7 ms·
The FBI’s most controversial surveillance tool is under threat
- olivermarks 4y agoThe word 'troubling' in the article sub head should be 'illegal'.
- halJordan 4y agoBut that's the thing- it's not illegal. These programs were legislated by the Congress and have been before the Supreme Court multiple times. If you want it to be illegal you need to get on your congressmen.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoPerhaps we could move collected intelligence data into an agency, specifically tasked with insuring it's only used in a constitutional manner. Search requests would be submitted to agents who know when warrants are required.
- sc68cal 4y agoA system similar to this was already in place for warrantless surveillance, the FISA courts, which have become a rubber stamp. These systems that are supposed to be a check on state power eventually become far too comfortable with the agencies they are supposed to have an adversarial relationship with.
- gameman144 4y agoI don't have any experience in this area, but how would one know that the FISA courts are a rubber stamp, as opposed to the requests being brought to the court being only the most reasonable and well-defined ones? It seems like from the outside the observable effect would be the same (high warrant-granting rate), but the reality between the two is very different.
- sc68cal 4y agohttps://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/05/foriegn-intelligence-surveillance-court-rubber-stamps-mass-surveillance-under https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/05/foriegn-intelligence-s...
- ttyprintk 4y agoThe issue with this editorial is that it quotes the Chief Justice. The next sentence should be: the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court unilaterally appoints all FISA judges himself.
- ttyprintk 4y agoTwo details: Only recently has FISA been expanded to allow an amici role for government-licensed attorneys to argue against certain requests. We’ve kind of had three phases of FISA: Church commission FISA rejected 4 out of 25,000 requests. And those were approved after re-submission. Numbers like that cannot refute rubber stamp allegations. Then, after 2001, submissions started getting wild. The rejection rate and public statements seemed to show some friction between branches. Then, cooly around 2013, FISA seemed to allow requests on American citizens. By 2017, Wrey was arguing that FBI depended on this. And only lately do we have the amici roles.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gameman144 4y agoAh, this is super interesting, thanks for the insight!
- ttyprintk 4y agoFor some reason, Wikipedia doesn’t provide its usual level of detail on the FISA court page. Amendments to FISA look like: 1978, formed out of the Church commission 1994, business communications added to scope, and surveillance might be physical. “Business” would eventually include GPS and cell tower locating information kept by cell provider businesses. 2007, expanded to legitimize a dragnet for cases where foreign agents are included among bulk collection. I say legitimize because in 2005 the intelligence community was busted surpassing the bounds permitted by law. Retroactive immunity of telecom companies is one of the more interesting policy debates, I think. Since 2008, it has been renewed by every President. While Snowden is perhaps the most prominent face of what the public is permitted to know, Trump campaigner Carter Page is the most prominent FISA target. Any American citizen is legally protected by FISA unless they’re a foreign agent. Page acted suspiciously like he was being paid by Russia to courier information. I think we can conclude that the FISA court acted in their typical knee jerk fashion to allow surveillance without bothering with civil rights; four times. The DoJ would eventually conclude it did not have probable cause to surveil Page. Republican legislators felt Page needed to be protected, and he became the face for some changes to FISA. Carter Page lied about trips to Moscow. Depending on your politics, this might be to cover up crimes, or you might fantasize that he was on a secret mission. Attorney General Jeff Sessions also lied about the trips. Anyway, fighting for changes to the kind of suspicion FISA is allowed to investigate is based on Page lying about when he was in Moscow. The material unconstitutionally gathered on Page is tightly guarded by the government. His lawsuits have been thrown out. Having been at one time such a prominent victim that he was changing FISA law, he would later be described by the White House as an unknown.
- mrkeen 4y ago> collected intelligence data. > constitutional manner. Collecting the data is the unconstitutional bit.
- tastyfreeze 4y agoThe temptation to abuse intelligence data is too great. I can't think of any structure centralized structure that wouldn't eventually be corrupted. This is why police powers reside with the states not the federal government. It is the federal government's responsibility to ensure states are following the Constitution.
- mistermann 4y ago> I can't think of any structure centralized structure that wouldn't eventually be corrupted. Do you mean this literally? Like, if you were to start with a clean slate, free of all norms, premises, and axioms, you couldn't design a system that wouldn't be corrupted (which is different from a system being imperfect)? Heck, one obvious approach is to involve citizens, and make the death penalty a consequence for corruption in certain roles. I think this would substantially alter people's behavior. Something else we could do in conjunction with this: start teaching the public how to think skilfully so they are not so easily misled by people who are taught such things (in schools not available to the public).
- simple-thoughts 4y agoWhy aren’t these people in prison? They broke the law and committed crimes. Is it connections or is it that they have some sort of immunity?
- mrkeen 4y agoBlue-collar actions are found to be criminal. White-collar actions are found to be unlawful and stopped. Government or politician actions are found to be unlawful and continue.
- SMAAART 4y agohttps://archive.is/r7wYt https://archive.is/r7wYt
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- fredgrott 4y agoWhat is distressing is that the pattern of misuse seems to mirror other misuses of police arresting authority at the local and state levels. Would this imply training levels not being what they should be in areas of complying with laws by law enforcement including the FBI, ATF, DOJ, CIA, NSA, etc?
