12 ms·
My grandmother died at home, just as she wanted. It cost $145,000
- novateg 4y agoIt's very weird to see someone posting about money spent for her grandma. In other cultures it's a shame.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIt's more a way to shame the system, where dying at home costs so much.
- krisroadruck 4y agoWhat's to be done about it though? Round the clock care requires people. Those people have to be paid. Paid enough to attract people to do the work. Someone has to pay for it. Shifting it to the tax payer base doesn't change the math, it just moves the food around on the plate. Honestly, if I lived well into my 80s and a last few horrible months was going to cost over $100K of money I didn't have to spend and eat up 2-3 peoples full time efforts, I'd probably just opt out.
- esotericimpl 4y ago[dead]
- TSiege 4y agoThat's the point the author is trying to make. That it is unjust to have to spend so much for end of life care and that as a society we should feel ashamed
- sokoloff 4y agoThe grandmother required 24-hour care, which they received for $13K/month. For a 30-day month, that's $16.77/hr to the worker plus $1.28 to SS/Medicare if you allow for 0 minutes of shift-hand-off, PTO/sick, etc. How much less than $16.77/hr do we think that care should cost? (Note that Massachusetts has a $15 minimum wage. This care cost less than 12% over minimum wage.)
- siilats 4y agoExactly. 24h will cost the same everywhere. Maybe you can use a video baby monitor at night to reduce from 24 to 16h a day
- pibechorro 4y agoFree obviously /s, because people dont understand basic economics and are either delusional it will be cheaper in a monopoly (socialized) (assuming you even have the choice to die at home with it) or want to imagine people working for free like doctors and nurses. That being said the corruption in the us system is insane, insurance companies being protected by regulations against competition, big pharmas regulatory capture and media control, etc. The answer is a more competitive marketplace, including non profits. Not a eu socialized model.
- em500 4y agoYup, it seems people gloss over that 24*7 care means 168hr per week, i.e. 4x42hr or 3x56 hr of labor per week. The only ways to make this cheaper is 1) lower salaries, 2) fewer hours or 3) have someone else pick up the tab (which can sometimes work on the individual level but not on the societal level)
- phphphphp 4y agoI think you're reading the parent post the wrong way around: in many cultures, paying for your relatives is an honour and obligation. i.e: Paying a lot of money for your grandmother's end of life care is the bare minimum, not something to complain about or expect the state to handle.
- stuaxo 4y agoIn other cultures there is no way it would cost that much, or anything at all.
- dpkirchner 4y agoHow much does paying for your relatives cost in places where those cultures exist, relative to median income?
- arbitrage 4y agoWhat's the shame -- paying for your grandma, or posting about it?
- weregiraffe 4y agoHaving one in the first place. ;-P
- weregiraffe 4y agoThere are no other cultures on Hackernews, only Nacirema.
- martin_a 4y agoAnother day, another horror story about the American health & care system. I'm just speechless about all of that at this point and very glad the I live in Europe, where we have things like these figured out. (edit: yeeeeaaaaaah, not everything is perfect in Europe, either, but nobody will be left with a bill of 150k € if your grandmother wants to die in her home.)
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- siilats 4y agoHow would you get 24h home care in Europe? Impossible
- manuelabeledo 4y agoElder care? It exists, and it's nowhere as expensive.
- lm28469 4y agoMy grandma's non medicalised public retirement house costs $2k+ per month, she's not even sick. A 24/7 _at home_ and _medical_ care will cost a fortune anywhere in the world and is never covered unless you have a very expensive private insurance to begin with
- manuelabeledo 4y agoI'm not saying it would be cheap, I said it would not be this expensive. Also, there are different healthcare systems around the world. I don't know why you would be so sure about the impossibility of at-home nursing.
- em500 4y ago24/7 care is 168hr/week, so the costs will be about 4 FTE in local salary. It's only less expensive elsewhere because wages are lower elsewhere.
- kickout 4y agoCan relate to TFA. Cost near the end of life are eye-popping the in the US, but the alternative is murky too. Just let elder relatives live in your home? Likely won't last 3-4 days, its hard. Cost of these facilities is astronomical and ironically the staff is usually underpaid and overstressed. Assisted death will get a lot of callout as its becoming popular but its not 100% the answer either. Legitimately wondering how older generations dealt with this problem. Did old people just die randomly and then they were buried and that was that?
- lettergram 4y ago> Did old people just die randomly and then they were buried and that was that? In most places on earth the elderly live with their children. The children care for them, then yes they die. They’ll often be buried in the yard if they have land or in a plot designated (graveyard). Alternatively, they’ll have some sort of cremation ceremony. Pretty much been that way forever. The last 70 years in the US has gotten exceptionally weird, looking through a historical lens. Frankly, it looks like we hate our elders.
