6 ms·
Sam Altman calls Google a lethargic search monopoly
- adityathakurxd 4y agoGoogle has had the monopoly for a long. I don't think it would be easy to overthrow them but Bing + GPT stands a good chance.
- holografix 4y agoSounds about right. Pissed away millions chasing stupid moonshots, instead of you know, actual moonshots like getting into the space industry.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoHey, ive heard good things about that guy that build that giant potatoe cannon. Big Head, big Brain, lots of great things to come. You dont just become Vice president of spite for nothing.
- autophagian 4y agoI wouldn't like to be the googlestronaut who learns that his moon hab is being surprised-discontinued as he's standing in it
- cryptoz 4y agoThey do own like 6% of SpaceX I think.
- moffkalast 4y agoThere's some irony there, since the space industry is literally pissing away millions in propellant every time they launch.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 4y agoThey don't seem lethargic when you look at the list of just their cancelled projects. Sam Altman just seems to be behaving like any regular CEO here. Praising their company's tech integration into Microsoft, which will pay them a fortune. Saying Google search is old and lethargic and Bing is amazing. It may turn out to be true, but consider the source.
- Tenoke 4y agoI expect that if he thought highly of them he just wouldn't say anything and that this is close to his real opinion.
- stingraycharles 4y agoWhy? Why wouldn’t a CEO say what’s best for business, regardless of what they think of their competitors?
- izacus 4y agoThinking that CEOs of anything are honest and truthful is a dangerous naivete.
- christkv 4y agoWill it though? The 10 billion Microsoft investment has to be returned first from what I understood.
- 4y ago
- Drakim 4y agoWhen Google started putting ads at the top of their search results that looks exactly like the organic search results (only differentiated with a tiny "Ad" label) is when they truly lost me. Everything up until that point I could attribute to ignorance and laziness instead of malice. But at some point somebody at Google suggested that a new way to drive ad clicks could be to confuse and trick their users, and everybody else in the room nodded along.
- antupis 4y agoyoutube is worse and starts getting closer and closer that sketchy streaming or pornsite terratory.
- miroljub 4y agoOn most porn sites, you don't have autoplay forced up your throat. They also have a much better recommendation system, that doesn't recommend you completely irrelevant or sponsored content.
- LrnByTeach 4y agoMicrosoft 2005 : computer viruses causing PCs run slow, let us not worry , users need to buy new PC in two years. Everybody in the room nodded along Google 2012: let's make Ads almost look like organic search results, everybody in the room nodded along. corporate greed repeats ...
- exodust 4y agoA low point for sure, but given a pass because the ads are meant to be relevant to the search. In many cases the ad links would satisfy the search intent. Unlike youtube videos which put ads for Big Macs and other horrible things on random videos. But why pretend ads won't infect "ChatAI" services: User: "Find and read me a nostalgic poem from the 19th century".... [processing].... ChatAI: "Introducing the Chicken Mince Big Mac with Super Special Sauce Combo Deluxe Mega Pack! For a limited time only"..... "He is not here; but far away The noise of life begins again, And ghastly thro’ the drizzling rain On the bald street breaks the blank day..."
- joshxyz 4y agoLook at the google graveyard, good lord Google please step up!
- ttrrooppeerr 4y agoEvery time they try to innovate or expand, they shoot themselves in the foot. They might have to stop comparing any endeavour they take with their Search revenue and let them fly free for a decade or so before making such U-turn decisions (talking about Stadia here)
- robert_foss 4y agoNews at 11! Tech founder disparages competitor.
- pyb 4y agoI am a bit worried by the various immodest public statements Sam has made in the last few days. A bit more gravitas would be welcome.
- sfjailbird 4y agoIs he even a 'founder'? As I remember he joined OpenAI as CEO relatively late.
- pyb 4y agoYes, I was referring, among other things, to a recent tweet where he calls OpenAI "his" startup. Some of his coworkers may find that irksome, as he was not there when GPT2 was released. (If I understand correctly)
- mshake2 4y agoNot to mention, the GPT paper comes from Google[0]. His part in this seems very very small. 0. https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/08/transformer-novel-neural-network.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/08/transformer-novel-neural-n...
