5 ms·
I can tell that this was written by an outsider, because it focuses on the perks and rehashes several cliches that have made their way into the popular media bu
by nostrademons 15y ago
I can tell that this was written by an outsider, because it focuses on the perks and rehashes several cliches that have made their way into the popular media but aren't all that accurate.
Most Googlers will tell you that the best thing about working there is having the ability to work on really hard problems, with really smart coworkers, and lots of resources at your disposal. I remember asking my interviewer whether I could use things like Google's index if I had a cool 20% idea, and he was like "Sure. That's encouraged. Oftentimes I'll just grab 4000 or so machines and run a MapReduce to test out some hypothesis." My phone screener, when I asked him what it was like to work there, said "It's a place where really smart people go to be average," which has turned out to be both true and honestly one of the best things that I've gained from working there.
A lot of the observations in the article fall out of this, but in ways that are less sound-bitey. Google doesn't enforce set working hours - you can get in as late as you want (the latest I've been in is around 4:15 PM, but that was because I had a DMV appointment, the latest from just not waking up was about 2:00), stay as late as you want (my latest was about 1:00 AM, though I worked from home until 6:00 AM last Thursday), duck out during the day if you're meeting a friend or have a date or need to pick a sick kid up from school, or work from home as necessary. You also don't have a set workload: you do as much work as you think is appropriate and then go home.
The thing is - you are surrounded by incredibly intelligent & fiercely hard-working people. Many of them were used to being top-dog at whatever institution they came from before - hell, many were top dog (we have a lot of ex-startup-founders; there's a good chance that you're working with someone that's founded a company or originated a successful open-source project). And that can be a big adjustment, and the types of folks that Google typically hire usually react to not being on top by working harder. It's up to you to set limits on the amount of time you're willing to spend working, and most new hires at Google are used to being limited by "the amount of work my boss/professor/thesis advisor throws at me", not by the number of hours in the day.
- sliverstorm 15y agoI don't work at Google, but I must say that being surrounded by incredibly intelligent & fiercely hard-working people is awesome- among other things, I always have something to aspire to, and somewhere to grow.
- noduerme 15y agoSounds brilliant. It definitely makes me wish I could go be among geniuses for a day. Went to Mirman, though; so I know what it means to be dull among geniuses while you're being probed, overworked and experimented-upon. I especially know what it feels like to have your own sense of obligation turned against you in the service of your employer. Just-under-geniuses -- and this is my observation only, as a guy who didn't make the cut to go to college when I was 12 -- have a desperate desire to prove their ability to whoever's in control. The closer you were to sparkling algebraic brilliance, or getting on Jeopardy at age-eleven, the harder it is. It can wreck your home life and your family. The desire to prove your intelligence to your surrogate father figure is a sickness. When you can run any kind of startup you want, and live wherever in the world you want while you're doing it, why's it better to be in an office that lets you come and go, and is filled with geniuses, but still looks and feels somehow like a preschool for kids with Asperger's?
