8 ms·
Peter Hotez on the increase of anti-science aggression on social media
- pcdoodle 4y ago[flagged]
- mistermann 4y ago> It’s no longer a theoretical discussion; Americans have lost their lives because they believed the politics, and to be able to articulate that is really threading a needle there. > But others are real people tuning into Fox News every night who totally fall into the rabbit hole because they seem to worship these contrarians. The other piece to this is a lot of Nazi imagery and fantasies, a lot of antisemitism, because they know I’m a Jewish scientist. And that’s yet another dimension to all of this. Watching Scientific Materialists trying to unravel metaphysical causality is a sight to behold.
- pjc50 4y ago? What does causality have to do with anti-semitism here?
- aww_dang 4y agoNothing. Some critics of Hotez are antisemites. Therefore according to the principles of guilt by association, critics of scientism are generally antisemites. It follows that it is all hatespeech worthy of censorship. https://jonathanturley.org/2021/08/04/baylor-professor-calls-for-prosecution-of-criticism-of-fauci-and-other-scientists-as-hate-crime/ https://jonathanturley.org/2021/08/04/baylor-professor-calls... >Baylor Professor Calls for Prosecution of Criticism of Fauci and Other Scientists as Hate Crime >Yet, what is healthy debate to some is criminal dissent to others. Dr. Peter Hotez, a professor of pediatrics and molecular virology at Baylor College of Medicine is calling for federal hate-crime protections to be extended to cover criticism of Dr. Anthony Fauci and other scientists.
- mistermann 4y agoAnti-semitism is an action conducted by human beings, thus it has underlying causality. A big problem is that both anti-semitism and observations of "it" are based on subjective perceptions that are typically perceived as objective reality. Causality is kind of "culturally sub-perceptual" (depending to some degree on one's geographical location and cultural/metaphysical training), I like thinking of it like the water in this classic parable: "There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older fish swimming the other way, who nods at them and says “Morning, boys. How’s the water?” And the two young fish swim on for a bit, and then eventually one of them looks over at the other and goes “What the hell is water?"
- macinjosh 4y ago[flagged]
- PedroBatista 4y agoA large part is due to the "because science.." crutch used in order to stop any questions. Also, it's the classic "Don't meet your heroes", because when the spotlight was pointed at the "scientific community" ( whatever that means.. ), the "plebes" saw a bunch of liars, fraudsters, careerists and also the complete opposite of scientific reasoning. Just like any other field... In my opinion the main event is the removal of the pristine mask that covered the "scientists" and that's a good thing. However, most of those who "expose the lies" are 10 times worse than the exposed. The only good way forward is to "scientists" go back into doing actual Science and nothing more. Social media is "just" a multiplier of things due to the networking effect, it can only increase something if the thing is not zero to begin with.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoAlso, administrators aren't scientists.
- Workaccount2 4y ago>the "plebes" saw a bunch of liars, fraudsters, careerists and also the complete opposite of scientific reasoning. Just like any other field... To me it was "The plebs read a bunch of words that they don't understand, running the information through their everyday layman brain and coming to totally wrong conclusions" This happens all the time. Remember "cell phones will fry your brain"? There is a large subset of the population who will never be able to understand the difference between a microwave oven, microwave communication, radiation, and ionizing radiation. Which leads to situations where someone from that subset stumbles upon some internal AT&T memo's reads them and comes away with "Holy shit, internally they blatantly talk about building towers that emit radiation over the whole population. Literally building huge microwaves to radiate over massive population centers!" More often than not, the scientists, engineers, big brains, whatever, have a good grip and the general population is fucking retarded.
- anigbrowl 4y agoRemember "cell phones will fry your brain" There is a huge overlap between '5f panic', anti-vax, panic, and all kinds of other panics. A lot of people who wind up things like the Qanon cult end up there because they had some sort of technological or political anxiety, networked with other people who had similar uncertainties, and were drawn into a radicalization funnel. There is plenty of financial and political capital to be made by fleecing such people. Flat earth nonsense is another example of the same phenomenon. If you go down that rabbit hole you find a warren of religious fundamentalism, built on the idea that earth ain't flat, space is fake, the Bible explains the stars are tiny lights mounted on a firmament, NASA is a satanic conspiracy, and it's time to take up arms against the forces of evil. All radical funnels follow the same sort of pattern, which is derived from sales and marketing: goofballs > grifters > true believers > organizers> extremists > martyrs/terrorists. Of course, you can make similar observations about partisan politics, geopolitics and so on; institutions function as funnels for the production of future elites who maintain the status quo through increasingly coercive means. Radicalization funnels differ mainly in terms of transparency, accountability, visibility, and speed of transition.
