3 ms·
I finally realized what the difference between gambling and investing was. Gambling - mathematically, you're going to lose over time. This is why blackjack, th
by WalterBright 4y ago
I finally realized what the difference between gambling and investing was.
Gambling - mathematically, you're going to lose over time. This is why blackjack, the lottery, and sports betting are gambling. Every system that has payouts based on what people put in, minus a cut for the bookie, is in this category.
Investing - the mathematical odds are in your favor. Stocks, real estate, etc., as the payouts are based on the ongoing creation of value.
- chii 4y agoSo what do you classify poker as? Gambling? There's no house in poker (cept for the fees for the dealer, which i would assume is fixed).
- WalterBright 4y agoGood question! For most people (myself included) it's a zero-sum game of luck, and a loser if the house takes a cut. For some people who dedicate their lives to it, it's a game of skill, and an investment when played against lesser mortals. If you're betting on the players in the game, then it's clearly gambling.
- cafard 4y agohttps://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/3189/pg3189-images.html#science https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/3189/pg3189-images.html...
- reducesuffering 4y agoBlackjack as an example doesn’t work for the card counters that have +EV which can be had in a half day of reading / memorizing and $5k bankroll. Technically, their investment EV is far higher than stocks and bonds. Could be on the order of 2% per day, if it wasn’t for those meddling back offs and limits.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe casinos know about card counters and throw them out. They also employ countermeasures: 1. limit the amount of bets 2. using multiple decks 3. reshuffling the decks long before the deck runs out making the return so miniscule as to be a waste of time.
- reducesuffering 4y agoCasinos know about card counters but are unable to deal with them effectively just like people dealing with social engineers. 1. Bet sizes can be up to around ~$10k with a 1% - 3% EV per hand. 2. Doesn't matter too much, standard 6 or 8 deck shoes still are 0.5% EV at true count 2 and +0.5% thereafter. 3. This matters more, but most counters eye dealers with 70%+ penetration of all the decks, which still averages to the +EV above. Returns are ~$50/hr at your average casino but the sky is the limit for having mid 6 figure bankroll and being a smooth social engineer with $5k bets at high roller tables. Some hands are +$50-$250 per.
- WalterBright 4y agoI thought blackjack bets were limited to $500. Seems my information is outdated. Nice to hear some better info!
- dlkf 4y agoThis is a prescriptive definition that doesn’t fully correspond to common usage patterns: - Some sports bettors apply advanced analytics and win consistently. We can still sensibly use the expression ”sports gambling.” - Conversely, people ”invest” in crypto schemes that are sure to lose The conceptual distinction you’re drawing may be a useful one, but I don’t think it perfectly follows the contours of the words ”gambling” and ”investing.” These words are used in different contexts for random historical reasons. On average, the contexts in which we would say ”investing” are a lot safer than the contexts in we would say ”gambling,” but it’s not totally cut and dry.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm sure it's not a perfect delineation, the world is complicated. Nevertheless, it's still quite useful.