5 ms·
> Extinction rebellion have a page on her (NSFW warning for some nudity in the banner image Controversial opinion: by scaremongering about nuclear power—which
by rayiner 4y ago
> Extinction rebellion have a page on her (NSFW warning for some nudity in the banner image
Controversial opinion: by scaremongering about nuclear power—which the west could have started adopting in the 1970s like France did—the naked tree huggers did as much to set back climate change mitigation efforts as the oil lobby.
At least with the oil folks, they were pushing a status quo that was likely to stand until today anyway, because renewables have only become cost competitive relatively recently. Even without lobbying by the oil industry people had powerful incentives until now to stick with the technology that didn’t require them to put on a sweater or pay more for energy.
The anti-nuclear movement by contrast knee-capped the last best hope for climate change mitigation. A technology that could have been deployed—and catalyzed electrification and energy storage efforts—decades ago when we had more runway.
- fumeux_fume 4y agoGeneral nuclear paranoia stemming from Cold War M.A.D., Chernobyl and Three Mile Island seem to spring to my mind. Not so much your naked tree-hugger in a historical vacuum theory.
- wirrbel 4y ago> Controversial opinion: by scaremongering about nuclear power—which the west could have started adopting in the 1970s like France did—the naked tree huggers did as much to set back climate change mitigation efforts as the oil lobby. You would have thought that France would have supplied the European continent with electricity now that Russia cut its gas supply, but it turns out that France received electricity from Germany even during this time. It turns out that even new builds of nuclear power plants take years to be completed. Getting safety right is a challenge, the more we know about engineering and material science for nuclear plants, the more we know about challenges in building them, the more we need to do to avoid these risks, the harder it is to build a safe power plant.
- robertlagrant 4y agoYou wouldn't have thought that unless you thought France had capacity to power Germany just lying around.
- mikojan 4y agoApparently Germany had capacity to power France just lying around.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoLiterally lying around in a pile of beautiful black lumps of coal.
- wirrbel 4y agoand also beautiful brown lignite
- ptilt 4y agoWhat you don’t know is that in the 2010’s the left wing had a agreement with the Green Party to stop all nuclear by 2050. That’s why we stop financing and maintaining a lot of nuclear plants. It turned out it was a bad idea..
- shortcake27 4y agoWhile I don’t know anything about that agreement, I assume it would have had been a push for renewables. By 2050 it will be easily possible to power the world using renewables. Ending nuclear at that point doesn’t sound like a bad idea to me.
- goatlover 4y agoHow do you know it will be possible by 2050 to go full renewable?
- shortcake27 4y agoBy using elementary grade extrapolation. Right now in 2023 there are multiple countries generating over 90% of electricity from renewables.
- Krssst 4y agoWhich ones? Are we talking 90%, an the entire year, without creative accounting? Disregarding electric dams because, while wonderful, those depend heavily on the country geography and I assume a lot of countries cannot build enough of them. (but we should build as much as we can of those, just don't expect 50% hydroelectricity everywhere)
- shortcake27 4y ago> Which ones? Norway 98% since 2016. Costa Rica 98% since 2015. Scotland 97% in 2020. Uruguay 98% in 2021. New Zealand pushing close to 90%. > Are we talking 90%, an the entire year, without creative accounting? I don’t know what this means. If a country reports that X amount of energy came from a particular source in a particular year, that means the entire year. And if you believe these countries are lying and doing “creative accounting”, then the burden of proof lies with you to prove it, not for me to disprove it.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoFrance was strongarmed by Germany and by shitty election related deals to elect Hollande into massive nuclear power closures and reductions, coupled with presidents unable to see more than 5 years ahead means that nuclear plants both do not get renewed and also get closed for absolutely no reason. See Fessenheim. The issue with construction isn't that it's hard to build a safe power plant, it's that there's been no will from anyone, or active harm from incompetent shitheads.
