3 ms·
In light of the little bitty thing lost/found in Australia, this is a good example of why they spent such an effort to find it. Forget making dirty bombs, just
by dylan604 4y ago
In light of the little bitty thing lost/found in Australia, this is a good example of why they spent such an effort to find it. Forget making dirty bombs, just have a "committed to the cause" person just carry something like this around as they tour the city. At least a dirty bomb would be obvious something happened, and people could know how/why they were getting sick in the aftermath.
This kind of thing would be the worst example of Silent But Deadly. Once the committed to the cause person was too affected from doing the work themselves, just have the next member pick up and carry on the mission. Ammo that never needs reloading. You just have to reload the delivery mechanisms.
- gus_massa 4y agoI asked in a previous thread about the relative strength of the device in Goiânia and the recent device in Australia. cosama replied: > The wikipedia article you linked mentioned that the Goiânia source was 50.9 TBq (1,380 Ci) when lost, the source in question here [in Australia] is probably 1-10 mCi, so about a million times weaker. See this other thread about the incidence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34549126 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34549126 .
- mrexroad 4y agoThanks, appreciate you posting it here. Was skimming for that comparison but didn’t see it.
- rimunroe 4y agoThe source in Australia was about 19 GBq (514 mCi) according to https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-in-outback/ https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-i...
- gus_massa 4y ago50.9 TBq / 19 GBq = 50,000 GBq / 20 GBq = 2,500. Can I round it to 1000? Thanks for the data. So it's 1000 weaker, not 1000000 weaker.
- rimunroe 4y agoHalf a curie is an extremely dangerous source! An acquaintance of mine who ran a research reactor for something like ten years was surprised they made a 0.5 Ci Cs-137 at that gauge. He had expected a mining source to be in the tens of mCi range when the news first broke (though he also admitted he's less knowledgeable about mining industry uses than other ones).
- KennyBlanken 4y ago...which is still a very, very serious danger to public health? Particularly since symptoms might not be as acute? Downplaying the seriousness of the Australian incident is a really weird flex. The lost source was still easily lethal.
- throwanem 4y agoHere and in the several prior HN threads on this topic, people often seem to insist on trying to make a movie plot out of it, as if it somehow fails to satisfy by being "merely" a serious industrial accident which was promptly and successfully resolved with at least as yet no evident casualties. I don't understand what narrative so many seem driven to look for here and then complain about not finding, and I certainly don't see what benefit accrues to them or anyone else from the attempt.
- dylan604 4y agoMaybe I was bored, and my mind wandered into something fanciful. No harm no foul, except it seems to have perturbed you. So I like to shoot short films and fun things with friends, and we're always chatting about random things from life that could be spun into a short story. It's habit. Never seemed to have bother anyone till now. Are you the type that gets irritated when people call out "great name for a band" during normal conversations. Some people just catch onto things in conversation and the mind takes its own spin on it. It can make for great conversations. Unless you're just against having fun. Edit: never mind the plot of China Syndrome was an industrial accident, yet a very compelling plot. Or "Sully", or the one where Denzel inverts the plane to avoid tragedy, or any of the other numerous plots involving industrial accidents like CHUD!!!
- marcosdumay 4y ago> "committed to the cause" Ignorance is enough already, you don't need any malice. A child that didn't have had the chance to learn about radioactivity is enough to kill plenty of people. That's why you control radioactive elements. Not exactly because of some antagonistic group. Any such group could probably kill way more people, way more easily by messing with something else.
- dylan604 4y agoAn ignorant child doesn't make for nearly as compelling of a plot though.
- twelve40 4y agoits terrible, but given that after smearing this stuff all over the place only 4 people died, it seems to take a bit more effort than just walking around the city. Those shooters like Las Vegas etc we get here cause way more destruction without having to use such extravagant methods.
- dylan604 4y agoi don't know if it's just because we've become numb to these events, but they just don't get the reaction from something esoteric like someone irradiating the local stores causing people to get sick invisibly. then again, maybe i'm giving the new "scary" too much credit. overall, we didn't take covid seriously. i could see people having radiation parties of groups of people convinced it's not real.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0cVlTeIATBs 4y agoThis kind of attack might be detectable with any digital camera. I'd hope the level it takes to produce visible noise is less than the level to be harmful. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2GNvHRjcz8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2GNvHRjcz8
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> just have a "committed to the cause" person just carry something like this around as they tour the city. They'd be dead in a day or two, with no ill-effects for anyone else.
- RC_ITR 4y ago>Just have a "committed to the cause" person just carry something like this around as they tour the city. Please don't fear-monger; the impact of radiation on the human body is cumulative and the inverse square law makes it hard for any point source to have a ton of impact (particularly with how much attenuating concrete and metal exists in cities). A person walking around a city with a Cs-137 capsule would emit a very dangerous field around themselves, but the impact would be very localized and require long exposure times for there to be a meaningful impact. Your scenario would primarily be a confusing suicide mission, where maybe a random assortment of people would have elevated cancer levels in future years. Hell, even the guy next to Slotin at the Demon core criticality survived 20+ years (before dying of a heart attack)[0] The most deadly disasters are the ones where a radioactivity source is in one place for a long time and people interact closely with it, frequently (usually because they don't know it is there). Take the Goiânia accident [1] as an example. Only the scrapyard employees who spent a few days with the capsule ended up dying. Other people with shorter interaction times were fine. Or take the Kramatorsk Accident [2], only the families in the apartment died of leukemia, despite it being a full building. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvin_C._Graves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvin_C._Graves [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kramatorsk_radiological_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kramatorsk_radiological_accide...
- dylan604 4y agoIf you took this seriously after Silent But Deadly to come away with I'm trying to practice fear mongering, "well, boy, I don't know." We have so many movie/book plots, that this is exactly how they start. Someone reads something, and then just plays with the idea. I'm not a writer, so it's not like I'm ever going to use the idea. But who knows, maybe somebody else reads and turns it into a good idea. We can still have fun in this world even with deputy downers like you ruining for everyone "because it's not accurate".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- throwaway675309 4y agoThats not how you would do it, the way you would do it is to place it in a shielded briefcase. There would be a mechanism on the briefcase that would allow you to open up an exposure focal point effectively exactly like a radiotherapy device. Taking this into a subway, coffee shop etc. opening up the aperture and aiming it at a person quietly for a hour would give them a potentially lethal dose of radiation. A serial killer, assuming they could construct and acquire the necessary radioactive materials could probably perform this many many times before being caught.