8 ms·
I would never want my friends to know how much I make, only 3 of my closest family members know that. It's a terrible idea. Couldn't care less of strangers, bu
by epolanski 4y ago
I would never want my friends to know how much I make, only 3 of my closest family members know that.
It's a terrible idea. Couldn't care less of strangers, but irl people are envious, toxic and potentially dangerous.
- dom96 4y agoIt's not just irl people. In fact, strangers can be even more potentially dangerous. That's what would stop me from sharing my salary openly. Actually thinking about it more I wouldn't be worried about friends/family knowing at all.
- serial_dev 4y agoWhy do you think strangers would be dangerous? I thought about sharing this info, too.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoEveryone knows doctors in the US earn a few hundred thousand per year, since I was a kid. They seem to be surviving just fine. I don’t think anyone’s pay is very secret anyway. Based on employer, house location, cost of house, job title, it is pretty deducible to the ranges that indicate quality of life and potential savings.
- gambiting 4y agoI literally don't see why. All my friends and family know what I make(and I know what they make) - what's the big deal?
- mock-possum 4y agosome people have shitty friends and family that's really the only reason why. I'll usually check in with people if they're comfortable with talking about money, but otherwise I've never had trouble with anyone knowing how much (or how little) I make. I kind of see it as a trap, I guess - if knowing how much I make prejudices you against me, than I'd rather you show yourself for who you are sooner, so I can keep you at an appropriate distance. I've got no time for people like that.
- epolanski 4y agoDid you know that 90%+ of house robberies and stealing happens by acquittances? It's people that know you that rob and steal, not randoms. I make much more than my friends. That stirs envy, jealousy, people asking for money and poses a danger to me and my family. I don't want someone to come rob me in the night because a long tongued friend told other. There's literally not one good reason to tell others you make good money. It brings NOTHING good.
- philosopher1234 4y agoenvy is a big deal. some people manage it better than others, but it exists in and affects all relationships. sometimes its best avoided.
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's also not always even envy. There's a whole range of possible reactions. It can be just as bad if people discover you earn less than them.
- pojzon 4y agoIf you earn really a lot, ppl who may want to hurt you or ypur family might pop up. Ransome, asking for money etc. Nobody care if you make 50k but if you make 500k suddenly things change.
- khazhoux 4y agoIt's sad that you are being downvoted, because I think you may be shedding light on an experience that comfortable Americans can't relate to, where landing into a pile of money is not just "awkward" for your friend/family relationships, but can become a serious problem when people in your circle feel entitled to a cut.
- epolanski 4y agoI'm Italian and that's the same. It's just never a good idea to tell people you make good money. I don't buy expensive things, i don't show off. I quietly invest and will retire asap and enjoy a quiet relaxed life. I don't want a target on my back or people asking me money or treating me differently.
- netsharc 4y agoBeing asked for money is awkward and uncomfortable and real, but are the risks of hurting/kidnapping for ransom very realistic in the real world? Yes they are non-zero, but so is the chance of a plane crashing into your residence...
- mawise 4y agoMaking a Bay Area tech salary is making a lot of money compared to people who don't--kind of like winning the lottery. Here's a fun(?) read about how winning the lottery is really bad for you, mostly because public information that you have a lot of money leads to other people trying to get your money and making your life miserable: https://www.ar15.com/forums/general/-/5-1485089/?page=1#i40486827 https://www.ar15.com/forums/general/-/5-1485089/?page=1#i404...
- Gigachad 4y agoThe problem with the lottery stories is the winnings are most likely to go to someone who doesn't know how to manage it and likely has friends and family who aren't the highest quality either. If you actually earned that amount you are much more likely to properly handle your finances.
- mawise 4y agoThe prime example in the post is someone who already had $15 million.
- IshKebab 4y agoYou really can't see how people could resent you for making so much money? Look at how much people resent MPs for making £85k, which is a totally reasonable salary. Probably too low actually.
- khazhoux 4y agoLucky you that you're haven't had problems. My own experience: non-tech midwest family got weird and treats me differently just suspecting I have silicon-valley-money (and they don't even know the actual extent of it).
- thwayunion 4y agoBut they're going to anyways. A non-tech midwest friend who drives truck treated me differently on that same suspicion. We basically fell out over it. The kicker: he was unionized; I found out years later he wasn't making that much less than me (and was making quite a bit more after adjusting for cost of living)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 4y agoPeople get really weird about money. Sometimes it sets a social pecking order. Sometimes it has a large effect on their opinion of you. If they discover there's a large differential with you either way, it can make life unpleasant.
- pwinnski 4y agoSimilarly, I think it's usually a good idea to share this information with coworkers, as ignorance only benefits the employer in negotiations. But friends? That's different. My coworkers are all in roughly the same socio-economic bracket, give or take, but I have friends and family who very much are not, and there's no need to ruffle feathers, no upside at all. If you're young and nerdy and making not too much more than the average American household, it's probably fine! Once you're quite a bit more than six years out of school and making multiple times the average family, it's a bit more dicey.
- Linton1177 4y ago[dead]
- kerpotgh 4y agoNot if you’re making more than others in your role.
- khazhoux 4y agoRight. Unless you and your co-worker are at the same level and making the exact same, or you're making different amounts but aligned with your difference in levels, or unless you and your co-worker are both 100%-envy-free people... exactly one of you is going to be pissed off!
- pwinnski 4y agoWhich is a problem for the company choosing to pay us different amounts, right? Keeping employees in the dark is what companies want, so they can underpay as often as possible.
