3 ms·
Do the mylar balloons noticeably expand? I thought they hold their size pretty well. Also, I wonder how the heat seeking missile can track such a small and low
by giantg2 4y ago
Do the mylar balloons noticeably expand? I thought they hold their size pretty well.
Also, I wonder how the heat seeking missile can track such a small and low thermal object. Must be one hell of a sensor.
- colechristensen 4y agoIf you've ever played with an IR camera, there's plenty to be seen. It would be quite hard to have a balloon without significant contrast with the background of the sky. Especially if it had running electronics. Consumer sensors can detect a fraction of a degree difference.
- myself248 4y agoThe pico balloon's electronics run so little and so infrequently, they're not likely to be generating noticeable heat. The solar panel itself, a big black-ish object just hanging in the sun, would be nice and warm just like an equivalent rectangle of black paper would, though. I think the envelope is gonna be the much more visible target. At high altitude silhouetted against the blackness of space, the balloon itself will be considerably warmer, even in what we consider "cold" air. Or if you're looking down on it from above, silhouetted against the warm ground, it will be quite cold. Also the mylar, which I presume is aluminized, is a heck of a radar reflector.
- colechristensen 4y agoAir at 30,000 ft is -50 F. You need, even for a very small box, heating measured in watts to keep your electronics at a temperature where they'll function. Even if you didn't, even tiny amounts of heating are going to be visible. The electronics box will look like a lighthouse beacon in IR. Source: have launched small electronics to 100,000 ft on a weather balloon.
- myself248 4y agoThis balloon did not have a heater. From TFA: > These floater balloons often use only solar panels, no batteries. Batteries were dropped from the projects early on because they have limited charging cycles before they stop accepting a charge, especially in the harsh temps at altitude, -40F/-40C or worse. When the battery stops accepting a charge, it ends telemetry from the mission. So they only report telemetry during daylight, when the sun is at a high enough angle to illuminate the tiny solar panels. In the Arctic winter, the days are short and the sun might not get high enough to wake up the electronics.
- tbrownaw 4y ago> Also, I wonder how the heat seeking missile can track such a small and low thermal object. Must be one hell of a sensor. A discussion thread somewhere a couple days ago said they're not really "heat seeking" but object-tracking from a video feed, and the video camera just happens (well, deliberately because it works better) to use IR bands instead of visible bands.
- nradov 4y agoSome people may be confused because originally the AIM-9 literally was a heat seeker and could only lock onto hot targets. The later models introduced after about 1977 use a completely different seeker and are far more capable.
- Lukas_Skywalker 4y ago„Since the AIM-9L model, which made its debut in the late 1970s, Sidewinders have been “all-aspect" missiles, which means they can pick out the heat of the skin of target against an ambient background instead of just hot exhaust parts of the engine“ [1] Apparently, against the cold background of the sky, a slightly warmed balloon is visible enough. [1]: https://www.quora.com/The-Chinese-spy-balloon-was-shot-with-a-Sidewinder-missile-a-missile-that-locks-on-to-the-heat-from-the-engines-of-aircraft-Are-high-altitude-balloons-really-hot-enough-for-that-Can-the-F-22-even-reach-high-altitude https://www.quora.com/The-Chinese-spy-balloon-was-shot-with-...
- ianburrell 4y agoThe big development was the imaging sensor in AIM-9X from 2003.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- infradig 4y agoThe article tells me they expand from 1 meter to the size of a car (American presumably). They can carry a radar reflector.
- myself248 4y agoLatex balloons stretch. Mylar balloons do not, unless they're underinflated at launch, and that's not really stretching, it's just filling out. I think the article has it wrong.
- hoppyhoppy2 4y agoWhat part of the article has it wrong? It says: >Unlike latex or rubber weather balloons which inflate and stretch as they rise into lower atmospheric pressures, these mylar balloons can't stretch, so their fully inflated ground size will be the same as their size at high altitudes, meaning the pico balloon won't get much bigger than 32". The parts that mention expansion say they're referring to latex balloons.
- myself248 4y agoThat's been edited since my first read-through, it was super confused before.