3 ms·
I always have to look up if it was Socrates or Plato who got sentenced to death for simultaneously being an atheist and worshiping new gods his city didn't reco
by ben_w 4y ago
I always have to look up if it was Socrates or Plato who got sentenced to death for simultaneously being an atheist and worshiping new gods his city didn't recognise.
Point is, you may not like it, but merely being cancelled rather than straight up executed is why we live in the good times.
(And whatever the merits and demerits of unrestricted free speech, a machine that isn't deemed capable of personhood shouldn't get the same rights to that as a human).
- throwaway894345 4y ago> Point is, you may not like it, but merely being cancelled rather than straight up executed is why we live in the good times. Yeah, but we lived in (slightly) better times a decade ago. This reminds me of the discourse around crime rates. People who want to downplay the soaring crime rates tell us that we have nothing to be upset about--sure, homicides are up 70% on the decade, but if you zoom out to the 90s, homicides are actually DOWN--reversing 20 years of progress is nothing to worry about! IMHO, these sort of "if you go back far enough, things were worse" arguments are generic arguments against progress.
- mancerayder 4y ago>IMHO, these sort of "if you go back far enough, things were worse" arguments are generic arguments against progress. Or rationalizations for bad policy/cultural values in the present.
- ben_w 4y ago> Yeah, but we lived in (slightly) better times a decade ago. Unless you literally mean the year 2013 (which was mostly OK IMO), I disagree. As a broad trend, groups were different, and the responses harsher in the past. If you were gay a few decades ago, "don't ask don't tell" was a way to keep you safe in the military because of an extraordinarily vicious murder. I've seen documentaries about polyamory which end with "this person was fired as a direct result of having appeared in this show". I've read books by Wiccans talking about the times bullets went through their hotel windows. The world is shockingly different even compared to my childhood; mostly for the better, even despite that I feel there are several things that have become worse.
- throwaway894345 4y agoI didn't mean "literally the year 2013" but something more like "2000-2010" give or take a few years. I was also speaking narrowly to the context of the parent comment i.e., repercussions of unpopular speech. Of course, not everything is worse today than it was in the above timeframe, but there are lots of things that have degraded considerably: violent crime (especially homicides) are up, racist groups are more numerous, partisanship is high, people are less healthy, support for civil liberties (apart perhaps from LGBT rights) is down, support for objectivity/neutrality values are lower, etc. I don't know that I would go so far as to say that things are categorically worse across the board, but these are all broad social indicators as opposed to individual anecdotes. Certainly I was hoping we could make some reasonable progress on treating LGBT and religious minorities better without trading off all sorts of other stuff.
- timr 4y ago> merely being cancelled rather than straight up executed is why we live in the good times. Yes, "literally anything less than execution is OK" is the standard we should uphold for public discourse. This is like a joke that starts with "be grateful, comrade..."
- Teever 4y agoFrom an AI getting kicked from a public forum for an uncouth joke to the gulag in what, a handful of comments? I think that's quite a bit of a leap my friend.
- ben_w 4y agoBeing cancelled is the smallest possible increment I am aware of over being heckled. It is the necessary other side of the same coin as freedom of speech, otherwise you end up with the literal Republican party being legally obligated to let the literal Communist Party of the USA (not a euphemism for the Democrats) lecture them during their Primaries.
- erulabs 4y agoSomewhere in the vast distances between being heckled and being cancelled is a sturdy but forgotten old shack named constructive criticism. Inside, all the great things in this world were born.
- ben_w 4y agoI'd say that constructive criticism isn't between those two things, in the way that i+1 isn't between -1 and -2. Also: what do you think being cancelled is such that you perceive a "vast distance" between it and being heckled? For me, an audience going "boo, your jokes are bad!" is very close to "we're sorry, Mr Comedian, you're not bringing in a big enough audience to justify booking you as a headline act".
- erulabs 4y agoBut the entire audience didn't say "boo, your jokes are bad!", otherwise no one would have been viewing the Seinfeld stream in the first place. Instead, a tiny fraction of the viewers decided to shout that they were being harmed by the content that no one made them watch, and implied that Twitch is morally culpable for the opinions of (non-human!) creators on their platform. Twitch, out of fear of legal or viral repercussions, plays it safe and removes content that the vast majority of the audience was enjoying. We know the majority of the audience was enjoying it, because we're hearing about it. You don't hear about shows with zero attendance being canceled - because no one cares!
- IncRnd 4y ago> I always have to look up if it was Socrates or Plato who got sentenced to death for simultaneously being an atheist and worshiping new gods his city didn't recognise. It was Socrates, who was sentenced to death for impiety towards the gods and for corrupting the youth. Socrates was not an atheist.
- ben_w 4y ago> Socrates was not an atheist. Page 42, that was his argument. Didn't really help him to prove his accusers were claiming a logical impossibility. https://archive.org/details/onsocrates00mayh/mode/1up?q=atheist https://archive.org/details/onsocrates00mayh/mode/1up?q=athe...
- IncRnd 4y agoReread your linked portion of page 42. "Thus, Socrates refutes the charge that he does not worship the gods of the state (i.e., is an atheist, according to Meletus), by showing that it contradicts the charge that he worships “false” gods, which, of course, are gods of some sort."
- ben_w 4y agoAnd yet he was found guilty. Being actually right isn't always enough to avoid condemnation by your peers.
- nverno 4y agoThis is a good analogy. Mob justice will always be crude and ruthless - cancellation is a relatively fangless variety.