2 ms·
We could also get rid of a lot of global logistics by going back to local manufacturing. There's absolutely nothing that dictates that iPhones can be built only
by mschuster91 4y ago
We could also get rid of a lot of global logistics by going back to local manufacturing. There's absolutely nothing that dictates that iPhones can be built only in China, or that every grocery store needs to keep strawberries or other agricultural products all year round (which have to be sometimes flown around the world [1]).
The key problem is that CO2 emissions still aren't priced anywhere near to true externality cost, and so no one has incentives for local, low emissions production - instead, everyone goes to the lowest bidder by employment costs (and sometimes, environmental regulations as well).
[1] https://lufthansa-cargo.com/industries-agriculture-food https://lufthansa-cargo.com/industries-agriculture-food
- nradov 4y agoThat's no "going back" to local manufacturing. Most places never had any real manufacturing in the first place, and the notion of replicating manufacturing infrastructure for consumer goods in every area is absurd. That idea is based on a complete lack of understanding over how supply chains work. The CO2 emissions for transporting an iPhone from Asia are insignificant. The real emissions cost is in the manufacturing, not the transport.
- mschuster91 4y ago> That idea is based on a complete lack of understanding over how supply chains work. Before extremely cheap overseas shipping was made possible by the standard shipping container and giant container ships to match, almost all production was local (i.e. actually regional or at least continental) by necessity. Silicon Valley is named after all the semiconductor fabrication ffs, and a ton of that has migrated off to Taiwan. And a lot of regions in Western countries got absolutely wrecked as they couldn't compete with cheap, environmentally destructive manufacturing or mining in China / India any more. It's high time to reverse that, not just because China is an increasingly hostile dictatorship, Taiwan is under constant threat of a military invasion and India is going off the deep end as well under Modi, but also because we need the jobs back domestically to prevent even more people falling to far-right scapegoat bullshit.
- mojomark 4y agoAs someone in the maritime industry (ship design), I tend to agree that local manufacturing is an important component. However, there is still the distribution of raw materials - from concentraded locations where materials are mined/recycled, to points of manufacture, then to points of end use. In an ideal world, we'd have universal star trek 3D printers that can build any imagined product, from food to cars, from some the atom up, that is used and recycled in situ. Until then, I'm afraid there will be a growing need for cargo transport. That said, I am a proponent of scalable/distributed vice monolithic transport modes. To me, that is where we need to head in terms of ship/rail/etc. systems. This revolution in design is already starting to emerge.