3 ms·
We the people shouldn't be wondering if this is violating the law. We the people should be deciding if this should be allowed or not. The law is ours to wri
by londons_explore 4y ago
We the people shouldn't be wondering if this is violating the law.
We the people should be deciding if this should be allowed or not. The law is ours to write, and we should make our decision what we want it to say and then work to make sure it is implemented as we want.
- labster 4y agoThis is from America, where national laws like copyright are very hard to change, due to lobbyists and both political parties thinking the other one literally works for the Devil. Your point about people deciding their own laws is great but it’s just not how our system works. Instead most law nowadays is made by judges interpreting anything controversial.
- mandmandam 4y agoOk, but, that system - "how things are" - is exploitative in the extreme to both people and the planet. It's unsustainable, eldritch, profoundly unjust and corrupt. Using "how things are" (fucked) as a justification to prevent discussion of "how things could be" (amazing) is fucked. I'm sick to the teeth of seeing it.
- mmahemoff 4y agoYou’re both right. It’s true the practical aspects many it hard to change laws, but I still appreciate OP’s starting from first principles. It’s easy to get caught up in debates over how to interpret current laws and conflate what’s legal with what’s (a) ethical (b) conducive to progress. However, we shouldn’t lose sight of the fact that these laws are merely social contracts and subject to change with enough impetus and savvy.
- Zetobal 4y agoThe truth is that nobody cares. Your "We the people" Braveheart speech is just cognitive dissonance with the rest of the world if you look at the reactions irl and on the web normal people, or better said people not in the tech bubble and overwhelmed artists, are rather excited.
- harshreality 4y agoThat incorrectly presumes that you[1] can make any law you want, have it enforced, and not piss off the vast majority of people or damage the fabric of free society. You can't make any law you want, and keep a free society. You can't tell people they can't train neural nets with publicly available data. You can't tell people they can't run something like stable diffusion without getting output approved by some approved entity. This is a line in the sand. If lawmakers are coerced into passing such laws, it will consolidate almost all future power (computing, language, speech, images, and video will all be heavily dependent on potentially copyrighted AI output) in the hands of government or corporate authority. [1] for all the people complaining about this: a) That's the collective "you", not the parent poster. b) The majority of people are not involved in Congress's decision to pass or not pass legislation. What moves the needle is the representative's own intuition (often flawed), or relatively small groups of people who have been motivated to contact their legislators, or corporate lobbying.
- lwhi 4y agoWe can change the licencing models used to release work into the public domain. In order to do so, we need the conversation and we need to educate inorder to have the conversation in the first place. Law is evolving.
- mejutoco 4y ago> That incorrectly presumes that you can make any law you want, have it enforced, and not piss off the vast majority of people OPs "we" _is_ the vast majority of people. You are answering as if OP said "I". Of course OPs implementation is complicated, but they are not presuming you can make any law you want.
- flohofwoe 4y agoThe parent wrote "We the people", not "I" nor "the government" nor "some corporation".
- ben_w 4y agoAnalogy time: Arguing if a new tech is legal is like saying the Earth is flat. Arguing that we can create and alter the laws and should therefore be discussing if we want this tech to be legal, that's like saying the Earth is a sphere. Both are wrong, but treating them as equivalent is even more wrong than both of them. > You can't make any law you want, and keep a free society. You can't tell people they can't train neural nets with publicly available data. You can't tell people they can't run something like stable diffusion without getting output approved by some approved entity. Depends what you count as "a free society". There are things which I'm not allowed to take photographs of or record videos of, such as the screen of a cinema while it's playing the latest superhero film. There are communications I am not allowed to make, such as the sequence of bits required to recreate even an approximation of the new song from that famous pop singer everyone likes. There is data I'm not allowed to be given or store, like a random stranger's medical records. You're allowed to be an anarchist and say those things should be legal, but most people don't really care very much about any of that — closest we get is people campaigning to "keep memes legal". Hmm. I'm no lawyer, but there's probably one here: what even is the legal status of companies selling the service of searchable archives of screenshots with text on them and short video clips? Is that "fair use" or "probably copyright infringement but nobody cares" or "they all need to be licensed, there was a court case"? (I assume it varies by jurisdiction, an answer in any will do).
- ekianjo 4y ago> We the people "We the people" means nothing. You are not in control.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoThat’s the problem. We, the people, are not in control. We, the people, have given up control to bureaucrats who play god with permission. We, the people, make society function and our society will continue to function without the bureaucrats. We, the people, should be demanding direct democracy.