11 ms·
Reeling MPAA declares DNS filtering "off the table"
- mlapida 15y agoYesterday SOPA was "shelved", today DNS filtering is "off the table". I'm not sure I follow.
- calloc 15y agoAll of it is double speak. The bill can be revived at a moments notice, when we finally let up and go back to being complacent it will be pulled from the shelve and passed as quickly as possible.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoSOPA was shelved in its current form. And DNS filtering was one mechanism to enforce the provisions of SOPA. That doesn't mean that the industry and congress have given up the basic premise of SOPA: the idea that all content on the internet should be pre-screened thoroughly for any hint of IP infringement, that standards of evidence and due process should be thrown out the window and the mere act of accusation should be sufficient to warrant adjudication of a punishment on the site owners.
- TDL 15y agoIt sounded to me as though DNS filtering was off the table until the controversy dies down. I don't think the MPAA/RIAA is going anywhere. They want to control the technology & destroy it if necessary. This is a strategic retreat on their part.
- sehugg 15y agoYes, my take as well. DNS filtering is the easiest thing to retreat on (it was the only thing specifically called out in the White House's response) and the NFL et al. can continue to work with ICE to seize domains the old-fashioned way.
- gigawatt 15y agoI'm having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that the MPAA gets to decide what's "off the table" in legislation. Is there no longer even a pretense of separation of corporations and the government?
- TDL 15y agoThe old content producers are very much in bed with the government. Radley Balko wrote about instances where RIAA (or MPAA, can't remember) representatives were with federal agents during raids.
- anamax 15y ago> Radley Balko wrote about instances where RIAA (or MPAA, can't remember) representatives were with federal agents during raids. That's fairly common wrt trademarked goods (such as high-end purses). I assume that the reason is something along the lines of "federal agents can't recognize counterfeit goods". If the trademark owner is liable for claiming that something is counterfeit when it isn't, that doesn't seem like a horrible idea. How do you think that federal agents should recognize counterfeit goods?
- corin_ 15y agoWhile their influence is obviously a big problem, keep in mind that you've picked one of two ways to read that line, that they are declaring their decision. The other way to read it is that they are stating a fact, which could come from discussions with politicians, even if in those discussions the MPAA was screaming for it to stay in the bill.
- ypcx 15y agoYou are basically asking "Why aren't they trying to fool us anymore?". Just look at opensecrets.org - it's all there, at least the visible part - donations and revolving doors (no blackmail, threats, assassinations etc.). People still discussing any other problem than money in politics are under a strong, remotely-induced hypnosis. You know, the hypnotists that can make people not see other people, seeing right through them. That explanation is the only thing keeping me sane these days.
- hughw 15y agoThe MPAA/RIAA argument amounts to: We would like to do business on the Internet but existing Internet architecture isn't satisfactory for our business model. Let's make a law to change the architecture.
- maeon3 15y agoNotice the stealth loaded question: censoring the internet is cool, just all this backlash is because dns blocking. They are thinking hmm, how can we get dns blocking without all this backlash?
- Canada 15y agoDear MPAA: You can take the whole table and shove it up your ass.
- drivingmenuts 15y agoHow about a movement to destroy the MPAA? Or at least a movement to hit them where it hurts until the MPAA starts coming up with some different ideas that don't suck? Start striking at the MPAA directly.
- mattmiller 15y agoI think that is a good idea. We should have a movement to destroy destructive entities like the MPAA, RIAA, NAR, and other groups that inhibit innovation with lobbying and lawsuits. How do we do that?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]