6 ms·
I don't think people realize how much of our understanding of physics needs to be broken for aliens to be visiting us. Or that these creatures are willing to sp
by godelski 4y ago
I don't think people realize how much of our understanding of physics needs to be broken for aliens to be visiting us. Or that these creatures are willing to spend decades or generations away from their planet/home/family. Space is a hell of a lot bigger than people really think. Even several times the speed of light is slow in terms of these interstellar distances.
- ALittleLight 4y agoThe UFOs could be autonomous, or they could originate from within our solar system.
- godelski 4y agoI wrote a longer post and linked to the sibling comment. Yes, they could be autonomous. But there are still issues with that, specifically with the time for the communication to get back "home." (see sibling comment) This doesn't make things impossible, but it definitely decreases the likelihood. As for within our solar system, I'm fairly certain this isn't true. There would be a crazy amount of effort to hide all that. Like you're hiding an entire civilization from x-rays, visible light, infrared, and radio. A civilization that would be constantly monitored (we pay a lot of attention to local objects). Possible, but these aliens clearly spent a lot of energy and resources to undertake this but have also hidden that resource collection (there's a feedback problem here). Combined with that we aren't sure for mechanisms for life. I'm not going to hold my breath.
- ALittleLight 4y agoAutonomous devices wouldn't need to send signals back home. They might be fully autonomous. Also, I don't think we can rule out aliens within our solar system. An alien civilization beneath the ocean of some moon?
- godelski 4y ago> Autonomous devices wouldn't need to send signals back home. They might be fully autonomous. To... what? Study a civilization and do nothing with the data? > Also, I don't think we can rule out aliens within our solar system. An alien civilization beneath the ocean of some moon? Yeah, we pretty much can. Odds are extremely low. Now, life might exist, but not advanced space fairing life. Those civilizations produce a lot of noise and make drastic changes to their planets (/moons).
- krageon 4y agoAnd of course it is easy to know in every case what those changes look like and what this noise sounds like. At every point of development.
- MockObject 4y ago> To... what? Study a civilization and do nothing with the data? Arguments like this neglect the relative inscrutability of even human motivations, with which we ought to be intimately familiar, yet can nevertheless perplex us. Humans undertake spectacular projects as jokes, religious activities, and as art. There's really no speculating about equivalent, befuddling alien motivations, and certainly nothing to rule out autonomous devices that travel unfathomable distances, and then play hide and seek when approached directly.
- vbezhenar 4y agoCan you elaborate on that? As I see it. Let's say that human civilization does not turn Earth to a nuclear wasteland but rather resolves its social issues and proceeds with colonization of Solar System. We already sent probe out of our Solar System. It does not look for me to be impossible technology to build a probe with AI and robots smart enough to reach another star system, decelerate there, build some factories on asteroids and copy itself sending copies to further star systems. Of course at the same time exploring its "home" star system and transmit information they got to Earth. So very quickly (in universe scale) our sphere of knowledge will expand limited only by some fuel tanks capacity required to accelerate and decelerate. Yes, there will be years, decades, centuries and millenniums for this information to reach Earth. That's the nature of cosmos (according to our current knowledge) and we will have to deal with it. Eventually probe will find planet with life. May be life is more abundant than we imagine now. May be not. Surely there will be protocols for the probe to investigate life. It's hard to imagine what those protocols would be. May be explore freely until certain technology advances are observed and then hide. So may be our ancestors saw alien probes on a regular basis and just didn't care. But now those probes observe that we've got quick airplanes so they hide better. My point is that developed civilization inevitably will expand its sphere of influence at speed limited by speed of light. Probably slower than that. But billion of years at 0.1c is still huge chunk of universe. Are we sure that no civilization born within this radius billion years ago?
- godelski 4y agoSure, I actually wrote a longer comment here[0]. My understanding of what you're saying (no FTL) kinda falls under point 2 that I made. While I understand the mechanism you're discussing, is a civilization willing to spend a billion years waiting for the information to travel back home? I'd be under the impression that this would be a pure data collection pov and a quite risky one at that. You can't act on that information in a meaningful way since the life evolves drastically within that billion years (but you can study it!). Even in a thousand things change a lot, but at least not evolutionary. The risk is that if anything goes wrong (glitch, crash, etc) then you've kinda contaminated that life system (this includes the transmission of their data). But maybe they don't care and it is an acceptable risk to them. I'm not an alien, I don't know their ethics. Do also take into account that such a project would be a rather massive undertaking and the idea of mining planets left and right is quite noisy. We're about the at the point where we'd start detecting such stuff since we're looking at exo-planets on the regular now. I'll bring up another point that I didn't in my longer post though. Maybe these lifeforms solved things like longevity and so such time constraints aren't meaningful to them. What's a few hundred years when you live millions? > But billion of years at 0.1c is still huge chunk of universe. Are we sure that no civilization born within this radius billion years ago? That's 1,000,000ly fwiw. That does cover the entire Milkey Way (but doesn't get us half way to Andromeda). But also consider that the Milkey Way is 13.6bn years old and life on Earth is 3.7bn. I'm not saying that your idea is crazy, it is definitely possible (and has been proposed by others, in quite high detail). I just think there isn't any evidence for this and there's reason to believe that this would be quite difficult to pull off. But we'll see as time goes on. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34672241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34672241
- literalAardvark 4y agoOur understanding of physics has been broken for 100% of humanity's history. We've greatly increased the amount of things that can be done, but I wouldn't be so confident about the things that can't be done.