- deepsquirrelnet 4y agoI’m not certain whether it’s an issue of training or an issue of lack of accountability. It certainly seems like a time of reckoning must come for all levels of law enforcement, where we get back to upholding the law rather than being above it. By now, almost everybody in the country seems to take issue with one or more areas of law enforcement and/or judiciary. Belief in justice seems to be at a very low point.
- willmadden 4y agoI think there’s a general lack of confidence in the integrity of elections, especially given what’s been revealed in the Twitter files and that “mules” documentary. I don’t see how anything can change without election integrity and ensuring the standing government cannot interfere in elections. That’s the only way any of the government overreach can be curtailed. Bureaucrats aren’t going to oversee themselves. They will always fight for larger budgets and more power. The deeper root level problem is how elections are financed. The politicians themselves are little more than actors at this point. No one is going to win a national level election without the support of the largest lobbying groups.
- philippejara 4y agoI don't think this is a problem of election integrity, the abuse is being done by un-elected people which while some are appointed most aren't. It is an accountability issue, call something a threat to national security and now everything's free game. The people doing those violations should at the very least be fired, but repeatedly doing them -or repeatedly overseeing them- should lead to jail, especially if it is targeted at political parties.
- sylware 4y agoThat's why you cannot ask any government to protect its citizen digital systems, because there are too much interested in to get security holes for their own benefit... Yep, we are alone in this, and with all those horrible standards/software(open source or not)/hardware, don't bother that much, it is unreasonable anyway.
- jacooper 4y agoI think the issue is more like, the agency that is specialized in security is also responsible for digital surveillance with practically zero oversight.
- newZWhoDis 4y agoI would be totally onboard with an NSA that acted purely in a defensive manner. Imagine getting a notice from the NSA that your Wordpress was vulnerable and exposed customer data because your server devs suck. Imagine an NSA that actually sent zero days to Apple instead of exploiting them.
- jacooper 4y ago> Imagine getting a notice from the NSA that your Wordpress was vulnerable and exposed customer data because your server devs suck. BTW, this already exists in multiple countries, like Germany and now the UK [1/2] [1] https://www.bsi.bund.de/EN/Themen/Unternehmen-und-Organisationen/Cyber-Sicherheitslage/Reaktion/CERT-Bund/CERT-Bund-Reports/Offene-Server-Dienste/offene-server-dienste.html https://www.bsi.bund.de/EN/Themen/Unternehmen-und-Organisati... [2] https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/british-govt-is-scanning-all-internet-devices-hosted-in-uk/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/british-govt-...
- mistermann 4y ago> That's why you cannot ask any government to protect its citizen digital systems, because there are too much interested in to get security holes for their own benefit... Any government that currently exists maybe, but not necessarily any government that is possible. The governmental forms we have now are ancient, designed in a period that pales in comparison to the complexity and power currently available to mankind. The runtime we are in physically supports improvements, but it appears to not support improvements psychologically - you can test this theory by asking questions of agents within the runtime, and you will discover that there is extreme and almost unanimous opposition to improvements, which to me seems highly counter-intuitive but that is what data suggests.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>While the analyst attempted to remove the US information, in some cases, it said, they “inadvertently failed” to do so. A reminder that every abuse we hear of is one they failed at covering up. The most famous example of this is MKUltra, where everything we know about the program is from one document cache that survived the incinerator by being mislabeled.
- uog2jeeY3Jaiphu 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- azinman2 4y agoI don’t know what the context of this is (or its legitimacy), but what you’re implying is extremely offensive… especially to the Jewish members of my family who did fight in WWII under extremely anti-semitic leadership who would send them on missions first (not last!) that they thought were the most dangerous.
- teddyh 4y agoIn what reasonable way is what you wrote an argument? Don’t be offended, be refuting.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThey refuted it with anecdotes of their family members serving. If you want more, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Jewish_Americans#World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Jewish_Ame...
- teddyh 4y agoI did not interpret it in that way; I thought it was “That is offensive to me and even more so to these other people I know”. Your point is correct – it can charitably be interpreted as being a form of refutation argument. However, anecdotes about individual people are a very weak form of argument. I could think of a few better arguments immediately from the top of my head: The clumsy wording of the text (in the PDF) itself. The fact that there seems to be no personal testimonies about what is implied to be an extremely widespread conspiracy. And, of course, your link is a much better argument than any individual anecdote. But ‘azinman’ did not do any of that; they chose instead to play the “I’m offended!” card. If this is allowed to fly, well, then anyone can be offended by anything, and argument and debate is dead here.
- wpietri 4y agoIt's good to see here that one part of the government is calling another part to account. But I have to think that's unusual, and I'd love to see a better balance of responsibilities here. In Greg Bear's novel "Queen of Angels", set in 2047, their solution to the conflicting needs of privacy and crime prevention was a separate organization called "Citizen Oversight". All the digital-trail data (cameras, financial records, etc) flowed into Citizen Oversight. If law enforcement wanted data, they had to ask for it and demonstrate need on a case-by-case basis. In that world it wasn't a perfect solution; if I recall rightly, part of the novel is driven by Citizen Oversight's swing from a too-loose era to a very stingy one. But I liked the idea of there being specific, named people responsible for protecting privacy.