- pyb 4y agoOk, but I think the transition from Transformers to GPT took a lot of hard work and insight, and the OpenAI research team deserves ample credit for it.
- mshake2 4y agoSure, the research teams involved. I only bring up Google because it's ironic Sam is shitting on them for the tech they shared with everyone and made OpenAI possible.
- bbor 4y agoCurious about your choice of “worried”. Are you rooting for openai? I love chatgpt and dalle but now that they’re effectively a Microsoft subsidiary I’m not empathizing with them in the slightest. Plus Sam has kinda always been like that, no?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trabant00 4y agoCEO sees tremendous benefits in business buying his product. He is confident his product can help displace "lethargic" market leader. Not exactly news. The serenity with which ChatGPT provides false information, the lack of alternative responses and sources in the answers makes for a quite a challenge for a search engine. Can it be done in a way that dethrones Google? I'll believe it when I see it.
- obayesshelton 4y agoYou see / hear it all the time. Some hot shot new CEO bashing the bigger companies. This didn't end well for quite a few CEOs recently. Google is no longer a Unicorn it is a Shark... Sharks have been around for a long time.
- BasedInfra 4y agoMaybe a basking shark filtering masses plankton but it’s no great white. A great white would have launched a GPT api competitor far earlier and recognised the search replacement use case. GPT3 came out in 2020. People had used it as a search like function in 2020, we’re coming up to 3 years and only now they’ve acted to then bum rush into a competitor that’s demo tanked the stock?
- obayesshelton 4y agoI do agree with you here. There is a small smell of "we want to build this" vs "we should buy that"
- falcor84 4y agoGenerally I'd agree, but I'd give Sam Altman more credit than this. He's been in this game for almost two decades, both as a CEO and as a VC investor.
- nailer 4y agoThey are. Google haven’t released a major product in fifteen years. 80% of their revenue is still advertising.
- thecleaner 4y agoAnd that's perfectly fine. Nobody else does it better. Plus why should Google focus on other non profitable verticals
- danpalmer 4y agoGoogle Play was started within the last 15 years (just turned 10 years old). I think it's "major" in all the ways that matter.
- nailer 4y agoYep, was at Google for the rebrand from Google Market. Google Market I think was 2007/2008, Android was acquired 18 years ago.
- pb7 4y agoGoogle Photos was launched in 2015 and has well over a billion active users. If that’s not major then neither is anything YC has ever produced.
- nailer 4y agoYes because Google Photos is part of Android, an 18 year old acquisition.
- pb7 4y agoThat’s not what Google Photos is. It was first introduced with Google+.
- nailer 4y agoIt’s cloud storage for photos - hardly a category defining product comparable to search, maps, docs, or android - and it absolutely comes with Android. How many iPhone users skip apple photos and install google photos like they do with maps?
- davidy123 4y agoGoogle is still about sources. That deserves respect. If this new wave of deep learning AI means sources are hard to find, that's unfair and dangerous because it's hard to validate and correct information. The downfall of using deep learning as a shortcut to the symbolic AI approach. A good AI search result should look like an annotated research paper, or a well curated Wikipedia article.
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoGoogle is about sources? Google just delivers the most popular sites. Not sure what you mean when you say it's about sources.
- kennyadam 4y agoYou can see where any result Google gives you has come from. Ask it for the weather today and it'll say at the bottom that it's sourced from weather.com. ChatGPT and the like are completely opaque.
- seydor 4y agoIn case you missed the demo, the bing GPT adds references to its results
- davidy123 4y agoYes, but there's not always a direct line, it implies it has an answer then … The whole batteries in the ocean thing is what happens.
