9 ms·
US spends most on health care but has worst health outcomes
- hunglee2 4y agoI think everyone is aware of this by now - the question is, do we understand what is preventing reform? It seems that we need to move beyond the revelation that 'the system is bad' and starting doing something about it. If so, what?
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- emodendroket 4y agoAll of that surplus spending is going to someone who isn't interested in seeing their cut reduced.
- Arnt 4y agoSo what? Both of the countries I've lived in have carried out health-related reforms (one a really big reform — almost half of hospital beds were closed, the other a much smaller reform). The people who lost income didn't matter for the success or failure of either reform.
- emodendroket 4y agoSo they can spend a lot of money to convince people that reforms are bad, they can buy influence among powerful politicians, and all the rest of the moves that make it so elite preferences do a lot to dictate policy the world over. Are we being naive here?
- Arnt 4y agoI think so, yes. You're basically saying that there are lobbyists and that's an insurmountable obstacle, and throwing your hands up in the air. You're not, for example, trying to learn how the countries that executed reforms successfully did so. EDIT: You could easily find a list online of the top ten health systems. Learning about the reforms carried out by each of those in the past 30 years requires effort, but it's really not impossible.
- junofan 4y agoUS health spend is bigger than the GDP of every country on that list. The biggest employer in nearly every congressional district is a healthcare system. It’s politically difficult.
- Arnt 4y agoYou make it sound as if closing nearly half of a country's hospital beds is politically simple. Was done. Or as if nationalising most of a state's hospitals is politically simple. Was done. (In some people's opinion, not mine, but lots of people described it in those words, so it's a fair way to describe the political controversy of the reform.) It's possible to learn how these things were done, or it's possible to just give up and say it's politically difficult.
- emodendroket 4y agoSince Medicare has served as a model for some countries that provided universal care, I don’t think lessons are what we need. The problem is overcoming strong, bipartisan opposition.
- emodendroket 4y agoMaybe I missed a rhetorical question but would-be reformers of the American health system were defeated by the efforts of moneyed interests (AMA, insurers, etc) in the past. It’s not that nobody thought of it. Argue about the wisdom of it if you want, but Obamacare was structured as it was with the idea of turning the industry into allies rather than implacable opponents.
- personjerry 4y agoThe issue is the medical-industrial complex in the US, intimately tied with a huge medical insurance industry, that spends a lot of money lobbying to fight against reform. And healthcare is already a heavily regulated industry so any political barriers become even harder to overcome. I believe Obamacare was an attempt to wiggle around to a (somewhat shitty) solution. I suspect change will only come once the existing tensions towards healthcare expenses boil to an outrage. Talk to anyone in the US though, they will complain about their healthcare!
- emodendroket 4y agoWell, some won’t and I think that exposes another issue: the poor outcomes have a lot to do with a lot of people not getting care or waiting too long due to cost. If money is no object the US healthcare system is as good as any (I bet you would see this if you broke down by socioeconomic status).
- stuaxo 4y agoOf course, though that is only the case for a very small minority of people. There is a big overlap with those people and the people that ultimately make decisions affecting whether that system exists though.
- nosianu 4y ago> If money is no object the US healthcare system is as good as any I don't think so. The medical personnel are way too stressed. You having money does not change that the people that will see you suffer in an inhuman system. Even apart from money, how on earth is it possible that the people who should know more better than anyone else the effects of stress and lack of sleep let doctors work in far too long shifts? How does the existence of 24 hour shifts make any sense? The system has a lot more problems than just money. Just one example link: https://bcmj.org/articles/sleep-deprivation-among-physicians https://bcmj.org/articles/sleep-deprivation-among-physicians It's not just the US: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jan/17/nhs-doctors-tired-impairment-sleep-deprived-survey https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jan/17/nhs-doctors-... Also always interesting to read: https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/ https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/
- altacc 4y agoSeems to me it's ideology and profit. The US isn't the only country with a partisan, ideological driven political landscape but it is probably the loudest. Ideologues on the right are able to pander to their base by equating any healthcare reform as socialist, substandard, death panel creating and an affront to freedom. People will accept a bad deal if they think it is the right deal. Healthcare companies benefit so much that they are one of the biggest lobbying industries in the US, spending $690 million a year on lobbying (quick Google result, so pinch of salt). The changes they want are those that will profit them more, so it benefit them to feed the ideologues.
