11 ms·
Whistleblowers take note: don’t trust cropping tools
- a_shovel 4y agoFor those who are thinking "Yeah, duh, just use an image editor to crop it," as I did at first, this article is probably most useful for barely-tech-literate people, who can use Microsoft Word, Outlook, Edge, maybe Teams, and not much else. They wouldn't think that they'd need to open a whole separate image editor when Word has a cropping function built in that's always worked for them before.
- tjoff 4y agoNot foolproof, there have been instances when people have been cropping in an image-editor and failed to realize that the thumbnail hadn't been updated and leaked information.
- a_shovel 4y agoOkay, that one might catch me. I couldn't tell if an image had a thumbnail stored with it to begin with.
- Hamuko 4y agoIf I need to ensure there's nothing on an image that wasn't supposed to be there, I just copy the visible pixels and paste it to a new document. No EXIF data, outdated thumbnails or anything.
- e28eta 4y agoI can actually imagine a tool that’d copy/paste the metadata along with the data, but I don’t know if any exist.
- chihuahua 4y agoUsing a screenshot tool should be safe. It will treat all pixels on the screen the same, so it doesn't know that some pixels have metadata beyond what's visible on the screen.
- hef19898 4y agoThen print and scan the screen shot before faxing it to authorities.
- toss1 4y agoAnd make sure that the scan is of low enough resolution that it fails to pickup the printer identification dot pattern in the printout... The fax should help with that, except that it'll reveal the location of your source fax. Using fax software/service needs its own security... maybe snail-mail... This is getting seriously nontrivial
- adolph 4y agoDon’t forget to pilfer newspapers from around the country and cut/glue letters from different fonts to compose the message and use homemade paper as the base layer.
- hef19898 4y agoInstead of home made, use the most prolific paper you can imagine!
- hef19898 4y agoWell, if we talk about goverbment whistleblower programs I assume using a fax from a random location while travelling would be good enough to not be identified by your employer (or whom ever you blow whistle on). If you do blow the whistel on the government, well, you better trust your journalist partner a lot. Or use a trustworthy lawyer as a go between. But hey, one could send the fax back and forth, cut of the fax numbers and physically mail it from a very busy train station! And have a someone put the letter into the letterbox for you, someone you pay out of view of any CCTV cameras!
- hilbert42 4y ago"...failed to realize that the thumbnail hadn't been updated..." Right, I'd never use part of the original image. Best print it out and rescan it, preferably on different scanner. Being truly anonymous is enormously difficult, even the Bauer pattern/Bayer filter shape in one's image sensor will give one away. That alone requires sophisticated filtering to decouple it from a specific sensor/camera. And that's only the beginning, there are many other factors that contribute to the leaking one's identity.
- acuozzo 4y ago> Best print it out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code
- jwestbury 4y agoBlack and white from here on out, then.
- hilbert42 4y agoRight. Good idea, see my 2nd comment.
- hilbert42 4y agoI'm aware of that, hence my comment about the many other issues that have to be considered in decoupling information from hardware. 1. First, most whistleblowing comes from B&W documents so color isn't an issue. If it is the case then there are alternative solutions which I'll not persue here in any detail (the post would be very long). 2. Printing then rescanning can decouple the camera to some extent as physical distortions are introduced by (a) the geometry of the inkjet nozzles or laser subsystem, (b) more geometric distortion is added by changes in paper size as its fused/dried, (c) additional distortion is added by the optics of the rescanning system, same goes for any further printing and so on. Also, each stage alters the gamma and adds other non linearities to the transfer. 3. Reducing the scanning resolution will add additional distortions, blurring is to be encouraged but not to the point of illegibility. (Doing a low resolution copy on a FAX machine with time/date/headers/footers turned off could help.) 4. This may sufficiently decouple the camera but it won't decouple the copying/scanning/rescanning equipment. Best do this on machines that are located well away from the source so they're not easily traceable or associated with you or your work. 5. Copying documents across multiple different photocopiers will help as they all add optical and other geometric distortions and transfer—gamma-type—errors. Deliberately lightening and darkening the image at each stage will further increase distortions. The combined distortions will make it very difficult (but not impossible) to reverse engineer the path back to the source. Have you ever wondered why the quality of the printed type in copies of evidence, FOIs, official documents etc. often looks so daggy and blurred as to be almost illegible? 6. The idea is to add as much distortion and blurring in the chain of copies as is possible and yet still keep the final copy legible/identifiable. It's a fine balance. 