7 ms·
“Hunger cliff” looms as 32 states set to slash food-stamp benefits
- eggy 4y ago'Slash' is a loaded word in the headline. Food-stamp benefits increased during the pandemic to help people get by, but now that unemployment is so low, and the pandemic is pretty much done, why shouldn't they cut them back? Unemployment is being touted as being the lowest since 1969. This seems fair to me. I grew up at and below the poverty line in Brooklyn, and my Dad would not apply for them. He had the old world tough it out and do anything to support the family creed. There were people in our neighborhood who would buy someone else's groceries to swap them for beer and cigarettes. I even shined shoes when I was 8, but that was my idea. I asked for a copper colored metal shoeshine kit for Christmas. Suits would see an 8-year old shining shoes and tip me big! I bought my first telescope at a fire sale at a hobby shop from my earnings at 9.
- zht 4y agoHow much more does stuff now than when benefits were increased? What was the median single family home price ratio to median minimum wage annual income when you were growing up?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoSNAP is inflation-adjusted annually: benefits increased 12.5% for 2023 for example. The income levels for eligibility are also inflation-indexed.
- superkuh 4y agoI guess you didn't read the article the linked to the study showing most working age adults on EBT actually have jobs. Those jobs just don't pay enough to survive (ie, food+rent). That's a relatively new trend that didn't exist back during your formative years. Anyway, it is a slash because the economic ramifications of the pandemic haven't ended. Food prices spiked dramatically because of it and have not gone down. They are continuing to go up. It's unfortunate that people who suffered generally want other people to have to suffer like they did. What you're describing is not a happy, uplifting story of bootstraps. 8 year olds having jobs is sad.
- ghiculescu 4y agoOP said shining shoes was their idea, and the money was used to buy something cool. Presumably not every family could afford a telescope. I think 8 year olds finding ways to make pocket money is awesome, not sad. (8 year olds needing to work to provide for their themselves or family is, of course, sad.)
- superkuh 4y agoOP brought it up in a thread explicitly about EBT. It's extremely clear what he was trying to say. If he was just talking about pocket money then what was the point in bringing it up?
- ghiculescu 4y agoBecause it gives context to OP’s worldview, and opinions presented in the first two paragraphs.
- colechristensen 4y agoGiving working people money ultimately subsidizes shitty employers and landlords making it more likely that low income employed people will need to get government assistance. I’m not saying you shouldn’t do it and other things as well, but such programs have other consequences. I’m a fan of the opposite angle, using zoning laws to force the construction of large amounts of high density large apartments and then heavily taxing vacancies, think 4br 2k sq ft. (No empty buildings, no new construction made off entirely studios and 1br, ever shrinking). A glut of high rent properties to drive the prices of everything else down, and a reason for people with money not to run to the suburbs and keep income diversity in cities.
- gruez 4y ago> Giving working people money [...] making it more likely that low income employed people will need to get government assistance. Getting the government to give people money makes it more likely that people will get money from the government. Who would have thunk?
- hobs 4y agoFair in relation to some arbitrary standard of survival we set before? Fair to whom exactly?
- pessimizer 4y ago> Unemployment is being touted as being the lowest since 1969. This seems fair to me. I'd second the request for the thought process behind this judgement. We should have a worse safety net when the number of people who need it is lower?
- MBCook 4y agoWe’re measuring a boolean aren’t we? You either have at least one job or you have no jobs. The fewest number of people who want jobs can‘t find one since 1969. That’s great. But that won’t tell us how useful the job is. If the job from 1969 paid 3x what a job today pays (after inflation) then a person working the same number of hours in a minimum wage job today may need assistance where the 1969 person didn’t. (3x was just an example BTW)
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoIt's not like SNAP is going away: if unemployment is lower but people are working lower paying jobs, those people are going to qualify for SNAP on the same basis as prior to the pandemic.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoWe had a massive increase in SNAP benefits that was in response to the pandemic and big spikes in unemployment. Unemployment is not obviously an issue now, and the pandemic has relatively little effect on most Americans day-to-day. I think what the poster was trying to get at was: if conditions have returned to status-quo, one would tend to think (all other things being equal) that a return to the SNAP status-quo would be reasonable. You can make the argument that the safety net ought to be better; but talking about a "hunger cliff" seems rather emotive.
- eggy 4y agoExactly this. Once a budget is increased for whatever reason, it is almost impossible to take it back to previous levels without a lot of effort. I didn't say abolish food stamps.