- roenxi 4y agoAs far as I can tell nobody agrees on the details of why the system is bad. I'll pick on the split between the medically assisted dying vs. preserve life at all costs camp as a simple example. Both sides could probably agree that the current situation is bad, but neither side is about to give ground on why or which direction to go next. In my view, there are a lot of trivial and important changes that could make US healthcare cheaper, better and more available. As long as I don't specify any further details, everyone can agree with me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 4y ago> If so, what? Bring it into the political discourse. And vote.
- panny 4y ago>the system is bad Doctors aren't paid when you are healthy. How would you suggest fixing such a system? Because if you figure it out, there's a whole system of auto mechanics that could probably benefit from the solution.
- altacc 4y agoIt is not necessary to have to propose a solution before highlighting flaws or having an opinion about some thing. This is arguing in bad faith. Besides, you only have to read any article like this to find examples of other healthcare systems that have better outcomes for less spending Second, you've not only massively oversimplified, you have also made a false equivalence. Doctor's aren't the only ones getting paid, the CEOs take home billions, as do shareholders. If you think going to the hospital in the US is the same as taking a car to a garage in the US, then you are greatly mistaken. To equate the 2 is either unthinkingly glib or willfully disingenuous.
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> Doctors aren't paid when you are healthy They are, here in my country. I am healthy (AFAIK) my taxes are paying for doctors too. Also, I am healthy (AFAIK) because I go to the doctor even when I am not sick to check on my health. I already paid for it.
- vaidhy 4y agoI have heard similar arguments from pseudo-medical practitioners and I am going to assume you are not trolling. There are huge logical gaps in your statement. 1/ Being alive is a constant fight against diseases, aging and myriad other illness. 2/ In any reasonable population, there would be a percentage of people who need more medical care than others. 3/ Children and old people are more vulnerable. 4/ Given these above, the doctors cater to people who need the medical care. 5/ The world is not static. You can eat something bad and get sick. The doctors and by extent, the entire healthcare system is not a sterile environment to put people in. Why not propose an alternate system where doctors can be proactive in asking people to take care of themselves - maybe like asking them to take a vaccine?
- alkonaut 4y ago
- silisili 4y agoThis isn't at all surprising, for multiple reasons. The entire insurance industry existing is a big one. That we are all overweight is another. I'm generally a very conservative person. But even I am for government funded healthcare. Who in the hell is against it? I've not met a single person completely against it, mostly just people against people abusing emergency rooms. Certain big media and politicians are against it, saying we have the best in the world and often pointing at waiting lists in other places. My last gastro had a 7 month waitlist. What in the hell am I paying a fortune for every paycheck, then?
- stuaxo 4y agoThe Insurance industry is a bug vampire squid sucking money out of the system, and ironicly stopping many from getting the health outcomes they need.
- pigsty 4y agoA small group chat I’m a part of has one person who works for an insurance company. Reading his messages about his work day is just depressing. “Oh, yeah, if someone has that cancer and they’re under 45 it’s an auto-reject from me. Just too unlikely for them to have it” was one message that’s stuck with me. You (or your company) pays thousands of dollars a year (or more) to an insurance company to cover you for when the worst things happen—and despite you or your doctors trying to get your shit together, somebody chilling 1500 miles away skims your report and auto-declines any form of coverage just because it seems unlikely. Then it’s an uphill battle of trying to not only battle your illness and your daily life, but a company that has employees with worse judgement than an AI thrown together by some dude on Twitter in a weekend. It’s disgusting to think about.
- bosie 4y agohow.... how... can they reject anything that the hospital says?
- 1123581321 4y ago
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoThere needs to be a big movement towards physical fitness in the US. Get people doing calisthenics at home (almost everyone can do incline pushups as a start), going to the gym, using indoor bikes, eating less, whatever it takes. Improving the health system won't fix everything.