- kickout 4y agoAgreed, and having watched the older generations go through heartbreaking experiences to squeeze out 2-3 months of 'living' has solidified me in insisting on never putting my family through that. My hope is multi-generational households become more prevalent in the US (I thin they are still common in Latino and Asian communities in the US). Leads to interesting debates/arguments on what is living versus simply being alive
- seti0Cha 4y agoWe don't hate the elderly, we just don't value family. We expect our kids to leave home as soon as they are able and we don't bat an eye when they move a few thousand miles away. Marriage rates have been declining for a few decades and something like half of marriages end in divorce. I have an aging mother and mother-in-law that both live alone because they "value their independence." Neither has the slightest interest in living with my wife and I, although we are fairly close. The norm is living independently and anything else is an imposition or a failure in our society. edit: Wouldn't have thought any of that was terribly controversial. I'd be interested if those having a negative reaction would post some response so I know what makes that opinion problematic. No need to get into an argument, I'm just genuinely curious.
- pard68 4y agoTo be blunt, I do not think I desire to eek out a few more years of my life hooked up to life support, taking medicines that prevent me from being me, and pooping my pants. I remember my grandfathers last years (both in nursing homes, hooked to machines, drugged out of their minds) and I do not wish for that. I would rather die a few years earlier than live my last few years this way. It'd sure cost less too.
- x86x87 4y agoThis is the way a person that is far away from death thinks. No matter what you think now, you will still want to live when death is near. Even if the conditions are suboptimal.
- sbarzowski 4y agoI wouldn’t generalize here.
- technotony 4y agoWhat's your evidence for this? In my experience, losing both my parents and all grandparents, everyone was ready to go long before they did. My dad passed away comfortably in his sleep in reasonable health (for 84 year old) and he'd been talking about being ready for months. My grandmother told us she wished she was dead like all her friends for a decade before she passed away (she was late 90s). My mother had cancer and chose to go at her own time like one of the comments above about MAID.
- giantg2 4y agoSimilar here. My grandfather told me he prayed for death to come a few months before actually dying. So it does depend on the individual and their specific circumstances.
- tfandango 4y agoI agree, very much depends on the individual. Currently witnessing a 94-year-old who can no longer get out of bed who absolutely does not want to die. Otherwise, I'm convinced it would have happened by now. I'm not surprised though, it's her personality.
- crazygringo 4y agoAs much as I sympathize, the title is clickbait and I'm not entirely sure what the point of the article is. From what I can gather, the $145K cost was the cost of medical care over the months (years? the article never says) at the end of the grandmother's life -- not the cost of "dying at home". The bulk of the cost seems to come from: > the total monthly cost was $16,200: $13,000 a month for the 24-hour care, plus $3,200 to rent the apartment It seems silly to include rent, and then of course round-the-clock private care is going to be $$$. As far as I can tell, the grandmother needed hospital-level care, but the family didn't want to keep her in a hospital. It's not surprising that hospital-level care at home costs a small fortune.
- bthrn 4y agoThe claim is that this $16,200 monthly cost was cheaper than the alternative. So it's not entirely silly to include rent in this figure.
- bunbunbun 4y agoLong term care facilities are 5-10k USD per month. For the cheap ones. So $16k seems reasonable for in home care. There are also different intangible personal and family costs to facility-based or home-based care that folks should also consider.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoHowever, there's a lot of options that are even cheaper.
- TheHypnotist 4y agoWhich is nothing compared to hospital level care at the hospital.
- ejb999 4y agothats how I read it to - the family didn't want the burden of doing the care, and also don't think anyone should have to pay for it - who are these magical fairies that are going to show up in your final days and take care of you for free? If the deceased person owed the medical bills - well guess what? she is dead and won't have to pay them unless the creditors go after her estate - if the family's complaint that now their inheritance is going to be less than they thought - too bad.
- irrational 4y ago> it cost our family $145,613.79 I'd like to know what this actually means. Where did the money come from? Was her grandmother destitute and so the money was pooled from other family members? Was this debt that her grandmother accumulated that was written off when she died? Or, was this paid out of her grandmother's retirement funds?
- oaktrout 4y agoAgree. Also, was that the cost of hospice or of all her medical care? If you're including rent in the cost, did grandma have a home that she sold? Would she have been paying that much in rent anyway if she wasn't sick? Would it have been cheaper if she didn't live in one of the nations more expensive cities?