- sys_64738 4y ago> I grew up at and below the poverty line in Brooklyn, and my Dad would not apply for them. He had the old world tough it out and do anything to support the family creed. If you qualify for a benefit then it is in your best interests to maximize utilization of such. I certainly wouldn’t have any concerns.
- monero-xmr 4y agoSame reason why I use every possible technique to lower my taxes as a wealthy person
- 1letterunixname 4y agoThe middle class is, sadly, ignorant of this gambit. The tax code is setup as a game of accumulated chicanery due to the regulatory capture of the political system by enormous centers of wealth. America isn't a good place to be anything but ultra rich. There are different strata of wealth: 1 car, 2 cars, 1 home, 2 homes, PA, 5 homes, ASW, 20 homes, and a personal wealth fund.
- SauciestGNU 4y agoYour strata are a bit insulting to Pennsylvania, no?
- eggy 4y agoI would too. You work for the money, and it is natural to want to hold on to it. I am arguing that I don't believe in gaming the system of taking government handouts, because I didn't earn it; I qualify because for some reason I could not earn enough to subsist. I want to work on my earning power for now and the future. I never said get rid of the food stamps. I am glad my Dad didn't have us go on food stamps. My brother and I are successful compared to our parents who never finished high school or owned a house. But it also taught us to be realistic with our money. I have acquaintances who complain about inflation on their second or third trip to Starbucks and they update their phone every year or two, because why, I don't know.
- mc32 4y agoSame. People back then went on stamps as the very last option after family, friends and community (including church) --then they'd go to get food stamps if they could muster the courage. I don't think that culture is widespread today. For good or bad, people have been conditioned to depend on others. Safety nets are of course good --but we also do not want to make society dependent upon them whether because adult jobs don't pay enough due to job exports, or unmitigated drug addition crisis or other. For psychological health, people need to have the opportunity to be self reliant.
- hakfoo 4y ago> For psychological health, people need to have the opportunity to be self reliant. Why does the noble level of "self reliance" always happen to be exactly where other people don't have to pay taxes directly to sustain others? Surely we should go further, and tear up municipal roads and utilities. People would feel so much more independent if they had to spread their own asphalt and wire their own substation. Realistically, there's a psychological value in dependency, particularly in understood dependency. If you have to think of yourself as beholden to others in some way, it incentivizes even the most self-centered of us to ramp up the civility and empathy.
- mc32 4y agoIt’s an innate force. People want to survive and excel on their own. Most mammals are competitive. Maybe we can extirpate that drive by creating a dependency on the state and sedating people via various means, probably, but it’s not our innate nature past infancy.
- eggy 4y agoNo, self-reliant people make enough income to pay taxes to have municipal roads made and this employs people to work for the municipality. A majority of toll roads were private in the 1790s on, and a lot were not subsidized by the government; they were capitalized by selling shares, however, people would 'shunpike' (go around to avoid paying the toll), so this cut into dividends. I believe in having empathy and civility without the notion of an IOU lingering over me, but from having principles and respect for my fellow human.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoSorry, but inflation has driven the prices of food up double digits. The people at the bottom get barely anything: $100-200/month depending, it can only be spent on certain items, in certain stores, and then they have to go through an ordeal every 6 months to a year that treats them like criminals. Compared to European countries, America is one of the worst places to be poor and most Americans don't realize how bad they have it. Taking away pennies from people who's inelastic needs would be seriously harmed by small cutbacks doesn't make sense when socialism for the rich delivers 200%+ net cash outflow. It's more than inhumane, it says "F U" to those who are living paycheck-to-paycheck or who are functionally disabled and cannot hold a job but don't qualify for SSDI. SSDI, in some cases, can take anywhere from 1 to 6 years to be resolved.
- locopati 4y agoAre wages equal to 1969 dollars adjusted to 2023 dollars and inflation? Somehow I doubt that very much.
- Gunax 4y agoMy understanding is that food stamps is federally funded, but administered by the state. I often seen foodstamp eligibility used a marker of poverty, but this is largely an anachronism from the past where foodstamps were reserved for the destitute. Many states now set the requirement at 200% of the federal poverty level. Which is allready fairly generous--that puts 5 member households as foodstamp eligible if their income is under 70k. Because eligibility is determined by household size and income, you can have two people living in the same city working the same job, but one is eligible for foodstamps and another is not.
- unethical_ban 4y agoThat last line seems... obvious. One person feeding a spouse and three children will have a harder time than one person feeding themselves, given the same low amount of money.