- motohagiography 4y agoIs it not reasonable to recognize that the majority of popular references to science fall into the logical fallacy category of an appeal to authority, where literate people recognize this as a ploy, and therefore respond to it as the patronizing provocation it is? We know that the official narratives of pandemic response included blatant and even malicious falsehoods designed to create social pressure and nudges for a percieved greater good, and do policymakers and scientists really think that this should come with impunity? Scientists and policymakers were wrong - a lot - and if they want to keep doubling down on antagonizing the people whose trust they have lost, they should probably game it out a bit first.
- watwut 4y ago[flagged]
- pjc50 4y ago[flagged]
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago[flagged]
- PaulHoule 4y ago[flagged]
- adra 4y agoSources welcome, and also can we please start criticising all those other people just trying to get shit done when in the middle of an emergency. I think those firefighters are doing shit jobs too, because you KNOW they could've put that burning building out better than they did!
- sharperguy 4y agoIt's more like. The building is on fire. The fire department denies it is on fire and calls anyone who claims it is on fire a liar. Then they admit it is on fire and pretend like they always said it was on fire. Then they point the water in completely the wrong direction, and call anyone pointing this out a liar. They use the fact that those same people were already known as liars as evidence, without mentioning that the 'liars' were in fact correct. Continue ad infinitum.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThe public trust is fragile thing. Once that trust is broken revolutions are inevitable. I fear the whole tech idea "move fast and break things" bled into society, and has caused a lot of irreversible damage. At my firm, the executive class are extraordinary distrustful of every expert lately from economics,finance, tech, and even science. These are people with multiple high level degrees like mba, phds, and masters! This happened with the last year, which is the surprising part.
- pcdoodle 4y agoI'm also the type to not tolerate lies. Maybe we'll call this the decade of mistruth. What really sucks is soon, we won't be able to tell in forums such as this, who's interests are on the other side of the text generator / click farm. I hope we can come up solutions to have trust again.
- fwungy 4y agoI have a PhD in Transportation and am amazed at the ridiculous consensus of my peers. It's almost as if they produce the research that will keep their grants coming in rather than what is logical and correct.
- mrguyorama 4y agoHave you talked to those peers? Have you attempted to falsify any of their research? You not liking what they are finding provides no view into whether they are correct or not.
- fwungy 4y agoResearchers operate on money. They write grant proposals to get funded. Those grants typically specify their objectives in such a way that the outcomes are limited to a range that is satisfying to the funder. If you take grant money and come up with results that the grant maker does not like they will not give you anymore grants. This creates a feedback loop in which compliant researchers are fed and independent researchers are starved. The peer review group then gets dominated by those who are good at making the relatively small pool of major grant makers happy. I work in tech now. I see orders of magnitude more honest debate in software engineering than in academia. On a tech team a Linus or a Steve Jobs can win, even though they may have some personal imperfections, they deliver major products. Winners in academia tend to be those who are best at working the social and administrative game. Questioning the herd is not a viable career strategy.
- fwlr 4y agoSeems like we’re mostly finished with denial and we’ve moved on to anger. After that comes bargaining, then depression, then acceptance. (Whether for good reasons, evil reasons, or stupid reasons, the public trust in “public health” has been broken, and the public health institution is naturally going to grieve that loss)
- pjc50 4y ago> the public health institution is naturally going to grieve that loss As well as the loss of a lot of lives.
- drewcoo 4y agoActually, the "Five Stages of Grief" thing has been debunked. Or did you mean that as another example of bunk science? https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/five-fallacies-of-grief/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/five-fallacies-of... https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/supersurvivors/201707/why-the-five-stages-grief-are-wrong https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/supersurvivors/20170...
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoI'm not sure that will be the way it's going to go. These companies and their respective lobby groups have a lot of power. The public is dependent on them, not the other way around.
- bluetomcat 4y ago“Because science” is a deeply anti-scientific and epistemologically-unsound view. Science is about observing natural phenomena in accordance with an established paradigm, creating hypotheses and accepting or refuting them from empirical evidence. A new empirical observation has the potential to change the whole paradigm and unlock a new framework for understanding.
