8 ms·
Does anybody know if Notch is self taught? I thought he had a CS Degree from somewhere? I can fluctuate between thinking I am a fairly competent developer to t
by jiggy2011 15y ago
Does anybody know if Notch is self taught? I thought he had a CS Degree from somewhere?
I can fluctuate between thinking I am a fairly competent developer to thinking that I am possibly the worst programmer there is. I'm not sure which is a better attitude to have, hopefully I am somewhere in the middle.
I think the issue with reading some of the discussion on HN is that you get people talking in detail about things like functional programming languages , systems with huge scalability , hardcore math problems and the finer points of memory management in the Linux kernel that you feel it is obvious that you should understand this stuff.
I have been trying to do some more book reading to improve, of course the issue is that whenever you read any book recommendation threads of HN there is always at least 30 or so recommendations of some pretty thick books and no chance I'd have time to read them all.
There is also a difference between having deep knowledge of the tools and libraries that you are using right now and having a deeper understanding of theory for example learning git vs learning graph theory etc.
- csomar 15y agoThere is much knowledge than you can learn. Try to focus your learning on what help you solve your clients problems. You'll become an expert only in a thing or two, and you'll be able to talk about it like the people here on HN. Also the smart comment writer is not a representative of the average HN visitor/population. There are always people who are expert in their niches.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThis is true, However at some point I want to move my career in a different direction and most of what I learn on the job is industry specific and the industry itself is not something that hugely interests me (although I have not decided for sure what I want to do). So I am trying to learn as much fundamental stuff as possible. The issue is deciding how much one should know about something before you confidently put it on your resume. For example I would say that I am an OK Java programmer but I avoid using enterprise frameworks which are commonly used in many companies so there are many parts of the language which I am not familiar with simply because I have never had cause to use them, for example I do almost all of my persistence using a database and ORM so I almost never have to use Java's concurrency locking features in the wild as I do all my locking in the DB. The same with functional programming, there is no reason to learn it for my job but I get a feeling it will become more important as time moves on so I should know something about it. There is allot of stuff on HN with people saying that everyone should have implemented a toy compiler at somepoint and if you haven't then your not a serious programmer , or perhaps it is a Toy OS etc etc.
- jcurbo 15y agoI have similar issues. For most of my adult life I've had so many interests that it is just impossible to keep up with all of them to the level I want. Even within computing as a field I am overloaded. I read a lot of stuff on HN and elsewhere I find interesting and I agree that it makes me feel like I should understand it all. First time I've came to that realization. My current solution to the problem of overwhelming interests is starting grad school in CS; by going through a program, I am forced to focus on certain things by outside forces, thus saving my sanity.
- tankenmate 15y agoYour other option is to become a consultant, if you can stand it. This is meant both seriously and as a joke.
- jcurbo 15y agoI already am one, kind of.. I work for these guys: www.mitre.org My day job is broad enough that I get to sate most of my professional desires in one way or another. Now I have grad school to explore some topics in depth and expand my education. It's working out very well so far.
- nlawalker 15y agoThis is my solution as well; I hope to start in a few months. Really looking forward to it.
- Dove 15y agoDoes anybody know if Notch is self taught? I thought he had a CS Degree from somewhere? I can't say with any degree of authority, but based on what I've read of his code, I'd guess he's self-taught. My bigoted preconception is that when it comes to abstraction in code, people with CS degrees err on the side of doing too much, creating extremely elaborate object frameworks that close down options as much as they help reuse code. Self-taught folks, on the other hand, err on the side of doing too little, relying on cut and paste, util packages, and promiscuous sharing of data. When it comes to algorithm design, people with CS degrees tend to pull in libraries of esoteric things, sometimes overengineered for the purpose at hand. Self-taught folks tend to write something from scratch that almost, but not quite, does the job right. Based on what I've read from decompiled Minecraft, I'd guess Notch is self-taught. The abstraction is just barely enough to get the job done, and the algorithms are decidedly homebrew. That's neither praise nor criticism, just a comment on style.
- jiggy2011 15y agoI think that's because university teaches abstractions and pretty much nothing else. A project that is done in the average CS class will be presented as a way to teach a design pattern rather than teaching how to solve a problem. Also the marking scheme will tend to favour a broken solution that is an attempt at an elegant abstraction rather than a more basic abstraction that is well tested and works. There is a certain danger in being educated, for example a self educated programmer might have a problem and just implement a O(n^2) solution and move on whereas a college educated programmer might spend excessive time trying to work out a way to do it in O(log N).
- jquery 15y ago> I think that's because university teaches abstractions and pretty much nothing else. Maybe my CS degree was unique (I don't think it was), but at the 400 level we had specialization choices including security, graphics, web development, databases, operating systems, embedded, software engineering, etc. > A project that is done in the average CS class will be presented as a way to teach a design pattern rather than teaching how to solve a problem. Design patterns != algorithms. My professors actually spent precious little time teaching me how to program, most of that was self-taught. What they taught me to do was how to solve problems, and that education has been very useful. If your CS professors are spending most of their time teaching you design patterns, you should ask for a refund. The only CS class that taught me design patterns was my 400-level software engineering course.
- nostrademons 15y ago"Does anybody know if Notch is self taught? I thought he had a CS Degree from somewhere?" The two are not mutually exclusive. I was talking with a friend recently who's working on her Ph.D, observing that everyone who thought I was so smart in college is now better educated, officially, than me. She was like "You're basically self-taught, but with a piece of paper that says you were willing to stick around in college for 4 years. Even in college you were self-taught." One of my teammates at work recently said I should become a professor. I was like "Don't I need a Ph.D for that?" All my other teammates were like "Naw, man, visiting lecturer!" If you're actually self-taught, you can treat formal education options as a menu that you might or might not choose to sample, depending on your goals at the moment. You don't have to define yourself as one or the other.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThis is interesting, when I studied CS at university I'd say there were 2 different types of people that got high marks. There were people who were self taught , either before they started CS or once they learned some programming at university they identified other areas outside the course that interested them and they could apply their new programming skills. These people typically got jobs in the software industry after graduation and become software developers. The other group of people were people who were just generally high achievers and learned enough programming to pass the course with good marks but nothing much else. They got equally high marks because they were good at passing exams. Most of them either retrained for a career in finance , went into academia or got management gigs at tech consultancy companies. I can't think of anybody I know who is a working programmer who is not self taught to at least some degree.
- doyoulikeworms 15y ago> They got equally high marks because they were good at passing exams. I don't understand how this makes sense, unless being "good at passing exams" means "cheating". Can anybody explain? I hear this said so often, and I usually chalk it up to the speaker rationalizing his own poor scores. My CS exams were always hard, and the only way to "get good" at passing them was to learn the material.
- technomancy 15y ago> Does anybody know if Notch is self taught? I thought he had a CS Degree from somewhere? I have a CS degree, and I'm 99% self-taught.
- ken 15y agoThat's an interesting dichotomy. I have a CS degree from a well-respected school, but as far as programming goes, I would say I'm at least 90% self-taught. I guess I assumed that all programmers are essentially self-taught, regardless of educational background.
- gooorack 15y agoHN is a good place to go if you begin to believe that you are truly awesome at coding and know it all. Brings you back to earth with a thud
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]