12 ms·
Junkyard computing – repurposing discarded smartphones to minimize pollution
- mouse_ 4y agoI strongly believe, after 5 years, every device with more than ~10,000 units shipped should have its bootloader unlocked, and its microcode/any necessary drivers opened up. Failure to open up should result in your license to sell new devices suspended. Unless we do something like this, we're headed towards potentially infinite e-waste. You can make the argument that everything should be a black box for security's sake, but x86/Apple laptops for example have unlocked bootloaders while maintaining security by means of OS encryption. The idea that security and privacy are fundamentally at odds is in my opinion industry gaslighting. People should have 100% control of the hardware they own, and 100% choice of the software they run on it.
- RedShift1 4y agoThe same should go for cars. I've got some bugs I want to fix on my in car entertainment system...
- EvanAnderson 4y agoWhile I agree that this sound nice this will virtually guarantee DRM-encumbered features of devices reaching their legally-required unlock date will be set to fail immediately. That'll force those devices to become e-waste anyway. No more streaming videos, no more using your bank's app, etc.
- RainaRelanah 4y agoI miss the days when computing was focused on trying to protect the user from developers. These days it's more and more protecting the developer from the users.
- mouse_ 4y agoI can still use my bank's "app" (read: web site) and stream videos on my desktop, which has an entirely unlocked bootloader.
- EvanAnderson 4y agoThat's coming. Just wait.
- stuaxo 4y agoSee Windows on ARM based PCs.
- Teever 4y agoSounds like you've stumbled on another thing we need to regulate. We should do this sort of iterative thought experiment w.r.t. regulations all the time. It's sort of like compiling a big package of code. Just keep trying to compile and fixing the errors that come up until it compiles.
- 3-cheese-sundae 4y agoWhere's this license to sell new devices that you speak of? And if it's hypothetical, what's the definition of a device that such a license would restrict?
- belltaco 4y agoHere https://www.fcc.gov/engineering-technology/laboratory-division/general/equipment-authorization https://www.fcc.gov/engineering-technology/laboratory-divisi...
- hummus_bae 4y ago> Failure to open up should result in your license to sell new devices suspended Isn't that a bit like death by a thousand cuts?
- judge2020 4y agoBut unlocking the bootloader, even only once official major updates has stopped, is a risky business move due to activation lock and Find My iPhone. If they did this, there's a good chance phone theft creeps back to high levels, since thieves could just 1. wait until Apple releases new firmware that unlocks the bootloader 2. use that new firmwaare to wipe the memory that handles activation lock 3. re-install a fresh iOS 4. resell the phone iPhone 8's still go for over $100 on eBay, so it's not unprofitable to 'inventory' stolen phones by throwing them in a desk drawer to sell within a few years.
- jefftk 4y agoThieves are not known for their patience. Stealing things that won't be valuable for several years is not a very good business.
- bigape911 4y agoThat's a lot of risk for $100 in 5 to ten years.
- judge2020 4y agoIt might be for a small-time thief, but the more likely scenario is that they ship it to China (like they already do when they snatch an activation-locked phone and sell it for parts) and get $100 now, and the long-running shops in China do the long-term inventory for these phones instead of disassembling them for parts.
- Gigachad 4y agoAndroid already has a solution to this. Unlocking the bootloader requires disabling activation lock. Even back on the nexus line, if the phone was stuck in activation lock, you’d have to unlock with the google account and then with the phone unlocked you’d use adb to unlock the bootloader.
- judge2020 4y agoUnless I'm misunderstanding, a big point of contention is activation lock specifically. Unless you're buying $50-100 iPhone 7's and 8's off marketplace, chances are tons of devices you see in landfills are activation locked phones that either had their battery cut out, got cracked to the point where the user couldn't use the device, or were so badly damaged they just threw it away with no thought to reuse. In this case the iPhone(/iPad/Mac) is still locked, but enabling scrapyards to repurpose them by disabling activation lock would either allow criminals to do this as well, or if you had some vetting process to be able to remove the lock, it might just then the scrapyards de-facto dumps for stolen iPhones (since the scrapyards will like pay more for each phone once they can repurpose and sell them).
