5 ms·
Other news sources have a lot more detail about this. 1. There's a high risk of debris falling on people on the ground. 2. Any sensitive information collected
by paxys 4y ago
Other news sources have a lot more detail about this.
1. There's a high risk of debris falling on people on the ground.
2. Any sensitive information collected would have been sent home already, so shooting it now isn't going to do much good.
So Pentagon leadership recommended not taking "kinetic action". What's interesting is that they have been tracking it for several days over the US mainland. You'd think the strongest military in the world could do something other than...just watch.
- advpetc 4y agoI don't understand it here. If it's detrimental to national security shouldn't it be dealt with immediate action? I think it's a propaganda with a lot of self conflicted information.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NegativeK 4y agoThere's definitely strength in saying "Your balloon is not a concern to us."
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoSadly, it could also come off as "we won't do anything about it"
- pengaru 4y agoThere's more strength in demonstrating "Hey, do you want this silly balloon back?" after retrieving it without incident at negligible effort/cost. Which is not at all what is occurring. Having flight tracks of multiple refueling tankers demonstrates far more resources have already been expended on this "not a concern to us" than was spent on deploying it...
- sinerath 4y agoThey could put Carrot Top and Andy Dick on it and send it back?
- nonethewiser 4y agoLess than surgically removing it with little effort.
- bentobean 4y agoYes, but you know what has even more strength? Sending up our own balloon in the shape of a giant ass and blocking its view.
- dole 4y agoOr pointing a bunch of AliExpress laser pointers at it…
- amw 4y agoI understand why the State Department hyperventilates over "Chinese offensive capabilities" but no normal person ever needs to. China is not a threat to everyday Americans.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoThe military could shoot it down in less than an hour if it was a priority.
- sammalloy 4y ago> There's a high risk of debris falling on people on the ground. That excuse seems really odd to me. Montana is the third-least densely populated state with 6.86 people per square mile of land.
- cronix 4y agoIt also has a lot of active nuclear ICBM silos. https://www.malmstrom.af.mil/About-Us/Fact-Sheets/Display/Article/346869/341st-missile-wing/ https://www.malmstrom.af.mil/About-Us/Fact-Sheets/Display/Ar...
- COGlory 4y agoYou can go drive past them, even stop to use the porta-potty. (ok, maybe not recommended) I've antelope hunted over there a lot. (East of Harlowtown) and it is as empty as it gets in the contiguous US. They could probably shoot it down without making much debris. And even if it made debris, at most it would hit a cow. The reality is it's not collecting anything of value.
- anon223345 4y agoYes, they are probably just counting silos under an informal agreement… These have taken place numerous times
- fbdab103 4y agoAre the silos even a secret anymore? With ubiquitous satellite coverage, I assume that anything even possibly a launch site is extensively monitored. To say nothing of traditional mechanisms of gathering intelligence.
- ofrzeta 4y agoThere is an exhaustive list on Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/341st_Missile_Wing_LGM-30_Minuteman_missile_launch_sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/341st_Missile_Wing_LGM-30_Minu...
- spacemark 4y agoTen bucks says they've already taken non-kinetic action. Jamming, optical lasers, etc.
- sfifs 4y agonope. why give away capability? if there was any risk, it would be shot down. it it wasn't, it was probably observing wilderness/pastures
- dylan604 4y agowhat's the point of capability if you're never going to use it. isn't this exactly what non-explosive weapons are made for? i say we launch a balloon that parks itself below theirs blocking the view. no capabilities given up then
- 2fast4you 4y ago> what's the point of capability if you're never going to use it. The point is to use them on a real danger. Accurate or not, the Pentagon clearly doesn’t see this ballon as a threat in any capacity. Why would they do anything other than keep an eye on it?
- anon223345 4y agoWe have a “consequences taxonomy” we only show our hand depending on level of threat Some bean counters decided this was low threat. And, more likely, China told us it was coming, and probably to just count silos like we’ve been doing back and forth since the 70s If it was spooky, it wouldn’t be bright white…
- rlt 4y ago> probably to just count silos like we’ve been doing back and forth since the 70s Pretty sure they've got satellites that can do that.
- sircastor 4y ago>You'd think the strongest military in the world could do something other than...just watch. There’s an argument to be made that the strongest military in the world showing restraint and just watching is probably a good thing.
- TurkishPoptart 4y ago"Just watching" what they're calling a "surveillance" balloon continue to collect (somehow) information sounds unwise. That they watch it crossing the Atlantic onto U.S. territory seems especially asinine. It's as if we're more beholden to Disney shareholders than national security at this point, under the "Biden-Harris Administration".
- Waterluvian 4y agoNothing is more intimidating than an adversary who is intimidated by nothing.
- nonethewiser 4y agoShowing restraint against a controlled takedown of the balloon? Cant say I see the value in that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 4y agoMoved Iran and Afghanistan back a hundred years or more. Watches ballon and earns reputation as "restrained".
- ARandomerDude 4y agoThe US moved Iran — the country simultaneously providing cruise missiles to Russia and modern anti-tank missiles to forces in Yemen — back a few hundred years? The 1700s must have been wild.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vl 4y agoApart from the question why it wasn't shot down before entering airspace, sensitive information it collects is altitude wind patterns over missile sites and inability of administration to make a decision.
- irrational 4y ago> There's a high risk of debris falling on people on the ground. In Western Montana? Rather doubtful. Just wait 5 minutes until it is over national forest land, which is the vast majority of the area, and then shoot it down.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoThey mention in the article that the balloon only provides a marginal increase in surveillance capability when compared to LEO satellites. Considering the US pioneered a lot of satellite surveillance technology I imagine they have built everything accordingly since the 1960s and there's not much the Chinese can see from space or a balloon or I'm guessing even from a low flying Cessna.
- anon7725 4y agoMaybe they did - gathering intelligence or probing for an exploit, etc.
- roamerz 4y ago[flagged]