5 ms·
> I am only left with one question which I did not find answered anywhere yet - what exactly does day and night mean in the context of the whole world trading?
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> I am only left with one question which I did not find answered anywhere yet - what exactly does day and night mean in the context of the whole world trading?
While we're at it, I have a related question: why do the exchanges even "open" and "close"? Surely in our globalized digital economy, it's not just "day" and "night" that are meaningless, but the very concept of "opening hours" itself.
- erfgh 4y agoProbably due to labor unions.
- techdragon 4y agoActually, it’s mostly down to the computers now. Having downtime is advantageous to the primary customers of the stock market. If you have the same “off and on” times as your competitors you can ensure your operations are structured in such a way that you don’t have to deal with a whole class of systemic risks, no need to roll out up’s to FPGA powered acceleration devices live where the smallest mistakes can cost money for every second they are wrong let alone if they are broken … to more mundane things like being able to reprocess the data trading data and analyse performance vs other prediction models… effectively the downtime is for the high frequency traders and the algorithm traders and all the players paying for direct access to the stock market for their computer systems… it’s effective a digital cage match from bell ring to closing time and it’s in the best interests of all the competitors to only have to fight the same 8-12 hours in the cage, lest it becomes a much more expensive 24/7 war of attrition.
- andy_jensen 4y agoYea, and people who drive electric cars!
- twic 4y agoI'd be interested to know how you came to that conclusion.
- bobthepanda 4y agoAs a profession, Wall Street traders could not be farther from unionized.
- cmcconomy 4y agothe stock market has "gone woke"
- twic 4y agoHistorically, it's because exchanges were real places that people went to, and it would be expensive and pointless to run them all night. These days, there is a trend towards opening hours getting longer (eg [1]). But there is still value to limited hours. Off the top of my head: 1. Liquidity gets concentrated. If there is a fixed amount of end-user demand (inflows into pension funds, oil production to hedge), then shorter hours means sort of 'denser' trading, which in turn means more quantity on the books, tighter prices, and better efficiency. 2. Trading is still done under human direction, or at least under human supervision, so shorter hours are less demanding on staffing. It's possible to run a productive soybean trading desk with two people at the moment. You'd need six people if trading was round the clock, and those people aren't cheap. Or else desks don't trade the whole day, and they miss out on opportunities, and other participants get less competition, and so worse efficiency. 3. Closing the market gives participants time to do various kinds of admin related to trading. Options markets close earlier than their corresponding futures markets, so that options market makers can get their position cleanly hedged. Bond markets close before repo desk traders go to the pub, so that bond trades can get financed. [1] https://www.eurex.com/resource/blob/2845114/ae56de359f7a578ebbc0b107cd379d84/data/presentation_trading-hours-extension.pdf https://www.eurex.com/resource/blob/2845114/ae56de359f7a578e...
- devnullbrain 4y ago>Closing the market gives participants time to do various kinds of admin related to trading. Trading firms can restart their software to fix the memory leaks.
- cwillu 4y agoJust another generation in the garbage collector.
- dahfizz 4y agoIf anyone is wondering, this is not a joke. Some of the trading systems I've worked on were designed to be restarted every night. The memory didn't "leak", but was designed this way - preallocate all the memory you could need, and its "freed" when you restart at night.
- vjk800 4y agoThe world of finance is full of anachronisms like this. Exchanges are also closed on various bank holidays which are different in every country.
- em500 4y agoYup, that's why I think that stories about the benefits of having HFTs providing micro-second liquidity are bunk. Even without holidays and weekends, large stock exchanges only operate 7 hours per day, with a 17 hour gap of non-liquidity every day.
- jjoonathan 4y agoIt's not an anachronism. Liquid markets behave verrry differently from illiquid markets. In liquid markets, "AAPL is $141.23" makes sense. It means that you can expect to buy and sell almost as much AAPL as you want at very close to that price because there are loads of buyers and sellers near that price. You can pretend that AAPL stocks have a price like a lamp at home depot: "I would like 2 AAPL please" is a safe thing to say. In illiquid markets, "AAPL is $141.23" does not make sense. "I would like 2 AAPL please" is not safe at all. There are bids and offers, but not necessarily a lot of them, and not necessarily near each other. If you were to place the "2 AAPL please" order (or something related like "$500 of AAPL please"), you might find that you have purchased 1 AAPL for $141.23 and 1 AAPL for $299.57 because there was a big gap in the order book. The price abstraction completely breaks down and you have to "haggle" with bids and offers directly. "Ok," you might say, "liquidity is important, but surely we can just let the bots provide liquidity at night?" The problem is that markets are adversarial and bots can't really deal with "attacks" as well as humans (or at least the humans staking the money don't trust them to). There is all sorts of craziness that a market-making bot can't handle, and if you encourage people to rely exclusively on market-making bots then they can be taken advantage of (oh no, AAPL is down 50%, better sell, wtf, price shot right back up, rage). It's safer and smarter to just have everyone agree on convenient blocks of time to crowd into the market. During those periods of time the market can be assumed liquid. The price abstraction works. "But I'm a big boy and I want to live in the danger zone, let me trade at night!" Go right ahead. It's not only possible, it's readily available and people do it all the time. You can probably request some degree of after-hours trading from your brokerage right this minute. It's usually pretty easy -- usually you just have to ask for them to enable permission and promise that you know what a limit order is. Usually market orders are disabled, too, because they know that plenty of people would hit "accept," shoot themselves in the foot, and complain anyway :)
- andreareina 4y agoI don't know if it's the reason, but I understand that a lot of market-moving news is released after close so that participants have time to digest it and decide whether their positions still make sense. The next day's opening auction will deal with the increased volatility better (see the story about the NYSE "forgetting" to hold the opening auction and the resulting chaos)
- dahfizz 4y agoNobody just presses "start" on their trading algo and takes a nap the rest of the day. Even market makers, who have a simple and easily-automatable trading strategy, have a team of traders constantly tweaking the parameters to their algos. I guess they could hire a second and third shift, but they also could have done that back when stocks were traded on paper and over the phone. The will just isn't there.