8 ms·
Donald Knuth on Machine Learning and the Meaning of Life
- dimtion 4y agoNote that this is from October 2021.
- johnea 4y ago"The meaning of life" is maybe the most persistent myth ever. It's only real competition is "the invisible guy in outer space". Both are stone age mythology that are embraced by the weak minded to avoid facing reality: There is no "meaning", we just grew here...
- ffhhj 4y ago...just grew here with the capacity to develop myths and theories. If a theory of an invisible guy drives progress, then that's what works. Machines without our motivations will find themselves simply contributing to the 2nd law of thermodynamics, making no sense of progress, and shutting themselves down. We will embed our myths on them to keep going. Enjoy the 2nd law, we grew here for it.
- rcme 4y agoDid the myths drive progress, or did progress happen despite the myths?
- voakbasda 4y agoHistory is replete with examples that strongly suggest “despite”. Hell, they are still holding us back.
- ffhhj 4y agoAs said, whatever it's that works. In the meanwhile let's wait for that progress isolated from culture, beliefs, not even a language?
- rcme 4y agoLanguage facilitates idea sharing. Clearly that’s useful for progress. What’s less clear is the mechanism in which mythology acts on progress. Especially when we have counter examples where mythology explicitly hindered progress, e.g. the resistance to the ideas Copernicus by the church. Yes we have mythology and yes we have progress. But that doesn’t mean mythology enables progress.
- drewcoo 4y agoSo is "progress."
- euroderf 4y agoNational Lampoon put the question thusly: Hairy Thunderer or Cosmic Muffin ?
- lampshades 4y agoAs a Christian, I really like that Donald Knuth is a devout Christian. In general, it feels like being an outcast as a Christian in tech.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThe fact that you're making a comment about how your Christianity makes you feel outcast probably means you feel compelled to push those beliefs onto others, which is deeply unlike Christ. Remember the first apostles were people who found meaning in the message, not in identity
- hazn 4y ago“The fact that you're making a comment about how your Christianity makes you feel outcast probably means you feel compelled to push those beliefs onto others” Rather seems like you’re reaching to push your opinions to others. The logical conclusion you took out of that outcast comment is crazy.
- lampshades 4y agoThe fact that you even made this comments makes me feel like you’re compelled to push your beliefs on others. You don’t know anything about me. Like I said, as a Christian I feel like an outcast because I have to deal with assholes like you.
- revskill 4y ago[flagged]
- shaftoe444 4y agoWhat a mean spirited comment.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoI feel deeply distributed by the modern Christian community's very un-Christ focus on "exclusion". The notion that the divine word does not support itself and we need the approval of "the tech community" is deeply offensive to me
- thomastjeffery 4y agoThere's an irony to religious people saying, "It's about the journey, not the destination." Faith in God is literally an assertion about the destination (conclusion), and not the journey (evidence). Anyway, this article has a short bit about solving tik-tak-toe with "ML-like methods", but not much else.
- hgsgm 4y agoThis is a deeply ignorant comment.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoIgnorant of what? The pro-religious perspective? If I am required to take that perspective, am I required to be ignorant of the atheist/agnostic perspective? I call that requirement itself ignorance. So I'm ignorant of ignorance... Double negative.
- saulpw 4y agoYou're setting up a strawman. Knowledge of one perspective does not entail ignorance of another perspective. The more perspectives we can integrate, the more thoughtful we can express ourselves to others. (Since many of us have different perspectives.
- lampshades 4y agoFaith in God is an assertion about the journey as well. I can’t speak for everyone, but a lot of us believe that God works actively in our lives. Not to mention, the journey gets a lot better when you realize what’s at the end.
- rcme 4y agoWhat’s at the end?
- lampshades 4y ago
- hhhhhhkkk 4y ago[flagged]
- w10-1 4y agoSome interesting quotes show how someone as brilliant as Knuth has enough self-understanding to adopt profound humility: "[when asked the meaning of life] I personally think of my belief that God exists, although I have no idea what that means [...] I try to imagine that I’m following somebody’s wishes. Lex: Even though you’re not smart enough to… Knuth: …to know what they are." Later: "it struck me that if I were in a position of responsibility for people’s lives, in most cases I wouldn’t have any confidence that any of my decisions were good — that these questions are too hard, probably, for any human being, but certainly for me…" It reminds me of the first two commandments: 1. Put no other gods before me 2. Do not take my name in vain, i.e., in vanity as yours i.e., 1. You're not expected to believe is something greater, but if you do, don't just project your wishes for a good harvest 2. Don't use any belief as a source of personal pride Doctor, heal thyself! Programmer, program yourself!