16 ms·
Interview with the founder of Teenage Engineering
- damver 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amrb 4y agoI've wanted to get their OP-1 portable synth since the first time I saw it, that price tho.. https://teenage.engineering/store/op-1/ https://teenage.engineering/store/op-1/
- dddw 4y agoAsk Monte Booker if you can lend one, he has two
- amrb 4y agoreminds me of the meme "I Have Three PS3s" :)
- marban 4y agoRecently sold my OP-1 to get the Field at some point but it's not really a convincing upgrade so far.
- noman-land 4y agoI waited, lusted, and saved for years, watching the price nearly double, before succumbing and getting one. I do not regret it.
- adwi 4y agoEchoing sibling: waited years, found good used deal, told myself I’d just sell it for the same price if I didn’t love it. Most inspiring instrument I’ve ever played. Reconnected me back to making music.
- exitb 4y agoI bought mine 9 years ago and it costed 790 EUR. It was regarded as a capable, but possibly overpriced synth. It’s quite shocking and disappointing to see that it’s so much more expensive now.
- kzrdude 4y agoscandinavianmind.com is not responding very quickly, but it is responding. Here's an archived copy: https://archive.is/x2oxd https://archive.is/x2oxd
- niekverw 4y agoWhat sick modular synth does he have there
- sctb 4y agohttps://www.colossus-synth.com https://www.colossus-synth.com
- alkonaut 4y agoWow that's a lot cheaper than I expected. Unlike buying a big Eurorack it's also dooming you to eternal poverty.
- wayvey 4y agoColossus AS100 classic: £26500K Colossus AS200 slim: £23500 Colossus DOUBLE: £50000 Limited Edition BLACK Colossus classic: £27500K wow...
- Tomte 4y agoWelcome back, Scott!
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoWhich is a remake, kind of, of the EMS Synthi 100. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMS_Synthi_100 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMS_Synthi_100 Which was part of the world's first private computer music studio. In 1969. https://www.historyofinformation.com/detail.php?id=2332 https://www.historyofinformation.com/detail.php?id=2332
- jacquesm 4y agoHey there, that's been a while! Nice to see you here again. And thanks for the link, awesome piece of kit (a bit out of the budget though!).
- ChrisThorton 4y ago[flagged]
- fassssst 4y agoI play my OP-1 during meetings and while waiting for things to compile. It’s one of my favorite objects, I often get lost with it.
- scotteric 4y agoYour coworkers don't have a problem with you being distracted and wearing headphones during a meeting?
- naavis 4y agoMaybe they are referring to remote meetings where you can mute yourself.
- fassssst 4y agoYea I mindlessly plunk around on it while muted.
- prmoustache 4y agowhy don't you just leave the meeting if you aren't paying attention anyway?
- benhurmarcel 4y agoIn most companies that's not an option. You sound lucky to not have to go through this, but waiting through hour-long meetings while waiting for an interesting topic or hearing your name is part of daily work for many office workers.
- prmoustache 4y agoWell I dutifully take part to a 30min daily meeting and a one 30min weekly one, from which I still sometimes excuse myself due to other obligations knowing that I will be contacted directly afterwards if a specific topic requires me, but these are short enough for me to fodus on them. Any other meeting need to have a precise agenda for me to attend it, especially if it means 1h of an engineer time might be wasted. If you are invited to a meeting and there is nothing in the agenda that concern you, you should mention it to the person sending the invite. A meeting has to be prepared to be effective anyway, you should know prior to the meeting what kind of input you are expected to bring. If all they give you is a vague title you should refuse until the scope is more precisely expressed otherwise people are wasting your company's precious money.
- jandeboevrie 4y agoFunny last name for someone living in a cold climate, KoutHooft translates to cold head in Dutch (minus the T).
- neilv 4y agoThe photography of this is interesting. I'm not sure I'd know how to approach this assignment (I might start with rapport and portraiture in the space), but some things I noticed on different photos: * Warm vintage color cast on the '70s-looking gear wood panel. * On-camera-flash-like directional lighting, with harsh shadow (maybe to separate person from gear background, but both in focus?). * Contrast and saturation jacked up. * Bluish cast on shot composed like a point&shoot snapshot. * Shooting through houseplants, like nature explorer discreetly observing engineer in their native habitat. Maybe the plants are part of the character of the space.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoAll of which says "stylised and arty" and is a look much used in The Wire and similar publications. I'm kind of irritated by this. TA are legendary for super-expensive toy-like products that must have insanely high margins. So somehow the "I was never into money (but now I collect antique synthesizers with four or five figure price tags)" line doesn't ring entirely true.