- jug 4y agoAnd how did it pick the facts out of these sources and compile it into a conclusion? That is a black box you will simply have to either trust or second guess everything it replies with. The first choice is naivety and the second choice is arguably a poor product. A more honest "knowledge engine" would be one that did not draw conclusions but simply replied with the links relevant to your question, letting you judge the quality and draw your own conclusions to not have the engine carry that burden itself. And then you are back to a traditional search engine again.
- thecleaner 4y agoNow he's the founder of chat gpt ?
- jasmer 4y agoSam Altman is not a 'ChatGPT founder' and he's the PR man for a research institution, not a business, so he's should be wary of comparing his org. to Google. Though he's obviously right. What's interesting is that so few people are in a position to say it out loud. That says a lot about the power dynamics of the Tech World. Sam obviously has another 'lazy monopoly' to protect him from the fallout from his PR statements; or more likely they're chosen words and he's now working for the 'other lazy monopoly' saying what Satya does won't say. Everyone should recognize the fact this language is being used as a welcome shakeup in the system. When Epic spoke out against Apple they failed to start a revolution and paid a heavy price, though it's likely they did get some balls rolling. If any of you are younger than 30 it might literally have been since you were a teenager that we had a lot of 'game' in the system. Things have consolidated in the last decade, it really did used to be much more wild. I'm not being cynical, negative or even 'harshly Darwinian' when I state that I really hope one of the Big Cos crashes and burns. The system needs to be loosened up. We don't need 'decentralization' but we do need out from under the thumb of the very powerful tech companies.
- ikt 4y agoHow did this get to the top of HN?
- jgrahamc 4y agoLogged in Hacker News users clicked the small equilateral triangle that points upwards sufficient number of times for score from the decay algorithm to move this above other stories whose score from the decay algorithm was lower.
- l5870uoo9y 4y agoSensationalism? With phrases like "AI war".
- jug 4y agoHe's touching a current topic with the launch of Bing AI which many consider might be transformative. But yes, "we" should know better at Hacker News and separate the mud slinging from the news.
- skilled 4y agoI love that people are not recognizing the fact that Google has been doing this ChatGPT stuff (to an extent) for years now. "People also ask", "Featured Snippets", the sidebar card panel for big topics. All Google has to do now is redo their UI a bit to make you the user feel like they are experiencing the ChatGPT experience. It's also obscenely hilarious how much hype there is around this whole topic, knowing very well that neither Google or Bing will turn their search engines into the actual ChatGPT interface. You think Google is about to wipe out its ad business to appease a small portion of its userbase? Think again.
- webscout 4y ago[dead]
- mejutoco 4y ago> redo their UI a bit to make you the user feel like they are experiencing the ChatGPT experience. > You think Google is about to wipe out its ad business to appease a small portion of its userbase? These 2 points are in conflict, because of the innovators dilemma: they might be hesitant to cannibalize a good business.
- bbor 4y agoWhy couldn’t you show ads next to the responses as usual? AFAICT the main new feature here is AI responses next to/above links, and if there’s links on a page then there could be ads. Either that or they switch google search to display ads and everyone looses their minds at once
- revskill 4y agoBecause Google hides it intentionally, so less people notice it. Why hide ? Because it's not as "smart" as real ChatGPT. You can think like an add-on.
- jasmer 4y agoI think this sentiment is misplaced. Both Google and MS are about to rewire their businesses in a more than superficial way to accomodate this kind of 'search'. Yes - a lazy incumbency won't want to adjust their algorithms - but MS will force their hand. ChatGPT is a bit like what we always imagined or wanted out of Siri and it represents a new dimension of quality interaction. Google was 'search' really now it's 'finder' chatGPT is like 'helper' and they will be a bit fused. The challenge is going to be how can Google remain true to search and find, whilst overlaying 'interactive helper'.
