6 ms·
> If you look at all the players, their interests, and their capabilities, I think the most logical conclusion is that the US likely did it. I disagree. The m
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> If you look at all the players, their interests, and their capabilities, I think the most logical conclusion is that the US likely did it.
I disagree.
The most logical explanation is tha Russia did it as a capacity demonstration and threat against Baltic Pipe to pressure contries in the region regarding Ukraine, but that, like all their threats against the West over Ukraine policy so far, the threat was hollow.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe US have been overtly against those pipelines and the close relations between Germany and Russia, including and especially energy dependency. In fact, a major win of the US so far in the Ukraine war has been the Europeans' and especially Germany's shift in gas supplies from Russia to themselves. Russia destroying their own pipelines (both NS 1 and the new NS 2 were sabotaged) looks like them shooting themselves in both feet at once. Like doing 'capacity demonstration' by nuking the Kremlin... They could, but would that be a likely scenario? Many, if not most, expert observers strongly suspect the US for a reason.
- syzarian 4y agoGermany gets its gas natural gas from Norway now. It would be unlikely that the U.S. would attack the gas supplies of a major NATO ally. Especially when that ally has been less than enthusiastic in helping Ukraine. https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/where-does-germany-stand-gas-supply-2023-01-20/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/where-does-germany-s...
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThey get a lot from Norway because it is near and there are pipelines, but US' LNG exports to the EU are through the roof and will keep growing as things get organised. Joe talks a lot: "If Russia invades, that means tanks and troops crossing the border of Ukraine again, then there will be no longer a Nord Stream 2, we will bring an end to it." -- Joe Biden, Feb 2022, with the German's Chancellor standing next to him! [1] So at the very least the US thought that they indeed had control over that "major NATO ally" and could make thinly veiled threats to their face. Why you think that the US would be above sabotage on a matter of strategic national interests is unclear. [1] https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-joe-biden-vladimir-putin-europe-moscow-46f8be10fa71af16bae8f3a9bd82918d https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-joe-biden-vladimir...
- syzarian 4y agoOn February 22, 2022 German Chancellor Scholz suspended certification of Nordstream2 following Russia formally recognizing Donetsk and Luhansk as republics. I believe that, but can’t find a confirming source, that Russia was obligated to make deliveries via Nordstream1 even though it did not have access to SWIFT. By it no longer being operational it was no longer required to make deliveries. It is inconceivable that Biden made that comment without consulting Germany. Also it was primarily Nordstream1 that was attacked. Gas prices spiked and it seems likelier that Russia was behind it. At least to me. I don’t know the truth of the matter.
- pphysch 4y agoWashington, under Obama, was caught spying directly on Angela Merkel and her government. What leads you to believe that Washington has ever respected Germany, which it occupies with tens of thousands of troops, as a sovereign equal?
- syzarian 4y agoIt requires one to be fairly detached from political reality to describe U.S. military forces in German as an occupation. You lose credibility by saying such a thing. You should reconsider the sources of your information.
- pphysch 4y agoOn the contrary, it is an objective portrayal of the facts which is not clouded by political smoke and mirrors. Washington defeated Germany and Japan in the 1940s and proceeded to demilitarize them and occupy them with its own forces. This is historically standard military practice. It is not a "nice gesture" from Washington. It was all part of a coherent strategy to contain and confront the rival USSR, around which Germany and Japan represent critical nodes.
- jonnybgood 4y ago
- theironhammer 4y agoThere's this from George Friedman in 2015 The Chicago Council on Global Affairs (@1:38 mins) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eyfTX5n_fdI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eyfTX5n_fdI where he mentions economic relations between Russia and Germany are the biggest threat to the United States. Also see here https://www.reddit.com/r/jimmydore/comments/10x3yfq/jimmy_dore_ukraine_war_is_about_making_sure/ https://www.reddit.com/r/jimmydore/comments/10x3yfq/jimmy_do...
- rank0 4y agoYou think Russia tried to send a message by……destroying its own infrastructure?! It was their biggest leverage over the EU. Now it’s gone and there’s no possibility of restoring Russian gas flows to the EU. If they were gonna destroy critical international infrastructure wouldn’t it make more sense to blow up something else?
- cactusplant7374 4y agoIf what you say is true, why has Russia blown up their own pipelines twice before?
- treis 4y agoCan you share details?
- cactusplant7374 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34712815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34712815
- rank0 4y agoNeither of the two sources you linked claim that Russia destroyed those pipelines. Play out the game theory here. Russia has nothing to gain and lots of leverage to lose by destroying the pipelines. They can just keep the gas flows off FFS! That doesn’t mean the US was involved but it makes zero sense for the Russians to do it to themselves.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoIf your standard of proof is that Russia admits it this conversation won’t go far. Russia is the only one that benefits. Russia weaponizes energy. Many people assume Russia is rational but it’s just not true. Like John McCain said, it’s a gas station run by gangsters. > They can just keep the gas flows off FFS! Russia would have to pay penalties in the contract. They don’t want to do that. > That doesn’t mean the US was involved but it makes zero sense for the Russians to do it to themselves. See above points. It is clearly not “zero.”
- bluecalm 4y agoYou don't need to demonstrate ability to blow up your own pipeline close to your own territorial waters. If it's Russia (which I don't think is very likely) I find it more believable that it's the result of internal politics as an option of killing the tzar, withdrawing from Ukraine and making a deal with the West to go back to old normal is now off the table.
- diimdeep 4y agoThe most logical explanation of why you have so much karma is that you write anything that will get you upvoted, no matter how stupid it is.