8 ms·
As much as I sympathize, the title is clickbait and I'm not entirely sure what the point of the article is. From what I can gather, the $145K cost was the cost
by crazygringo 4y ago
As much as I sympathize, the title is clickbait and I'm not entirely sure what the point of the article is.
From what I can gather, the $145K cost was the cost of medical care over the months (years? the article never says) at the end of the grandmother's life -- not the cost of "dying at home".
The bulk of the cost seems to come from:
> the total monthly cost was $16,200: $13,000 a month for the 24-hour care, plus $3,200 to rent the apartment
It seems silly to include rent, and then of course round-the-clock private care is going to be $$$.
As far as I can tell, the grandmother needed hospital-level care, but the family didn't want to keep her in a hospital. It's not surprising that hospital-level care at home costs a small fortune.
- bthrn 4y agoThe claim is that this $16,200 monthly cost was cheaper than the alternative. So it's not entirely silly to include rent in this figure.
- bunbunbun 4y agoLong term care facilities are 5-10k USD per month. For the cheap ones. So $16k seems reasonable for in home care. There are also different intangible personal and family costs to facility-based or home-based care that folks should also consider.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoHowever, there's a lot of options that are even cheaper.
- TheHypnotist 4y agoWhich is nothing compared to hospital level care at the hospital.
- ejb999 4y agothats how I read it to - the family didn't want the burden of doing the care, and also don't think anyone should have to pay for it - who are these magical fairies that are going to show up in your final days and take care of you for free? If the deceased person owed the medical bills - well guess what? she is dead and won't have to pay them unless the creditors go after her estate - if the family's complaint that now their inheritance is going to be less than they thought - too bad.
- ryandrake 4y agoThis is a pretty uncharitable read of it. Assume good intentions and think about it from the grandparent's point of view: "I saved my whole life, and wanted to make sure I could give a little back to my loving family, but instead the healthcare industry soaked it all up during my final months." In civilized countries, somebody else would pay for it. Not through magical fairies, but through taxpayer-funded public healthcare. Instead, in the USA, we're Rugged Individuals™ so we prefer to have a gigantic profitable End Of Life Industry precisely designed to sponge up whatever remains of an elderly person's savings. If you have $500K in assets left, your end of life care will cost $500K. If you have $100K left, your care will cost $100K. If you have $10K left, it will cost $10K. The solution, in our flawed system, is to do smart estate planning so you die with zero assets. I don't need my parents' money when they go, and I've already told them if they want to help out my sibling or give it to charity, either do it before they die or get it in a structure that can't be confiscated by death profiteers. Either way, have $0 to your name when you finally pass away. Don't give these vultures another gold-lined toilet for their executive suite.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago"In civilized countries, somebody else would pay for it." Somebody else paying doesn't make the cost go away. Would it be better to make their children or grandchildren pay? Would they be better off if they payed 150k in taxes and had no inheritance because of that?
- ejb999 4y agoI don't think it is uncharitable at all. "I saved my whole life, and wanted to make sure I could give a little back to my loving family, but instead the healthcare industry soaked it all up during my final months." An awful lot of people in this country will never get an inheritance; why is it fair to ask them to pay higher taxes so that the most privileged people can leave bigger inheritances to their kids? I have no problem with people leaving money to their kids - after they pay their own bills. Don't ask me to pay them so your kids can get a bigger windfall.
- AllegedAlec 4y ago
- kickout 4y agoPossibly a little clickbaity, but it was a first hand experience from the author. There are likely thousands of examples of this exact scenario playing out every year: $old_family_member needs assistance and all of the options cost $small_fortune. What do we do? I think the theme is important rather than the _exact_ details of this particular situation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- newshorts 4y agoI found the article extremely informational by explaining what the situation could look like for my aging parents. In fact it even motivates me to start planning out costs with them. Sometimes the point of articles can simply be to relate one’s own experience to other people.
- RansomStark 4y agoIt only looks like clickbait because you're used to a system that costs $$$ to get medical care. In the UK when my mother got told she was terminal and had a couple of months left, she chose to spend them at home. In the end she left hospital in mid-December and died the following May. 5 months at home in a specialist bed, provided by the hospital, all of the equipment required to keep a dying person comfortable again provided by the hospital. Nurses and doctors there every day. Because of her illness, the government paid her rent, it paid my father a carers allowance, so he was able take time off work. Total cost: £0. 5 months of excellent at home care for £0. You shouldn't be dismissing the article as clickbait, it shouldn't cost $145k to die, there shouldn't need to be a discussion here. You should be so very angry that a country that takes in $3tn a year in federal taxes won't support a working healthcare system
- redeeman 4y ago> Total cost: £0. > 5 months of excellent at home care for £0. a lifetime of having way more than HALF your income stolen from you..... 0? okay..
- IOT_Apprentice 4y agoYou can lose all your savings and your home in the US as a result of just Healthcare expenses alone. Do you think that is a good idea? None of the other industrialized nations of the world do. Hmmm.
- redeeman 4y agoand in the UK you can die while waiting for the ambulance.. in canada they will recommend you go kill yourself... every system has problems, but there is a thing in common with all the systems.. they all have the hands of government deeply involved
- gabereiser 4y agoRidiculous. https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates It's clearly closer to "just under HALF your income..."
- peteey 4y agoThe point is: >Medicare should restructure hospice reimbursement to cover more of the hands-on caregiving, thus decreasing the financial burden of dying at home. The main pitch is somewhat hidden in the middle of the article. Its a tough point to open with, but I think leading with the thesis statement is proper.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAnd it is written by a geriatric nurse practitioner, so presumably they would benefit. Not that it would necessarily be inappropriate.
- oneoff786 4y agoI think it’s also intentionally misleading though. It’s not dying at home. It’s riding out the rest of your days under detailed medical supervision which presumably intervenes and prevents you from dying.
- mhb 4y ago> As much as I sympathize, the title is clickbait and I'm not entirely sure what the point of the article is. Yes. Where are all the people who were apoplectic about the Nord Stream post?
- Spooky23 4y agoTypically not - you're looking at nursing home care. That means you'll pay $300+ a day for care that is awful at best and horrific more typically. Sometimes hospice patients have a better experience because the outside entity (the hospice) has eyes on the patient and (in)competence of the nursing home staff. The tragedy of modern medical care if you're over 65 is that it's hard to die. Medicare only pays hospitals for results, so there are powerful incentives to limit hospital stays as much as possible - unless you're in an ICU or similar scenario, if you are hospitalized more than a week it's likely because someone fucked up, and Medicare will reimburse the hospital next to nothing as a result. It's easy to get sick or become incapacitated, but people can and will "save" you and leave you in a situation where you are not well, but not dead. The options are 120 days of Medicare nursing home coverage, followed by a slow drain of all of your assets and ultimately Medicaid enrollment. Nursing home means you're effectively warehoused, and the more help you need, the less care you get as you become a cost center. It's not just a matter of finances, it's a matter of humanity. The harsh reality is your disabled loved one will be treated like cattle unless someone who cares is directly engaged in caring for you. After the horror that my father went through after a suffering a stroke, and the pain caused to my mother after she took on full-time care, I did what most doctors do and have DNR care instructions on file with every hospital in a 50 mile radius.