- ttyprintk 4y agoUsing civilian oversight of police as a metaphor, the high-profile civilian killings lately have come from police departments with civilian oversight. Less than 1% have it, which means an even smaller fraction have civilian discipline.
- wpietri 4y agoThe US has a long history of dubious police killings. That some are now high profile seems like a step forward to me. Yes, civilian oversight of police in many places is weak. But to me that's an argument for stronger oversight.
- ttyprintk 4y agoI should have picked a milder example. If in the future, civilian oversight has burgeoned to be powerful-enough that it impedes what law-enforcement feels it’s entitled to, then civilian oversight will have passed traditional American powers. Your metaphor is begging the question, how do we get there from here? America has the institution of juries and grand juries, and in a very small number of police departments, long-term officials with regular contact with the department. I suppose juries and grand juries are the path toward overpowered civilian roles rather than today’s meager civilian oversight boards.
- localplume 4y agoOf course here come the articles undermining the intelligence community, right in the wake of the Chinese balloon incursions and continued Chinese/Russian foreign intelligence efforts, and at its core are republicans. As usual these articles pertaining to the IC massively misunderstand, misrepresent, and downright act against the interests of the United States by so feverently spurring on the de-fanging of intelligence capabilities.
- beecafe 4y agoHello CIA!
- gigibec 4y ago[dead]
- fit2rule 4y ago[dead]
- gigibec 4y ago[dead]
- newZWhoDis 4y agoI don’t believe my tax dollars should fund the CIA, NSA, DHS, etc. DIA seems reasonable.
- criddell 4y agoNow I’m imagining an ad-supported NSA.
- beebmam 4y agoThe FBI is already profoundly ineffective. I'd be good with empowering it further it as long as there is bipartisan congressional oversight, same with our police in general.
- ren_engineer 4y agoeven if this gets fixed they can still use 5 eyes to get around it, US and friends use loopholes to have each other spy on their citizens to get around their own laws protecting citizens. It adds an extra step but they still get the info they want
- newZWhoDis 4y ago5 eyes as a concept is essentially institutionalized treason. There’s no such thing as a friendly foreign intelligence service, their goals are directly against the interest of the American public/civilian world (which in theory our intelligence services work for) A CIA officer conspiring with GCHQ to defraud the United States should result in lifetime imprisonment.
- brookst 4y agoThat is not a good take. There are many moral and political concerns with five eyes, but casting all international cooperation as “treason” discredits your position.
- taftster 4y agoHyperbole runs rampant like the roadrunner on winding roads of the internet these days.
- akira2501 4y agoCasting spying as the only means of international cooperation is disingenuous.
- brookst 4y agoHuh? The post I replied to said that agencies working with international counterparts is necessarily treason. Where in the world did you get that strange claim about what I said?
- 4y ago
- philippejara 4y ago"In another incident, the FBI ran searches using the “names of a local political party,” even though a connection to foreign intelligence was “not reasonably likely.” The DOJ explained the errors away by saying FBI personnel “misunderstood” the search procedures, adding they were “subsequently reminded of how to correctly apply the query rules.”" Fascinating, FISA was created iirc in part in response to nixon's spying on political groups, half a century later this is what we see and the response is just to...remind them how to correctly apply the query rules? If that is the response to such a thing I find it hard to believe it isn't a common occurrence that is just being hand waved away because it "leaked". And the article itself is filled with even more examples. I'm not opposed to calling the new age church committee politically motivated, it clearly is, but at the very least they are trying to do something about it. It's pretty sad how after the russiagate conspiracy theory took steam the "left-wing" media started putting the intelligence community in a pedestal and now it seems like distrusting them is a republican position, bizarrely.
- LgWoodenBadger 4y agoThere are worse consequences for bank tellers looking up celebrity banking info, or customer service reps looking up celebrity medical info, than there are for this crap. Ridiculous
- ren_engineer 4y ago93% of DC voted Democrat in 2020, surrounding areas about 80% Democrat. Not sure why anybody would be surprised by this. The people in charge are fine with it and only promote people with similar ideology. Anybody in the FBI who might change things gets assigned to some FBI field office in the midwest and their career is over. Similar situation in the Pentagon and most other DC/Federal government institutions
- tzs 4y ago> 93% of DC voted Democrat in 2020 A minority of DC voters work for the government, and only a small minority of those work at the top of their agencies or departments. The people in charge are appointed by nationally elected people, or promoted by the people those nationally elected people appoint.
- influx 4y agoWhy do we have to rely on Republicans to curtail the FBI's civil liberties violations? That's scary AF.
- theptip 4y agoWe don’t, Ron Wyden (mentioned in the OP) is a prominent Dem who has also been campaigning hard on this issue. IIRC he had committee access and said things like “there is unconstitutional stuff going on that folks will be outraged about” prior to the Snowden leaks. He was very critical of the Patriot Act.
- Kukumber 4y agoFBI this FBI that, they are useless, why do they try to divert the public opinion away from the CIA?