8 ms·
You can understand the 2020/2021 hiring at certain companies with a very clear pandemic-related angle like Zoom. But I've lost track of the number of non-answer
by ghaff 4y ago
You can understand the 2020/2021 hiring at certain companies with a very clear pandemic-related angle like Zoom. But I've lost track of the number of non-answer answers, both public and private, to why companies apparently overhired. We hired more than we meant to. How does that happen?
Especially at a company losing large piles of money.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoHere's my explanation: 1. In the Internet era, we live with much bigger markets and hence much more of a "winner-take-all" (or at least winner-take-most) economy for companies that exist primarily on the Internet. You see this over and over in different areas - there is usually one giant leader that takes the lion's share of the money, then maybe 1 or 2 frequently discussed competitors, then everyone else. 2. With this "way fewer points for second best" dynamic, most investors and business leaders are biased much more towards FOMO than fear-of-losing-money. 3. Thus, when the pandemic came along, many folks did see it as the start of a new dynamic with how people used online services. And they weren't entirely wrong, e.g. remote work is obviously much more prevalent now than pre-pandemic. But again, from a business leader's perspective, I'm sure most of them thought it would be much worse to miss out on a paradigm shift in online services than to over-invest. Of course, any discussion about this topic should lead with the huge sloshing of money due to low interest rates that abruptly reversed. Whenever that happens you see investors pour money into risky assets as they chase yield.
- ghaff 4y agoFair enough. I would say that looking around in general, the "new normal" looks a lot more like the "old normal" than a lot of people expected in 2020 or 2021. Business travel is essentially back to pre-pandemic levels. There's more workplace flexibility but--especially outside tech--there's relatively little full remote. A lot of food and meal delivery seems to have really tapered off. And arguably it didn't cost companies that much to hedge for an upside. It's not even clear if employees now being laid off were in general worse off for having a job. (Modulo some things like being in the US on a visa.)
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoDo you have a source on business travel being back to 2019 levels? Everything I’ve seen about this shows it’s at only half to two thirds, but numbers seem to vary a lot.
- ghaff 4y agoEyeballing TSA passenger volumes: https://www.tsa.gov/travel/passenger-volumes https://www.tsa.gov/travel/passenger-volumes That's not just business travelers of course but I can't believe there's been a huge spike in tourist air travel in the US in non-holiday season winter. In-person tech events still seem to be down but that's probably sector specific.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>remote work is obviously much more prevalent now than pre-pandemic. I am willing to bet on a 5 year picture we will see not more than 10% growth in WFH, as companies do back to the "old" ways
- lillecarl 4y agoI'm willing to bet every other company that can will be hybrid work, come in at least x days over y time. You won't retain talent if your competitors are more flexible. Unless you pay an "absurd" amount to have me come in every day, and at that point you're just wasting money on me and your oversized office.
- varjag 4y agoRN tech talent is getting desperate to keep any job out there, perks or not.
- lillecarl 4y agoRight now as in this very moment? Maybe people are more careful what they wish for, but how many of these fired people will go unemployed? I bet most land a position pretty much anywhere they point, I'm still getting LinkedIn recruiter spam daily.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>> I'm still getting LinkedIn recruiter spam daily. yea and they have not filled those positions for a reason.... >>Right now as in this very moment? Ironically it is very regional. Some areas in the US are seeing very high unemployment numbers. Largely because most remote work has dried up, and the few companies still doing remote limit to states where they have an office so you can not just "live anywhere" like the promise of FT WFH was
- nradov 4y agoWhich specific areas are seeing high unemployment numbers? https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm
- moneywoes 4y ago> In the Internet era, we live with much bigger markets and hence much more of a "winner-take-all" (or at least winner-take-most) economy Are there markets that aren’t like this? I guess local cad dealerships, medicine?