- brookst 4y agoYes, but you either have to do science or respect science. You don’t get to treat a single personal anecdote as equivalent to a body of peer reviewed studies.
- bluetomcat 4y agoWhy should personal anecdotal evidence be worthless per se? A unifying scientific theory usually explains stuff by using a hierarchy of abstract models, detached from a concrete local environment. The subjective experience defines a plethora of factors which are hard to fit into a general theory. If you live in a high-crime neighbourhood, you'd better trust your anecdotal evidence instead of relying on nation-wide sociological evidence.
- brookst 4y agoMe: a personal anecdote does not have the weight of a body of peer reviewed articles. You: why are personal anecdotes worthless? Binary thinking is too transparent. You seem to be using binary thinking to suggest that if anecdotes have any value, they must be treated as having equal value with any other source of data, including rigorously designed and executed studies.
- fwungy 4y agoYes, but that's only true if peer review is functioning as intended. Peer review has been gamed and is broken. Science is a career and an industry and individuals have figured out how to protect their fiefdoms within it. The financial incentives in pharmaceutical research are particularly corrupting due to their size.
- imchillyb 4y agoScience isn't a document with truths laid out in plaintext. Science is a method. Science is a method humans use in order to create a repeatable experiment, with repeatable outcomes. That's it. As our tools improve our measurements, those measurements lead to a greater understanding of the world around us. That is science. It's why science seems to change, because our tools improve, our measurements improve, and our data gathered becomes more refined. Science is simply a tool used to garner truths.
- xeonmc 4y agoSomewhat tangential, but I feel like a neat children's story could be written in a similar vein as "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" but replace Christmas with "Science", and the various things stolen being scientific implements, demolishing peer-reviewed journal institutions, deleting research data/past knowledge etc.
- pjc50 4y agoI upvoted this, but now I'm just going to flag it off the front page because exactly the same thing is happening here. (I know at least one scientist who no longer dares post about their work on social media, because it's immunology. Not even anything to do with COVID, just immunology as a field!)
- fl_ciq 4y agoPeople aren't anti-science, no one cares about a bunch of papers saying vaccines are / aren't effective, people care that you aren't allowed to go to a restaurant without you're vaccination papers or mask, that's not science, that's politics / policy. Also, it turns out that many of the risks of the vaccine were understated or unknown. That's also not science. And it's especially not science when the "anti-science" people proposed a theory that turned out to be right. Namely, that the risks of the vaccine are not known / being understated. And yes, a lot of the anti-vax activists also publish a whole bunch of non-scientific bs. I like vaccines, I got vaccinated, and it pisses me off that the anti-vax people we're right about the risks being unknown / understated. I dunno if I'm still pro-COVID vaccine, but I never thought it was right that people who didn't want the vaccine couldn't enjoy the same rights as those who did. My thoughts were I'm vaccinated, I'm protected, if you want to get COVID without a vaccine, that's your business.
- ted_dunning 4y agoCare to cite an actual example of a COVID vaccine study that didn't have a caveat about what risks might still be unknown?
- fl_ciq 4y agoI cite its approval. Again, "the science" mostly revolves around policy, instead of you know, science. "The science" as presented popularly regarding the COVID vaccines was that the risks were low and it less risky for anyone of any age group to get vaccinated rather than risk COVID, that turned out to be false. For some age groups, especially young people its less risky to get COVID, especially omicron, than to get vaccinated. The messaging still hasn't really changed in this regard. Either way no matter the risk of COVID, the lockdowns, and vaccine passes, and mask mandates were ridiculous and very unscientific.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jvickers 4y agoI find it just a little surprising that the former Twitter COVID 'misinformation' policy prohibited sharing details concerning the different vulnerabilities between the young and the old. I'd think that an analysis of what information this 'misinformation' policy disallowed would figure into discussions of how the social media sites can aggressively pursue an anti-science through prohibiting the transmission of scientific information.
- chabes 4y agoI know this was only posted here an hour ago, but yikes… the comments here just add even more credibility to the assertion that anti-science sentiment has really spread like a disease. Even here, where I expect at least a semblance of thoughtful discussion on topics that are based on data and evidence, the comments are littered with Twitter-level reactionary nonsense.
- miguelazo 4y agoHere’s some data that might explain why some people are so upset. And since most people are unaware of these things and the media ignored/suppressed them, they dismiss such sentiments as “anti-science.” https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/timeline-the-proximal-origin-of-sars-cov-2/ https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/timeline-the-proximal-ori...
