3 ms·
> But some bugs in the tax code are also vulnerabilities. For example, there’s a corporate tax trick called the “Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich.” So how co
by amelius 4y ago
> But some bugs in the tax code are also vulnerabilities. For example, there’s a corporate tax trick called the “Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich.”
So how come financial hackers exploiting vulnerabilities in the tax code and making these sandwiches never do jail time, while computer hackers regularly do?
- pcthrowaway 4y agoComputer hackers don't necessarily do jail time. Someone hacking a single-player video game, to give them increased stats or something, won't do jail time. Even when it's a multiplayer game, someone finding a hack that benefits them is unlikely to face jail time. Hacking is a crime if you're gaining unauthorized access to a system, especially a remote one. I think hacks involving money and personal user data have different criminal classifications as well. And that's ignoring the massive number of hackers ("researchers") who actually get paid to do it (many of whom started out doing illegal things).
- amelius 4y agoYes, but a hacking and making millions is generally a crime, while exploiting the tax code to make millions or even billions is accepted behavior.
- grenoire 4y agoAs if there's an implicit belief that companies artificially reducing their tax liability will lead to better growth or something? Perceived benefit is then positive, I suppose. On the other hand, an individual doing it for their personal gain is vilified indeed.
- xwdv 4y agoYou don’t understand, when it comes to taxes we follow the letter of the law, not the spirit. Financial hackers are technically using legal means to accomplish their goals. The law is the law.
- amelius 4y agoMy point is that this is strange. Breaking into a government website is illegal. However if the code on their server was part of "the law", it suddenly becomes legal?
- xwdv 4y agoIf the law says it’s legal, that is the law.
- amelius 4y agoStill strange. It should be: if it's against the spirit of the law, it's illegal. Otherwise we could replace judges by computers who just evaluate logic statements in the book of law.
- xwdv 4y agoNo, fuck the spirit of the law. If that’s what society runs itself on then the written laws don’t matter and the real laws become whatever subjective bullshit the judges decide at the moment. “Hidden” laws essentially. Dystopia. Logic statements that evaluate to legal or illegal is the ideal when it comes to laws, judges are only necessary when logical certainty isn’t possible.
- amelius 4y agoI see a contradiction there. You want the law to be like code, but actual computer code you are still not allowed to use in unintended ways? How would that last part be encoded in the law? Anyway, I'm ok with a more logical, objective interpretation of the law, but then also the loopholes in the law should be treated as code exploits: it should be possible to report them and then they should be fixed asap.
- xwdv 4y agoThe loopholes are not exploits. They are unintended consequences of poorly written laws. What you are asking is for laws to be rewritten. There are already normal procedures in place for proposing changes to laws. Write to your congressman.
- jason-phillips 4y agoIf you mean "exploiting" loopholes, then they are lawful and usually working as intended. I never considered my CPA a criminal hacker; I'm sure he'll be amused. If you simply mean "not paying your taxes" then this is a crime that is frequently prosecuted and is not particularly clever or a hack. You appear to be conflating the two for some reason. If you mean, "unauthorized access of a computer system", then yes, that is unlawful and would possibly be one reason why some people are prosecuted and sent to jail. Nit: >> For example, there’s a corporate tax trick called the “Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich.” This has not been a thing since 2020.
- amelius 4y ago> You appear to be conflating the two for some reason. No, I'm just abstractly (like TFA) considering hacking to be an activity where a system (code or financial law) is brought outside of its intended use. > "exploiting" loopholes Anyway, why aren't there bounties for finding loopholes and why aren't they fixed as soon as possible?
- jason-phillips 4y agoBecause the loopholes are a feature. Working as intended in the vast majority of instances.
- palata 4y agoYou seem to consider that the law is defined by the system being hacked. It is not: the law is the law. The code of a website is not the law. It is legal to hack a system if it does not break the law (I can use a fork as a screwdriver if I want to), but it is illegal if it breaks the law (I can use the fork as a weapon and break the law). A loophole is legal. It may feel like it should not be, because it allows to work around the law. But it is legal.
- drdec 4y ago> So how come financial hackers exploiting vulnerabilities in the tax code and making these sandwiches never do jail time, while computer hackers regularly do? That's because Schneier defines hacking in the original sense of the word, subverting or misusing a system to get a desired, but unintended, result. The computer "hackers" doing jail time are not hackers by Scheier's definition.