- Krasnol 4y agoHollande wanted to diversify France because it's not and they had to pay for this stupidity and still do to this day. Fessenheim is the perfect reason for why Hollande wanted to close some of those plants: old, accident ridden, one of those which have to be closed down in summer due to possible overheating of nearby rivers and to top that off: it's in a region which may have earthquakes for which it is not prepared... > The issue with construction isn't that it's hard to build a safe power plant, it's that there's been no will from anyone, or active harm from incompetent shitheads. Weird because there are plenty western countries which do have popular support for nuclear energy but still struggle with construction times and costs in astronomical ways.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ohgodplsno 4y agoFessenheim was amongst the top performing nuclear plants, and had no issues being given a 10 year renewal because of how safe it was before it was closed for political reasons. The EELV/Die Grunde kool-aid is not a good thing to drink considering how anti science they are. And as always, the same awful arguments about "don't overheat the rivers", when the limits set by the safety regulations are way under anything that could damage the environment. You could triple the output heat in the river and it would change absolutely nothing. Hollande did not want to diversify our energy production. It was a purely political play to get EELV's support and used Fessenheim as a sacrificial chip. Glad to see the German energiewende led to such diversification that you're running half your country on coal right now btw. https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoOur national energy company EDF has been the largest energy exporter in Europe for ages, in 2019 it was the largest in the world. In addition to that it's made us the cleanest country in the continent for close to 40 years (along with hydro-rich countries). The notion that 2022 is a smoking gun for nuclear is ridiculous. All it reflects is the past 12 years of successive liberal governments writing laws and reforms to gut our nuclear fleet and EDF in favour of private companies.
- wirrbel 4y agothat is if La Hague isn't leaking nuclear waste
- natmaka 4y agoEven if it doesn't leak... France seeks strategy as nuclear waste site risks saturation point. https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/france-seeks-strategy-nuclear-waste-site-risks-saturation-point-2023-02-03/ https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/france-seeks-st... Moreover the long-term deposit site (dubbed 'Cigéo') isn't ready.
- Krssst 4y agoCovid maintenance postponed + corrosion issues led to this bad timing; otherwise looks like it worked pretty well for decades. France closed a working-order nuclear plant for political reasons just two years before, so we're not making exactly the brightest decisions here either.
- andrewflnr 4y agoAgree. It's quite possibly, and I say this in full awareness of the scope, one of the biggest own goals in the history of Earth.
- mjhay 4y agoThe fossil fuel lobby has actually promoted nuclear FUD, including by funding anti-science "environmentalist" groups.
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> Controversial opinion: by scaremongering about nuclear power—which the west could have started adopting in the 1970s like France did—the naked tree huggers did as much to set back climate change mitigation efforts as the oil lobby. I've always hoped they're secretly funded/friends with the oil lobby, because otherwise that's just pure sadness.
- JohnBooty 4y agoI don't know if they were directly funded by the oil lobby, but I'm not sure that they needed to be either. At a minimum, it seems that (thanks to ignorance) they lapped up all of the anti-nuclear FUD that was generated by the oil lobby and others.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoActually just by russia.
- DiabloD3 4y agoI'd like to also echo this. Best analysis of the history behind the anti-nuclear craze of the 60s and 70s is basically Russia infiltrated the Hippie Movement of the 60s to exploit the "government is bad" soft anarchism (=minarchism) in the movement to delay America from getting a leg up. For the past 100+ years, Russia has been one of the largest energy players in the world, bigger than Saudi Arabia. You can see this today in the Russian Invasion in Ukraine, as Germany tries to comply with the international regulations and shut the Russian Nord Stream pipeline off and can't; Russia has a stranglehold on everyone on that side of the world. So, given that, they feared an America that could meet its energy needs without pollution, heavy investment, and significant cost; while Russia was literally killing its own people to make the oil and gas flow as a cost of doing business. Thus, they slipped right in and used the Hippies to astroturf an anti-nuclear position. Reagan may have torn down that wall, but Russia won the cold war; and then they made sure, post-Soviet, to make sure we'd never attain energy independence. The end result of that trainwreck is currently under investigation by the FBI as per the recommendations of the Jan 6th Committee.