- shagie 4y agoAlmost anything that isn't internet based. There are lots of companies that sell stuff that is profitable - where the barrier for entry isn't putting up a web page and having a developer work on it but rather have something that you hold in your hands that you can sell to someone (and that is profitable to make). Look for product based companies rather than service based ones. And yes, that means that as a software developer you're not likely in the "engineering" part of the company or a profit center... and that will have a corresponding impact if you are looking for a salary based on being in a profit center.
- krashidov 4y agoExcellent reply and I think you can add a number 4 - Remote work makes the barrier to hiring so much lower. You no longer need to source people from specific Geos. You no longer need to provide office space, desks, parking, etc for new employees. Even the interviewing process itself is so much faster. No arranging flights, hotels, ubers, interviewing is 100% remote now for most tech companies.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoAnd interest rates were low and investors were willing to throw $$ at these bets.
- Rastonbury 4y agoCompanies generally only make detailed plans a year ahead based on data from the prior year or two. Which works out most of the time and the times it doesn't you can't really do anything about like financial crisis and covid boost then normalization. If you were buying in the stock market early and didn't sell (or held on to vested stock), you probably felt the same and wouldn't have predicted such a precipitous crash. It looks obvious now but if you said mid-2022 that 2023 growth is gonna be lower than even pre-covid you get funny looks. Then the unplanned growth strains support, customers are complaining, your competitors are doing well too and are going to keep R&D expense ratios, so you do the same to stop your product falling behind. Investors are high on the bubble, you can spend money with much less scrutiny
- qqtt 4y agoThe thing is, the companies didn't overhire given the expected growth rates they were forecasting. Companies doing layoffs now are doing so with the same reasoning they used when they did hiring during the pandemic - they are forecasting their growth based on current economic realities. The pandemic years saw companies accelerate their growth, even those who didn't have a clear 'pandemic angle' like Twilio. 2020 Q4 saw Twilio revenue growth 65% which encouraged them to hire more. Again, this is just the flip side of the current growth they are seeing (20-30%) which is causing them to re-balance their cost structure for lower growth. There is risk in hiring during high growth periods - the risk being potentially these employees either won't deliver the value you expect, your strategy is wrong, or your growth rates won't continue. If these things happen, you might have to do a layoff. There is risk is NOT hiring during high growth periods too - if the company doesn't structure itself to capitalize on the current growth it is seeing, competitors could come in and sweep up market share. At the end of the day, no one has a crystal ball for when high growth rates will stop, or when low(er) growth rates will pick back up again. In these cases, companies will hire during high growth periods and might have to lay off during low growth periods. Many people seem to want to frame "layoffs" as a de facto failure, but it really isn't a failure as much as it is a company responding to dynamic market conditions (again, the flip side of hiring when growth is high). It's hard to say if the pandemic era hiring was really a bad idea - that hiring did fuel many of these companies to rapidly expand their revenue base and capitalize on many growth opportunities. Now that their future growth is expected lower, they are re-balancing their cost structure to respond.
- jedberg 4y ago> even those who didn't have a clear 'pandemic angle' like Twilio. Twilio absolutely had a pandemic angle -- they help provide telephony to people outside of the office. As people suddenly moved home, they needed a way to get their phone calls forwarded to all their employees and other related telephony.
- jjeaff 4y agoYes, and not to mention all the notifications for all these different communication apps that people were using more and more and all the new remote work tool startups that use telephone, texting, and other notification services that Twilio offers.
- readthenotes1 4y agoParkinson's law, first written about in the 1950s, explains that work expands to fill the available time. In his essay he noted that what that means is that managers work to expand the people they manage as that gives them more budget more prestige and more power. He has an amusing anecdote about the British Navy in the early 1900s to illustrate his point. They essay is very well written and I highly recommend it. https://www.economist.com/news/1955/11/19/parkinsons-law https://www.economist.com/news/1955/11/19/parkinsons-law
- spamizbad 4y agoBecause technology is still in the "land grab" era of business. Say you don't hire during the COVID boom, well, ok, now you don't have to do layoffs but now you have to battle 2-3 new entrants into the market who snarfed up customers you were unable to serve because you were understaffed. There only "downside" to not hiring is the chance you have to layoff 5-20% of your workforce in a year or so. The upside is tremendous.