7. That still does not guarantee anonymity. Sensitive documents are often 'doctored' so that each recipient receives a subtlety different copy, spacing between words may change so may the page layout, also small seemingly insignificant and barely obvious 'marks' on the page will differ between copies thus identifying each recipient. None of the camera techniques above will overcome this problem. 8. One technique is to retype the document so that it is almost identical in both looks and content but with lots of subtle changes in both layout and wording—but NOT to the extent of changing the document's meaning. Same goes for modifying images (a complex matter). As a last resort this could give you a degree of plausible deniability in cases where marked documents are issued. If you do this it would be very advisable to spirit away actual copies of the originals in a truly safe location—you may really need them one day (after you're accused of, say, forgery). I'd suggest you only go down this path if you are very competent and the stakes are very high. 9. None of what I've said should be taken lightly. No matter how hard you try to decouple yourself totally from the source (or from any involvement) it is nigh on impossible to hide from formidable and sophisticated forensics if applied relentlessly. 10. Moreover, whistleblowers, more often than not, end up being reveilled by fellow workers and usually without a job or decent reemployment prospects. Unfortunately, our culture hasn't embraced whistleblowers and whistleblowing as it should. It's a very risky business. Take the case of whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg and the Pentagon Papers; his effort wasn't rewarded as we ought to expect and he nearly ended up being locked up. Moreover, at one point Ellsberg wistfully noted that reaction by the American public to his efforts wasn't very favorable. When it comes to whistleblowing it seems not much has improved in the last five decades. _ Edit: FYI, there are many excellent videos on Daniel Ellsberg and whistleblowing on YouTube.
- knodi123 4y agoReferring to TechTV presenter Cat Schwartz, I presume? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catherine_Schwartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catherine_Schwartz
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 4y agoi just screenshot images. that way it'll lose any metadata. any parts outside of my screenshotted area can't be included... and i think the black rectangles are genuinely black in sharex...
- kerblang 4y agoI think I would do this by default because I'm so ignorant/incompetent with the fancier tools that I'd never think to look for a cropper. I'm the cretin that says, "Oh I can do this in MS Paint!" and even spends a 1/2 hour remembering how to do that much...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bcrosby95 4y agoIirc some formats support cropping too. So even if you crop in an image editor, all the data may still be there.
- SapporoChris 4y agoI sometimes get smartphone photos of computer screens sent to me by friends. It makes me cringe every time, but now I'm thinking maybe they're onto something.
- c0nsumer 4y agoWhile I doubt they are meaning it as such, it's not far off from the technique of physically redacting a printout and then scanning that as duotone so there was never, ever a digital path between the original and the resulting digital copy.
- LarryMullins 4y agoI believe this is often done to avoid corporate surveillance on the computer that might record the screenshot and exfiltration.
- thrashh 4y agoI think it’s usually done because copying a file from a computer to a smartphone universally is still a pain in 2023 - Bluetooth file transfer… I don’t even know where to begin - AirDrop requires you to be in the Apple ecosystem. I think default settings also require you to be logged in the same Apple account on both devices too - Cloud storage services need you to install the app or login into the website on both your phone and the computer with the same account. Very few of my non-tech friends even have any cloud storage service outside what their phone uses Ngl, I take photos of my screens sometimes
- burkaman 4y ago> barely-tech-literate people I think this is a little unfair. I would not blame anyone for thinking that the part of the image they cropped is deleted. That's what the word means, that's what it looks like is happening, there's usually no warning that it's recoverable. When you delete text it is really gone from the document, even though you can undo to get it back. It's totally reasonable to expect images to work the same way.
- a_shovel 4y agoWhat I had in mind when I was writing that was a story I once read of a user who did all of her computer interactions through Word (i.e. all of her emails were empty with a Word document attachment containing the text, among a few other amusing anecdotes). But yeah, the characterization is a bit unfair from that perspective.
- alpaca128 4y agoI know a few people personally who mainly used Word (and increasingly also web browsers) when working on computers, and it's sometimes obvious they view everything a computer does through that lens. For some people only used to Windows even appstores are a foreign concept, a relative's first impulse when trying to install a phone app is to open the phone's web browser and do a Google search. Those are things many recent UI "improvements" haven't considered.
- heavenlyblue 4y agoArguably even undo is probably now saved in the documents themselves.