- dole 4y ago“Shit ain’t broke unless you’re broke, that’s some real shit.” - Lil Yachty
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI get it though, there are lots of expensive things I’d like to collect, but it’s about the object and not what it’s worth. If they were cheap I’d still want to collect them. You see it a lot in art, some people collect only as an investment vehicle - others buy what they like without regard for future returns. Ones mostly about the money.
- smoldesu 4y agoAnd people fall for it. It's crazy how many people blindly buy into TE's "homestyle" marketing like they're some hibrow synth company. The OP-1 tickles every American's "Product Cortex" in their brain though, immediately associating brutalist design and Corinthian leather with quality engineering. It doesn't matter if we're not the target audience, we just want to spend money on pretty things that make us feel good. The OP-1 is like the rich man's fidget spinner, I see it on someone's desk and assume that they have too much time and money on their hands. Just goes to show that you can take pretty much anything, market it to relatively affluent and bored tech workers and make a killing.
- suction 4y ago[dead]
- krosaen 4y agoReminds me about my neighbor who designed and then sold a batch of portable modular synths: https://www.modernsounds.co/pluto https://www.modernsounds.co/pluto amazing work and so cool that that sort of thing is possible from a solopreneur these days.
- apgwoz 4y agoI’m not knowledgeable about synths and such (I wish I had more time to learn music, though), but I always look at this stuff because the devices are aesthetically beautiful — pluto as well. It’s probably almost a shoo-in that if you focused on aesthetics you could sell out a small batch of modular synths with the most basic beep / boop making capabilities.
- ilyt 4y agoThe market is quite saturated for those. You'd have to make something pretty and doing something more than basic.
- jacquesm 4y agoNote the Moog Theremin sitting around casually used as a dump for patchcables!
- robocat 4y agoBehind the Theremin is a kakelugn/kachelofen/masonry-heater fireplace. https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Masonry_heater https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Masonry_heater https://duckduckgo.com/?q=swedish+round+ceramic+stove https://duckduckgo.com/?q=swedish+round+ceramic+stove
- jacquesm 4y agoThose are beautiful!
- malthaus 4y agoI too would live in a pinterest-ready castle filled with toys but i dont have the stomach to rip off customers as shamelessly as TE is. The B&O of our generation.
- tomashubelbauer 4y agoI am not saying I wouldn't love to be able to buy an OP-1 or an OP-1 Field for a lower price, I would absolutely love that. But no-one held a gun to my head and made me buy one for a retail price. It is a luxury synth, not a basic good like bread or water people's lives depends on. Everyone who buys a thing from TE and feels like they were ripped off should realize they volunteered to get ripped off.
- smoldesu 4y agoYep. Ostensibly there's nothing wrong with making pricy hipster audio equipment, but the rampant success of their marketing just makes me facepalm. People out there genuinely think the OP-1 is a $1000 product in 2023, which should inspire riots in the street. The OP-1 Field raising the price instead of lowering it is the last nail in the coffin for me. $800 is a pricy toy - $1500+ puts you in brand-new Octatrack territory. Hell, that puts you in brand-new-Macbook-and-DAW territory. But, people pay for it. They want the whittled down, inspiring experience without any of the effort or trouble. I sympathize with those people, but Teenage Engineering's products are like the Disney Star Wars hotel of audio equipment. It's a one-of-a-kind, pretty-looking, dumbed-down, expensive scam. Some people will defend it, and particularly affluent guests might even say it's worth the money. Undeniably though, much like every Disney park, TE's product line is built to fleece the customer. I've got half a mind to chew Moog out for the same thing, but they have legitimate excuses for why their instruments can't be mass-produced. Teenage Engineering doesn't.
- kubb 4y agoshouldn't there be a normally priced equivalent product on the market? it's not like we're talking about cutting edge silicon here
- 4y ago
- notRobot 4y ago> With any kind of creative work you start disabling as much as possible and narrow it down only to the necessary tools you need, and from there start making the work. That’s what I believe makes you super creative. This also (at least for me) is the joy of esoteric and weird programming languages!