- jrgd 4y ago> potentially infinite The moment we run out of rare minerals to build touch screens, there wont be an infinite e-waste problem anymore, unless we find some other fancy uses. It’s a finite resource logic that is needed; that mindset should be adopted globally and there should be a general agreement on how to best manage these finite resources…
- tzs 4y agoAs far as e-waste goes from discarded smartphones goes, it is not clear to me that it is a problem we have to solve now, as opposed to just storing the discarded phones somewhere until it becomes economical to break them down for recycling. Given the number of smartphones currently sold world wide per year, and allowing for reasonable growth, if everyone discarded their phone every year and those discards were all just dumped into a 1 km x 1 km pit, if you made that pit 30 m deep it would be able to hold well over a century's worth of phones.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI love this. I've been thinking of building a "poor man's cluster" using every old phone, Kindle, or laptop. They make a good point how phones have batteries that can charge at off peak hours. I figured if I built my cluster I'd remove the batteries to reduce the fire risk.
- moremetadata 4y ago> I've been thinking of building a "poor man's cluster" using every old phone, Kindle, or laptop. I think the Africans have beaten you to that idea already. https://sm.pcmag.com/t/pcmag_uk/news/c/cleaning-u/cleaning-up-the-e-waste-mess-big-tech-needs-to-do-more_3q9d.1920.jpg https://sm.pcmag.com/t/pcmag_uk/news/c/cleaning-u/cleaning-u... On a more serious note though, repurposing old tech is perfectly valid, all we need is more programmers, so should programming become a mandatory lesson taught at schools in order to reduce e-waste, alongside Maths English & Science? And would it lead to a world looking like this https://i.redd.it/z123hws4wtj31.jpg https://i.redd.it/z123hws4wtj31.jpg or like this https://i.redd.it/shvbec21k8y81.png https://i.redd.it/shvbec21k8y81.png ?
- h0p3 4y agoOwning the means of production is no simple task.
- arbitrage 4y ago> I've been thinking of building a "poor man's cluster" It's not a bad idea, but what would you do with it?
- awoimbee 4y agoThe same things you would do on a cluster of raspberry pi, the possibilities are endless!
- _yb2s 4y agoThis is impressive, the energy efficiency of even outdated phone tech is way above server/desktop systems. It seems like phone technology will be the only viable computer technology for virtually all use cases soon. Arguably, Apple already realizes this, with their Apple Silicon computers now very similar in design to an iPhone.
- Steltek 4y agoIt's too bad that Apple hardware is arguably impossible for this use case. You can't flash a custom ROM so you're limited to what the OS allows (which isn't much). And that's only if you have a developer account that can still build and sign apps for old hardware/OSes, which also need to be refreshed every 7 days.
- judge2020 4y agoBest case scenario is to stop updating the OS and wait for a jailbreak, which does allow you to run full virtualization[0]. 0: https://worthdoingbadly.com/hv/ https://worthdoingbadly.com/hv/
- Gigachad 4y agoYou can install custom OSs on the Mac line though. A Mac mini would make a great server.
- npretorius 4y agoHas anyone ever looked into repurposing wifi devices like phones as mesh routers? Or open cell networks? They would have to always be plugged in but seems like a good start to an open infrastructure
- cjsawyer 4y agoMy biggest hurdle reusing old phones and tablets is the battery failing over time wile living on the charger. We need a project or company that makes dummy batteries that just report 100% full all the time.
- ianai 4y agoCouldn’t that be done in software?
- cjsawyer 4y agoI'm imagining firmware level checks, but both directions should probably be investigated
- Steltek 4y agoI've seen at least one hacker do this. It's not so much the voltage but you need to provide a valid temperature sensor as well (the 3rd pin on most phone batteries).
