3 ms·
The key difference is that systemd is system-wide orchestration, and docker-compose controls a specific set of containers connected in a specific day, and likel
by nine_k 4y ago
The key difference is that systemd is system-wide orchestration, and docker-compose controls a specific set of containers connected in a specific day, and likely otherwise isolated from the system. The latter allows to "ship" entire configurations that work together, as one unit.
- mariusor 4y agoI think that existing tooling on nix environments can work much better than docker compose to aggregate a set of containers and resources. Setting resource limits using cgroups, isolating users/paths/networks using the capabilities of systemd and all together used from a common shell script seems more expressive and more versatile than using docker/docker compose and requiring an extra daemon to deal with everything.
- scns 4y agoMore expressive? I think so too. Less convenient? I think so. Sadly history shows that convenience wins.
- sitkack 4y agoIf you have to roll your own, you now own it. This should be a huge bar, and better isn’t enough. This is the same flexibility trap as C++ build systems. Whereas in Cargo, adding a dependency is a single line. Knowledge and practices that are pulled from the ecosystem compose, and can be ephemeral in ways that hand rolled solutions are not.
- Jnr 4y agoThe thing with docker-compose.yml is that it is well known, well documented and relatively easy to learn and get running even for more complex configurations. I would not want to go through that common shell script for every new project because it would probably look very different from project to project.