- bombcar 4y agoCompanies hired because other companies were hiring. If you're big, you would have to explain to shareholders and the board why Google and Facebook are doubling/tripling in size, but you're not - is it because the company is moribund? SELL SELL SELL! If you're small, you would have to explain to investors and the board why other startups/unicorn wannabes are doubling/tripling in size, but you're not - is it because the company is moribund? SELL SELL SELL! Here is my company leadership heuristic: what option requires the least discussion/interaction/explanation with the board? That's the one that will be chosen.
- 300bps 4y agoWe hired more than we meant to. How does that happen? Every explanation here thus far misses one simple fact: interest rates. Imagine the more people you hire, the more money you make and/or the more dominant of a market position you assume. Now imagine the Federal Reserve has lowered the Federal Funds Target rate to 0 and is performing FOMC operations to buy $9 trillion of bonds to lower interest rates across the board. This is what they did: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren... So imagine firms can go on a hiring spree with almost-free money. Consider that WACC (weight average cost of capital) is one of the key factors in calculating the NPV of a project. Now consider that a positive NPV means you should do the project. This means a lot of projects (and hence hiring) get greenlit. Now imagine the Federal Reserve says, “Party’s Over, guys!” and raises the FFT rate and stops buying bonds. Almost free money goes away, the WACC increases and now the NPV of all those juicy projects goes negative. Add in an expected recession, the ability to cull the bottom x% performers and you get a recipe for widespread layoffs.
- VLM 4y agoOne way to think about 10% downsizing at a company that doubles in size roughly annually is its being off schedule about a month. IF they go back to doubling in size every year, THEN its a short term one month layoff. Looking at the numbers, this specific company example is not going back to doubling every year. I think it gets engrained into the DNA of the company that they double every X months or X years and its hard to shift the culture when the company flatlines or even slightly declines. "Why, we always onboard 10% of our workforce per month, its just what we do" and when you grow that fast there are literally people who's entire day job is onboarding, like typing in new W-2 and insurance forms all day long or whatever.
- nocsi 4y agoInterest rates were incredibly low. It was free money to take on more people with not much downside
- ss48 4y agoHaving a shortage of people is as debilitating as having too many people. Not only is a company not able to fulfill their goals for business development, but they also can't sustain their existing responsibilities and existing customer base. People were switching jobs left and right, and inspired a desire to retain people instead of adding people on demand, in the same way as the supply chain caused people to stock up on chips resulting in today's oversupply of chips. In 2020, companies were envisioning that the way we worked was so drastically different from how it really turned out, surprisingly similar to before. That meant a lot more investment in new markets that would need a lot more services and goods (ex. remote work meant a lot of work for people to develop homes more, allow more to be done fully virtually, move many services originally in cities to suburbs). When things didn't turn out that way, and people started to get back to normal, projects that would have had a huge return if realized and need more people working suddenly different. Then it was a game of chicken of how to admit that they invested in the wrong efforts because things didn't turn out how they had expected.
- philwelch 4y agoInterest rates. Money was incredibly cheap in 2020/2021, but now it’s expensive.
- surge 4y agoMy guess from what I've heard, or at least a factor. A lot of cheap money (low interest govt loans, etc) as part of the market propping up in April 2020, and beyond lead to a lot of incoming capital for a lot of these companies. I think just over half or at least close to half of the money printed to assist people went straight to Wall Street. That flooded the market with money which while propping up the market, probably got used to hire a lot of people who weren't necessary for "growth" or not strictly necessary and wasn't sustainable.