- nostrademons 15y agoYour post is grey right now, which I think means it's in the negative points, and I don't think it should be. Anyway, you've touched on something I've been thinking about a fair bit lately, though perhaps bystanders shouldn't take this post terribly seriously. Just idle musings... I was talking with a friend last night, when I found out she got the exact same score I did on the SATs: 1590. She is younger than me, working menial jobs in the immediate post-college funk, and went to a no-name liberal arts college instead of even applying for big names like MIT or CMU. And it occurred to me that I know 3 broad user-populations among my friends: 1570s, 1590s, and 1600s (yes, I categorize my friends by SAT score and have a sample size of at 3-4 in each; I told you not to take this post too seriously). The 1600s are grinds, but smart grinds. Think of Hermione Granger from Harry Potter. Google is absolutely loaded with these people - on my team alone are two people who graduated college at age 20 and numerous Stanford/UIUC Ph.Ds, and I've worked with IMO gold medalists, etc. My friend's boyfriend (also a Googler) scored a 1600 on his SATs. The 1570s usually end up being reasonably happy in high-level professional jobs. They get a nice six-figure income, and then they concentrate on other things like their family. And they don't worry about it too much; they're doing just fine. It's the 1590s that end up being crazily insecure. I know several of them, besides myself and her. And while the more well-adjusted of us hide it pretty well, it seems like there's always this desire to prove ourselves, which seems to come out in the form of occasionally odd behavior and attempts to push the envelope. My friend is always asking me why she's crazy - she's not really crazy, she just tends to make decisions that have an odd form of internal logic that makes sense to her but are probably not what other people would've done. Sometimes they work out, and people herald her as a genius (which isn't really helping); other times they don't, and they despise her as a crazy bitch. The most famous 1590 was Bill Gates, and you can definitely see this pattern in his business decisions. Not all of us have wealthy, socially-connected parents and lots of money to fall back on. You're right that this sort of behavior is a sickness, of sorts. And the cure is to realize that it just doesn't matter all that much. Whether you got a 1600 or a 1590 or a 1570, what matters is the people around you and the task at hand. And being smart can help you with those tasks and make it so that other smart people want to be around you, but it doesn't define you. It's a number that one test assigned to you back in your formative years. As for why Google instead of a startup - it is much easier to realize that these issues don't matter when everybody around you has them too. It's like they fade into the background. Everybody has their 1600 SAT or Ivy League degree or IMO gold medal or past startup or open-source project, and so you can't measure yourself by your accomplishments. And so, if you're smart, you start measuring yourself by whether you're pleasant to be around, or whether you make the lives of the people around you easier, or whether you can understand & make users happy. Eventually this becomes a habit, and - I'm hoping - that can be taken to experiences throughout the rest of your life. I speak from experience when I say that startups - unless you really luck out and find the right startup - generally don't offer this. It's far easier to lose yourself in the desire to prove yourself when the rest of the world doesn't give a damn about you.
- palish 15y agoHey Nos. I hope you've been well! Is there any way you could give your first-reaction answer for "what is the worst thing about working at Google?"
- nostrademons 15y agoHey, it has been a while. My first reaction would probably be "communication overhead". It is a big company, and while we try very hard to work like a startup, it usually means that you have to interact with a lot of teams to get anything substantive done. The great thing is that you get to interact with a lot of very smart people; the hard thing is that you have to interact with a lot of very smart people to get anything done. I had a back-and-forth with another (ex?) Googler yesterday about this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3466439 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3466439
- tytso 15y agoOh, you haven't seen "big company" yet, if you think Google is a big company.... I came from IBM which has something like 350,000 people working world-wide. I came to Google and said, "how refreshing!" VA Linux Systems was too small (and taught me an awful lot about how not to run a startup). IBM was too large (and awfully bureaucratic). Google for me is a very nice mid-sized company.
- michaelochurch 15y agoIs there any way you could give your first-reaction answer for "what is the worst thing about working at Google?" If you care a lot about programming languages, you're going to be frustrated. Python: deprecated in production. That leaves Java and C++, which are le suck. Go is genuinely decent but none of the legacy projects (what you'll be tasked on in your first 18 months) are in it. If you don't care about PL quality or actually like reading thousands-of-lines-long legacy C++ modules (some people do, and it's great for the world that "Sherlock Holmes" types exist). Google has a lot of pluses, too, and if you get put on a good project it's pretty neat. Plus, the food is awesome (better than what most restaurants serve).
- mjwalshe 15y agoAlso the article smells like a spun article for SEO
- resnamen 15y agoI agree. HN often seems to fall prey to these linkbaity articles about trendy subjects. As users, we do a poor job of filtering for quality before we click the upvote button.