- ejb999 4y ago>> it cost our family $145,613.79 I would be willing to wager that the 'cost' was in a reduced inheritance.
- irrational 4y agoThat was my thought. It’s not their family’s money. Assuming the grandmother even gave the money to her family in her will, it is hers to do with while she is alive. That includes using it to pay for her end of life care.
- dnndev 4y agoWe just moved to Mexico for this very reason. My mom now has 24 hour nurse care (at home) for 1,200 usd per month. In the US we were quoted 10k per month and not 24 hour. My mom receives a small pension which puts her in a spot where she qualifies for no government benefits but also cannot afford care at the current market rate. It’s not for everyone but she is much happier here than in a nursing home.
- technics256 4y agoWhat city in Mexico?
- dnndev 4y agoAjijic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ajijic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ajijic
- technics256 4y agoThat's a beautiful town
- nine_zeros 4y agoI suspect a lot of boomers will discover this option soon. As soon as you retire, say at ages 60-65, it is more optimal to leave the US and live in Mexico/SE Asia until health permits. Then return back to the US in your early 70s with the full support of medicare and SS.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 4y agoHeh, you write "full support of medicare and SS" as if that's a solution. It's not really a solution (as the article alludes to). IME - 1. Kid(s) that will take care of you, or at least hands on supervise your care and fill in gaps in staff. 2. As little time as possible between being in rehab/hospital, and hospice. 3. Money If you have at least two out of those three, you won't have a horrible experience dying. Otherwise you end up in the state-paid nursing home gristmill, where you can at least take solace that they've checked the boxes on the paper saying they're turning and cleaning you.
- xipho 4y agoFor all those in the US who hear nothing but horror stories about how bad it would also be if you lived in another country, particularly in Canada, I always feel it's important to relate stories like this. My father died in Canada last year after a 9 month battle with cancer during which time he spent almost 2 months in cancer ward. He was not rich. He recieved cutting edge targeted chemo-therapy. He died peacefully with the aid of MAID in his small home town. It cost my mother $150.
- fortran77 4y ago[flagged]
- hobs 4y agoAs a grandchild of multiple people who went out HARD and died badly, your comments come off as the height of insensitive boorishness and you should think hard about what got you to this place. Having a peaceful death is something I wish, even for people like you.
- carlosjobim 4y agoHow sensitive of you, wishing death on a person just for not having the same opinion as you do. The whole world is by now familiar with the Canadian death programs and how the government uses economical reasoning to justify them. That has nothing to do with your grandparents.
- hobs 4y agoYou don't have to wish the inevitable on anyone, and making it easy is a kindness because in your final moments of pain, fear, and anxiety you might find yourself wanting to crawl up the walls screaming while your cancer riddled body fails you. You might be in memory care, slowly draining out until there's nothing left, committing suicide by tearing out your catheter and refusing medical attention, taking hours to die in agony. You might find yourself in such brutal pain that the only haven you have is deep in drug induced stupors, leaving yourself a hollow shell with tubes in their face and not much else. Which part of these curses would you wish on yourself or others? I have seen them all up close and this is why I wish us all an easy exit.
- Zetobal 4y ago24h at home care isn't covered anywhere except with really expensive private insurance. In most European countries the family either covers the burden financially or they do it themselves. This post is more entitlement than anything else.
- gwbas1c 4y agoWhen my mother passed last September, about 30 miles (~50 kilometers) west of Boston, private onsite hospice care cost about $400-ish a day. It's about the cost of staying in a fancy hotel. The state also covers the cost when you are on your final days, (there's a specific medical term,) but for longer-term stays, (weeks, months,) you have to pay out of pocket. Being "on hospice" when you are in your last months (again I don't remember the medical term), in Massachusetts is free. The family is responsible for the round-the-clock care, though. The real difficulty isn't the money: The state is very good at placing people who can't pay. The people who get squeezed are those of us who want an inheritance, or the spouses who need to keep money for their own end-of-life needs, yet are unable or unwilling to take time off from our lives. In my case my dad was under quite a bit of emotional stress, and when he's in that state, he gets irrational and can't make a decision. My mom was clearly in her last few days, but he was afraid he'd have to pay for many weeks or months of onsite hospice stay out of his own pocket. Even if that happened, he still had her brand-new Lexus and his own 1-year-old Highlander, a much larger house than he needs...
- ejb999 4y ago>>The people who get squeezed are those of us who want an inheritance You just said the quiet part out loud, and is my biggest gripe about sob stories like this - it is almost always about the children resenting the fact that some of their parents money is going to be spent on their elder care when they would prefer 'someone else' pick up the bill, so that they get a bigger inheritance.
