9 ms·
Seawater electrolysis by adjusting the local reaction environment of a catalyst
- moffkalast 4y agoCompared to conventional alkaline electrolysis at around 70% apparently. Doesn't brine electrolysis also produce chlorine, or has Factorio fed me some horseshit?
- strangeattractr 4y agoPretty sure it usually produces chlorine gas and caustic soda, but I could be wrong.
- moffkalast 4y agoAh yeah right of course, it's something like Na+ Cl- H2O --> O2 NaOH Cl2 (sorry chemists, I know your eyes are probably bleeding) But if they manage to get H2 from it then the sodium, oxygen, and chlorine have to bind into something else than usual I guess.
- LarsAlereon 4y agoThere is a proposed method to sequester carbon and reduce ocean acidification by doing this process, extracting the Hydrogen and Chlorine (or hydrochloric acid) for industrial purposes, and releasing the sodium hydroxide to absorb dissolved CO2 (carbonic acid) into sodium carbonate.
- philipkglass 4y agoYou're probably thinking of this paper from 2007: "Electrochemical Acceleration of Chemical Weathering as an Energetically Feasible Approach to Mitigating Anthropogenic Climate Change" https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/es0701816 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/es0701816 It was mind blowing for me at the time! Subsequent approaches to accelerated silicate weathering like Project Vesta dropped the chemical component and just used mechanical crushing of rocks to accelerate weathering. The all-mechanical approach is less complicated and energy intensive.
- LarsAlereon 4y agoIf you're extracting chlorine to react it with rock it probably makes more sense to just react the rock directly. But if you can use the chlorine industrially it makes more sense not to involve the mining and transport of rock. There's currently a significant industry of chlorine and HCl production that isn't linked to a carbon sequestration process that we can supplant.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoNeeds massive energy input which would come from where? Also, massive amounts of toxic chemicals. Use biology to solve climate change by growing biomass (bio CCS) in the form of kelp, diatoms, and other high growth life (maybe GMO) to sink to the bottom of the ocean.
- LarsAlereon 4y agoNuclear plants can provide plenty of excess electricity as well as heat for thermal desalination.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoSounds like wishful thinking/hand-waving. Plus, the risks of and limitations of nuclear energy. Biological processes are far more efficient at fixing carbon into biomass and using unlimited free solar energy. Bio CCS.
- pfdietz 4y agoOne could also release the chlorine into the atmosphere to destroy atmospheric methane. Elemental chlorine in sunlight is rapidly (within minutes) broken down into chlorine atoms. These atoms, being free radicals, efficiently extract hydrogen from methane molecules, starting a chain of reactions that converts the remaining fragment to CO2 and water. You'd need a hell of a lot of chlorine to compensate for current methane injection, though.
- arbitrandomuser 4y agoNo , cholrine radicals will also deplete ozone layer , Besides I don't think releasing highly reactive gases at any concentration into the atmosphere is a good idea, there can be other effects we haven't studied well enough.
- pfdietz 4y agoThey wouldn't make it to the ozone layer, if released in sunlight.
- pmontra 4y agoIf you could release it close to methane concentrations. Otherwise it's going to react with anything close to it. Soil, lungs, vegetation, etc.
- pfdietz 4y agoMethane is present throughout the troposphere -- it has an atmospheric lifetime of something over a decade and becomes well mixed. You'd want to release the chlorine in a sufficiently dilute and dispersed form that it didn't overwhelm the methane in the air it which it was released.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> But if they manage to get H2 from it then the sodium, oxygen, and chlorine have to bind into something else than usual I guess. It's the same electrolysis process used today in swimming pools to generate chlorine. The hydrogen evaporates, the chlorine ends up in the water, and the chemical reaction ends up producing the same salt it started with. You don't have to add salt[0] and the chlorine pretty quickly evaporates and breaks down in sunlight if you don't put cyanuric acid in the water to bind it. Mostly it could be ignored, though if the chlorine level got high enough it would kill the organic things. [0] except for losses due to other reasons than chlorine generation
- lazide 4y agoNot with this process, that’s the breakthrough.
- Retric 4y agoYea it produces chlorine. Nuclear subs need to use reverse osmosis first to get around that problem when they want to produce Oxygen from seawater. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3Ud6mHdhlQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3Ud6mHdhlQ
- lazide 4y agoThis process avoids producing chlorine, and doesn’t require purification of the input either. It seems quite promising.