- mindcrime 15y agoPart of the problem is that "save" and "upvote" are the same thing. I am an obsessive bookmarker, so I "upvote" stuff all the time, without reading the article, just because the title strikes me as sufficient to into "Hmmm, look at this later" territory. If there were a "save" feature (ala Reddit) that was separate from upvoting, I think that would help. Or maybe I'm the only one who does that and it wouldn't matter a bit. :-)
- jacktoole1 15y agoFor articles like this, I find it more interesting to go to the comments. Sometimes I'll read the article first, sometimes I'll start with the comments and read the article if they are interesting enough. But I'm more interested in what the HN community thinks about a post than the standalone post. I get to see the amount of people who read this sort of news who agree with the post, and the people who disagree. I feel I can make a more informed decision about the content from reading several comments than reading just one opinion.
- cunac 15y agoI don't see how smart it is to work 10-12 hour days and for sure you are underpaid. Think a bit , you work 3000 hours a year as opposing to 1800-2000 , which turns your 250K/year salary to 160K and you don't have life. Sure it works for single under 30 kids , but how that would fit in 40+ group with regular family ? Don't get me wrong I was working in startups (and I was over 40 at the time with regular family) insane times (100+ hr weeks) but just for year stretch ant that barley makes sense because of gold rush to the pushing product out of door. Otherwise I prefer "work smarter not harder" way and seems google has "if you work hard it will seem smart"
- nostrademons 15y agoI don't think I work 3000 hours a year, or if I do, it's probably time I would've otherwise spent surfing Reddit or Hacker News. Not all hours are created equal. In past jobs where I've worked set hours (whether 9-5 or 10:30-6:30 or whatever), I've found I spent half the workday surfing the Internet and then didn't have time for a life anyway because of the commute and set schedule. I value being able to duck out of work for 2-3 hours mid-afternoon because a friend of mine who I haven't seen in 7 years is passing through on her way from Marin to San Diego. I value it a whole lot more than the actual 2-3 hours of work time that I'll presumably be making up later. I'll happily work 2-3 more hours in the evening if it means I can go out for dinner & a movie with my friends at the normal time and still sleep in until noon. I don't have kids, but my teammates that do take similar advantage of this. If their kid is sick, they'll work from home instead of needing to scramble to find childcare. If their kid pukes all over their teacher in day care, they can duck out in the middle of the afternoon to pick him up. If their kid has a school play in the morning, they can come in late, no problem. You're responsible for your work product. If you feel you need to spend extra hours to achieve it, then do that. If you feel you can do it by working smarter (which is absolutely possible and encouraged with some problems, and not really possible with others), do that.
- dholowiski 15y ago"Oftentimes I'll just grab 4000 or so machines and run a MapReduce to test out some hypothesis" Fuck the food. Who cares about hammocks. Isn't this most geek's wet dream?
- gnosis 15y agoOnly if they're hypothesis on something I care about, and not about how I can get people to click more ads or make more money for some trendy corporation.
- dholowiski 15y agoThat's the point... "to test out some hypothesis" - this is something you can do just for fun if you work at Google.
- adgar 15y agoDon't feed the trolls.
- jrockway 15y agognosis' arguments seem worth refuting. I can see how someone outside of Google would assume that using 4000 machines to scan the Internet on some whim would be a big deal. But at Google, it's not. That's why working at Google is so cool.
- adgar 15y agoI'm saying somebody who blithely asserts that Google is just "about how I can get people to click more ads or make more money for some trendy corporation" is a troll and not a comment worth responding to.
- acqq 15y agoScott Adams nailed it: http://www.dilbert.com/2011-12-19/ http://www.dilbert.com/2011-12-19/
- gnosis 15y ago"The thing is - you are surrounded by incredibly intelligent & fiercely hard-working people." Good that they're intelligent. Fiercely hard working -- not so good. I don't want to be surrounded by workaholics, no matter how intelligent they are.
- andrewflnr 15y agoHard-working is not the same as workaholic. A hard-working person might be a workaholic, or they might just care about accomplishing stuff.