- godelski 4y ago> Our understanding of physics has been broken for 100% of humanity's history. I'll let Asimov speak on this because he says it better than I can. But this is not even remotely accurate. We've become less wrong over time. https://hermiene.net/essays-trans/relativity_of_wrong.html https://hermiene.net/essays-trans/relativity_of_wrong.html
- literalAardvark 4y agoThanks, I'll read it. I was quite precise in my wording and didn't say what you are responding to. My opinion (and it's just that, I'm unprepared to defend it) is that we've always been [less and less] wrong on everything. And since we can't know what the boundaries of knowledge are, and it could easily be some insane unbounded fractal existence, it seems rash to me to decide that we know enough to say that there can't exist civilizations whose technology is magic to us.
- the6threplicant 4y agoA lot of things would be demonstratively broken if Special Relativity is wrong.
- literalAardvark 4y agoIt doesn't need to be too wrong, just incomplete. Much like Newton's laws. See my comment in the sibling subthread.
- godelski 4y agoProblem is that this technology breaks our understanding of causality. So it isn't a "less wrong" type of situation so much as we have to rewrite everything. Specifically it means things that happen in the future can affect things in the past (communication past the light cone). The discoveries of quantum and relativity didn't break classical mechanics so much as extend it. But to rewrite how a sequence of events happens, well that's a big fundamental change. The light from my flashlight turning on at t=1 does not force me to press the button to turn it on at t=0.
- crosen99 4y agoOur understanding is so incomplete that we have to posit the presence of dark matter and dark energy - comprising the majority of the universe - to explain the parts we think we do understand. With so much we cannot account for, it seems unwise to have firm beliefs like this about what isn’t possible.
- mikrotikker 4y agoYes exactly its a bit arrogant to think that we know it all or that we can know it all.
- godelski 4y agoThere's a big difference between claiming we know it all and that our understanding is incomplete. There's also a big difference between claiming something is incomplete and that something has to be rewritten from the ground up. I believe our knowledge is incomplete, I do not believe there is something out there that requires us to rewrite everything. The problem here is that to go down this path you need to violate quite a few fundamental aspects of physics that we have. Several of which have stood the test of millennia despite many serious attempts to disprove.
- ikrenji 4y agomillennia? modern physics goes back a couple hundred years tops. relevant physics that aka prohibits FTL travel is less than a hundred years old (theory of relativity)...
- godelski 4y agoNo, relevant physics that prevents FTL is information flow connected with time. This is why people keep referring to the light cone. In other words, something that happens tomorrow is not a causal factor for something that has happened yesterday. The ancients knew that the order of time marched ever forward and that the future does not dictate the past. Even the concept of entropy and disorder was understood at a basic level for quite some time. Probably even before we were humans we understood that an object that has shattered does not spontaneously place itself back together. Or that a log that burns from fire cannot be put back together. Or that the future doesn't influence the past. These are physics concepts so old that they are often forgotten about because they are so obvious.
- bostonwalker 4y agoRight, absolutely fair comment. I would also add however that people don't realize how much of our understanding of physics needs to be broken for these objects to have a terrestrial technological origin. Consider the following aspects of the observed phenomena: - Intelligent characteristics (chasing / following / loitering behaviour) - Ability to generate and withstand extreme G-forces - Ability to expend/sustain extreme bursts of energy - Lack of visible exhaust - Bizarre aerodynamic characteristics I'm not an aerospace engineer, but I am a technologist and I took some aerospace-related courses in university. The first two aspects combined seem to rule out control by a human in the cockpit, and given the history of AI I would say autonomous control by a computer as well. Although not altogether the possibility of remote control by a human. But the last three aspects transcend not only everything I think I know about existing technology, but also my understanding of: - Newton's Third Law of motion and the rocket equation - Fluid mechanics/Navier-Stokes equation - Thermodynamics i.e., it exceeds our current science by such an enormous margin that I couldn't even begin to approach how to analyze it. Therefore, I think that if we rule out the possibility of a delusion/hoax, it's far more likely that these objects are alien than a secret skunk works project.