- sonofhans 4y agoI can't believe you're blaming "tree huggers" for this, when the clear beneficiary is the global fossil fuel industry, who've been lobbying against nuclear power since the 50s. Shit, many anti-nuclear groups have been funded by fossil fuel industry for decades. At best, their protests were political cover for governments to do what the oil industry paid them to do.
- sgu999 4y agoDo you have sources for these claims?
- Eduard 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-nuclear_movement#Fossil_fuels_industry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-nuclear_movement#Fossil...
- api 4y agoThe rabid anti nukes were more useful idiots. You’re right that the real power is in the fossil fuel industry which was happy to use them.
- goatlover 4y agoIs that really true in Germany? Chernobyl was such a big deal to the German public, making nuclear very unpopular.
- himinlomax 4y agoAre you sure there's a difference here? https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Greenpeace_Energy https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Greenpeace_Energy
- ALittleLight 4y agoI don't think so. People in the US have and have had net-positive views on nuclear energy. It's not like public sentiment has turned against nuclear energy because of naked tree hugging protesters. For example, this polling [1] from Pew shows that only 27% of the US public thinks the government should discourage nuclear power with everyone else saying the government should either encourage or be neutral towards it. Of course some green energy climate tree hugger whatever protesters oppose nuclear energy, but they are powerless and don't change public opinion much and certainly don't influence outcomes. To my knowledge it's government regulations and laws that stifle nuclear energy - not protesters or climate people. 1 - https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/03/23/americans-continue-to-express-mixed-views-about-nuclear-power/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/03/23/americans-c...
- pydry 4y agoSo, between the sheer 5x higher cost of nuclear power and people who hug trees your consided analysis is that the latter held back nuclear power more? It's like an Illuminati conspiracy theory except with people who dont use soap...
- JohnBooty 4y agoNuclear power is only "5x" higher cost if you utterly ignore the environmental catastrophe of fossil fuels. Global warming will cost countless trillions and displace, sicken, and/or kill billions in the coming centuries.
- Krasnol 4y agoI'm quite sure op meant 5x higher than certain renewables not fossil. Nobody is talking about fossil anymore. It's on the way out just like nuclear.
- goatlover 4y agoAt some point it will, but has fossil fuel use actually declined so far? From what a I’ve read, the Arctic is being looked at as a new frontier for oil and gas exploration as the ice retreats.
- Krasnol 4y agoYes, it has declined in countries which invest into renewables: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-consumption-and-power-mix-charts https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-c...
- pydry 4y ago>Nuclear power is only "5x" higher cost if you utterly ignore the environmental catastrophe of fossil fuels. Well, from, like 1960 until about 2010 everybody who built a power plant did exactly that. And, from about 2015 onwards if you didn't ignore it it's still 5x more expensive than solar panels or wind farms. So, between "expensive" and "people who hug trees and have no power", maybe it's the tree-illuminati people.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> which the west could have started adopting in the 1970s like France did France is often considered to be in "The West".
- debacle 4y agoFear of nuclear is distrust in the government. I believe in nuclear as a technology, and I believe in mankind's ability to perform science and engineering tasks. I don't have a lot of faith in the role of the government in properly and adequately regulating a booming nuclear industry.
- eropple 4y agoThe hypothetical specter of government incompetence is greater than the actual harm being done here-and-now?
- dylan604 4y ago>Fear of nuclear is distrust in the government. Is it though? The US Navy has a pretty impressive nuclear safety record for the number of reactors they have in service. To flip it, would you have more trust in a private company with nuclear safety? If the same decisions being made that allows PG&E to cut their funding for maintenance that allows their lines to be the cause of California's forest fires, why would we trust they would pay for the upkeep on a nuclear reactor?
- debacle 4y agoI've worked in the energy industry. There is complete capture there. When PG&E is the "bad guy" it's because the government needs them to be. ERCOT works the same way (though is better). If the government wanted PG&E to properly fund their line maintenance, PG&E would properly fund their line maintenance.