- pjc50 4y ago[flagged]
- mrguyorama 4y ago[flagged]
- brookst 4y ago[flagged]
- actually_a_dog 4y ago[flagged]
- brookst 4y ago[flagged]
- petodo 4y ago> I’m constantly surprised at how much of an anti-science, anti-technology undercurrent there is on HN. I doubt anyone here is anti-science, you can't just cherrypick science results which suit your agenda and call other side anti-science because they see also different results. As for anti-technology, it's perfectle understandable people who are more familiar with technology than majority of the society are also more aware of potential risks, so they have problems with some new technology which brings new problems.
- MrMan 4y ago[flagged]
- brookst 4y ago[flagged]
- HPsquared 4y agoI don't think many people are against science itself; most "anti-science" sentiment is against scientism.
- joemazerino 4y agoWhat a fun trope. Hiding behind "this is Science!". Science is dynamic and ever-changing. It does not stay still. The reality is during the COVID crisis "scientists" who touted only one side of the public risk debate were given the podium and everyone else was shut out. The public won't forget about this.
- anigbrowl 4y ago"scientists" who touted only one side of the public risk debate The other side being 'it's just a cold/flu', 'only the unfit will die', 'statistics are fake', 'muh Chinese bioweapon' etc. Edit: you know it's true. 'touting' suggests bad faith, and ignoring the existence of bad faith discourse in the opposite direction is facile.
- YtGoodman 4y agoBut even Bill Gates is now saying that it’s just like a cold and only risky for the very elderly. And the virus did leak from a lab? Two of the three points you’re trying to straw-man are rooted in obvious fact.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoIt's simple: "Science" has lost a lot of its credibility in the past year or two: Here are some reasons - Purposeful public misleading of the populus regarding vaccine side effects - Shaming and censoring of serious, critical voices - Self-censoring of scientist communities by avoiding publishing of truths that oppose a particular narrative (we have seen evidence of this in the concurrent thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34724174 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34724174) - Scientists self-censoring for fear of political repercussions - Heavy public discouragement and shaming of critical thinking that goes against what certain approved "scientists" say Over the past year alone I have come across several examples for each of these. The bottom line is the public has been, and still is being misled. You have been fooled regarding science. Edit: I forgot the classic silent downvoting of course! Best example for what I just said. Constant attempts to silently suppress differing views. Thanks for proving my point. If the downvoters were scientifically well versed they would at least attempt to make a fool out of me by countering my arguments with better ones, but alas ;)
- mrguyorama 4y ago> I forgot the classic silent downvoting of course You are not entitled to a response just because you are angry about something.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoOf course not. On the other hand, considering that the downvoters are unable to vocalize their angry reaction to me, I simply consider my argument/observation reinforced. It certainly illustrates my wider point: When it comes to critics, most people opt to censor (yes, downvoting is a form of censoring) rather than engage, then wonder why the notion that there is something sinister going on is becoming more rather than less accepted.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epups 4y agoThe anti-vaccine movement is one of the most dangerous mind-viruses in the world. After Covid exacerbated it, we now see lower levels of vaccinations for all types of disease in the West. Millions will die or be physically impaired due to their inability to process information. As we can see in this thread, unfortunately many (presumably) educated people will end up victims as well.
- fwungy 4y agoVaccines have saved hundreds of millions of lives. Now we have a population and climate crisis. If idiots want to end themselves by not vaccinating maybe we should stop fighting them?
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe problem with that take was always that communicable diseases do not care what you believe when they kill you and spread
- fwungy 4y agoYou got the vaccine right?
- jdthedisciple 4y agoIf I don't take the vaccine, I am still 99% immune against the Cov, and I am 100% immune against vaccine side effects. Who is the idiot now?
- YtGoodman 4y agoIn what way do we have a “population crisis”?
- fwungy 4y agoGHG = population * GHG/person As Bill Gates said, "to get zero GHG's one of those has to go to zero".
- tastyfreeze 4y agoAnother "scientist" to throw in the bin of dogmatic ideologues. If you can't refute opposing claims with evidence then as a scientist you should shut the hell up.
- callmetom 4y agoThat is what happens when doctors and scientists play politics. A minority of them actively supported the agenda through disinformation, but the vast majority of them sat quietly and offered no pushback - presumably out of fear for being blacklisted. I remember one testifying before Congress that he knew there were clear indications pointing to gain of function tampering, but said nothing because it might influence the upcoming election... Any attempt to garner sympathy from the public, who as a result were coerced into deciding between taking an experimental drug or being fired, will be fruitless.
