9 ms·
Teams is so horrific we banned it. If you force us to use teams you'll have to find another supplier. Seriously, it is incomprehensible that Microsoft would shi
by jacquesm 4y ago
Teams is so horrific we banned it. If you force us to use teams you'll have to find another supplier. Seriously, it is incomprehensible that Microsoft would ship something so utterly broken. I know they don't have a reputation for writing good software but Teams is on another level, and I don't mean that in a positive way. I've really tried to get it to work but it is so messed up that I don't think it can be done. Meanwhile, even Zoom 'mostly works' (though we don't use that either). Eventually we standardized on Google 'meet', it works most of the time, we had a single issue in four years of intensive work and that was mostly related to a Google meet Chromebox auto-updating in the middle of a meeting (brilliant) and then never coming back up again. It serves well as a small PC now, we cancelled our subscription and just use laptops and desktops with webcams.
What really bothers me about all this: we had the basics of these setups working in 1995, and since then enough time has past that this should be a complete non-issue. But there is no interop between the various systems, everybody tries to push their own little walled garden and it breaks randomly for no apparent reason. If the phone system had been built like this we'd still be living in a disconnected world.
- mk89 4y agoWhat's the issue with zoom? I think it's one of the best software I have on my machine. It never ever stopped working since I have it installed, not even in meetings/webinars with 1000+ people. And the integration with Slack is really convenient, you can start a meeting in seconds anywhere you are.
- jacquesm 4y agoOn what operating system?
- larrik 4y agoI used to use it (Zoom) constantly on Linux Mint, fwiw. I switched to Mac only because I couldn't get parts for a new desktop at the time. I miss Linux, though :/
- jacquesm 4y agoNeat, so at least for some people it works.
- mk89 4y ago99% of the time: Mac. From time to time: iPhone, iPad, android phone, android tablets, windows. I hear from colleagues having Linux that the OS might indeed be an issue sometimes, they have to restart the system, etc.
- Macha 4y agoMeet does not require a desktop client to work reliably (it does, however, require a Chromium browser). Zoom really tries to bury the browser link. First it says the meeting has launched, which it won't have if you don't have the client installed, then it tries to prompt you to download the desktop client, and only then does it reveal the web join link. Our security team has banned the installation of Zoom after some of their issues in 2020.
- wvenable 4y agoIt's so weird -- I use Teams all the time and I've never had a serious problem with it. It's not the greatest software ever made but it's certainly functional. It's definitely getting a lot of work done to it.
- xattt 4y agoYour definition of broken is likely different than the GP.
- wvenable 4y agoBroken means "doesn't work". I've used Teams for 2 years now for conferencing, chat, desktop sharing, etc. It works just fine. I think a lot of Microsoft hate is clouding judgement here. People want Teams to suck.
- jacquesm 4y agoI simply can not get it to work. Note that we are on Linux/Chromebooks depending on the person in the team and this alone seems to be a major barrier for something that should be a non-issue. Every two bit video chat site in the world seems to have this figured out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>I simply can not get it to work. Seems like that is something you should have stated in the first comment. >>Linux/Chromebooks depending on the person in the team and this alone seems to be a major barrier Something like les than 1% of the world uses Linux on the desktop. Dont get me wrong I love Linux, I used it as my primary desktop from 2005 until around 2012 when I went back to Windows (windows 10) But calling problems on linux a "major issue" seems to over state the usage of Linux Desktop further depending on when you tried it, and what client you were using that is likely the root cause The Linux Desktop client always sucked, so much is no longer a thing, 100% a web app now. The web App teams should work just fine.
- xmodem 4y agoMy team had a meeting with Github sales and product a few weeks back. After I secured a booking of the special Teams-capable meeting room and arrived 10 minutes early to make sure everything was set up in time, we spent the first 10 minutes of the 30 minute meeting with 2 people from Github unable to join. At that point I generated a Google meet link, put it in the email thread and we were up and running a minute later. I've found Meet to just work about 98% of the time. My biggest complaint is the framerate. I'm not sure what it actually is but it feels like 15fps.
- jacquesm 4y agoAh good point, yes, framerate can be an issue, but I've long ago decided to not worry too much about the video but to concentrate on the audio instead, I have a much lower tolerance for audio drop-outs than for video issues.
- dheera 4y agoPart of the reason is that when Teams (or any Microsoft product) has issues, people blame Microsoft. When any other product has issues, they blame whoever made the decision to use that product. When IT people pick Microsoft, it's not an optimization for quality. It's an optimization for liability. Nobody was ever fired for picking Microsoft.