- bboygravity 4y agoNot sure if that's controversial? I don't think the fossil fuel industry (or Putin) could've wished for better allies than the Energiewende (anti-nuclear, pro Russian gas with a bit of solar and wind) supporters in Europe. Whoever was behind it successfully managed to delay nuclear fission adoption by about 60 years for all of the EU and UK except France causing massive amounts of totally unnecessary CO2 emissions in the process.
- MikePlacid 4y agoPutin is an omni-present monster, sure, and an oil and gas monster to that. But he also is THE biggest nuclear power monster: [Rosatom] ranks first in the overseas NPP construction, responsible for 76% of global nuclear technology exports: 35 nuclear power plant units, at different stages of development, in 12 countries, as of December 2020. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosatom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosatom
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- syvolt 4y agoI agree and I think the damage to humanity that the anti-nuclear movement has done is incalculable. So many years of progress have been missed out on... and while some of it was due to greed (fossil fuel industry funding), most of it was just misplaced fear, whether propaganda induced or from an inability to see the full picture. The anti-nuclear movement is also still alive and doing well but at this point it's like arguing over spilled milk, the damage is mostly done and a lot of is irreversible. We can try to salvage nuclear but we've already regressed to further impure sources in some countries so progress seems unlikely.
- geysersam 4y agoThere is so much wrong with this comment I'm not sure where to begin. 0. Nuclear is not forbidden. 1. Nuclear power is exceedingly common in many countries. 2. Electricity production is not (by far) the only source of carbon emissions. Why have we also not seen any major action to reduce emissions from other sources? Or did the treehuggers also force people to fly, eat meat and drive large cars? 3. > Last best hope. Energy efficiency. Regulation incentivizing fuel efficiency. Low carbon public transportation. Incentives to reduce the carbon emissions from agriculture. Renewables. The list of available remedies is long. But sure, go ahead and blame environmentalists for the destruction profit driven market capitalism caused. If that soothes your cognitive dissonance.
- ackfoobar 4y ago> Nuclear is not forbidden. What is this point replying to? Anyway, over-regulation can make nuclear energy commercially unviable. It doesn't take a ban for nuclear to die.
- geysersam 4y agoThe regulation is there for a purpose. The idea that nuclear was "killed" by regulation is a kind of "stab-in-the-back" conspiracy theory. If nuclear was truly this obvious answer to aquire abundant clean energy, wouldn't our business friendly leaders embrace it with open arms? A couple of treehuggers didn't stop them from allowing overfishing the sea, or from extracting fuel from oil sands. Despite those things having very clear negative environmental consequences. And strong popular opposition. But for Nuclear apparently they went totally in the opposite direction. Deaf to the cries of businessmen they heavily regulated an obviously harmless and extremly profitable energy industry to death? Occam's razor says there's a simpler explanation.
- dTal 4y agoThe regulation is there for a reason, but it doesn't have to be a sensible or proportionate reason. Nuclear power is held to a ludicrously higher safety standard than fossil. You are right to suspect that business interests had a hand in subverting nuclear power - the issue is that while nuclear was getting off the ground, the fossil fuel industry was already well established and integrated with government. The anti-nuclear movement wasn't the ultimate cause, but it allied public opinion with a business interest it should have been viciously fighting.
- somethoughts 4y agoTo me - it seems the existential fear around climate change is the topic of the day for environmentalists only because nuclear ended up not gaining traction. Nuclear waste/proliferation is not the number one existential threat these days only because it's used so little (both because of PR issues and lack of economics/long term maintenance challenges). The masses of environmentalists moved on from nuclear in the 80's but would surely return if nuclear regained traction.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoSmith-putnam was early 40s and both PV and the concept of an economic learning curve have been known since the 50s. We could have had the wind and solar revolution any time in the last 70 years. Instead trillions were gifted to fossil fuel and nuclear con artists. This blame of the failure of nuclear on them being forced to sort-of clean up some of their mess rather than just sending native people to mine with no PPE and dumping tailings and waste wherever is a sad attempt at gaslighting.