4 ms·
Is it still Fair Use if you make money with it?
by croes 4y ago
Is it still Fair Use if you make money with it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nerdponx 4y agoIn the USA, yes. For example, the unanimous ruling in Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. determined that parody is fair use, even if the parody is of a commercial nature: > Held: 2 Live Crew's commercial parody may be a fair use within the meaning of § 107. Pp. 574-594. The ruling states explicitly that commercial usage can be a determining factor in determining whether usage is fair or not, but that it does not in and of itself make the use "unfair". https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/510/569/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/510/569/
- klyrs 4y agoI don't think that question is particularly relevant to the case. A newspaper can publish, for profit, a book review which quotes excerpts. As far as I understand it, the case hinges on the distribution of major portions of copyrighted works and derivatives thereof, in violation of their licenses. Likewise, see Aaron Swartz, sci-hub, etc -- distribution of copyrighted works need not be for profit to be a violation.
- pdonis 4y agoNot necessarily. For example, you can make money by writing a review of a book that includes quotes from the book; that is considered fair use. But if you make money by publishing a book that consists solely of quotes from other books that others have copyrighted, on the grounds that this assembly of quotes from other books might be useful to future authors, that would not be fair use. To me, the latter scenario is much closer to what Github is doing with Copilot, which is one of the things the plaintiffs are alleging violates open source licenses.
- henryfjordan 4y agoMaking money from the work is one of the factors for Fair Use but it is not an automatic-fail kind of situation. A judge/jury would need to hear the facts and consider all the factors. Here's a good link explaining the Fair Use test: https://copyright.columbia.edu/basics/fair-use.html https://copyright.columbia.edu/basics/fair-use.html
- croes 4y agoBut it's pretty clear from the start that Copilot is neither criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, nor research which are covered by fair use.
- henryfjordan 4y agoThe law on fair use says "such as" those categories you list but it is not read that you MUST be in one of those categories to enjoy fair-use. In fact, it goes on in the next sentence to say you need to consider the 4 factor test in every case. > The fair use of a copyrighted work ... for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include ... https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107
- croes 4y agoSounds even worse for Copilot (1)the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes; (2)the nature of the copyrighted work; (3)the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and (4)the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. It's commercial, they use all of the code to built the model and the original code loses its value because you can get through Copilot. 3 of 4, depending on the original license it's 4 of 4 against fair use
- Dylan16807 4y ago> they use all of the code to built the model That's not what "portion used" means. If you summarize a book then the portion used is <1%, not the entire book. > the original code loses its value because you can get through Copilot That's not even remotely true. You might get a fragment or two but you have to rebuild a program from scratch to replace it. And as far as "nature of the copyrighted work" it's a completely different beast. It's a programming tool instead of whatever code was fed into it. Only commerciality is a clear mark against it, and that factor is far from decisive by itself.
- shagie 4y agoYes. Prefect 10 vs Google https://cyber.harvard.edu/people/tfisher/IP/2007%20Perfect%2010%20Abridged.pdf https://cyber.harvard.edu/people/tfisher/IP/2007%20Perfect%2... > Additionally, the district court determined that the commercial nature of Google's use weighed against its transformative nature. Although Kelly held that the commercial use of the photographer's images by Arriba's search engine was less exploitative than typical commercial use, and thus weighed only slightly against a finding of fair use, the district court here distinguished Kelly on the ground that some website owners in the AdSense program had infringing Perfect 10 images on their websites. The district court held that because Google's thumbnails "lead users to sites that directly benefit Google's bottom line," the AdSense program increased the commercial nature of Google's use of Perfect 10's images. > In conducting our case-specific analysis of fair use in light of the purposes of copyright, we must weigh Google's superseding and commercial uses of thumbnail images against Google's significant transformative use, as well as the extent to which Google's search engine promotes the purposes of copyright and serves the interests of the public. Although the district court acknowledged the "truism that search engines such as Google Image Search provide great value to the public," the district court did not expressly consider whether this value outweighed the significance of Google's superseding use or the commercial nature of Google's use. The Supreme Court, however, has directed us to be mindful of the extent to which a use promotes the purposes of copyright and serves the interests of the public. --- I will also draw attention to: > The fact that Google incorporates the entire Perfect 10 image into the search engine results does not diminish the transformative nature of Google's use. As the district court correctly noted, we determined in Kelly that even making an exact copy of a work may be transformative so long as the copy serves a different function than the original work.