- gnosis 15y agoThe OP didn't say "hard-working". He said "fiercely hard-working". Anyway, I'd still call even someone merely described as "hard-working" a workaholic -- meaning that they are probably working an excessive number of hours, and have an unbalanced life/work ratio. The amount of hours Americans work compared to much of the rest of the world is already insane. It's quite typical for employees to be expected to work more than 40 hour weeks -- 50 or 60 hours is much more the norm. So when someone's called "hard-working" that means that they're probably putting in even more hours than that. I don't even want to imagine the hours a "fiercely hard-working" Google employee puts in to compete with other brilliant employees who've all just gone from being exceptional at former jobs to "just average" at Google. And don't even get me started on the startup rat race. I'd take a cushy, "boring" job where I can work a sane number of hours without needing to impress anyone over an "exciting", high-pressure job at some trendy corporation any day. I can find plenty of challenge and fulfillment outside of work, thank you very much. My life outside work means a lot more to me than any trinkets they can dangle in front of me at work, even if it is 4000 servers I can run map/reduce on at whim. As for "accomplishing stuff", any company where you have to put in more than 40 hours a week to accomplish what you need is dysfunctional.
- jrockway 15y agoThis is not what Google is like. Google is a normal workplace but with smart people who care, and with all of your needs taken care of. Need a USB cable or a new laptop battery? Grab one out of the storage closet. Need a coffee? You're never more than 100ft away from an automatic coffee maker, premade iced coffee, and a $10,000 espresso machine (and burr grinder, of course). Need a new monitor? Open a ticket and it will be on your desk in hours. Need an adjustment made to your desk? Open a ticket and someone will do it for you today. When I worked at Bank of America, I spent about 6 hours a day dealing with bullshit and 4 hours a day working. At Google, there is no bullshit. I show up and can work for 8 hours. That makes me twice as productive even though I'm actually working less. (And, with all the great internal libraries and software... well, it was depressing for me to realize how little "infrastructure" software I would need to write.) I get the impression from outsiders that they hear a lot about how great Google is and then assume that they can't work at Google, so they then decide that what Google does is actually bad. The flaw is thinking that you can't work at Google. You can! Apply, brush up on your algorithms a bit, and start enjoying the amazing coffee!
- cageface 15y agoThe thing is, thanks to the net and open source, I can "surround" myself professionally with very smart people from the comfort of my home office. Of course it's not the same but it's close enough that other concerns dominate. At 25 I would have jumped at the chance to work at a place like Google but at 41 it just doesn't appeal to me.
- eternalban 15y agoThere are some "really hard problems" that could definitely use the brain power assembled but apparently are never pursued. Are there effectively (company) political red lines at Google Inc. that preclude pursuit of solution to problems such as distributed, non-centralized, social networking, or, somehow the engineers unconsciously choose to [only] pursue solutions that fit with the corporations business model?
- nl 15y agoThere are some "really hard problems" that could definitely use the brain power assembled but apparently are never pursued. Like self-driving cars I guess. Are there effectively (company) political red lines at Google Inc. that preclude pursuit of solution to problems such as distributed, non-centralized, social networking, or, somehow the engineers unconsciously choose to [only] pursue solutions that fit with the corporations business model? Google had at least 3 goes at building decentralized social networking[1][2][3]. As an external observer the one time I've seen behaviour that could have been characterized as avoiding pursuing a solution because of Google's business model is that Chrome has decided not to implement the "Do not track" solution that Firefox has implemented[4]. Google does have some reasonable technical arguments on their side (arguments that are best made by Apple, which doesn't really have a lot of skin in the tracking game[5]). Still, if you want to look for political interference that's where I'd look, instead of expecting yet another tilting-at-windmill quest to build an decentralized social network. [1] http://www.waveprotocol.org/ http://www.waveprotocol.org/ [2] http://code.google.com/p/pubsubhubbub/ http://code.google.com/p/pubsubhubbub/ [3] http://code.google.com/apis/opensocial/ http://code.google.com/apis/opensocial/ (Ok, OpenSocial isn't decentralized. But it does allow application portability between social networks which certainly has the effect of decentralizing power) [4] http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2011/04/chrome-do-not-track/all/1 http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2011/04/chrome-do-not-track/a... [5] http://www.w3.org/2011/track-privacy/papers/Apple.pdf http://www.w3.org/2011/track-privacy/papers/Apple.pdf
- bane 15y ago"You also don't have a set workload: you do as much work as you think is appropriate and then go home." Looking at both sides of this: the common complaint in most traditional companies is being under the thumb of the beancounters, and work being shipped incomplete, or buggy, etc. Or people working insane hours to make things happen. It's a wish then for many in technology to eliminate this problem. At Google it appears this has happened. However, it seems to have introduced an entirely new problem...with no communication with end users, and no real deadlines, google's user facing software is often lacking obvious features that don't get worked on for ages...and forums full of users complaining without much of an acknowledgement or response from Google. The lack of focus and community interaction on certain Google products is at times bizarre. It's an interesting note that you're damned if you do or damned if you don't. But it's very interesting to see both sides of this.