- wolrah 4y agoOP isn't saying the person is barely tech literate because they didn't expect the image to be restorable, but that they're likely barely tech literate because they were using a word processor as an image editor. Abusing Microsoft Office applications to do things they're not designed to do has sort of a bathtub curve of likelihood versus tech literacy. The people most likely to do it are either largely tech illiterate or skilled hackers with far too much time on their hands.
- godot 4y agoIt really would benefit most people to learn to use (Windows) Snipping Tool or (Mac) cmd-shift-4 to crop an image that is currently displayed on their screen; that would create a new image altogether (cropped screenshot). It's truly even easier to use than whatever Gsuite or Office alternatives they would otherwise use, once you know of their existence. My significant other is outside of tech and wasn't aware of either of these. Once shown, there was no reason to go back to using anything else to crop images. No image editors involved!
- thrashh 4y agoScreenshotting an image will easily destroy resolution. It’s not a good way if you are making a document intended to be printed
- albert_e 4y agoyes. saving a screenshot as JPG (lossy format) adds more loss - if you started with a lossy image in the first place then we are losing even more information by screenshotting it and saving it again in a lossy format. even when not intended for print, when making formal documents and presentations I look for the original images at highest resolution available.
- alpaca128 4y agoMac OS' preinstalled screenshot tool saves in PNG, same with Android screenshots. Not sure about Windows' Snipping Tool but it would surprise me if it was different there.
- zellyn 4y agoAn increasing number of image editors are focusing on “non-destructive editing” too…
- alpaca128 4y agoThat's true, but the information for that is usually stored in the image editor's own format, not in the exported image file.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoExcept when we're talking mobile apps. Samsung apps have a penchant for producing... enriched files in common formats. For example, "motion photo" feature I used few years ago would give you perfectly normal JPG file that also happened to store a short video. Nothing I know other than Samsung phones can read the video part directly, though there exists desktop software that can extract it and save as separate video file. More recently, I've noticed photo editor tools on Samsung phones allow you to undo previously made edits on an already saved file, including any destructive crops and transforms - meaning the original is being persisted somewhere. I haven't checked where, but I imagine it's again attached to the back of the JPG you thought you've cropped/redacted. Somewhat related: PlantUML. It's a tool for generating diagrams from plaintext descriptions. One of its most interesting, if not well-known, features is that it saves "editable PNGs" by default - that is, PNGs it produces have the plaintext diagram code attached to the image as metadata. Seems mostly harmless, but it could technically leak information you put in the diagram code but made not visible in the image.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoThis reminds me of Federal Public Service Finance of Belgium. When they take possession of items for various reasons they want to sell them off to reclaim lost tax revenue. Cars for example, now you must know that in Europe for some reason people are very weary of their VIN. It's not shown on websites as it is in the USA. So the tax office posts a PDF with all the cars they possessed with their VINs, but with 80% blacked out. With black boxes. And they didn't flatten the PDF. Sending around data is a minefield. Metadata everywhere. It's so easy to lose track of it.
- pxx 4y agoVINs are by design very visible on cars? You could get the same information by just going to the lot... Though the overall lesson of the story is good: analog redactions with a permanent market and a b&w photocopier are recommended for anybody without 100% confidence in their tools.
- Something1234 4y agoCan you really trust photocopiers with the microdots they encode nowadays?
- jaywalk 4y agoIf all you're worried about is redaction and not anonymity, a photocopier is perfectly fine for the job.
- Something1234 4y agoThis about anonymity applies for whistleblowers which the forwarded article was about.
- sokoloff 4y agoAren't those only in color photocopiers/printers (relying on the lesser visibility of yellow ink)?
- charles_f 4y agoThe only method I somewhat trust is taking a screenshot of the thing I want to strip the metadata from
- jraph 4y agoMake sure you don't care about the time and location of the screenshot and possibly the user name being leaked if you are not careful :-)
- tjoff 4y agoI wouldn't even trust that blindly, I totally imagine that there could be metadata in the screenshot containing for example the title of the window being screenshotted etc. If noone does that right now it is just an update away.
- chasd00 4y agoi think if you export to a bitmap then you at least have a fighting chance. The bitmap format is simple enough that you could probably use a hex editor to read the header segment and be reasonably sure you understand what is tagging along with the file. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMP_file_format https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMP_file_format
- kurthr 4y agoUse a separate digital camera and JPG rescale/compress the hell out of it after the fact. Screen grabs are convenient, but not sufficiently lossy, and can leak information. If you're feeling rough, run the screencap through an OCR and a spell checker first before taking an off axis picture in Times New Roman.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- antegamisou 4y agoCorrect answer is always getting buried to the bottom haha.