- gwbas1c 4y agoYeah, on the last day she was in the house, the social workers came to evaluate her to see if we would pay, or the state would pay. They determined that we should pay. The (cough) mistake that we made was we gave her painkillers before the visit because she was writhing in pain. If the social workers saw the writhing, they would have picked up the tab. (The hospice later retroactively admitted her so we paid nothing.) Edit: And I don't regret giving my mom painkillers. But, I had to make a point to my Dad that the social workers saw his nice, well kept house, all of our nice cars, pictures from nice vacations, ect, and decided that $400-$1200 to keep Mom comfortable was well within our budget.
- mnw21cam 4y ago> For this reason, dying at home is often unattainable for many... Currently, Medicare only covers an average of two hours per day, five days a week, of home health aide coverage for a patient in hospice care. This article left me fairly confused. Why is the author talking about dying at home and in a hospice interchangeably?
- mikeyouse 4y agoMany hospice services are provided at patients’ homes. Hospice is end of life care, it doesn’t require a medical facility in most cases. A “hospice nurse” will do rounds to ensure everything is okay but for fairly stable patients, the bulk of the time/energy is provided by the family.
- ecommerceguy 4y agoLife insurance can be writen with an LTC rider, standalone LTC policies have gotten very expensive since they were oversold throughout the 80's and 90's. SS kicks in upto a portion of the hospice and at home care, depending on circumstances. In Canada a growing in popularity option is to kill yourself.
- b3lvedere 4y ago"How will you afford to spend your final years of life? How much will your death cost you and your family? Can you afford it?" We've had this talk with both my parents and my wife's parents. All four of them insisted they do not want to be a burden to us and we should never allow them to move in with us. Most of our parents took care of at least one terminal person in their life and experiencing that changed their opinions radically. It can be an almost impossible burden, no matter how much you love someone. Thankfully in our country we have both the law and basic insurance that takes care of all those costs in the last (terminal) phase of our lives, but you still have to design your testament and other documents in such a way that your money cannot be claimed for these costs. When the time comes, i want to be put in the Euthenasia Coaster ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthanasia_Coaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthanasia_Coaster ) , but if they have not built that yet i might settle for the $20 heroin overdose.
- standardUser 4y agoThis reminded me of one of our society's most twisted and grotesque norms, forcing people on their deathbed to die "naturally", meaning to starve and dehydrate to death while being pumped full of opioids, instead of mercifully and humanely ending their life. We treat animals better than this. I hope by the time it's my turn my family is able to end my life once the outcome is certain instead of watching me waste away day after day in a hospital bed until my body finally fails.
- adolph 4y ago> As a clinician, I’ve been trained to explain hospice to patients as “an extra layer of support” at the end of life. Offering advice on the provision of goods and services without cost information is stupid. It’s like one grade schooler telling another “yeah, you should totally buy that real life Ferrari.” > The problem is that the bulk of the hands-on care in hospice — including changing diapers, feeding and giving medications — still falls to the family. Amazingly, she acted as a salesperson for services whose service level she didn’t understand. On top of that, instead of learning a lesson and sharing better approaches with others she promoted additional subsidies to the existing dysfunctional system.
- karol 4y agoThis reminds me of the trend to value women's work at home on a per hour basis. Then an inevitable conclusion is reached: being a homemaker is like being employed but not compensated. The point is taking care of your family is something people want to do to maintain family relationship, connections between generations and self-identity. It's a choice, not a forced expenditure. And it's not meant to be pleasant or easy. It's not a hobby. It's a fabric of a well lived life.
- BenFranklin100 4y agoI realize this may seem like a tangential point, but this story highlights the dire shortage of caregivers, especially elderly care workers. This shortage is a factor behind high costs and substandard care. Many of these jobs don’t necessarily require extensive medical training; a caring hand is literally the most valuable gift, especially near end of life. Immigrants can help fill these roles, but the United States restrictive immigration policy prevents this. The problem is only going to get worse as the Boomers continue to age, and as US demographics tilt towards an older population. Immigrants can help avert this crises while at the same time beginning a better life for themselves. We should do a better job of welcoming immigrants.
- freedude 4y ago"the United States restrictive immigration policy prevents this." It is more than a restrictive immigration policy. Many other caregiver policies exist as well. I have an acquaintance that runs an adult foster care home with 5 rooms. When he added a second facility he went from providing care to being a paperwork pusher for the federal, state and local governments. This is the real reason is costs so much.
