack stuff in CCNA class in high school/votech and b) dot-com surplus started showing up really cheap on eBay. Nowadays my desktops are either SFF or mid-tower CAD workstations. We've got some control computers racked with test equipment/tools but they're not really general purpose workstations.
- withinrafael 4y agoI'm slowly migrating some homelab equipment to a StarTech 24U but am stuck at cable management. Are there any resources on how you manage cables, particularly at the sides/rear of the rack? Are those cable management arms still a go-to?
- pbronez 4y agoZipties. So. Many. Zipties.
- geerlingguy 4y agoI use zipties when I have a more permanent install (like this one), but will use velcro ties (you can get a huge pack on Amazon for under ten bucks) when I know I'll be swapping things out here and there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- justinlloyd 4y agoZip ties, velcro, channel guides, punch down harnesses, gangways, and so forth. Just be sure to add strain relief by utilizing anchor points in the case so you don't have 20lbs of cabling hanging off a few RJ-45 sockets.
- suprjami 4y agoI have a coworker whose entire family PCs are rack mounted in the garage. He has HDMI and USB extensions through the house, so the only thing on desks is a monitor and powered USB hub. Perfectly silent. It seems very comfy.
- rektide 4y agoWas super easy & fun when we were on 1080p60! But that became kind of limiting for my preferences. For a while it wasnt really practical, unless you could accept this pretty low bandwidth stream. But now fiber-optic display cables are readily available. My first purchase was a 100ft/30m 32Gbps DisplayPort cable, for $55! To be honest, I couldnt believe it worked; I assumed it was a scam. It's indeed excessively long... too long! I can make it out my room & up to the roof & compute from there with less than half the cable. It's way harder to unroll & reroll than any cable I've ever had before, but also way longer. I have since gone back and bought shorter cables. Thankfully active extension cables are pretty good & tend to just work. Newer models have an inline 1-port usb-hub every 25ft/7.5 (used to be every 5m), and then a wall-wart at the end to power the hubs (to honest that feels like it should be unnecessary; a dc-dc booster mid-span & bus power should be fine, albeit leaving nearly no power available at the end). Also beware, there's a 7 tier limit from root-hub to device, so 5 hubs maximum * 7.5m, if you only plug in a single thing (a wireless keyboard/mouse dongle).
- ciupicri 4y agoWhat about peripherals and latency?
- rektide 4y agoPeripherals are all usb2/usb3 attached. Latency would be super interesting to test for both. I tend to think 4-5 usb hubs are still under 1ms latency. I'd expect the DisplayPort digital->optical->digital path takes less than 1ms too. But I'm guessing, for sure.
- lxchase 4y agoLikely marginally higher, but if you wire the house up with fiber, you can run USB/TB docks over fiber.
- abudabi123 4y agoIs there science to support the vertical arrangement of server-pizza-boxes as books on a bookshelf as being passively cooler? The horizontal orientation makes sense for servicing which would be possible by a hinge mechanism like those hidden tables in the arm rest of a fancy design chair.
- justinlloyd 4y agoI moved my workstation in to a 4U rack mount case. Can highly recommend it. Built a custom rack mount cabinet that looks like a traditional arcade game cabinet. Moved the workstation along with the rack mount UPS, and several other bits of computer hardware, in to the arcade cabinet. Fabricated some shallow drawers with over extension, soft-close, self-locking slide outs, and installed a separate computer for running the emulators. Lots of noise reduction padding, lots of air flow with large dimater fans. Then I made another custom rack mount case, side-by-side, again lots of noise reduction padding, for the Synology NASes, Mac Mini, laser printer, cable modem, network switch, and various bits of networking hardware.
- amarshall 4y agoDoes anyone know of short-depth ATX chassis (preferably 2U)? Short as in <13" (330mm)? I’m jealous of the ITX case here, at only 55mm over the ITX width; that should mean a <300mm ATX case should be possible, but I’ve never found anything close to that. Most everything is >14", usually 15"+, and wasted space to fit a bunch of HDDs or something.