- nlstitch 4y agoGIF of someone eating popcorn
- retskrad 4y agoChatGPT have changed the game and Google is finally forced to compete again. However, people who say it's doom and gloom for Google can't see the forest for the trees. 1. Google is one of the most beloved brands in the world. Only Apple's brand is stronger. 2. Chrome has taken over Windows and it's the default browser on Android. Also, Google pays Apple to be the default search engine on iOS. 3. Bing.com on desktop is already years behind Google in UI & UX. Add the ChatGPT part on the right side of the search results and it gets from bad to worse. 4. Google will release a competent answer to ChatGPT at I/O 2023. It's going to be much more polished than Microsoft's version. Microsoft will steal some users from Google but Google will recover. Like Satya Nadella said in the recent The Verge interview, they are looking to steal away one user at a time.
- bluescrn 4y agoI don't see a ChatGPT-based search tool as desirable, given that so much effort appears to be going into preventing it from outputting 'wrongthink'. Search for anything vaguely controversial and it'll likely just respond with its equivalent of “I'm sorry Dave, I'm afraid I can't do that”
- graphe 4y agoGoogle doesn't do that too? I don't need to use chatGPT to look up crime statistics, most of the info that you'd find on these "news" sites are just as bad.
- graphe 4y agoIs Google beloved? It was good. I use YouTube and the experience sucks now, google kills all the cool software they make too. People grudgingly use it but it's not beloved by users. Advertisers might be different.
- pb7 4y agoYou might be in a bubble. There’s a great big world out there that doesn’t share the sentiment you see on HN.
- marban 4y agoAI in serps is like self-driving tech in cars; and Google is like Mercedes who has a reputation and trust to lose when delivering half-ass results (the way Tesla ships products).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjallen 4y agoI think to be a little more specific and accurate here, we could view Google as very much needing to protect its "golden goose". It has this massively profitable search business that it needs to protect at all costs. It doesn't want to be seen as a competitor to everyone publishing web content. If it answers questions in the SERPs it will consume screen space from in-search ads and reduce page clicks to pages that show Google's ads. So I think that is less about lethargy and more about being scared to disrupt itself. If it shows some AI-generated content that is perceived negatively it could cause reputational damage (like Boston Dynamics was) and cause advertisers to not advertise with Google. And this fear is a classical instance of a large company being scared to do anything that could hurt its primary business, which reduces innovation and its ability to act in a forward-thinking way. This gives a chance to competitors that don't have this same fear of hurting their profitable business. Often these are upstarts like OpenAI.
- notahacker 4y agoGoogle's been answering certain questions above the fold in the SERPs for a while, sometimes very well, other times hilariously badly. I'm not sure Bing doing the same thing a bit more with technology probably less suited for typical search questions is quite as disruptive as is being made out...
- jjallen 4y agoMaybe it won't be now, but at the rate these LLMs are improving in a few years it likely will.
- bjarneh 4y agoFor the fellow non native speakers: lethargic adj 1: deficient in alertness or activity; "bullfrogs became lethargic with the first cold nights" [syn: {lethargic}, {unenrgetic}] [ant: {energetic}]
- miroljub 4y agoLethargic and lethargies comes from the old Greek (or was it Latin, too lazy to check). It's a relatively common loan word in most of the European languages. My guess is that for most slightly educated non-native English speakers that word is more likely to be known than its English equivalent if it exists.
- agilob 4y agoGloves off.
- mr_mitm 4y agoThis development of search engines becoming answer finding machines doesn't sit well with me. It seems that they are confounding two use cases: 1) I want to find a certain website 2) I want to find an answer to this question I have These often overlap, but not always. Google used to be great at 1), then progressively started to solve 2). LLMs are better at 2), but are useless at 1). It's like Google wanted to become a search engine for people who don't even know what a website is and just go to Google for 2). I think the products "search engine" and "chat bot" should stay separate. However, I'd like to see LLMs merged with WolframAlpha.