- dendrite9 4y agoI noticed strange power behaviour in an old phone after not using it for a period and storing it charged. It seemed to run down, and have less room at the low end between 20 and 0% charge. I'd like to do something with the phone but I am not sure if I can easily get inside and access the battery. I do have an old galaxy 2 without a battery that I could do something with but I'm not sure what.
- Semaphor 4y agoOn rooted android you can use Advanced Charging Controller (ACC) [0] to control at what levels to charge. I use it to exchange normal capacity for longevity. [0] https://github.com/VR-25/acc/ https://github.com/VR-25/acc/
- 1-6 4y agoThere should be something like a 'right to repurpose' for old tech. The only reason I keep old PCs laying around is because the BIOS allows anything to come along and install on it.
- S201 4y agoMore than that, there should be a "right to do whatever the hell you want" from day one. It's your device, you paid for it, and you own it, yet for whatever reason we allow these companies to tell us how we can use the hardware we paid for and own.
- jodrellblank 4y agoYou have a right to do whatever you want with it. You can take a hacksaw to it, hit it with a hammer, flash the BIOS with random noise. You won't be imprisoned, the government won't disappear you, the company won't sue you and won't care at all. What you are demanding is more like "after I bought it and the transaction is complete, I want the company to put person-years of unpaid work into making it work a different way which was never offered or part of the deal". That's completely different.
- S201 4y agoNo, this is not correct at all. I am saying that I should be able to run whatever code I want on hardware that I own and pay for. There's no effort from the manufacturer required at all for this in the same way that I can currently run whatever code I want on my laptop without the support of the manufacturer.
- oblib 4y agoI had a two old smartphone sitting in a drawer for a few years, an old iPhone5 and an old Android phone. A few months ago I looked into using them for security cams and did a search and found https://alfred.camera/ https://alfred.camera/ Alfred is pretty cool. They have a free version that does what I wanted and a premium version that's got quite a few nice additional features. I'm still using an old iPhone 10. Apple has obsoleted it too. I can't install any apps from the "App Store" but it still does what I want most. The phone and the "Maps" and text apps still work fine. One of my daughters works at Verizon and asked me if I wanted a new iPhone for Christmas last year but I really don't need one. I work from home, do not work for anyone else, and don't need any additional "Apps". My apps are "web apps" so they run fine on those old phones.
- everly 4y agoThanks for posting, was recently wanting exactly this and was dreading wading through the app store/Reddit posts to find out what actually worked
- ok_dad 4y agoDo you know if they stream the video to the cloud or just connect locally? I am looking for a kid-cam for my son's room, but I do NOT want to have it streaming anywhere outside my LAN. This could work, because I have two old Androids I could use for this.
- nelblu 4y agoTry this, it isn't exactly meant as a camera but it is local only : Meshenger (P2P voice- and video phone App.) https://f-droid.org/packages/d.d.meshenger/ https://f-droid.org/packages/d.d.meshenger/
- komali2 4y agoThey stream to the cloud. They're based here in Taiwan at least so maybe no NSA snooping? Idk I vaguely used them for my lizard camera until I could muster up the energy to self host my own setup.
- 4y ago
- spiritplumber 4y agoWe help you turn old android phones into robot brains if that's your thing. No bluetooth needed, we use the audio jack as a serial port. https://robots-everywhere.com/ https://robots-everywhere.com/ (all designs are free on the wiki, or you can buy it)
- ck2 4y agoIf lineageOS (formerly cyanogenmod) is available for your old smartphone (or tablet) it will give it many more years.
- jabl 4y agoThere's also postmarketOS, which is more like a 'normal' Linux distro, so probably a better choice if you want to use the phone as some sort of compute node.
- alejoar 4y agoWhat's beautiful about pmos is that you can use docker on it. Very easily you can set up a very functional home lab/server off an old phone. I did so with an old OnePlus 5
- EamonnMR 4y agoBig if though. Each device requires special support from the community, and even big name devices don't always make it.
- jdiff 4y agoPlus some providers mandate that bootloaders can't be unlocked if sold bundled with their service, even if that device is normally unlock-friendly.