- thunky 4y agoProbably true. But would you be ok taking a pay cut in order for you and your equivalent peers to make the exact same amount? Cuts both ways.
- secondcoming 4y agoYup, nobody discusses their salary. I made the mistake of complaining about giving 50% of a bonus to the taxman and now people think I'm rich. I'm far from it.
- Volundr 4y agoAren't you? What's the threshold for rich? Top 20%? 10%? 5%? You might be closer than you think. Rich does not necessary mean independently wealthy.
- JohnFen 4y agoVery few of the wealthy people I've known have considered themselves rich.
- notinfuriated 4y agoDownvotes on this comment are evidence of the toxic envious nature of people. Prove me wrong.
- deanCommie 4y ago> my friends ... irl people are envious, toxic and potentially dangerous. bro, i don't want to tell you how to live your life, but if you are describing people as envious, toxic, and potentially dangerous than either these are not your friends, or you have a horribly low opinion of people. We don't have evidence if the problem is you or them, but I would say a fundamental baseline expectation from a "friend" is that they should be HAPPY not envious of your successes.
- epolanski 4y agoI don't know, maybe it's an American thing, but here in Europe we boast much less about our success. It's considered rude. Anyway, boasting of financial success is something I find sad, unnecessary and potentially dangerous. Tomorrow some friend of a friend junkie may need money and may think I'm collecting rolexes or idk. Better people don't know shit.
- wruza 4y agoA friend of a friend of a friend may seek some easy money (“six handshake rule”). Friends talk about friends. Guarding your family from various criminal activities may be hard. This all may add up not in your favor eventually.
- notinfuriated 4y agoI still remember when a company I worked for had a spreadsheet where people were anonymously sharing their salary information along w/ title, demography, notes, etc. Most of the people who posted their info with some self-perception that their salary was "low" for the role added notes to the spreadsheet suggesting they think it's "low" because of racism or sexism. To you, that might be good, positive, and normal. IMO it was toxic and fueled by envy with no actual information to support their position (and, admittedly, no information to deny it either). They only wanted my salary information to help progress their position in life, which to me is not so different from Google or Facebook wanting such private information for their own monetary gain.
- khazhoux 4y ago> bro, i don't want to tell you how to live your life, but if you are describing people as envious, toxic, and potentially dangerous than either these are not your friends, or you have a horribly low opinion of people. I found this interview eye-opening of how serious (and dangerous) money can be, when the people around you don't have any: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKutkXy1Eeo&t=1178s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKutkXy1Eeo&t=1178s Even when it's not a situation of danger, though, money can still drive a wedge. The friends you made growing up, you were then equals (and neither of you had anything). Your financial success can become a mirror into their financial struggles, and not everyone does ok in that situation.
- bradleyjg 4y agoAre all these people in danger? https://www.seethroughny.net/payrolls/ https://www.seethroughny.net/payrolls/
- dannyphantom 4y agoI wish I never even told my family about anything. Before I finally made the decision to just not talk to my parents anymore my dad would constantly shame and belittle me about what my earnings were; he's at a partner level in finance and is under the impression that my lack of income - while still being in college - is representative of his 'failure to raise me correctly', as...unhinged as that sounds. I don't have any other family because my parents have basically had this attitude for the last 20 years and their siblings understandably do not like to be anywhere near them - as a byproduct I've never met my extended family.
- vernon99 4y agoNever too late, by the way. It could be a lot of fun to travel around and meet your relatives. Or not :) But only way to find out.
- kenjackson 4y agoI wouldn't describe people as envious, toxic, etc... but even well meaning people who know how much you make can create issues that you simply would prefer not to have. For example, if you make a lot people may expect you to pay for dinner more, or worry less about inconveniencing you financially. Not in a mean malicious way, but in a "Tommy's not gonna sweat this $20". Or the opposite, they may question why you have that new car, when your finances don't really justify it. They may be looking out for you, but really that decision should be yours and your spouse. I'm not sure what upside there is to letting anyone know.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bradlys 4y agolol - this seems like a great way to keep a class divide. “I can’t let the poors know I make so much. They might try to take my money!” Way to not work on class unity. I’ve told my friends, family, peers, and anyone else how much I made all the way from delivering newspapers for criminally low wages, to doing random IT work in my local town of 4,000 people as a high schooler, to working as a cashier at a department store making minimum wage, and all the way up to my 7 figure TCs. You know why? I want people to know what’s possible and what’s available out there. I want them to advocate for more money. When I tell them what I make - they think, “fuck, I should ask for more. You’re right!” They become more incentivized to advocate for unity among the working class as well because they realize without good bargaining - they will lose out. Terrible idea for everyone. If people get jealous - tell them how you made it happen. If it was luck - fucking acknowledge it. If it was back breaking work - acknowledge it too. Acknowledge all the parts good and bad that got you to where you are. That’s what I do and everyone has no substantial resentment at the end. Btw - I work as a typical engineer in SV. Nothing special.
- epolanski 4y agoPeople treat you differently, generally worse when they know you make many times what they do. It's also dangerous and unnecessary and comes as posturing. I live a modest life and no one has to know how much I make. It's a terrible idea to share it, if you want that's your business.
- JohnFen 4y agoYeah, I won't share mine with anyone unless there's a need for them to know. It's literally nobody's business. But "need" isn't a terribly high bar. For instance, I recently shared that information with my best friend, in an attempt to get him to come work where I work.