- ilyt 4y agoand 3) Filter out SEO spam and other crap out of the two. Which is slowly becoming worse, and I'd imagine that would only accelerate now that would-be SEO spammer could just feed ChatGPT like and get a prompt for reasonable (for search engine bot) article
- molasses 4y agoUsing google to find specific websites, only amounts to me typing hacker news or facebook. That's about it. My main bulk of queries are question based, but I'm also from a previous era, where I throw keywords at Google rather than questions, which is a learned response from back then. I do 'ask' google assistant questions, and it doesn't do a bad job at it. I would love it to be a glorified PA and general knowledgeable 'person' I can go to for advice. At the same time, I've containered much of my interaction with Google so it can't draw on my past history. So I have no idea what I'm missing. It did have a tendency to feedback loop a bit too much for me in the past, pigeon holing me to specific websites. There's a huge trust issue, you leak your ID in about four common regular queries so I'm not so sure I can even beat it.
- bbor 4y agoImagine teaching an LLM to guess whether the user wants 1 or 2, and in the case of links it can curate the best ones based on their exhaustive logs of your browsing history and demographics. A beautiful, technically stunning, only slightly dystopian future The core point here is that search isn’t going away, LLMs are just being added on top. They’re not gonna just turn off their page ranking algos, cause LLMs are worse than useless without cited sources
- LeanderK 4y agoThe fact that Google has an honestly enormous investment into AI for years invalidates this statement, probably the biggest of all players. Google has the skill to quickly produce a competitor, they have a lot of experience and capabilities in the ML-area. They were also so early that you can't frame them as a slow moving monopoly. An early investment and strong commitment does not guarantee for you to be the first, as we have seen with ChatGPT. But I think google can move so quickly that it won't matter much. This also means we are not yet in AI-Winter. Yeah!
- jsemrau 4y agoNot to be snarky, but investing in AI and building amazing products around it are two different shoes. I am developing quite heavily in AI and hardly found a use for Google's ecosystem. Colab is nice, I guess but the documentation is impossible to comprehend and just running a local Jupyter notebook to test a few things is usually much more efficient.
- jsemrau 4y agoGoogle lost their way since 2015. What used to be a beacon of innovation and inspiration to push forward has stagnated into an also-ran of amazing but boring tech. Absolutely YouTube has been the most successful Social Network of last 7 years. It is amazingly powerful and I use it daily. But, Google bought Youtube in 2006 and the platform largely benefited from improvements in networking and productivity tools more than in product innovations. With ChatGPT I use Google search significantly less when writing code and debugging errors. What's the point of search if most I can get are promoted results?
- revskill 4y agoPromotion is good. Competition is good. The issue is, promotion by more $$$, instead of more quality.
- marban 4y agoTo out-GPU someone in the short run doesn't mean you will out-innovate them in the long run.
- Idiot_in_Vain 4y agoReminds me of the time one of the Netscape founders called Windows a “Poorly Debugged Set of Device Drivers”. That really got Microsoft moving and a few years later IE6 won the first browser war.
- quickthrower2 4y agoCounter point would be often you want to land on page crafter by a human rather than an AI summary. Especially with the provenance of who wrote it and trust in that site. The irony being this story is interesting because Sam Altman is involved in it as much as what it has to say. Where as asking chatgpt what it thinks of Google strategy would produce the usual drivel - but even if it were great drivel it would still not be a real viewpoint produced by someone with insight, so you couldn’t trust it much deeper than basic facts.
- falcor84 4y ago>Counter point would be often you want to land on page crafter by a human rather than an AI summary. I might pay for this if this was indeed possible. A very big chunk of the results on a typical google search are to algorithmically-generated content, and this will probably only grow.
- plehoux 4y agoI think Google is fine. Will win this in the end. But I was curious about DuckDuckGo and Gabriel's take on this, https://twitter.com/yegg https://twitter.com/yegg... not a word. AI is a scale game, how can they offer this without blowing all their revenues to MS?
- SilverBirch 4y agoI very much feel like Google today is going through what Meta went through for the last 5 years, and what MSFT went through in the early 2010s. Everyone absolutely insisting the company was dying and that the end was nigh.... whilst the company absolutely continued to crush it. Yes yes innovators dilemma, sure. Do you think maybe Google also know about the innovators dilemma? Do you think maybe the fact that they basically invented big chunks of the underlying tech for this indicates that they're not going to just sit on their hands? Even if Bing successfully sticks a ChatGPT into it's search engine to give you a first good guess before you have to look at the actual search results... do you know what will happen? Google will do the same, and everyone will keep using Google. Why? Because if the ChatGPT answer is wrong, no one wants to pay the price of using Bing. Google has an enormous incumbency advantage. Search is going nowhere.