- Gunax 4y agoSure. I can support needs-based tests. My point is that we shouldn't use the food stamp threshold as signifier of poverty. This is a common tactic that left-wingers use to prove that wages are insufficient, and that companies are exploting society because some full time workers are eligible for food stamps. This fails on 3 fronts: 1. The threshold for food stamp eligibility is sufficiently high that normal wages qualify, eg. 70k. 2. Technically any wage can qualify for food stamps if one's household size is large enough. 3. We also believe in equal pay for equal work.
- yardie 4y agoFPL is $13,500 for an individual. Not sure where you are where $27000 seems livable because I don't think even grad students can get by on that.
- refurb 4y ago$2000/month is more than livable for an individual in a LCOL state.
- PebblesHD 4y agoI don’t understand how access to food is not a globally solved problem. We have such high levels of food waste and access to so many resources for other things like militaries and space programs, yet people in quite wealthy countries are still struggling to put food on the table. Growing up my parents would sometimes skip meals to make sure my sibling and I had enough to eat, and thinking about it now in the context of both a housing crisis and increases in low income families cutting back on ‘discretionary’ spending such as food, I’m left quite dissatisfied in the modern world that it cannot provide a basic level of sustenance to the people. Oh well, someone needs to own several mega-yachts so some level of starving is required I guess /s.
- slibhb 4y agoThe idea that hunger is the result of "people owning mega-yachts" is populist nonsense.
- officialchicken 4y ago“Qu’ils mangent de la brioche” -Marie Antoinette
- leereeves 4y ago-Not Marie Antoinette. Rousseau wrote the anecdote about an anonymous princess who said that in 1765; Marie Antoinette didn't arrive in France until 1771.
- pessimizer 4y agoOnly if those people made their money from paying low wages would it make sense. edit: maybe years of tax subsidy and/or tax avoidance might add additional culpability.
- darth_avocado 4y agoIt is not entirely untrue. EBT is essentially subsidizing businesses using tax dollars. If a business cannot survive without paying people liveable wages, it should not survive. Yet they exist because the government shares the burden of those wages. There is absolutely no reason why someone who works for Amazon or Uber or all the fancy tech companies where the upper management takes millions should not earn liveable wages and rely on food stamps to supplement their income.
- poorbutdebtfree 4y agoCan't have rising "food insecurity" and rising obesity rates at the same time. Big Food loves EBT.
- hakfoo 4y agoBy the same logic, you can't have record-low unemployment and rising poverty rates. Somehow we squared that particular circle. Like the unemployment rate and actual standard of living, obesity and food insecurity are loosely coupled but somewhat independent things. An EBT program might be able to funnel dollars into grocery store tills, but it doesn't necessarily mean efficient delivery of quality foods. Poverty often involves multiple dimensions of constraints. While it might be easy to simplify an argument by saying "buy 20kg bags of beans and rice and cook that for 93 meals a month", that neglects factors like: * Burdened workers/parents who lack the time/remaining energy to prepare labour-intensive home-cooked food. Opening a tin or putting something in the microwave for six minutes is an awfully compelling proposition. * Poor housing, where you might not have good cooking or food storage facilities. If you don't have a working fridge, many fresh ingredients are too perishable. If you have an infestation, bulk foods are just a hazard. There's plenty of wholesome meals you might have a hard time cooking if you're limited to a hot plate or microwave. * Food deserts, where you have to buy what's reasonably available at what's likely extortionate prices. There's also a bit of a hedonistic limit. We're not just chugging Food Packets to increase an on-screen stamina bar. Most people are not going to be able to stick to a tightly planned, "optimal health" meal program if it doesn't offer at least occasional luxuries and modest variety. Look how even rich people can't stick to diets. This is not a moral failing, but trying to balance health and taste concerns with tight financial restrictions often triggers "poor choices".
- mynameishere 4y agoI get the feeling a lot of people here on "Hacker News" don't do a lot of their own cooking. So here is some information on the topic of Home Economics. For example, if you want to eat bread, it is 40 cents a pound for the base ingredient, flour: https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-All-Purpose-Flour-10LB-Bag/122814298 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-All-Purpose-Flour-10L... That 4 dollar bag has ~16000 calories in it, so at 2000 calories a day, this works out to about 50 cents a day, for a base level diet that will prevent hunger, as the word "hunger" is understood by us readers-of-dictionaries. If you prefer cake over bread, you will primarily need this other base ingredient: https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-Pure-Granulated-Sugar-25-Lb/10403009 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-Pure-Granulated-Sugar... ...and that is a bit more--55.9 cents a pound. Now, you may say, "Cake is not good enough." If you thought that, you share a very common sentiment. Ask anybody who actually works at Walmart about what is being purchased on EBT cards, and it is not flour and sugar for making cake. If people just wanted cake, they could pay using their own money and not even notice the expense. But that is not what they want.