- cma 4y agoIf this new way is 100% efficient wouldn't it break conservation of energy to produce chlorine (and instead it should remain salt)? (Edit n/m, 100% efficiency was now removed from the headline)
- breckenedge 4y agoWhat mods are you playing that have chlorine?
- cwkoss 4y agoSounds familar to me. I think bobs, maybe angels.
- photochemsyn 4y agoIt's one of those reactions that depends on concentration and acidity, basically not going to be a concern for seawater electrolysis. Making chlorine gas is a pretty involved process, the NaCl salt has to be highly pure, etc. > "In all cell processes, the filtered brine is heated and passed through a bed of salt in a saturator in order to increase its salt concentration before feeding it to the electrolyzers. In some plants, the brine feed is acidified to improve the cell current efficiency. The acidification reduces the alkalinity, which would otherwise react with the chlorine in the anolyte compartment, forming chlorate." https://knowledge.electrochem.org/encycl/art-b01-brine.htm https://knowledge.electrochem.org/encycl/art-b01-brine.htm At neutral-alkaline pH with seawater you can get hypochlorite (ClO-), basically relatively weak chlorine bleach formation at 0.5-1%, this is used when seawater is used for industrial cooling systems (see nuclear power plants etc.): > "A more realistic picture of the problems DSS faces can be gained from on-site hypochlorite generators, a technology established since the early 1970s for industrial water cooling systems. There, low concentrated hypochlorite is used to avoid the growth of marine organisms as they tend to foul equipment and worsen heat transfer. The hypochlorite is formed by direct oxidation of Cl- from the filtered seawater feed. The electrolysers are one compartment cells made of titanium, and the electrodes are comprised of a titanium core with a precious metal oxide coating (Ru, Ir, Pt)." source: Hausmann et al. (2021). Is direct seawater splitting economically meaningful? (sci-hub) Hydrogen from seawater directly seems pretty speculative, be interesting if it works, you could have hydrogen production at sea maybe. Scale might be an issue (giant barges with solar panels making hydrogen for fueling shipping?)
- SigmundA 4y agoI only played vanilla, but my pool at home with salt system has taught me that. It uses a 48v cell with 3000 ppm salt to create chlorine to sanitize the pool water. Many pools now days use this kind of system rather than chlorine tablets or whatever.
- kepler1 4y agoMy understanding is that the cost of producing hydrogen is not one of the major bottlenecks about why those vehicles are slow to be adopted? I mean, good to have such breakthroughs, but this is not (right now) a huge limiting factor on why we don't drive more H vehicles, is that right? It's more the storage of it? And specialty fuel cells needed to power the cars?
- dheera 4y ago(a) There aren't enough hydrogen charging stations, even in California. (b) I'd rather drive around with a Lithium battery than a pressurized tank of hydrogen.
- ggm 4y ago(b) you don't seem to understand how hydrogen functions as a fuel. It can be burned but it can also be used to make electricity. "it depends" (c) it's either ammonia cycle engines so liquid ammonia storage (which is bad enough but not hydrogen tanks) or .. (d) sintered metal storage of hydrogen for .. (e) electric motors where the regen of electricity from H2 produces water as a byproduct of electricity from H2 (a) who cares about ordering? (f) yes there is hydrogen combustion outcomes for H2 powered cars too and yes early demonstrators do H2 in tanks but the scale industry here isn't targetting Gaseous H2 tanked vehicles AFAIK.
- dheera 4y agoIf there's a pressurized tank of hydrogen and something pierces the car, it's kaboom. If something pierces a lithium battery you at least have a few seconds to get out.
- ggm 4y agoIf there's a pressurised tank and something pierces the car. its not necessarily kaboom. H2 is lighter than air. It disperses. Its burn patterns are different. I don't doubt its scary but the assumption it's worse than other fuels is an open question. It might be better than LNG in some circumstances. As I said, the goal is not H2 tanks. Did you read that? do you understand how sintered metal H2 storage works? or NH storage? (NH is btw, also scary bad. people used to die when ammonium refrigerators leak)
- kurthr 4y agoNot much there to comment on. The actual paper is at: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-023-01195-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-023-01195-x DOI for those who want to search other databases: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41560-023-01195-x https://doi.org/10.1038/s41560-023-01195-x
- teruakohatu 4y agoDoes 100% efficiency here mean that the energy of the hydrogen equals the energy used to produce it?