- scaredginger 4y ago...or we could find a real solution
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoLiving a healthier lifestyle in order to rely less on the healthcare system should absolutely be part of a "real solution". Both for cost reasons as well as the fact that some problems caused by obesity simply can't be fixed. It also has other benefits like improving general quality of life.
- mcv 4y agoWhy indoor bikes? Why not outdoor bikes? That will solve even more problems. > Improving the health system won't fix everything. Of course there's no silver bullet that will fix everything, but it's silly to think you can fix the outrageous costs of the healthcare system without fixing the healthcare system.
- FartyMcFarter 4y ago> Why indoor bikes? Lower barrier to entry. A lot of cities have no good infrastructure for outdoor biking. I agree that the healthcare system needs fixing as well, in addition to making the country healthier by lifestyle.
- docdeek 4y ago"But the harsh fact of the matter is that there is also an increasingly large number of young Americans who are neglecting their bodies—whose physical fitness is not what it should be—who are getting soft. And such softness on the part of individual citizens can help to strip and destroy the vitality of a nation. For the physical vigor of our citizens is one of America’s most precious resources. If we waste and neglect this resource, if we allow it to dwindle and grow soft then we will destroy much of our ability to meet the great and vital challenges which confront our people. We will be unable to realize our full potential as a nation." - President-elect John F. Kennedy, Dec 26. 1960 https://tomnikkola.com/soft-american/ https://tomnikkola.com/soft-american/
- 2devnull 4y agoThis implies we should spend less?
- KyleJune 4y agoImplies the US is doing domething different that is causing it to cost us more and get worse health outcomes. It's probably our whole health insurance system. It would probably be better and cheaper if we just had a universal healthcare system like many other countries.
- otikik 4y agoOf course it does. Three reasons: * A big chunk of the money goes to private insurance, never materializing into “health”. * Health centers being run as a business, not a national necessity (like roads or the military) * An obscurity in health practice pricing that would be illegal in any other activity.
- HourglassFR 4y agoI would ass a fourth reason: health is a very much a public (as in collective) issue, not a sum of individual medical problems. Something that is fundamentally at odds with the dominant ethos of how to deal with problems in america in the past 50 years or so.
- otikik 4y agoThat is what I was trying to convey on my second point, but perhaps I didn't do a good enough job at it. Yes as a European I see it as a mere "efficiency" thing. My (admittedly, very simplistic) thinking goes like this: > In a population of 1000 perhaps 10 will get a Really Bad Health Issue that requires Really Expensive Treatment that costs 100. So those 1000 people pool their resources up and each pays 0.1 so that if they happen to be one of the unfortunate 10 they are covered. Given that this is a shared risk for those 1000 people, the higher possible entity (the state) is put in charge. It seems the Americans thinking starts the other way around: > Anything public is awful and should be avoided at all costs. I'd better take my chances with a private entity (even if that means grouping with another 100 people instead of 1000, and that the private entity takes one cut, so we end up paying 2 each instead of 0.1) because the alternative is just awful. ... But then they are fine with having a very well publicly-funded military and police departments.
- mapremap 4y agoA risk pool being split among multiple companies doesn't actually increase the average amount that each group would have to pay. For the group of 100 in your example, only one tenth of a person is going to have to get one tenth of the expensive treatment, so each one still has to pay 0.1. As long as each underwriter has a sufficiently large group to ensure that the average cost incurred by its members is sufficiently close to the population average, the relative sizes of those groups isn't going to affect their members' premiums. Insurance administration is not an economy of scale so competition in the marketplace would ensure downward pressure on prices. In contrast, a state provider would have little incentive to cost-cut or innovate since they wouldn't have to earn people's business, and any public option would necessarily be attempting to balance the interests of multiple groups (such as public sector unions/government employees, health care providers, and health care consumers) at the expense of the consumers whose interest would have been prioritized in a competitive market. Taking that into consideration, it's doubtful that the lack of shareholders in a public system would represent enough of a benefit to actually lower costs for consumers. Americans have enough experience with poorly managed government programs to intuitively understand that a socialized health care system isn't going to be an improvement over our current system. And yes, since national defense and law enforcement are desirable services that can't be provided by a competitive market, we are fine with the government providing those specific services in a constitutionally-limited way. That preference is actually more ideologically consistent than your preference to socialize our healthcare system unless you're going to advocate for abandoning capitalism entirely.