- jacooper 4y agoNot for server workloads though. Docker is still a PITA to run on android, needing a custom kernel and also a patched version of docker https://gist.github.com/FreddieOliveira/efe850df7ff3951cb62d74bd770dce27 https://gist.github.com/FreddieOliveira/efe850df7ff3951cb62d...
- victornomad 4y agoThis has been a bit of my philosophy with PHONK for the last 10 years. “A framework for old and new Android devices” https://phonk.app https://phonk.app Basically it is a device-hostable framework and IDE that allows rapid scripting to do interesting stuff. I made robots, IoT controllers, music devices, tools and many more with it!
- cdchn 4y agoI like the UI stuff like the knobs, very cool.
- victornomad 4y agoThanks! :)
- qup 4y agoI would love to see a page or README section or something dedicated to showcasing some real-world examples of what can be built with PHONK. I tried googling it and didn't turn up anything, really.
- victornomad 4y agoThanks for the feedback I will try to include some :)
- enobrev 4y agoI absolutely love this. Looking forward to trying it out soon.
- victornomad 4y agothanks!
- didip 4y agoI can see the love poured into this project. Impressive!
- jedberg 4y ago> Most of these unwanted smart- phones are neither discarded nor recycled but languish in junk drawers and storage units. The people who wrote this must not have kids. :) All of my old smartphones become PBS Kids devices until they are destroyed. Then they get recycled. Except for the one we lost on a plane. I hope whoever found it found a good use for it.
- yamtaddle 4y agoPhones without an active sim can still dial 911. Risky to give to kids, unless they're older.
- lostmsu 4y agoNever heard anyone complain about this. You must have had some rare things coincide to get to that conclusion.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWhat do you mean? The phones can dial 911. That's just a fact. Curious young kids have been dialing 911 just to see what happens since before cell phones existed.
- paulkrush 4y agoThis reminds me of the souper computer! Except with better efficiency. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_Soupercomputer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_Soupercomputer
- widowlark 4y agoI fear that these devices are going to become less and less usable, not because they arent physically operable, but instead because companies like Apple are allowing them to become bricks if the owner doesn't pre-empt their demise or recycling. It's done today in the name of theft deterrence, but once these machines end up in drawers and storage lockers for years, I doubt most people will be able to unlock them successfully, rendering them sadly useless.
- eldaisfish 4y agoi disagree. The theft deterrence feature that apple offer is actually useful and does what it says - deter theft. I anticipate the opposite happening because devices are becoming more powerful and more power efficient. I own a PS Vita - this is 2012 hardware - and it holds up very well. granted, this is the exception to the rule but there is no reason why an iphone 12 (for example) cannot be repurposed down the line. the hardware is good enough and fairly durable.
- widowlark 4y agoif it stays in a state where it cannot be reused (because the user no longer has the ability to unlock due to forgotten password, etc), then no matter how powerful it is, it will be a brick.
- hosh 4y agoThere are some folks in the permacomputing community working on this in a generalized way. Some, like the folks making CollapseOS and DuskOS foresee an eventual collapse, where our civilization is unable to fabricate new microprocessors, and so we have to repurpose and scavenge old ones. We're talking things like, repurposing z80 (such as in older TI calculators) as an environment for reprogramming microcontrollers.
- smackeyacky 4y agoI don't think that paper considers the issues of the batteries seriously enough. If you're going to build a cluster of old phones, I'd highly recommend disconnecting the batteries. A quick look at the phones in my drawer show two with swollen batteries and one with a battery that no longer holds a charge, which is the reason they all got retired. My appetite for risk doesn't include setting fire to a building to save money on data centre costs. I miss being able to change out the battery on a mobile and the push for making un-fixable phones has an obvious recycling issue.
- nielsole 4y agoMy Samsung Galaxy S4 for example won't boot without a battery. Also the battery protection circuit is checked for. To get the phone to boot without battery i had to remove the cell from the battery and then connect a power supply to the leads of the protection circuitry. Not without risks either.
