4 ms·
So they waited until the balloon was over sea. This raises the question: why didn't the military see it coming and destroy it before it crossed the border?
by amelius 4y ago
So they waited until the balloon was over sea.
This raises the question: why didn't the military see it coming and destroy it before it crossed the border?
- luxuryballs 4y agothey claimed they started tracking it over the Pacific even, my guess is we just don’t have the full story, perhaps they didn’t want to fail at shooting it down quickly, succeed at responding the “real” way and give something away, or spring some other “trap card”, or it’s all a lie and was our own thing that got away or just a distraction and everything after that was reactionary and opportunistic, we may never know
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoBecause it wasn't a political kerfuffle then and they weren't gonna be the ones to make it into one.
- themodelplumber 4y agoI wonder...is there any value to: - IDing components, maybe even using some x-ray tech like US satellites have - Developing an idea of what this thing vacuums up, informationally - Switching our monitoring posture to also vacuuming up the same as it travels along, as if we are co-spying on our own stuff - Using the information product to help harden any sensitive information that was vacuumed, for counter-intel purposes This would fit the general parameters of what the public saw happening (almost nothing, then bang as soon as the balloon is floating over literally nothing).
- darkwraithcov 4y agoIf its anything like the cold war where we did this with the Russkies (and prior to that, The Nazis) it makes sense to me it would have significant electronic warfare value.
- ascotan 4y agoThis isn't the first balloon with equipment on it that has overflown US territory (which should also put to rest the 'rogue weather balloon' theory). China has been doing this ever since Trump started levying import taxes on Chinese goods. This particular balloon was brazen enough to be loitering over military targets for some time. It makes sense to do a shoot down over the ocean so you can have a better chance to recover the payload for analysis.
- jeffbee 4y agoSince you appear to believe this balloon had a surveillance mission, please explain what data it could conceivably have collected that isn't much easier to collect some other way. The military targets over which you suggest this aircraft intentionally loitered do not even have restricted airspaces. Anyone could get in a plane and fly right over them at whatever altitude they choose and nobody would even notice. You can fly circles over Malmstrom AFB until you run out of fuel, if you want.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoI think it would be considered illegal espionage if someone working for the PLA rented a plane and flew it over military bases. Balloons have more plausible deniability and less personal risk.
- giantrobot 4y agoSIGINT, ELINT, and MASINT. Putting a bunch of radars on a balloon platform is relatively cheap, much cheaper than a satellite. It's also got better plausible deniability than a similarly equipped airplane. Ground penetrating radar over military bases can yield useful intelligence. So can gauging the response times and radio characteristics of air defense radars. Then there's good ol' photo reconnaissance. Such a huge platform could easily have stabilized mounts for high resolution cameras. Being an order of magnitude closer to the targets makes for better photos.
- ascotan 4y agoThe most likely scenario is the network surveillance. The defense dept has already confirmed the balloon was carrying surveillance equipment. I think the real point here was to probe the US response.
- dendrite9 4y agoI posted this link earlier but it was tracked. Here is a flight path of Canadian fighters checking the balloon out as it crossed towards Montana. https://twitter.com/steffanwatkins/status/1621362998081110016 https://twitter.com/steffanwatkins/status/162136299808111001... The link was in this longer, and good article: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/chinas-spy-balloon-over-montana-is-part-of-a-larger-more-troubling-pattern https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/chinas-spy-balloon-ove...
- amatecha 4y agoOh wow, that's messed up. Kind of irritating to see the thing was being closely tracked all through BC and just... nothing? Nice...
- dendrite9 4y agoI mean we only know what we know so far. I admittedly haven't followed this really closely but I wouldn't be surprised if there was a gamble that the public wouldn't notice it. Or maybe it was incompetence or indecision. It was surprising how this balloon spread through the public consciousnesses, kinda like the balloon boy hoax I suppose.
- amatecha 4y agoYeah, we have no real vision into the actual facts, only what gets told to the public, so it's tough to judge. I can imagine it not even being a surveillance balloon at all (though it probably is). I'm always skeptical around stuff like this, haha
- wkat4242 4y agoMaybe they weren't sure at that point that it was unmanned? Shooting it down would have been a whole different story then
- cm2187 4y agoCF18 seem to have a service ceiling of 15km. This thing was about 20km high. Could they shoot it if they wanted?