- kamaal 15y ago"It's a place where really smart people go to be average," That really might be OK and might work if you are unmarried, without kids and living alone. As you grow up to take more responsibilities. It definitely makes more career and financial sense to.. Be best among the average than to be average among the best.
- m0th87 15y agoWhy? It's not as if you risk job stability working at Google. And at least while I was there, I didn't get the impression that devs were overworked (slightly different story for PMs).
- jrockway 15y agoIt's makes financial sense to get someone to pay you your market value. Google knows how to give people good raises without them having to float themselves on the open market and threaten to leave. The process is transparent and well-documented. Speaking from experience, Google's offer was lower than what I had in mind. But I couldn't find anyone else that would pay me more. That means I'm probably making the right amount of money. And the good news is, I know what I need to do to ensure that I get good raises. That's something that's never been clear to me at any other company; it was all "you did really well this year! thanks!" and then "oh sorry, no money for raises or bonuses". Google does not do that. It's the first place I've worked where I've thought, "wow, I won't have to quit in two years". Also, you're not competing against other people, so being average is fine. To get promoted, you have to be good at your job and continually do good work. That's it. You don't have to be Guido to get promoted.
- kamaal 15y agoFirstly I'm from India, our salary structure differs from you in many ways. Nice perspective. I definitely agree that Google is probably paying best among all. My point was, If I can be the best guy in a team of average everyday software engineers. It makes my appraisals, appreciations and growth far more easy. At the same time if I'm average despite my best efforts and then it makes things a little difficult for me. One more question to you. Unless there is a next 'Google' aren't you worried that you are already in the highest paying company(Forgive my ignorance If Im wrong, or there are companies are that pay more than Google in the US) and moving onto something else may not get you a better hike than what you have now?
- gcp 15y ago"Most Googlers will tell you.." "I remember asking my interviewer" "My phone screener, when I asked him..." Your examples are all things that were promised during the hiring process, not your own experience. This raises a red flag for me.
- pyre 15y agoMaybe none of the stuff that he/she does sounds as cool as just grabbing a couple thousand machines to run some MapReduce... just for kicks. I doubt that everyone at Google is always running interesting-sounding side projects.
- nostrademons 15y agoFWIW, I regularly grab a couple thousand machines to run some MapReduce over all of Google's copy of the web. This is not a one-off occurrence, it is (for me, someone whose "official" job duties usually focus on UI) a roughly once-a-month occurrence. It can be as much as several times a day for people whose daily job is crunching data. I also work on a team where I am the only one without an advanced degree, and all but two of the others' have Ph.Ds. Two of my teammates graduated college at 20. Many of them have published. And I get to push cool things out to the results page with fairly little bureaucracy. Sometimes I even get to do it in response to HN users' comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3364339 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3364339 The thing is, if I'd just said "I get to do this, and I get to do that", this comment would've read "Yes, but I doubt you're a typical Googler. I doubt that everyone at Google is always running interesting-sounding side projects." Damned if you do, damned if you don't. (Truth be told, not everyone at Google is running interesting-sounding side projects. The point is that everyone at Google has the ability to run interesting-sounding side projects. Whether you make the time to do it is up to you.)