- BizarroLand 4y agoSeems like something that could be solved with a small capacitor bank. I may have to give this a try and see what I can figure out. I figure the input voltage would be somewhere around 5 volts and the expected output current would be 3.3 to 4.2 volts, but I bet a static 5 volts should be fine if the chip only checks to see if there is current.
- jacob019 4y agoI've done this a few times, just an electrolytic capacitor across the battery pins often works.
- milleramp 4y agoPhones won't boot with battery disconnected, there are very high current spikes, especially while booting. Also there may be a required boot check for i2c/spi handshaking with the battery.
- password4321 4y ago
- Papychulo0217 4y ago[dead]
- JanMa 4y agoDoes anyone have an idea how they built the cloudlets? I find the concept very fascinating but I don't have any idea how one would go about building such a large cluster of old phones
- tony_cannistra 4y agoI'd imagine you're asking like, how did they _physically_ do it? That is an interesting question, I'd love to see pictures. But from an infrastructural standpoint I'd imagine that just putting a bespoke Linux distro on each of the phones and connecting them to the same network would enable the same kinds of orchestration you'd do in a "regular cloud."
- JanMa 4y agoBoth actually. How did they do it physically and what did they run on the phones? I found it especially interesting that 20% of the devices had to act as master or networking nodes
- BizarroLand 4y agoI would guess that it would be an app that uses wireless networking. Probably slow as molasses compared to a blade server but also probably pretty powerful since it has so many compute nodes.
- elvis10ten 4y agoSomething similar (in terms of using idle smartphone time) that I worked on in past is running automated tests on a distributed network of mobile devices. Stopped working on it but the code is open source and I wrote about it a while ago: https://elvischidera.com/2020-11-23-building-distributed-android-remote-testing-platform/ https://elvischidera.com/2020-11-23-building-distributed-and...
- anderspitman 4y agoThe use case I'm most excited about for old phones is selfhosting. There's no reason things like a Plex server can't just be an app on your phone. Plug in a USB hard drive, go through a quick OAuth flow to open a tunnel with a service like Cloudflare Tunnel or ngrok and you're set.
- brightfuturism 4y agoI would like to combine forces with a project I’ve designed utilizing and repurposing phones as a documentary tool.
- RobotToaster 4y agoI've wondered about using an old smartphone as an SMS server, seems like it would be ideal.
- zoom6628 4y agoAny suggestions on what approach to take. Rooting and jail breaking seems over the top to serve compute power. Anybody got say an AIDE built app or similar that works from Android 4 or something similar for iOS? I have a shoebox of old phones and tablets waiting for a project like this. I just don’t know where to start.
- chlorion 4y agoMy ~$200 Moto G has 8 arm cores, 4G ram and 64G EMMC storage. That is actually significantly more powerful than the VPS I pay monthly for, and could easily host git repos, a website, irc bouncer, and much more, and the hardware is already payed for! I see people complain about silly things using trivial amounts of electricity killing the planet (like Gentoo & building software from source) meanwhile there are huge targets like this that consume unimaginable amounts of power and resources and a lot of waste to go with it.
- fireant 4y agoI really wonder if total cost of ownership/energy required to run a cluster of old android phones would actually be lower than one or two servers. The phones are ARM, will have battery issues (esp if they run 24/7) so you need to provision for safety, can only be connected over wifi, have thermal issues (they are meant for burst, not sustained load), have non-homogeneous bootloaders/bugs and so on
- chlorion 4y agoYeah these are all very valid issues! I imagine it would depend on the specific use case and how much computing power you need. Also the energy going into the production of the phone should be considered as well. Being able to remove the battery and run from AC would be very helpful I think. Phones used to be able to do this but a lot of modern ones don't have removable batteries which is a problem of it's own. My VPS use is actually fairly bursty though. It spends 99% of the time asleep since I don't do much with it. Even a small website/webserver or hosting cgit and git over ssh would be very light and almost entirely burst loads for me!