- frankreyes 4y agoDuring the early days of the pandemic I has in a heated discussion on social media about face masks with other scientists (private group of 20k scientists). I was in favor of using face masks. Most of the comments were by other scientists against using face masks. Two days later the Surgeon General of the US turns around and openly on YouTube asks for the general population to use face masks. Until this days some people are still using face masks. Appealing to authority is exactly the opposite of what science stands for. Science denial is a self inflicted wound.
- monetus 4y ago> Until this days some people are still using face masks. Is that supposed to be a bad thing?
- frankreyes 4y agoI clearly stated in my comment that I was supporting the use of face masks.
- monetus 4y agoIndeed; sorry, sorry. I was pretty groggy when I asked that - hope you're doing alright.
- fwungy 4y agoI feel like I should take a shower after I watch a Peter Hotez interview. I'd probably do the opposite of whatever he said just based on the vibe I get from him. Science is just a rigorous process for the investigation of natural phenomena. I have no problem with that, for the record.
- anigbrowl 4y agoObligatory: a pre-pandemic examination of the scope and methodology of weaponized health communication online: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/ You will recall that the skepticism about RNA in COVID vaccines was not a sudden break in public health discourse, but was preceded by many years of 'vaccines cause autism!!' arguments and the like, and that a decline in public confidence about vaccine had led to the re-emergence of measles outbreaks in recent years, reversing the long-term trend of declining hospitalization and mortality for well-understood diseases.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI might add that downvoting this is equivalent to rejecting observations of a control group.
- crashingintoyou 4y ago[flagged]
- stareatgoats 4y agoI can understand where he (Hotez) is coming from, especially in view of his personal history of having an autistic child. We need to take seriously and combat the disinformation that pours in through social media like a flood over scorched plains. But when this fight increasingly becomes partisan and/or self-interested it becomes hard to discern what is merely propaganda using the "hoax" and "conspiracy theory" bludgeon, and what is the noble fight. Nowhere is this clearer than regarding the "lab leak" theory (that a Wuhan lab leak is the ultimate covid-19 source, something which if true likely would make continued Gain of Function research nigh impossible). Leading scientists like Peter Daszak even Hotez himself that have been at the forefront of talking down this verily possible hypothesis have been proven to have serious conflicts of interest in the matter. [0] [1] Anti-science sentiments is a problem, but for Hotez to come complaining about it in such a context becomes problematic itself to say the least. [0] https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2414 https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2414 [1] https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/critic-of-congressional-probe-into-gain-of-function-research-helped-fund-wuhan-gain-of-function-study/ https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/critic-of-congressional-p...
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago>Leading scientists like Peter Daszak Weird, there must be another scientist with the same name. https://theintercept.com/2021/09/09/covid-origins-gain-of-function-research/ https://theintercept.com/2021/09/09/covid-origins-gain-of-fu...
- stareatgoats 4y agoNot sure why you think so. It's the same guy, he was been at the forefront of trying to discredit the any notion of a "lab leak" all while being involved in research in Wuhan involving genetic manipulation the infectiousness of corona viruses. That doesn't necessarily mean that he is trying too hide an actual lab leak, or that there was one at all, only that he behaved unethically when he didn't disclose conflicting interests. The why is interesting, but can only be speculation: could be political seeing that everything is so polarized nowadays: when the "lab leak" was first vented it was seen as a republican (Trumpian) notion that could lead to intensified clashes with China. But reading the correspondence brought to light by the Intercept and RightToKnow it seems that major fear from scientists was that lawmakers might shut down GoF research if a "lab leak" was found credible - something most of the big names in virology are heavily invested in, viewed as a necessary tool in future pandemic control.
- kthejoker2 4y agoThis comment thread is just supreme intellectual navel gazing and using hindsight to recast what happened. Science is messy, communicating is messier, acting as if every bit of mess comes from some negarious agenda or that somehow the mess was avoidable with finite budgets, time, and knowledge is ... completely against the entire history of human behavior. Your time on this planet is short, generally full of ignorance, confusion, and lying to yourself. By all means learn from our mistakes and reduce that ignorance and confusion going forward, but if your conclusion is to reject scientific inquiry as the only tool we have to move forward, you are just contributing to the confusion and ignorance.