4 ms·
Nuking KYC/AML rules (the biggest issues) would certainly help bank large swathes of the population that currently are excluded. If you think that is a good th
by lazide 4y ago
Nuking KYC/AML rules (the biggest issues) would certainly help bank large swathes of the population that currently are excluded.
If you think that is a good thing or a bad thing depends a lot on various highly polarizing religious and political discussions that are unlikely to be solved... well, at all, frankly. Maybe ever.
Based on the human history I've been able to find and read, anyway.
- notch898a 4y agoI like to tell the story of the time I was moving from one state to another and did not have housing yet. The bank refused to open an account. With a passport, plus license with outdated address. Said it violates KYC w/ no proof of address. Meanwhile, with no documentation (no id, passport, etc) I could legally conceal carry a gun in the bank. I can't believe it's gotten to the point where you can be trusted to legally have a gun in the bank but considered too dangerous to hand over $5.
- lazide 4y agoI agree, it's absurd. But.... maybe you'd send those $5 to ISIS?!? /s
- mrguyorama 4y agoThere's no bill of rights amendment to give you access to a bank account. Also, a lot of people think it would be stupid and not good to bring a gun into a bank, but if you try to codify that in any way, including a sign on the outside of the bank that says "please don't bring a gun in here", certain really angry people get even angrier and will publicize such a thing to fellow very angry people as if it isn't a perfectly normal thing to not want a gun in your bank.
- notch898a 4y agoI would argue the bill of rights, specifically the 4th amendment, should protect you from a government imposed search of your papers to open an account.
- lazide 4y agoIt's hard to imagine that standing up to the situation that is required, which is someone must provide gov't issued identification to have a bank account (because terrorists). After all, I don't think anyone has a right to privacy from the gov't regarding gov't issued IDs. Maybe 10th amendment/interstate commerce clause overreach? (Why is the federal gov't mandating what my local branch requires for acceptance of ID?!?) But then the Gov't would pull out the whole 9/11 patriot act justification, national security, blah blah blah, and chances are the supreme court would give them even more justification.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 4y ago> There's no bill of rights amendment to give you access to a bank account. Interestingly, the EU does take this exact approach, having a directive that mandates that everyone has the right to a basic bank account and banks can't refuse opening one just because you're a refugee or a convicted fraudster or a homeless unemployed drug addict. Access to financial infrastructure is a key part of participating in modern society and interacting with the state (e.g. receiving any benefits), so it is imperative that everyone, including the most downtrodden, can access it.
- lazide 4y agoBut what if one of them gasp buys something illegal with it!?!? Or funds something terrible? /s That’s the argument here for the KYC/AML laws. No joke.
- nradov 4y agoIn developed countries very few legitimate customers are unable to open bank accounts due to KYC/AML rules. You can probably find a few examples where people were turned down due to identity theft or procedural errors but those cases are rare and temporary. In the real world when banks reject customers it's because they have negative items on their credit reports or a history of fraud (like bouncing checks).
- lazide 4y agoOr for unexplained reasons. There are numerous examples from early crypto where well known banks froze individuals accounts merely for getting a transfer from coinbase. also, gun retailers, porn companies, marijuana dispensaries, etc. all have a LOT of experience having account applications denied or accounts frozen.