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoWould like to know when they'll start selling their pocket operator synthesizer and sequencer again. Rumors that a chip shortage has negatively impacted on their production, but who knows! It's been months now that they've been out of stock on their website - https://teenage.engineering/store/po-20/ https://teenage.engineering/store/po-20/
- voakbasda 4y agoGiven their other marketing, they could simply be keeping it out of stock intentionally, to increase demand by creating a (false) sense of scarcity.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoYes, you get that sense alright when the $500 units all seem to be in stock no problem.
- selykg 4y agoI mean, if my $500 product has better margins I’m going to take my limited supply of materials and put it into my best money makers.
- voakbasda 4y agoWhy is this so hard to believe? I truly don’t understand the unvoiced objections to my hypothesis.
- ilyt 4y agoSame over whole synth market, it's slowly clearing out
- fijiaarone 4y agoWhat do you expect from a fifty something marketing executive from an ancient banking family who names his company “teenage engineering” — something with shag carpet and wood paneling right out of the 1970s — when he was a teenager.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoDidn't notice this detail in the interview - do you mean that he comes from a very wealthy family, and that was a factor in his founding of the company?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewmcwatters 4y ago[flagged]
- rsync 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewmcwatters 4y ago> and possibly reevaluate your participation in Don't ever talk to me or anyone else on HN this way. We have enough backhanded civility here, and you're not improving discourse by commenting like this. It's a parody comment of the "I'm Rich, You're Poor" segment. https://www.google.com/search?q=on+today%27s+episode+of+i%27m+rich+you%27re+poor https://www.google.com/search?q=on+today%27s+episode+of+i%27... It's a joke. Take a joke.
- Entinel 4y ago> I sell overpriced aluminum audio equipment And yet everything they make sells out. Almost like it's worth the price.
- gtyras2mrs 4y ago>And yet everything they make sells out. Almost like it's worth the price. I dont think, A implies B. With great marketing and lower volume production, you could probably make most overpriced, average quality widgets sell out. Doesn't mean that because they're sold out therefore they were priced "right". (as subjective as pricing is)
- Entinel 4y agoIf you are stripping out all context then no A doesn't imply B but we aren't talking in a vacuum. We are talking about a specific company. > average quality widgets Everyone I personally know who has bought anything from teenage engineering has nothing but good things to say about the quality.
- cfr2023 4y ago[flagged]
- Towaway69 4y agoPerhaps slightly OT but I found building my own synthesizer using a cheap midi controller with a few dials and supercollider[0] to be very enjoyable experience. Somehow I have a better connection to making music since it was my own virtual Synthesizer and it does just what I need it to do! [0]=https://supercollider.github.io/ https://supercollider.github.io/
- ilyt 4y agoIf you have not already see in https://vcvrack.com/ https://vcvrack.com/ Modular synth emulator, all the plugging wires manually without the desk space and $$$ cost of modular synth
- bmitc 4y agoSupercollider is unfortunate because it has a very restrictive license.
- chuchana 4y agoIs it the GPLv3 you're calling "very restrictive" or are we seeing different licenses?
- cfr2023 4y agoI think the work of this company is fragile and shortsighted, encouraging creators to put their energy into a cascade of non-standard paradigms, but without creating any valuable new conventions. As such I do not enjoy hearing what their founder thinks about anything, or puff pieces about him, like this one. I'm open to being convinced otherwise but all of the new information I receive fits in with the prior assessment - they want your money for a cool looking music toy.
- Gracana 4y agoI don’t see the problem, though I am also not sure what you mean. What is standard? What should people be doing instead? Do TE’s products differ from other grooveboxes?
- cfr2023 4y agoStandard = generic. The difference between telling someone to play guitar and telling someone to play a Black Les Paul Custom with Block Inlays through a Mesa Mark I head into a tall Marshall 4x12 cabinet. Both have their places, but telling someone just "play guitar" is an inherently more useful thing. People looking for music tools that will serve them over time, or even a lifetime, will be better served investing their time into tools and practices that are not bound to the fate of a single company. All of this stuff can be fun to play with, but they market these things as serious tools for creators, when they are better equipped for store window demonstrations. There is nothing that a TE box can do that a DAW can't do out of the box except for be a silly dedicated box with cryptic controls.