- treelovinhippie 4y ago[dead]
- luminadiffusion 4y agoThis whole entire industry is a racketeering scheme. The medical industry justifies their excess profits as necessary for supporting the "free market" in "generating innovation". In reality: 1. Their "free market" is anything BUT a free market. 2. "Generating innovation" is not a substitute for generating positive health outcomes. 3. Their excess profits are primarily used for propaganda and bribery to justify their own existence and protect their racket. Just look up the laws restricting Medicare from bargaining on medical care and prescription drugs to understand just how much of a racket this whole industry is. It is criminal in every way - aside from the written law, since the people who make the laws are co-conspirators in the scheme. It's so much worse than the "most expensive" healthcare in the world. This nauseatingly overinflated healthcare is further subsidized by US taxpayer funds from the shit medical care and extortionate drug prices that Medicare is legally obligated to pay. It actually adds trillions to our Federal Deficit each year... so we get the worst health outcomes WHILE driving the US government into bankruptcy. This whole system maximizes profits for a limited number of players at the expense of our doctors, our patients, the fiscal health of Medicare, and the future of our republic.
- mcv 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230206073329/https://www.wesh.com/article/us-health-care-worst-outcomes-high-income-countries-new-report/42745709 https://web.archive.org/web/20230206073329/https://www.wesh.... (Because the article is blocked in some regions.)
- DoreenMichele 4y ago"To catch up with other high-income countries, the administration and Congress would have to expand access to health care, act aggressively to control costs, and invest in health equity and social services we know can lead to a healthier population." The U.S. has the highest rate of people with multiple chronic health conditions... and the highest obesity rate... I think they are seriously missing something. Obesity is related in part to our built environment and car-centric lives forced on us to a large degree by our built environment. Pollution may be a root cause of multiple chronic conditions. Just beefing up our health care system likely isn't sufficient.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is why the problem is intractable. The very way of life, the lot sizes houses are on, the paved earth in all 4 directions are at the root of the problem, and there is no fixing that on a US wide scale. And people like that lifestyle, they like their individual, huge cars and huge (relatively) houses and huge parking lots and huge roads and huge food and drink portions. Trying to fight that in a democracy will take a long, long time.
- sofixa 4y ago> And people like that lifestyle, they like their individual, huge cars and huge (relatively) houses and huge parking lots and huge roads and huge food and drink portions. Do they like it or have they simply never had any choice in the matter and have never experienced anything else? The extremely high housing prices in the few dense walkable places seems to imply there is more demand than supply for such developments, so at least some prefer them.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSure, some of them. But nowhere near the critical mass of voters needed to redirect entire infrastructure budgets away from prioritizing cars and large indoor spaces, to prioritizing public transit/walking/cycling and denser living. And this transition would take decades and cause a lot of pain in that time for eventual benefits the voting populace will never see, so it is a nonstarter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rgmerk 4y agoIt comes down to a few issues: a) The USA pays more for drugs than the rest of the world does. b) private health insurance is really inefficient. c) The US doesn’t do public and preventative health very well. d) The US wastes money overtreating rich people and undertreating poor people more than other countries. e) The US does a bunch of expensive and more importantly counterproductive end-of-life care than other countries. f) The US pays its doctors more than other countries because the supply is artificially restricted and governments don’t push back like they do elsewhere.
- mapremap 4y agoD and E are simply the result of healthcare consumers choosing to spend their money on care that wouldn't even be available under a public system. Taking that into consideration, "look how much of our GDP we spend on healthcare" is not the glaring indicator of a broken system that people make it out to be. People are allowed to spend their own money.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoUS spends most on health care but has worst health outcomes, BUT, it has the best healthcare profits!
- hulitu 4y ago> US spends most on health care but has worst health outcomes US does not spend on healthcare. It spends on people making profits from healthcare. But, Europe is slowly getting there too.