- epilys 4y agoI'm just a nobody, but I wouldn't trust the Intercept on OPSEC advice. From a purely technical point, they did fail to protect their sources when they exposed Reality Winner to the US government.
- jvanderbot 4y ago"Has failed in the past" would remove every company from doing opsec advice columns.
- probably_wrong 4y agoThere's a second possibility, though: that after having screwed up this badly they are now doing their best to protect future sources. Or as Thomas J. Watson put it: "Recently, I was asked if I was going to fire an employee who made a mistake that cost the company $600,000. No, I replied, I just spent $600,000 training him. Why would I want somebody to hire his experience?"
- bell-cot 4y ago...and the 1970's (first I heard it, IIR) comeback: Don't fire him, and you've paid $600,000 to train just him. Fire him, and you've paid $600,000 to train everybody else at the company. Which one is the better value?
- egberts1 4y agoOriginal employee, especially the higher up they are in skillset.
- karaterobot 4y agoI would not pay $600k to teach everyone at the company that if they make a mistake I will fire them to set an example. If that was my position, it's a lot cheaper just to walk around threatening people and making them feel paranoid every day at work. But I think it's a bad position to take. So I'd probably keep the one guy who is never going to make that mistake again around, and fix whatever system allowed the mistake to happen in the first place.
- paulpauper 4y agoThis is why sensitive screenshots should always be edited and saved in something like MS Paint. This way you see everything and minimal metadata. no surprises. Fancy editing tools always have hidden stuff. Text should be redacted by blacking it out, not blurring, which can also be reconstructed.
- Maxburn 4y agoIt pains me that the easy crop handles in mspaint seem to have gone away in win11. I don't have a win11 machine in front of me but I'm thinking there is now a tool to accomplish simple crop in the new and "improved" mspaint?
- wlesieutre 4y agoSeems the same as always to me, the top left corner is fixed but you can click and drag to change the canvas size from the bottom right. Alternate way is to select the area you want to keep and then click the crop button on the toolbar.
- Maxburn 4y agoThat's exactly how old paint worked. Ctrl-a for select all and place things so that the top & left is where you want it and then you can grab the handle to do the bottom & right. Always done it that way. I'll look for the crop button in paint 11, don't think I've noticed it yet. Sadly looks like win 10 does hit EOL before I retire so I've got one more generation to deal with before I slip away to linux and mac.
- hacknewslogin 4y agoI find the "snip and sketch" tool handy. If you push the "windows + shift + s" keys it lets you draw a box around what you want a "snip" of. Then you'll get a notification you can click on that will bring up basic editing tools, including image crop.
- Maxburn 4y ago
- nhchris 4y agoSomething to keep in mind when accusing people of overreacting to "minor" data leaks, such as a little extra metadata here, some telemetry there... they add up. And one day, you might have to do something actually important, and there will be all these little landmines lying around.
- LarryMullins 4y agoWe need a return to WYSIWYG principles. Any metadata stored in a file should be shown to the user in some way, to make them aware of that metadata existing. And if the metadata is incomprehensible to the user, then maybe it shouldn't be stored at all. There shouldn't be any surprises. If a file has an embedded thumbnail preview of itself which could become out of sync with the main image data, both should be shown to the user so they have an opportunity to notice it.
- jefftk 4y agoThat's a bit of a weird use of WYSIWYG, which is usually used to mean that you can't see the metadata. For example, imagine you're editing a WYSIWYG document and enter: A Ctrl+I Enter Ctrl+I B This will look like: A B If you later start typing on that intermediate line, though, your text will be in italics. This is what users expect, and is in contrast to outting a little "italics" markup symbol on the line, as people did pre-WYSIWYG or do today in Markdown, HTML, and other markup languages.
- adolph 4y agoEven “plain text” includes hidden metadata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byte_order_mark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byte_order_mark
- gurjeet 4y agoThe phrase "death by a thousand paper cuts" comes to mind.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoA random example I realized the other day: your Android phone has a record of exactly what app was active at what time. Even if you delete both the app and whatever documents you were working on, the log of you using it still persists. And that bit is user-accessible in the UI (at least on modern Android) - system logs probably have much more. And then, the app use information is also independently stored on your Google account. For your convenience. So even if you flush your phone down the toilet and get a new one, the information remains. Even if you wipe your Google account, organizations with enough pull (e.g. governments) could get at it. And don't get me started on battery level / charging status or what WiFi networks were seen when.