- ganoushoreilly 4y agoMake one! Protocase is a great resource. Alternatively reach out to Sliger they may have something that works. They are in the process of moving (or were over the holidays), but they make great cases.
- fundad 4y agoSpon con
- Aloha 4y agoInterestingly I've gone the opposite way for a couple years - desk side cases (full towers) instead of racked equipment, part of that is I prefer 2 post racks to four.
- tibbon 4y agoMy gaming PC lives in a rack in my basement now in a 4u case. There is a 150ft optical hdmi cable running to the third floor, and a usb over cat6 cable returning control signals. I like how it is entirely silent to me, and does not warm my room
- ascagnel_ 4y agoI have a near-identical setup, and it’s absolutely spectacular. The worst part was running conduit, since the layout of my home is such that I had to run conduit up from my office, run wire across the attic, then more conduit down the opposite exterior wall to my basement.
- tibbon 4y agoI'm in a 140 year old victorian. Getting cables through these walls is interesting
- aidenn0 4y agoA 3U really opens things up for possibilities: - Full-height PCI cards fit (though some GPUs have taller than full-height coolers; if the HS/F protrudes above the mounting bracket, you'll have to measure). - You can use larger fans, which can help a lot with airflow and/or noise. Just throw away the fans that come with the case as anything designed for a rack assumes you'll be wearing hearing protection while working around it. - More motherboard options. If you use a power-supply designed for rack-mount, standard ATX motherboards fit fine. If you want to use a desktop power supply there are plenty of micro-ATX options.
- ajxs 4y agoI have a music studio here in my home, for my own personal use. It's fairly common for high-end studio hardware such as signal processors, and synthesisers to be made in rack-mountable format. At some point I figured I could save some desk space by building a studio PC in a 2U rack mounted case. This meant I could keep it directly together with the rack-mounted power conditioner, audio, and MIDI interfaces that it connects to. I figured this was hitting a studio ergonomics home run, as the heart of my studio now fits in 5U of rack space. As the years have gone on, I've found it less and less convenient to build my studio around a bulky 19" rack. These days I'm looking at ways to shrink this setup further. Less and less mid-range hardware is rack mounted these days too. I'm not about to get rid of my setup anytime soon, but I won't be building another one like it when it comes time to upgrade. In the home studio world this kind of setup is much more common. I think a lot of people are attracted to the aesthetic of rack-mounted studio gear. I know I definitely am. I personally don't find this setup as ergonomic as desktop modules though. I think manufacturers are coming to the same conclusion.
- parker_mountain 4y agoI used to have a rackmounted pc, and audio interface, personal server, etc all on one rack. Over time, things shrunk, and it made more sense to put it all in a well ventilated spot in the garage with a 10gbps link to my office. I could have used wifi, the bandwidth would have been fine, but where's the fun in that ;)
- tkanarsky 4y agoYou could also throw a Thunderbolt interface card in it and fish a 50m optical tb3 cable through the walls to a dock on your desk :)
- pbronez 4y agoThat's the dream! Going another step, I'd love to have a Thunderbolt to fiber adapter without having everything baked into a single cable. These products exist, but cost $5000 for each end https://www.atto.com/products/thunderbolt-adapters/thunderlink/thunderbolt-to-fc/TLFC-3322-D00 https://www.atto.com/products/thunderbolt-adapters/thunderli...
- ghostly_s 4y agoThere are so many more convenient alternatives to the traditional massive tower for consumer PCs today, yet they are all severely limited by the same issue: modern GPU form factors. I really wish the GPU makers would get a clue and come up with a more flexible standard. I suspect just making the heat sinks modular/swappable would mostly solve the problem.
- rldjbpin 4y agothe title is very misleading. he downgraded to lower-powered parts to manage assembling a system without modifications in the space restraints. all well and good, especially given the hardware was sponsored. but it should not be titled as such imo. "moving" to me implies that the 3080 was somehow made to work inside that case. regardless, the conversation of this thread has some interesting takes about this concept.