- vkou 4y agoBread takes so much labour at particular timings spread out over the day to make that it's not a practical solution for someone with a day job. There's a reason a loaf is $3-8 at the grocery (And it's hard to, with a straight face, describe most of the $3 ones as bread.) It's not the 17th century, or the 1950s anymore, most households don't have someone spending 24/7 on domestic chores. You could have picked a million better cooking examples, I don't understand why you went with bread.
- jodrellblank 4y agoSoda bread is easy and quick to make: get the oven on very hot gas 7-8 with a saucepan or casserole dish in it. Get a a bowl, 450grams flour, half to one teaspoon salt, heaped teaspoon bicarbonate of soda, optional teaspoon sugar, mix, ~350ml milk, mix until dough, shape into blob with hands, dust the hot saucepan with flour and drop the dough in it. Bake until crusty and done, 30-60 minutes ish. Voila, delicious soda bread. No kneading, no rising, no yeast, no proving, no loaf tins, no mixer, no added time, no work surface, just mix and cook. Optionally swap ~50-75g of the flour for oats, or some-all of the milk for plain yogurt. Yes yeasted bread takes more time but soda bread is really good and way more convenient.
- emmelaich 4y agoMaybe too much money is spent on unhealthy food and subsidising Coca Cola. > on a typical day less than 1 percent of households now face “very low food security.” That low figure contrasts with the 17 percent of U.S. households that currently receive food stamps. > The study found that SNAP shoppers bought slightly more junk food than non‐ SNAP shoppers. Quotes from https://www.cato.org/blog/snap-15-billion-junk-food https://www.cato.org/blog/snap-15-billion-junk-food SNAP is Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Another pertinent quote. From NIH in case you don't like Cato. > It is no longer controversial to say that the United States food system does not support a healthy diet https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6168179/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6168179/
- UncleEntity 4y agoBack in the cab driving days I used to see what people were buying with their food stamps when I helped them unload the trunk and all I have to say is it wasn’t healthy foods. Also heard a bunch of different ways to turn them into cash.
- iudqnolq 4y agoFirst off, this isn't that important. Our first priority should be stopping people starving to death. Healthy eating is an optimization on top of that. Second, this is complicated by the fact that "healthy" vs "unhealthy" food vibes are often factually incorrect. People assume cheaper and less labor intensive food is unhealthier, when in reality sugar is sugar. For example, this study points out SNAP recipients bought more "prepared deserts". That makes complete sense - they're far less likely to bake themselves or eat out, but there's little evidence that premade the sugary baked goods they ate less healthy than home baked ones. Third, this study is talking about tiny effect sizes. A 2.15% increase in sugary beverage purchase, really? Finally, on a moral level I believe everyone has the right to make poor decisions. Just because someone receives government benefits doesn't mean they shouldn't be allowed to trade off momentary enjoyment for long-term health issues, especially if society has ruined their long term anyway.
- unmole 4y ago
- 1letterunixname 4y agoConsider how little recipients get for food stamps ($100-250/month and can only be used for certain items and in certain stores), this is just turning the screws on the poor.
- rasz 4y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2010/12/01/soda-subsidy-gives-tax-dollars-to-beverage-companies.html https://www.cnbc.com/2010/12/01/soda-subsidy-gives-tax-dolla... https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2018/10/29/659634119/food-stamps-for-soda-time-to-end-billion-dollar-subsidy-for-sugary-drinks#:~:text=SNAP%20households%20spend%20about%2010,amount%20they%20spend%20on%20milk https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2018/10/29/659634119/fo... https://www.miaminewtimes.com/restaurants/coca-cola-to-face-criticism-for-food-stamp-lobbying-6583712 https://www.miaminewtimes.com/restaurants/coca-cola-to-face-...
- dole 4y agoThese are rather old sources (2010, 2013, 2018), not that I doubt the lobbying continues but that the there’s better things to focus on, gains to be made than chasing after soda SNAP expenditure edge cases.
- rasz 4y agoApparently this edge case was 40% of US CocaCola 2022 revenue.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoPetro-agribusiness is a racket. The US subsidizes cheap, unhealthy crops like cow corn to manufacture HFCS. Without subsidies, cane sugar would likely be cheaper than HFCS or beet sugar. And that Walmart can grossly underpay its employees so much that they need social benefits to survive is another indirect, but pervasive and perverse, transfer of wealth from the lower and middle to the wealthy owners of corporations.