- femto113 4y agoIf this article doesn't make you sufficiently paranoid may I refer you to my all time favorite Underhanded C Contest, the leaky image redactor from 2008. The winning entry is just brilliant: it's simple, it works perfectly, does nothing tricky, but still allows near perfect recovery of redacted text. http://www.underhanded-c.org/_page_id_17.html http://www.underhanded-c.org/_page_id_17.html
- encryptluks2 4y ago[dead]
- icelancer 4y agoWow. Meacham's method is brilliant.
- knodi123 4y agoI don't get it. How is his code treating pixels differently according to intensity?
- manchmalscott 4y agoBecause the code iterates per character, not per pixel. If a pixel's value is '7' and in the redacted zone, the program will iterate over the single character and output '0'. If the pixel's value is actually '174', the program will iterate over all three characters, outputting '000'. Any normal PPM image viewer will display these identically, but high contrast areas like text will be recoverable.
- leereeves 4y agoWhat image format stores pixel values in text?
- manchmalscott 4y agoThe Netpbm family of image formats, including PPM, have both binary and ascii standards. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netpbm#PPM_example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netpbm#PPM_example
- dbg31415 4y agoFor PDFs at least there are tools to reduce file size that get rid of the originals and just save the image as it is used.
- RandomTisk 4y agoAny risks with Windows Snipping tool?
- barbazoo 4y agoNot that I can think of, that would be the much more sensible thing to do. And CMD+SHIFT+4 or whatever your shortcut is on a Mac.
- dbg31415 4y agoReference to Red Dwarf. +1
- pard68 4y agoExport/save to PDF should fix this
- korroziya 4y agoAnother reason why MS Paint is king.
- doodlebugging 4y agoFor many years I have used SnagIt for cropping photos and documents. It has excellent features for marking up the resulting images too. It is very useful for customizing something for insertion in a Powerpoint slide. I do hate the nag screen poking me to upgrade from version 8 though. Fortunately it is a two click operation that has become muscle memory to me now.
- andix 4y agoIf you’re whistleblowing you should probably convert all your pages to images first and then create a PDF out of those images. If you convert to b&t images (1 bit) the risk of watermarking with some colored dots in images may be reduced. But there is probably still a lot of watermarking that could leak through.
- jay-barronville 4y ago> [. . .] convert all your pages to images first and then create a PDF out of those images. PDF’s are risky business. So much metadata can be hidden in a PDF depending on how it was generated. Stick to optimized JPEG’s (as I suggested in another comment [1]). [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34794953 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34794953
- andix 4y agoThat's really an easy option. For clean PDFs you would need a dedicated tool. I wouldn't trust PDFs that were created by any standard office software (Word, Acrobat, ...). There is always the risk some information about your computer, user name, time zone, location or maybe even license key/hash of the software may leak into the created document.
- jay-barronville 4y agoA very simple and easy way to pretty much guarantee an image doesn’t contain unnecessary metadata, can’t be uncropped, etc. is to first convert it to JPEG and then run it through an image optimizer (like ImageOptim [1]). Don’t use cloud software for any of this — do it all locally. [1]: https://imageoptim.com/mac https://imageoptim.com/mac
- sudobash1 4y agoPersonally, when I want to make sure that no metadata gets copied, I just take a screenshot. Simple, and nothing tricky.
- jay-barronville 4y agoYour screenshot likely has metadata encoded in it too.
- andix 4y agoI just checked the PNGs created by the Windows screenshot tool (win+shift+s). There was no obvious metadata inside. If there is something, it is not easy to find.
- icelancer 4y agoSnipping tool + recompression + conversion is usually enough to get the job done. That's what I do when I put public screenshots up that I care about redacting or protecting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Permik 4y agoBtw, you don't actually want to use a lossy image container in the modification steps if you don't want to leak any data. JPEG has ways of extracting data that was either cropped out or written over, by how the compression is performed over the parts of/whole image. Compression artifacts can and will propagate data that you are not fully aware of. PNG is a safer bet for screenshot content for the middle steps. Only the final image should be compressed using a lossy image compressor as then any details can't be diffused to the image if they simply aren't there.
- taubek 4y agoI didn't use Word in years now, but I remember that there was an option for reducing image size. That option would remove cropped part. I've just searched for help and this is what I've found https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/reduce-the-file-size-of-a-picture-in-microsoft-office-8db7211c-d958-457c-babd-194109eb9535 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/reduce-the-file-s...