- bob_theslob646 4y ago>Search is going nowhere. The entire model of it is shifting. Prior to chatgpt, it was ad supported, now that it is 100% in flux in my opinion.
- SilverBirch 4y agoAgain, going back to the comparison, everyone is still using Windows, every is still using Facebook. They're no longer the new sexy innovative thing, but they're both enormous and massively useful as leverage to push into other markets. Microsoft Azure exists entirely as a result of Microsoft's leverage that they established with Windows.
- quickthrower2 4y agoCrappy site. Horses mouth: https://stratechery.com/2023/new-bing-and-an-interview-with-kevin-scott-and-sam-altman-about-the-microsoft-openai-partnership/ https://stratechery.com/2023/new-bing-and-an-interview-with-... and scroll to near the bottom
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stephc_int13 4y agoThere is not much debate about it, Google did not see this coming, and so far they are reacting poorly, but this is expected. ChatGPT demos only highlighted the fact that search could be so much better than what we have today, people were already disappointed/bored by Google search, but the status quo was seen as too entrenched. Now Google search is really looking bad and outdated, and quite a lot of us are realizing that something much better is possible. The AI war has started, this is good, healthy competition, for once.
- timeon 4y ago> The AI war has started, this is good, healthy competition, for once. As much as I don't like SEO driven search I'm not sure if this is right direction. From technical point of view it could be but I'm worried how this will be gamed.
- stephc_int13 4y agoDifficult to predict, the current state of ML might not be practical yet, only time will tell. I have no idea about the potential roadblocks ahead. But we can all see the potential. The thing is, old search is dead (and has been for a while if we're being honest) so it will be replaced by something at some point. No matter what, I believe that monopolies are bad and competition is good, but of course we could end up with something even worse than what Google search is today.
- jug 4y agoI just generated a C# code snippet with ChatGPT, converting an integer to a base32 string. On a glance, it looked correct. But it could impossibly have generated the given answer because it helpfully claimed how it used Crockford's Base32 algorithm (that avoids I, L, 0 and U) and had correctly adapted the code for that. However, the answer had an "L" in it. So it could impossibly be correct. And indeed, the entire answer was bogus. And besides, it forgot to tell that this algorithm also avoided "U" in its explanation of what characters it avoided. ChatGPT is littered with these things once you actually get down to business with it. This raises many philosophical questions for me. Is the AI hype trumping responsibility? When is AI good enough? "Always check your sources", sure, but the point with AI is that it can, and will, reply to questions where sources are missing by compiling a very large sum of knowledge and drawing conclusions. Do you think these are words Sam will have to eat up? Of course, Google search results can also lie, but at least you know which kinds of sites you are looking at and if they are renowned. The new Bing Chat AI _will_ list its sources but it's still drawing conclusions and compiling facts from cherry picked data from the sites. So you still end up squinting, second guessing it. I'm sure I will jump on to the new Bing AI ASAP, hell I'm a computer engineer after all and get hyped about these things, but I also admit that the failure of LLM/GPT AI to admit uncertainty, but conversely also be very willing to be bold. A dangerous combination if there ever was one that I think is an early red flag we should heed to.
- adenozine 4y agoWhat is Sam Altman’s credibility again, besides wealth? Are we to assume he actually knows anything other than neuro-grift? I’m not buying it.
- rvz 4y ago$10BN is enough for Microsoft to pay Sam Altman to say such nonsense in the name of AI hype. We need another Stable Diffusion-like disruption for ChatGPT and GPT-4 involving open-sourcing the model and being a rather smaller model which can run on device to ruin ClosedAI's rent seeking.
- KingLancelot 4y ago[dead]