4 ms·
It's strange that the count increase too much near the wall. If you have a 1/r^2 decreasement from a point source, the if you have an infinite wall it becomes
by gus_massa 4y ago
It's strange that the count increase too much near the wall.
If you have a 1/r^2 decreasement from a point source, the if you have an infinite wall it becomes a constant value that does not decrease with the distance.
Clearly the wall is not infinite, but when the distance from the wall is much smaller (1/5?) than the distance to the border of the wall, the approximation is good enough. The wall is like 8 tiles tall , so I expect the radioactivity at 1/2 tile (15cm, 5in) to be almost equal to the radioactivity when the counter is touching the wall.
- perihelions 4y agoYes, I noticed that too. I think it's mainly beta radiation close to the wall. It would be attenuated by air absorption further away.
- gnramires 4y agoGood question. Another intuitive way to view (no pun intended) 1/r^2 law is that the solid angle visible from an isotropic emitter (like supposedly this wall) gives the exact decay coefficient. So near the surface the solid angle is like 1/2 sphere (1/2 4pi), and doesn't change much with distance. Only when you get a bit further away it starts to decrease. Eventually at large distances, any finite object will have the apparent radius decay as 1/r and solid angle as 1/r^2. I think in this case it could be atmospheric absorption or just getting near a peak point of emission.
- penteract 4y agoDoes that apply if the emitter is neither coherent nor opaque? If we were interested in gamma radiation, is the sum from each part of an infinite wall infinite (if we pretend the wall and the air are perfectly transparent to gamma rays)?
- gnramires 4y agoNote that in this case radiation is definitely incoherent. This rule applies to incoherent isotropic emission. The coherent case is similar I believe, but because for an antenna (emitter) the field is usually tangent to the surface, you get some additional trigonometric factors (not purely solid angle). But by my calculations it's still 1/r^2.
- penteract 4y agoAm I doing a calculation wrong then? For e.g. gravity towards an infinite plane, then the force is finite because components in opposite directions cancel out, but for radiation, then if you're 1m away from the wall, you could consider an infinite set of disjoint squares on the wall, each 2^n meters by 2^n meters and with the furthest point 2^(n+1) meters away from you. Since 2^2n / ((2^(n+1))^2) is 1/4 and an underestimate for the radiation you would receive from each section of wall, then the total radiation should be infinite.
- gnramires 4y agoOh you might be right! I think what I wrote is incorrect in this case. For gravity, it's clear the orientation of a small surface doesn't influence its gravitational force. In fact the source can be replaced by a point of equivalent mass. For radiation, it seems the angle of a surface matters? For example, lambertian surfaces (everyday diffuse surfaces) do depend on their angle for total incoming radiation? Does only reflection exhibit lambertian behavior? There's something funny at work here. In the lambertian case, there's a cosine term making your terms go to zero and sum converge. When observing a small oblique (lambertian) surface, you get less radiation by a factor of cos(angle). I believe this is true for black body radiators as well (think a small glowing plate emitting red light). I'm not completely sure it would be true for x-ray and high energy radiation, and intuitively I suspect it indeed isn't. It seems like for high energy emissions, or generally isolated emissions (discounting opaqueness), only the total power is relevant like in gravity. I think self-absorption might be the culprit here. If we say self-absorption (material absorption) in the high energy case is roughly negligible, then it becomes more strongly non-lambertian and the received power is simply a 1/r^2 integral (which would also explain why radiation gets stronger as it approaches the surface). --- Here's a simple proof of the solid angle formula I've found I believe is correct for lambertian surfaces: chop your object into infinitesimal pieces (limit goes to 0). For each piece, it tends to behave like a point, so we expect the radiation scaling with distance to be 1/r^2. But solid angle also scales as 1/r^2 for small enough pieces. (it's probably missing many technicalities to make the proof work, but I think it works). Note that for oblique surfaces their solid angle is a function of cos(angle), which follows Lambert's cosine law exactly as well.
- hanslub42 4y agoUranium (both U238 and U235) is an alpha-emitter. Alpha particles travel at most a few centimeters in air.
- addandsubtract 4y agoThis is U8, though.
- snovv_crash 4y ago(that's the name of the subway line for any non-Berliners who might be confused)
- gus_massa 4y agoThat's a good explanation! I made a mistake and assumed it was Beta or Gamma radiation that travel easier in air.
- tomxor 4y ago> If you have a 1/r^2 decreasement from a point source, the if you have an infinite wall it becomes a constant value that does not decrease with the distance. It will still decrease with distance. If you represent the wall as a collection of point sources distributed over a plane, as the distance to the plane diminishes, the distance to individual points do not diminish to and from the same distance as each other, and do not diminish at the same rate. However they still all diminish, and thus the sum intensity must diminish. Though the appropriate function describing the sum of the contributions from each point is no longer 1/d^2. There will be some continuous equation to describe this... someone more familiar with radiance feel free to chime in!
- thehappypm 4y agoThey’re referencing a classic Electricity & Magnetism proof. Given an infinite sheet of uniform charge density, the electric field is constant at all distances from the sheet, which is deeply unintuitive.
- tomxor 4y agoThat is unintuitive, but then is my mistake only in representing the wall as an infinite plane? Would my parent comment still be true for a finite plane, or is that merely technically true but missing the point of the function shape being almost constant up to some threshold (depending on the limits of the finite plane). I feel like I want to plot this now to build an intuition.
- AdamN 4y agoThe problem is that this wall does not exist in a vacuum - the OPs comment is otherwise valid. The air is absorbing the radiation (very effectively).
- tomxor 4y agoYes, I understand that. I'm wondering separately (in a vacuum if you will), what the falloff looks like with a finite plane, and how that relates to the infinite version. Obviously we cannot actually represent the wall as an infinite plane, from my current location it's accurate enough to represent it as a point source... so there is some threshold for a particular finite plane after which the "constant" nature is clearly not true.