- knodi123 4y agoDoes anybody remember the famous incident with the TechTV host Cat Schwartz, who took a topless photo, and then cropped it to just her eyes and posted it on her blog? And then a fan told her "btw, the original photos contained a thumbnail version in the exif data, and photoshop did not update or remove that." So you really could do that gag from Red Dwarf where they "uncrop" a photo. (red dwarf scene) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6i3NWKbBaaU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6i3NWKbBaaU
- tantalor 4y agoI don't know which is worse, storing the thumbnail in Exif, or not updating it when the image is modified.
- burna_aws_acct 4y agoAnecdote: I experienced this first-hand with Facebook actually, in 2017. I tried to crop a screenshot, and then post the cropped image in a FB Messenger group chat. FB Messenger defaulted back to the full screenshot image. I decided to no longer use FB after this. Also, all TikTok videos are restored to their original form and archived, by TikTok, both in the US and China. All those "blurry" nudes, "a day in the life at the office", and more, belong to TikTok. Along with all that metadata. TikTok you don't stop!
- r3trohack3r 4y agoDon’t entrust your freedom to tools you don’t understand.
- nikanj 4y agoPrint, apply scissors to parts you want to redact, scan. Foolproof, easy to explain to anyone, and 100% reliable.
- theossuary 4y agoThis reminds me of something similar from the guy who implemented AVIF in Firefox. He gives a talk about the implementation [1] where he talks about the CLAP privacy problem. Basically the spec adds a field that allows for cropping of the image, but the binary file would still contain the original. This would lead users to believe some image data was deleted when it really wasn't. I always thought he spent a lot of time and effort to restrict clap for little gain, but now I'm starting to think it was worth his effort. [1]: https://youtu.be/BUkRlfkv2D8?t=2199 https://youtu.be/BUkRlfkv2D8?t=2199 And the related GitHub issue: https://github.com/AOMediaCodec/av1-avif/issues/188 https://github.com/AOMediaCodec/av1-avif/issues/188
- mLuby 4y agoCouldn't Snowden (or someone with similar credentials and reach) provide bulletproof tools for this? Speaking of The Intercept…
- fomine3 4y agoMy frustration for a decade is that I don't know any handy image editing tools on smartphone for simple editing like trim, resize, paint, add text, rectangle filling/blur. There are many photo editing tools for who love Instagram, but it's not what I want. I have both Android and iOS but still I don't know. Anyone could recommend? I love paint.net on Windows.
- windthrown 4y agoDoes Snapseed fit the bill? https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.niksoftware.snapseed https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.niksoftwar...
- fomine3 4y agoSnapseed is closest to what I want AFAIK but lacks some feature like painting
- nyanpasu64 4y agoPocket Paint (https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.catrobat.paintroid/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.catrobat.paintroid/) is okay though a janky UI, Simple Gallery (https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.simplemobiletools.gallery.pro/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.simplemobiletools.galler...) has an editor but it can't crop and draw in one go, I haven't tried Simple Draw (https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.simplemobiletools.draw.pro/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.simplemobiletools.draw.p...).
- fomine3 4y agoI tried Pocket Paint and looks better, thanks. I like "janky" UI for such application.
- nyanpasu64 4y agoNote that I've seen it halve the resolution of large images imported, but I don't know if it always does that or never (and I was mistaken), and I couldn't find a switch to turn off downsizing.
- Waterluvian 4y agoAre there any image file formats that support a concept of image diffs? Your edits can be overlays of rasters with an alpha layer?
- Too 4y agoThe wisdom that you should never enter anything sensitive into a rich document editor is older than the internet. I remember lots of people getting busted after news spread that Word 97 kept the complete undo-history within the doc-file itself. Leaking a lot of redacted hate-mails and plagiarized then edited home assignments.
- leobg 4y agoReminds me of the BTK serial killer Dennis Rader who got caught because of leaked metadata in a Word document. > Police found metadata embedded in a deleted Microsoft Word document that was, unknown to Rader, still stored on the floppy disk. The metadata contained the words "Christ Lutheran Church", and the document was marked as last modified by "Dennis". An Internet search determined that a "Dennis Rader" was president of the church council.[1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Rader https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Rader
- haspoken 4y agohttps://archive.is/r3Qm3 https://archive.is/r3Qm3