- ge96 4y agoI like this idea. I've kept all my old phones. Part of it is for nostalgia. But yeah be nice to plug them in and use them even if it's not efficient.
- acd 4y agoWe shall demand legislation with enforces that phones and other devices can be used like normal computers. Ie demand open boot loaders, open specs so that open source software can run well on phone devices. If we can run open source software the length the devices lifetime last will be greatly extended. This will minimize electronic waste and e-waste pollution. Its essential that all electronic devices can run open source software. That boot loaders and access to devices are not monopolized or crippled by device vendors. Vendors have one main interest to is to sell new devices to consumers and maximize profit. Consumers and the government have different intrest in that devices last longer so we minimize the impact on the environment.
- anonuser123456 4y agoNo thanks. I’m happy with my iPhone as is.
- dehrmann 4y agoDidn't Apple just release an patch that covered the 5S? The phone's 9 years old, now. An open bootloader is a different story, but so far, Apple's delivered on long-term support.
- franga2000 4y agoThat's a great to hear, but unfortunately nobody else is doing it and Apple does so many other bad things to more than make up for that from an environmental pov.
- Farbklex 4y agoAnd you can continue using it as is. But let the rest of us have full access to the hardware to extend its capabilities and lifetime.
- franga2000 4y agoDevice reusability is an environmental issue, so your happiness is utterly irrelevant here. Making devices (or their parts) easy to keep using or repurpose means fewer need to be created and fewer end up in the landfill.
- JamesAdir 4y agoMany great ideas both in the paper and in the comments, but people forget that we don't own our devices any more, we just rent them. If we owned them we could have replaced the batteries ourselves, or change the bootloads or do anything we want. Contrary to what happened with TVs, were models are being sold at a lower pricce with the help of spyware installed on the TV, some phones are sold at full price and still we don't own them.
- dehrmann 4y agoI'm skeptical. At a small scale, you could put together a cluster, but other than for the fun of putting it together, I don't see the point. I'd rather have a older Xeon with a high core count and use VMs or processes because it's more reliable and easier to manage. Or rent a cluster in the cloud for an hour. For large scale, dealing with heterogeneous hardware with questionable life remaining strapped to batteries that might start fires connected over USB or Wifi isn't ideal. Not to mention installing cluster software on all of them. At scale, you'd really want to strip the CPUs and mount lots of them on a single board, but that's not cheap to do. You're also dealing with 3+ year old technology that's been replaced by something more power-efficient.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoIn the hands of kids, old smart phones are not obsolete so long as they can play games: https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/2470654.2481379 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/2470654.2481379
- noisy_boy 4y agoMy old android phones are repurposed as web camera and single purpose devices (e.g. the local sports complex expects that everyone, including kids, has their smartphone (obviously), so I just installed their stupid app on the old phones for this; they stay turned off otherwise).
- jmnicolas 4y agoWhat about security? I didn't see it mentioned in the paper. Most of the "junkyard phones" are way out of support, who's going to build anything serious with this? It's a security disaster waiting to happen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pontifier 4y agoThe National Upcycled Computing Collective (https://www.nuccinc.org/ https://www.nuccinc.org/) is a group dedicated to this concept. They are doing some very interesting work along these lines.
- everdrive 4y agosmartphones are terrible. I might just try to get lodged into some good-enough well paying company for the rest of my life, and go back to dumb phones. Any given new tech company might expect you to have a smart phone for MDM or multiple authenticator apps. Asking for alternatives during the interview is not really popular. If it weren't for jobs, I wouldn't have a smart phone at all.
- guru4consulting 4y agoI'm surprised no one mentioned about Google's Project Ara. A modular smartphone with reusable components that can be plugged/replaced as needed. I was really excited to see a big company like Google committing to such a green project, but unfortunately it was discontinued for unknown reasons. I think all electronic items (and electrical and mechanical items which are increasingly electronic) should be regulated by gov such that they are designed and built to be modular, composable, repairable, parts-replaceable.. that will be a huge win for environment