- hulitu 4y ago> Nobody was ever fired for picking Microsoft This was about IBM. From what i know, IBM does some interesting things (from a HW perspective). OTOH nothing MS does is interesting (except maybe as a challenge in network filtering)
- skibidibipiti 4y ago[dead]
- ljm 4y agoI love how IRC was the fundamental solution to the problem, and technology improved it over the following decade or so with XMPP, and then the same technology conspired to extend it and extinguish it. Slack did it, Google did it, Teams never supported it in the first place... XMPP wasn't perfect but the solution to that has been walled gardens around real-time chat apps. Everybody wants to share when they're the underdog but when success hits them, they roll the red carpet back.
- larrik 4y agoMy supervisor and I once had a Teams meeting on the calendar that was created via Outlook. We both joined, and wound up in different meetings with the same id, wondering where the other person was... We never scheduled a meeting for Teams again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y ago> it is incomprehensible that Microsoft would ship something so utterly broken Is it though? Heck Microsoft shipping a high quality product is the exception. The entire company runs on half-assed software being pushed by sales teams to CIOs and others high up on the corporate ladder who evaluate it on the basis of dollar amounts, kickbacks and marking checkboxes and not factors like usability and user experience.
- pdmccormick 4y agoI scanned the replies to see if this comment specifically had been made. Thank you.
- FpUser 4y ago>"I know they don't have a reputation for writing good software" I think they have a problem that regular person supposed to hate MS and Windows. I also think MS is quite capable of and does produce good software be it their own OS, Visual Studio, Visual Studio Code, Word, Excel, Flight Simulator etc. etc.
- hulitu 4y ago> I also think MS is quite capable of and does produce good software be it their own OS, Visual Studio, Visual Studio Code, Word, Excel, Flight Simulator etc. etc. All i can say: good luck using it. I did not have, any.
- FpUser 4y agoBeen using it forever. No problems except skipping some windows versions like Vista and Win 8.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoYou think Teams is horrific? At a certain large company who's all-in on Google Cloud, they use Google Chat. Everbody wants to use Slack but management thinks it's too expensive while Google Chat is free and comes with G Suite which they already paid for. You don't know what horrific means until you've used Google Chat. Teams is a delight compared to that.
- hulitu 4y agoI hate to say it, but, my experience with Google chat was better. It was around 2016 so maybe they haven 't implemented web 3.0 stuff yet.
- cloogshicer 4y agoWhat makes me very angry about Google Meet is that you can't configure it so that guests can just join without asking. This means if you have a meeting with a lot of people, you constantly have to babysit the "Someone is asking to join" box, as people come in late. Also, this box has got to be the worst UI design I've seen in a while, since it even blocks yourself from muting/unmuting yourself and disabling the camera, until you make a decision about whether you want to admit the person.
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, agreed that is a nuisance. But fortunately that is just a click, it gets a bit frustrating when there are > 10 participants and when people join late.
- whatever1 4y agoHow can the company who makes one of the best (if not the best) electron app (vscode), also ship one of the worst electron apps (Teams)? Can’t they just set up a meeting and and take notes on how the other team did it?
- clepto 4y agoThey tried to setup a meeting to go over it but no one was able to join because Teams was broken
- Dunedan 4y agoI agree, the user experience of Microsoft Teams is beyond bad. Thankfully I don't have to use Microsoft Teams on a regular basis. However, some times when I had to, it wouldn't show any audio or video devices to select and consequently audio and video didn't work. Turns out that's the behavior Microsoft Teams exhibits under Linux when it can't add inotify watches for whatever reason. There is no visible error message of any kind in this case, just an empty list of audio and video devices. How on earth do they expect users to debug and fix that?
- Scubabear68 4y agoOur teams have found that it gets things done with the basics, but has no advanced anything. Chat is OK, video is OK, Files is OK, Channels are OK. But they are all basic. Things like wikis or anything more advanced is very primitive. Plus of course some things like File are a thin facade over the horror that is Sharepoint, and you occasionally have to drop down into that swamp. So not a horror show to me, but feels like ten years out of date or more.
- b112 4y agoSeriously, it is incomprehensible that Microsoft would ship something so utterly broken It has to be said, what on earth do you mean?! This is Microsoft, they are famous for broken.
- briffle 4y agotheir markdown code block formatting is mostly working this week. 2 weeks ago, it didn't handle new lines correctly, for about a month. a few weeks before that, it stripped any whitespace from the start of a line for a few weeks, and a few months before that, you couldn't only copy what was in a markdown code block, you had to copy the entire message, including sender and timestamp. These 3 problems have resurfaced over and over for the last few years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brocha 4y agoEvery time I have opened Teams, I have had a problem. I have a "not simple" webcam/audio setup with virtual webcams and audio sources and half the time, Teams will show black and audio will not work, and the sources won't show up in the list. Not only that, every time I've gotten a Teams link for an interview, the desktop app tells me "this version is only for organizations" then the webapp refuses to load. A huge pain when every other client I've used (Discord, Webex, Zoom, Google Meet) works with minor tinkering.
- xnx 4y agoLack of interoperability in chat and video conferencing reminds me what a miracle it is that email has worked so reliably and consistently for 40 years.