6 ms·
Imagine if you launch a balloon for say $10k so that your adversary has to spend $400k on a missile plus $70k x number of planes x hours in flight. And now do i
by giantg2 4y ago
Imagine if you launch a balloon for say $10k so that your adversary has to spend $400k on a missile plus $70k x number of planes x hours in flight. And now do it multiple times per week. Seems like a decent strategy.
- oneoff786 4y agoUntil the frequency of it escalates into a damaging economic conflict.
- nradov 4y agoThe damaging economic conflict already started in 2018. https://www.forbes.com/sites/anthonytellez/2023/02/08/here-are-all-the-us-sanctions-against-china/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/anthonytellez/2023/02/08/here-a...
- lolc 4y agoIt's a decent strategy until you realize you're just providing target practice on sorties the enemy would fly anyway. Shooting one missile a day is not affecting that budget. And pilots need constant training.
- themitigating 4y agoThat depends on the cost difference between training and the missiles. May they have to use more fuel maybe the person on duty didn't need training. I'm being picky but still
- XorNot 4y agoFlight hours are flight hours is my understanding: all the pilots involved are in the air a certain minimum number of hours per month just to keep their qualifications up.
- dirtyid 4y agoPLA use USN activities in SCS and recon off her shores for training as well but US activities persist because there's mutual intelligence gathering going on, usually favouring the gatherer since the trade is info on one ISR platform vs said ISR platform gathering from host of sources. PLA probably knows alot about US P8s but those P8s learn about PLA navy, air bases, coastal defenses, radars etc. PRC can't simply shut down their hardware to deny info if collection occurs frequently. The benefit and burden is disproportionate. Hence it's favourable strategy to prod at US capabilites currently limited to CONUS that could be deployed in IndoPac. Imagine PRC sending ballons with iterative hardware to break through US EW, or counter measures to test against US missiles. These are activities US limits elsewhere but pressured to "reveal" because CONUS politics demand shoot downs. US alleged they jammed 1st balloon but likely only PRC on recieving end knows how successful. Learning more about US EW capabilities alone makes such missions useful and in return US... gets to shoot down balloons and get hand on carrying hardware PRC wants to reveal. Which might be huge, or nothing like PRC doing their 1000th P8 interdiction. Economics favouring the balloon is likely secondary consideration.
- sph 4y agoNot enough acronyms in your comment. EDIT: judging from your post history, I wonder if you're a ChatGPT bot trained on US military documents. You do love the lingo and unnecessary acronyms.
- dirtyid 4y agoIm a bot trained on us and chinese military documents, i contain multitudes. But TBH my grammar to lax to be bot. Anyway they're entry level acronyms for anyone following defense. pla peoples liberation army usn us navy scs south china sea isr intelligence surveillance reconnaissance p8 recon plane conus continental united states ew electronic warfare tldr you learn more rummaging through someones house than going through their mailbox. You can limit how much the house owner knows about you by limitting what you carry. Previously US mostly rummaged through PRC house and mailbox using very expensive tools. PRC limited to US mailbox but broke into the house using a paperclip. The price of tools matter less than the kind of new info that can be gathered. US also not happy PRC is finally in her house. US family more opinionated and may compel US to reveal she would otherwise not want to reveal to kick chinese home invader out. Chinese s family locked in the basement and don't know any better.
- elorant 4y agoA balloon that requires a missile to be brought down has to be really big, like soccer field big. In which case it won’t cost just $10k.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoMy understanding is that basically all of these balloons require missiles due to their altitude, not because of their structure. Edit: looks like I was wrong. The balloons were only 40-60k feet, which is within the range of military aircraft. reply
- bagels 4y agoDo we the modern jets have guns still?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYes, some do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 4y agoWhat would they cost? $10k seems reasonably close given the price below. https://weatherscientific.com/collections/weather-balloons/products/kaymont-hab-tx-4000-balloons https://weatherscientific.com/collections/weather-balloons/p...
- Rebelgecko 4y agoDoes that 70k per plane per hour actually cost an additional 70k? If it becomes frequent enough I imagine they could start shooting down balloons in lieu of their regular training missions. Same for the missiles.
- giantg2 4y agoI believe that $70k is actual operating cost - fuel, maintenance, salaries, etc.
- npnpnp 4y agoA lot of other comments have covered other aspects, and here's another one. If balloons become commonplace, I'd bet that they don't scramble the latest and greatest to shoot them down. It could probably be done with a turboprop. The F-22 was probably used in the most popular case as a show of force.
- catketch 4y agoTurboprops have a max ceiling of around 30,000 ft, while these types of balloons can easily be more than twice as high. Really not the right mission profile
- somat 4y agoThe f-22 was used because it was the on-call aircraft and the balloon was at 60+ thousand feet. the f-15 perhaps could have done the job, but the f-16 would have trouble. Apologies for the meme format but it explains it so well. https://youtube.com/v/koEQp8ImlnI?t=649 https://youtube.com/v/koEQp8ImlnI?t=649
- tzs 4y agoThe hours in flight probably should not count. Those planes and pilots fly a lot of training hours. They could just use some hours that would otherwise be training to go deal with a balloon. As far as missiles go, I wonder if you even need any weapons to down a balloon? A supersonic pass in its general vicinity would hit it with a shock wave and a lot of turbulence. Would that be enough to damage it sufficiently to down it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]