- strawpeople 4y agoWhat’s so wrong with a cool looking toy? Once upon a time I worked a full time stressful job at a startup and was well paid. I didn’t have a lot of time for hobbies, but an op-1 would have been a great way to play around with music. I’d have been a perfect customer and very happy with it. Edit: Looks like this commenter is exactly the way I imagine myself back in the day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34665229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34665229
- bikeformind 4y agoRemember this thing? https://play.date/ https://play.date/ (Gameboy with a crank) Made it to the front page on here a couple times, if I’m not mistaken. Did this ever ship? looks like it’s been in pre-order for the last three years?
- evan_ 4y agoYes it has shipped. It says pre-order because they’re shipping in batches so if you order now you’ll get it in a few months rather than right away.
- michelb 4y agoHad it for a few months now and it’s a fun little thing.
- jasonpeacock 4y agoI've got mine. It's exactly what was promised, and fun to play :)
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoThey shipped the first batch but didn’t secure enough processors so are having to re-engineer for a different chipset/platform last I heard.
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoThese photos are carefully curated, real electronic labs are rarely that neat (unless he is only doing the high level design on EDA and letting his employees do the actual hardware and board work).
- kzrdude 4y agoThe photos are from his flat, not from the company.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- darkwraithcov 4y agoSo that’s where all the profits from the OP-1 went.
- barrenko 4y agoComments here are peak HN.
- pengaru 4y agoOT but this page is a breath of no-js-required fresh air for 2023...
- sambapa 4y agoIt seems to me that hardware synths are like vinyls - people buy them because of connotations, a certain image. In almost all terms software is unquestionably better. And if you want to be a "quirky artsy synthesizer person", don't buy into this hardware shit, just download SunVox or Pure Data.
- slater- 4y agosome people do, for sure. but i've gotten so much mileage out my Moog because of its knob twiddling interface. i hate using software, it doesn't inspire me to play in the same way. i appreciate the tactile sense and also the limitations of a piece of physical gear. but also it makes me look quirky and artsy.
- chuchana 4y agoDepends on your definition of "better". Having dedicated controls can make a huge difference, having limited possibilities, too. If you know what you want and how to get it, both those points are probably much less important than when you are getting started. Of course you could also design your ideal environment including controls, but that's still one more thing to do before you get started.
- ravagat 4y agoThanks for sharing, I've heard of TE on and off and tried their OP-1, good interview to read about the founder behind TE. Very interesting to read the comments from HN readers.
- agentultra 4y agoFor all the folks who immediately react to any mention of TE with, “it’s expensive garbage only idiots would buy!” Have you seen a full tear down and did a component cost analysis to get a rough idea of the unit cost? I’ve seen some breakdowns of the PCBs in the OP-1 and it doesn’t look like they’re skimping on parts/design to me. I’m not huge into hardware nor an EE so maybe I’m wrong here. However I would think that given the volumes they sell and the component cost with all of the custom bits that go into an OP-1 Field, it’s probably fairly reasonable. Most businesses want to make products they can sell. I’m only suggesting that maybe the engineering that goes on at TE isn’t pure marketing fuzz and that they’re not selling underwhelming products at inflated prices to suckers who love a brand more than decent gear. Having read the article I think it’s interesting how they’re running the business. It seems that they value creativity and skill rather than time to market or feature lists. It’s pretty easy to make a pure software synth with high-end DACs that is basically a laptop trapped in a custom box with an opaque interface of some sort. Almost everyone does it in some way. Features! Deep menus, tonnes of buttons, endless tweaking. Probably easier to do on a laptop. It’s a neat feat of engineering to put limits on where you allow yourself to go. Different things happen when you have to get creative to avoid the limits. The Pocket Operator series is dope as hell. What a neat idea that almost effortlessly pulls in the Game & Watch aesthetic. Few places are doing stuff like that. I’m curious what other oddball stuff they will work on next. It’s not necessarily my cup of tea but I really think they do good work. It’d be interesting to get a deep dive into specific products in their line. He talks about influences in general. I wonder how that ends up playing out.