- JonChesterfield 4y agoUnlikely. What with thermodynamics. I'd guess it's something like "nearly" hides some sins and ignoring things other than oxygen that result hide the rest.
- MBCook 4y agoI would think it means that (nearly) 100% of the energy input is used in useful chemical reactions doing work as opposed to generating waste heat or something else.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoMy understanding is that a perfectly efficient device would take ~39 kWh to produce 1 kg hydrogen [1]. So I'm imagining this is close to that? IIUC, 1 kg hydrogen = ~33.6 kWh. [1] https://wernerantweiler.ca/blog.php?item=2020-09-28#:~:text=How%20much%20electricity%20is%20needed,kWh%20per%20kg%20of%20hydrogen https://wernerantweiler.ca/blog.php?item=2020-09-28#:~:text=....
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoCurrent battery storage costs are $143/kWh. The LCOE of solar is <$0.04 now. A hydrogen powered combined cycle peaker plant would have ~60% efficiency. Meaning, you should be able to produce solar-hydrogen fuel for $0.04/0.6/(33.6/39) = <$0.08 per kWh. Why isn't anyone doing this? Natural gas costs >$3.45/MMBTU = $0.01 per kWh. That sounds like it's 8x more expensive. But the wholesale cost of Natural Gas electricity is $0.18 per kWh - meaning going to Hydrogen shouldn't even increase that by 40%. But in the EU, it's already higher than that!
- _hypx 4y ago
- Octokiddie 4y agoAs far as I can tell, this process doesn't make any electrolysis process more energy-efficient. It merely allows the use of untreated seawater, thus sparing possibly scarce freshwater resources. It's not nothing, but it's also not a giant leap forward AFAICT.
- rwke 4y agoI’m not very deep into the topic, but this new process might positively affect the economics and scalability of pilot plants like these as well: https://techcrunch.com/2022/12/20/porsche-pumps-first-synthetic-fuel-as-chilean-plant-finally-starts-producing/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/12/20/porsche-pumps-first-synthe... With advances in nuclear fusion or other technologies that lower the price of CO2 neutral electricity, we just might be able to build plants that produce conventional fuel, using seawater and removing CO2 from the atmosphere at the same time. This would allow scalable production of conventional fuel, without affecting our drinking water or having to replace several billion cars all over the world. I’m probably simplifying here way too much, but exciting developments in that space.
- ogrisel 4y ago> advances in nuclear fusion or other technologies that lower the price of CO2 neutral electricity We are still far from the point where anybody serious could reasonably affirm that advances in nuclear fusion would be expected to lower the price of CO2 anywhere in the foreseeable future. That does not mean we should slow down R&D in nuclear fusion in any way but rather bet on the fast deployment of renewables if the objective is to lower the price of C02 neutral electricity in the coming decade(s).
- conviencefee999 4y ago[dead]
- japanuspus 4y agoSynthetic fuels will be nothing but greenwashing for the next 20 years: there is massive demand for industrial hydrogen (most fundamentally for synthetic fertilizers), and as long as that demand is not met with hydrogen from renewable sources, it will be supplied (as today) from from methane-steam reforming -- using the exact fossil hydrocarbons that synthetic fuels would replace. But yes, synthetic fuels would allow people with money to go to Davos and run their yachts while claiming total greenery, so I have a feeling we will end up with green synthetic fuel and black synthetic fertilizers even if causes larger net emissions.
- hannob 4y agoIt's very questionable if this helps at all. The energy needed to desalinate water is tiny compared to the energy needed for hydrogen production via electrolysis. You're saving small amounts of energy in exchange for a more complex process. Here's a more detailed explanation: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paul-martin-195763b_new-electrolyzer-to-split-saltwater-into-activity-7016069691395760128-S-Ch https://www.linkedin.com/posts/paul-martin-195763b_new-elect... Here's the crucial sentence: "Desalination of seawater by reverse osmosis takes only about 0.035 kWh/kg of H2 produced, i.e. a trivial fraction of the energy (50-65 kWh/kg) required to produce a kg of hydrogen by electrolysis"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]