4 ms·
Pichai needs to go, and I've been calling it here for over three years. It's been so obvious Pichai isn't the one to lead Google. Here's a mountain of evidence
by echelon 4y ago
Pichai needs to go, and I've been calling it here for over three years.
It's been so obvious Pichai isn't the one to lead Google. Here's a mountain of evidence where you can see him failing to adapt to a risky situation and changing market:
2020: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549445
2021: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27588571 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27588571
2019: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21819608 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21819608
2021: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25986216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25986216
2023: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34484142 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34484142
Pichai has a history of not being bold, not responding to threats, not innovating, not fixing broken culture, not seeing the 20 year view of the market. He's lost some of the biggest advantages Google once held. He needs to be done. And he needs to be done three years ago.
Now when he's tasked with reversing the sinking ship? Totally fumbling.
Show him out and get a Nadella.
- ProAm 4y agoGoogle has entered it's IBM age.
- GenerocUsername 4y agoAs if Google has half the staying power of IBM. You have to eeek along for 50 years to be IBM. Google has 1 cash cow and if it does it will be more Nokia than IBM
- sebastiansm 4y agoNokia has more years than IBM?
- hackitup7 4y agoSeriously... IBM, even in its completely decrepit and uncompetitive state, still kicks off $1-3 billion in free cash flow per quarter.
- langitbiru 4y agoWho do you suggest to replace Pichai? The founders (Sergey and Larry)? Eric Schmidt? Or someone new? Who do you think the "Nadella" or the One who can lead Google?
- bushbaba 4y agoThomas Kurian.
- fooker 4y agoThis was the guy responsible for importing Oracle culture into Google, which has since overtaken Google Cloud, search and ads organizations.
- Bilal_io 4y agoI am curious what you mean by culture here, specific focused culture or the general culture? I don't know much about Oracle's inner culture, but I've heard people always hated it throughout the years.
- throwaway5959 4y agoIs that a good or bad thing?
- fooker 4y agoGood for managers, bad for engineers. Maybe good for the company, I don't know.
- dekhn 4y agoKurian should be the CEO of an Alphabet subsidiary- but not Google. Cloud should be pulled out of Google and turned into a full subsidiary.
- dekhn 4y agoId be totally willing to see Jeff Dean promoted to CEO. Not that I think he'd do a great job, but it would be interesting to watch. He's been building a case for this for quite some time.
- waboremo 4y agoI agree, but not with the conclusion. I don't think a Nadella is what they need. He's far too much of a stabilizer, which makes sense for Microsoft given their incredibly rocky years. This archetype is also what Pichai is trying to fill and why Google isn't working out. When you step back for a moment, it's utterly bizarre Tim Cook was able to pivot Apple towards being this privacy-focused company who is now able to eat Google's ad lunch from right under them. Tim Cook, the very same guy people called just a boring distributions-focused leader, yet he has a more forward-thinking vision than Pichai. Pichai, the man who once led a team to create Chrome. It's outright absurd how much one has stalled in comparison.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoWhat I like about Nadella is that he is very responsive to threats, and I think he fundamentally gets the business. Much of MS' product line is improving across the board and ramping up vs AWS. Cook really understands the customer perspective around privacy, and I view him as part of the A bomb that will destroy the glacier of Surveillance Capitalism. FB is limping, and Google is bleeding. He'll likely be ramming it at Mach5 with the subscription icebreaker which feeds right into the Apple ecosystem. Now, I do think he needs to drop %s and bring them down to reality as part of a long play to make it the best platform and defeat monopoly arguments.
- dmitrygr 4y agoHe never led chrome creation. He was a random PM. By the time he rose in the ranks, chrome already existed.
- sebastiansm 4y agoIt would be interesting to know who were the key players on that Chrome team.
- fidgewidge 4y agoHe was a PM but there's relatively little PMing to do on a browser. If you look at the features Chrome launched with it was all engineering focused stuff: speed, security, non-functionals like that. The project itself was really driven by Page and some hires from Mozilla/Safari teams.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Show him out and get a Nadella Better yet, break it up. It's clear a behemoth is no longer in shareholders' interest.
- fidgewidge 4y agoNadella has done a better job than Ballmer but don't overrate him too much! He has many major failures on his watch. Microsoft has been very effectively buying a warm reputational glow with developers by splashing money around, but that's all relative to their previous state. It's still a company with a lot of problems: - With the exception of VS Code, the Microsoft things developers like are purchased or just catching up with where competitors were 20 years ago e.g. GitHub, Minecraft, OpenAI, Windows Terminal, WSL. - There's a top thread today on HN all about how much people hate Teams. Teams is an abomination yet forms the central pillar of their collaboration strategy; how can they have executed so badly that people seriously say they'd rather quit their job if it's introduced than deal with its terrible design? - Windows has totally rotted away on Nadella's watch. The execution failure here is total. Does Nadella even use Windows himself? It's still critical infrastructure for much of the world but the entire Windows platform has no vision, no ideas and has become (just like Teams) mind-blowingly buggy. Absolutely nothing they introduced in the last 15 years or so actually works properly. A good measure of the totality of Nadella's failure here is that Microsoft's new apps are all Electron based and Edge is a fork of Chrome i.e. they institutionally prefer to use Google's code to their own. Also they apparently hand out MacBooks to new employees! - Visual Studio was once dominant in its space but is now apparently considered a writeoff, so VS Code is a totally different app written from scratch. - .NET has experienced major product and branding churn that has left anyone not fully committed to the ecosystem confused about what it is and can do e.g. .NET Core vs Framework. .NET isn't a failure but it doesn't seem to be growing or exciting devs either, and in terms of core R&D they've been blown away by the work Oracle is doing with Graal. - Azure is very successful but is showing worrying signs of the same bugs-and-tech-debt problems that plagues the rest of their products. When I had to use Azure, I was constantly amazed at how even basic things were flaky or did not work. Like even just holding open TCP connections between machines wouldn't work properly. This is despite the fact that Microsoft was able to built out Azure seemingly only by raiding the rest of the firm for talent, hence the Windows brain drain. Also cloud is becoming strongly associated with cost disease, which opens up a possible weakness in future (in fairness, a problem shared with AWS and GCP). - HoloLens is cool but does anyone use it? Nadella fixed the monolithic our-way-or-the-highway approach, which allowed them to import tech from elsewhere to fix their weaknesses. But compare that to Apple, which consistently doubles down on its own tech stack and has become even more successful with the monolithic integrated approach and it's hard not to see this as something Nadella was forced into rather than some great act of leadership.