- lucideer 4y ago> companies apparently overhired. We hired more than we meant to. How does that happen? Everyone here is replying with various explanations of why these companies made the "mistake" of over-hiring but no-one is stopping to ask if it was a mistake. Sure the announcements are full of apologies and stories of taking responsibility for mistakes made, they need to be: they're marketing. But cui bono, or more pertinently, the inverse: who is negatively affected by layoffs? It isn't shareholders. Meta just did massive buybacks after layoffs. Over-hiring isn't a mistake because the only real downside is the subsequent layoffs, and layoffs don't negatively effect anyone that "matters". Sure there's institutional knowledge loss but that only matters for product quality which, let's be honest, isn't any indicator of revenue.
- code_biologist 4y agoPOSIWID is perennial: https://design4services.com/concepts/systems-thinking/posiwid/ https://design4services.com/concepts/systems-thinking/posiwi...
- pm90 4y agoIMO BigTech had the notion that for the most part you wouldn’t be laid off unless you “underperformed”. The fact that people with long tenures and good perf were still let go definitely has an impact on how these companies will be perceived by future employees.
- qwerpy 4y agoThat sounds reasonable but will it change anything? Pretty much every major tech company did layoffs, and they're all going to keep paying same relative to each other. I'm a guy who wants a big paycheck, so I'll still be working for FAANGs. Sure, now I know my job isn't 100% secure and maybe I'm less inclined to go above and beyond, but I'm sure they'll address that by having bigger "differentiation" in pay between top and average performers.
- lucideer 4y ago> IMO BigTech had the notion that for the most part I'm not sure this is "for the most part" Sure, FAANG may have had this notion (or at least FNG; not sure if the As ever had), along with the sort of religious/dogmatic "drinking the koolaid" type culture they were trying to instill within their employee-base (helped to no end by outsourcing large portions of their sales operations so they'd have a smaller core to "spoil"). Thinking of BigTech more broadly though, & especially big old enterprise-y tech like the IBMs, Oracles, SAPs & telcos, layoffs being arbitrary & indiscriminate seems like nothing new.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoEveryone, including people who should have known better, bought into the narrative that this was the "new normal".
- dragonwriter 4y ago> But I’ve lost track of the number of non-answer answers, both public and private, to why companies apparently overhired. We hired more than we meant to. How does that happen? Overhiring isn’t “hiring more than we meant to”, its “hiring more at time X than is appropriate for the market conditions at X+Y”. It’s what normal, capital-controlled firms do in times of easy money, the hire more when throwing more stuff at the wall to see what sticks is cheap, and then when a contraction occurs, they cut and milk the stuff that is already working. Its normal business-cycle things. When there is talk of cooling inflation by tightening monetary policy, one of the core mechanisms that that works by is causing firms to cut employees in roles that don’t contribute to short-term returns as much, reducing consumer demand and constraining price increases. (“Overhiring” is something of a misnomer from any perspective other than the perspective of the time after the hiring when market situations have tightened.)
- twblalock 4y agoBecause companies are accountable to the incentives expressed by their shareholders. Companies that didn't get in on the gold rush would have been punished. Now, companies that don't cut costs or shrink will be punished.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> How does that happen? In my opinion, it's ok if it happens to rookies. Like, small mom and pop business owners who got excited during a "gold rush" (surge in sales during CoVID) or whatever. But like... executives with net worths $20m who are like, elected (and kept quarter after quarter) by a board of massive publicly traded companies? I thought they needed to be next to perfect / the gold standard. "Eh, we messed up, sorry, we're human". I thought the bar was higher. Maybe I'm over-exaggerating the whole thing anyway. If Microsoft is done doing 1 time layoffs past 3 years at 10k, people after CO=oVID, not a big deal. If it's just the beginning and every quarter or so they shed more and more, it'll be interesting.
- nabeards 4y agoOne thing that seems to go unmentioned, unless I missed it, is that many of these companies bought other companies and brought over those teams. Initially, they probably needed more members of those acquired teams than they do now that those products are integrated. So layoffs are almost guaranteed in that sense. Add in higher interest rates mentioned elsewhere, and instead of buying more and more companies (which means you can move staff around to new teams), there isn’t any buying so layoffs are the result.
- pers0n 4y agoWere the PPP loans part of the reason???