- pkphilip 4y agoAs someone who has had two older people who were at home virtually till the end - my mother-in-law (she finally died in the hospital after a very short stay) and her mum (who died at home) who were both terminally ill and bedridden for a while before they died, I have to say that the inconvenience to the rest of us was worth it because it enabled them be with the family, be part of what the family was doing etc.. And so also the family benefited from being with them till the end. It did require having nursing help at home and it did cost some money - but it was still cheaper than being admitted in a hospice or a hospital.
- sshine 4y agoMy father died at 83 at home, and the only cost was the funeral expense, which would have been the same. When he stopped coming at the hospital for regular blood work, they expected he'd die in two weeks, but he lasted six months. During those six months my mom acted as his caregiver and vigil, and the state compensated her financially. She was allowed to continue working, and since she worked from home, she did work a little next to looking after him. Once a day for those six months, a nurse from the public health system would come by and check up on him. This is Denmark.
- logicalmonster 4y agoI think we're looking at things backwards. The question that society seems to be encouraging is "how are we going to pay people to take care of the old?". The question we should be asking is "why are we paying strangers to take care of you when for most people, their children should be there at the end of life helping, showing love, and thanking mom and dad for all they've done?". There's a significant cost to the direction that society has gone in the last hundred or so years. > Deemphasizing the importance of family bonds by encouraging government to be the social safety net. This problem will only be exacerbated by increasing the social safety net further. > Compelling nearly all women into the permanent workforce, ensuring that most families are in no position to be able to do anything other than maybe get in debt to pay a stranger to care for their elderly parents. > Encouraging women to have fewer and fewer children even while encouraging mass migration to replace the existing population, ensuring that the problem will be even worse the more time goes on.
- s0rce 4y agoDoesn't this require everyone to have children and your children to live nearby? Also, it seems like the OPs aging parent required specialized care which contributed to the high cost, not everyone could provide this level of care.
- logicalmonster 4y agoPlease note that I said "most people", not "all people". Most people should aspire to have family caring for them at an old age as the best possible situation at that stage.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y ago> their children should be there at the end of life helping, showing love, and thanking mom and dad for all they've done?". Speaking to the possible point that kids 'owe' their parents for their upbringing: As a father of 5, I strongly disagree. Fatherhood is, by necessity and actuality, service. Children don't ask to be born; I believe creating them into a position of debt is a poor rendering of that service.
- esotericimpl 4y ago[dead]
- yboris 4y agoNot a criticism of the action, but an observation. In the book The Elephant in the Brain by Kevin Simler & Robin Hanson, the authors observe that part of the reason healthcare may be so expensive is that we (unintentionally) communicate how much we love a person by acting as if money is not an issue. This means that despite last months of life often being the least pleasant for the dying, we expend a tremendous amount of money and resources intentionally to show them (and ourselves?) that we love them. A really worthwhile read are some of the essays online with basically the same title: How Doctors Die. Doctors, who are familiar with the process of dying in a hospital, typically do not wish to die there (it is miserable), and choose to die at home. I wish our society had a better ritual around death. Having an option for the dying person (if they are of sound mind) to choose euthanasia would be very merciful.
- freedude 4y ago"dying at home is often unattainable for many, unless they have family members who are willing to give up their own lives to be caregivers or the patient is willing to spend down their life savings to qualify for Medicaid to pay for around-the-clock help." You mean like what Grandma or Grandpa did to bring life into this world. Your life I might add. You owe them so much and you haven't clue. It is worthless and shameful.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y ago> You mean like what Grandma or Grandpa did to bring life into this world. You owe them so much and you haven't clue. I don't agree that my children should be responsible for the obligations that follow my choice to have sex. Further, decades of parenting taught me that as far as there is a debt, it is mine to pay. Parenting is service. ref: Father of 5. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34724289#34725607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34724289#34725607
- freedude 4y agoI can appreciate that parenthood is a form of service because I have lived it. What I cannot appreciate is an ungrateful child. Society will continue to descend into morass because of unwillingness to care for others. However I didn't learn this in a vacuum but had instruction as a child to value others. Generally to "love my neighbor as myself". But more specifically... Leviticus 19:32 Exodus 20:12 Ephesians 6:1-3
- teilo 4y agoI agree that this is clickbait, but then I come from a family that just doesn't think this way. I've been through this twice now, for both my parents. They died at home. Not in a rented apartment. At home. We, their children and grandchildren, were their caregivers. We did everything a nurse would have done. We took shifts. We spread the burden among us. Yes it was a sacrifice. But it was a sacrifice that was worth it, and nothing less than what we owed to our parents.